Elsevier

Geriatric Nursing

Volume 36, Issue 4, July–August 2015, Pages 261-266
Geriatric Nursing

Feature Article
The development of the MIBBO: A measure of resident preferences for physical activity in long term care settings

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gerinurse.2015.02.004Get rights and content

Highlights

  • The MIBBO was feasible for identifying preferences of physical activities in most of the participating residents.

  • Preferred physical activities are often related to household activities.

  • Preferred activities should be embedded in a personalized physical activity plan.

Abstract

Offering physical activities matching with the preferences of residents in long-term care facilities could increase compliance and contribute to client-centered care. A measure to investigate meaningful activities by using a photo-interview has been developed (“MIBBO”). In two pilot studies including 133 residents living on different wards in long-term care facilities, feasibility, most chosen activities, and consistency of preferences were investigated. It was possible to conduct the MIBBO on average in 30 min with the majority (86.4%) of residents. The most frequently chosen activities were: gymnastics and orchestra (each 28%), preparing a meal (31%), walking (outside, 33%), watering plants (38%), and feeding pets (40%). In a retest one week after the initial interview 69.4% agreement of chosen activities was seen. The MIBBO seems a promising measure to help health care professionals in identifying residents' preferred activities. Future research should focus on the implementation of the tailored activity plan, incorporating it into the daily routine.

Introduction

In numerous studies, it has been established that physical activity, even with low intensity, has beneficial effects on both physical and mental functioning in older people aged 65 years and over.1, 2, 3 Despite these benefits, it has also been shown that many people in this age group are insufficiently active to achieve these positive effects. They hardly meet the required 30 min of moderate physical activity a day, as recommended by several international guidelines.4, 5, 6 A specific sub group within this target population is formed of residents of long-term care facilities (e.g. nursing homes). They are, on average, (even) less active than their peers living at home and, in addition, due to cognitive and communicative impairments, they are often difficult to stimulate to become more physically active.7, 8

The American College of Sports Medicine defines physical activity as ‘body movement that is produced by the contraction of skeletal muscles and that increases energy expenditure’.2 According to this definition, all sorts of routine activities in daily life have a ‘natural’ activity component. For example, activities such as setting the table for a meal and watering plants involve walking, reaching, grasping, and carrying. Daily activities residents prefer to do could be integrated in their daily routines, increasing their physical activity level and contributing to person-centered care. However, according to a recent study, only a minority of residents (18%) seem to participate in these kinds of routine everyday activities.9 In these types of activities, informal and professional caregivers can be involved to supervise residents, but at least partly the residents may perform them independently. This increases the physical activity opportunities for residents as they are not merely dependent on the caregivers' availability or a specific location (e.g. gym).

Many long-term care facilities organize exercise activities for their residents, such as gymnastics, walking programs or recreational activities (e.g. woodwork) that may have a physical component. Residents are invited to participate in these activities but often caregivers have limited insight into which kind of activities residents prefer. The activity program is often based on what the institute has to offer, not on what the residents would like to do.

Including residents' preferences in selecting activities can improve interest and compliance.10 According to the recommendations of the American College of Sports Medicine and the American Heart Association every older adult (aged 65+ years) should have a physical plan based on individual abilities and preferences.6 The same is true in the Netherlands. The Dutch Inspectorate for Health Care has defined seven modules for physical activities in elderly care that must be taken into account when developing personalized activity plans. According to one of these, health care facilities need to incorporate the wishes and preferences of elderly people when planning, performing, and evaluating policy with regard to physical activity.11 However, it remains unclear how the perspective of this communication vulnerable group of residents in long-term care facilities can be investigated.

A variety of generic and standardized assessments and tools to investigate abilities of older adults on different levels (e.g. cognition or mobility) are available for care professionals. With the increase in client-centered care, more individualized tools and measures to explore a person's needs, preferences, and aims have been developed. The existing tools are, however, related to goal setting within rehabilitation or to a certain medical treatment.12, 13

A measure to identify preferences with regard to physical activities tailored to the situation of residential long-term care facilities has therefore been developed. The measure is named “MIBBO” which is a Dutch acronym for “Measure to Identify Meaningful Physical Activities in the Elderly”. The aim of this study was to investigate:

  • 1)

    The feasibility of the MIBBO in residents of long-term care facilities

  • 2)

    Which activities residents of long-term care facilities prefer

  • 3)

    How consistent preferences of residents are over a short period of time (1 week).

Section snippets

Design

This study was a descriptive study in two phases testing preliminary use of the MIBBO. First, feasibility was assessed in a small sample. Subsequently, the MIBBO was used with a larger sample to identify the activities that residents chose most often. In this second phase, a test-retest procedure was embedded using a subsample to research how consistent the preferences of residents were.

Sample

The population of residents in long-term care facilities is heterogeneous in terms of physical,

Results

The results of the study are presented according to the three research questions.

Discussion

In this study, a measure to identify preferred physical activities of residents in long-term care facilities, the MIBBO, was developed and evaluated. The MIBBO was considered to be feasible for use with most of the participating residents based on the following results. First, in general, the residents understood the procedure of the MIBBO and wished to participate in the interview. Second, care professionals needed 30 min on average to conduct the MIBBO. Although this is a relatively long time

Conclusion

The MIBBO seems a promising measure to help health care professionals identify residents' preferred activities and tailor physical activity plans. These activities can be embedded in daily routines. Future research investigating the relation between the residents' abilities and characteristics, and the support needed to perform the preferred activities is warranted, as well as research assessing the benefits of performing the preferred activities for the residents' functioning.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank Fenna Graff, Kirsten Pieters, Monique Kokkelmans, Marloes van de Molen, Katharina Burgholz, Michaela Spiertz, Arantxa Vos, Milou Janssen, Naomi Pelser, Daisy Erens, Kristin Blanckers, and Michel Bleijlevens for the input and effort in the development of the MIBBO and the pilot testing. We would also like to thank Monique Lexis for her valuable comments on a concept version of this article.

Funding: This study is financially supported by Innovation Alliance Foundation

References (28)

  • M.E. Nelson et al.

    Physical activity and public health in older adults: recommendation from the American College of Sports Medicine and the American Heart Association

    Circulation

    (2007)
  • B.M. Bates-Jensen et al.

    The Minimum Data Set bedfast quality indicator: differences among nursing homes

    Nurs Res

    (2004)
  • S. Kalinowski et al.

    Physical activity in nursing homes-barriers and facilitators: a cross-sectional study

    J Aging Phys Act

    (2012)
  • D. Edvardsson et al.

    Everyday activities for people with dementia in residential aged care: associations with person-centredness and quality of life

    Int J Older People Nurs

    (2014)
  • Cited by (7)

    • Reliability and internal consistency of the Swedish version of the MAastrIcht Nurses Activities INventory (MAINtAIN(S)) – A pilot testing of the tool

      2020, Geriatric Nursing
      Citation Excerpt :

      Internal consistency for the MAINtAIN-barriers have not been reported earlier. In the present study the nursing staff encouraged everyday activities among older adults in nursing homes when the activities were linked to ADL and to a lesser extent if they were linked to household activities, as reported in previous studies.5, 13 The nursing staff perceived that it was according to routines at their workplace to take over ADL and household activities from the residents, even though they could carry out these activities themselves.

    • Older adults' personal routine at time of hospitalization

      2017, Geriatric Nursing
      Citation Excerpt :

      This might be because in the hospital setting, caretakers perform certain activities for patients instead of just being present and providing partial assistance. Discussions of assisting dependent residents with daily activities are evident in the nursing-home literature,45 which usually presents the inherent contradiction between staff-efficiency goals and residents' goals of maximizing independence.46 We assume this tension to be even stronger in the hospital setting, where staff are even less knowledgeable of independence maintenance goals in older adults.47–49

    • Daily (In)Activities of Nursing Home Residents in Their Wards: An Observation Study

      2015, Journal of the American Medical Directors Association
      Citation Excerpt :

      Moreover, it is essential to know which activities the residents prefer. This preference of the residents could, for example, be identified by the MIBBO (Dutch acronym for “Measure to Identify Meaningful Physical Activities in the Elderly”).26 The MIBBO is a photo-interview conducted to investigate the preferences of residents.

    • Quality of experience during horticultural activities: an experience sampling pilot study among older adults living in a nursing home

      2018, Geriatric Nursing
      Citation Excerpt :

      However, both the occupational and horticultural protocols required low-cost materials and can be adapted to residents' levels of physical and cognitive abilities, thus making it possible to verify and possibly replicate present findings in different facility types. Finally, regarding horticultural activities, the benefits of this treatment could be improved by the possibility of taking care of plants between weekly sessions.32 Unfortunately, for safety reasons, during the week it was not possible for participants to access the gym room, where the plant were kept, and this aspect could not be assessed.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text