Elsevier

Chemical Engineering Science

Volume 65, Issue 21, 1 November 2010, Pages 5699-5715
Chemical Engineering Science

Local analysis of the tablet coating process: Impact of operation conditions on film quality

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ces.2010.07.007Get rights and content

Abstract

Spray coating is frequently used in the pharmaceutical industry to control the release of the active pharmaceutical ingredient of a tablet or to mask its taste. The uniformity of the coating is of significant importance, as the coating usually has critical functional properties. However, coating uniformity is difficult to predict without significant experimental work, and even advanced particle simulations need to be augmented by CFD models to fully describe the coating uniformity on a single tablet.

In this study we analyze the coating process by using detailed computational fluid dynamics (CFD) multiphase spray simulations. The impact and the deposition of droplets on tablets with different shape, as well as the production and evolution of the liquid film on the surface of the tablets are numerically modeled. Spray droplets are simulated with a Discrete Droplets Method (DDM) Euler–Lagrange approach. Models for multi-component evaporation and particle/wall interaction are taken into account. The wall film is treated with a two-dimensional model incorporating submodels for interfacial shear force, film evaporation and heat transfer between film, solid wall and gas phase. Our simulations show how different physical parameters of the coating spray affect the coating process on a single tablet. For example, we analyze for the first time the deposition behavior of the droplets on the tablet. The outcome of our work provides a deeper understanding of the local interaction between the spray and the tablet bed, allowing a step forward in the design, scale-up, optimization and operation of industrial coating devices. Furthermore, it may serve as a basis for the combination with state-of-the-art DEM particle simulation tools.

Introduction

Coating is an important step in the production of many solid oral dosage forms, such as tablets and granules. The goal of film coating is the application of a thin polymer-based film on top of a tablet or a granule containing the active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs). In the last years, more than half of all the pharmaceutical tablets were coated (IMS Midas Database, 2007). Functional coatings are usually adopted for taste masking or to alter the tablet’s dissolution behavior, for example by controlling the rate of dissolution via semi-permeable membranes or by making it resistant to gastric juice through enteric coatings. Furthermore, active ingredients may be incorporated in the film layer. Colored non-functional coatings are commonly used to improve visual attractiveness, handling and brand recognition. A well-known example is the “blue pill” VIAGRA® by Pfizer Inc. Depending on the tablet’s dimension and coating functionality, the film thickness varies between 5 and 100 μm. A detailed description of the coating process and the different coater devices is presented in the book of Cole et al. (1995).

Historically, this process was developed by the confectionery industry to sugar-coat different types of candies. The pharmaceutical industry implemented this technique using open bowl-shaped pan. Nowadays, sugar-coated tablets are rarely developed due to the intricacy of the process and the high degree of operator skill required. Instead, tablets are typically coated with a polymer film of various compositions using modern equipment, such as drum and pan coaters.

The first commercially available pharmaceutical film-coated tablet was introduced to the market in 1954 by Abbott Laboratories. Tablets were produced in a fluidized bed coating column based on the Wurster principle (Wurster, 1953), which was further developed by Merck in their US and UK plants. This new technique could be realized due to the development of new coating materials based on cellulose derivatives, e.g., hydroxypropyl methylcellulose. Nevertheless, in the following decades coating columns were substituted by side-vented pans and the use of aqueous film solutions, which reduce the use of organic solvents and the related costs of the recovery systems.

Nowadays, tablet coating is typically carried out in pan coaters or fluidized bed systems. Modern production-scale pan coaters have batch sizes ranging from 500 g to 2000 kg, have a fully perforated cylindrical drum and use two-material nozzles for an effective spray generation. Today’s fluidized bed coaters allow continuous coating or have special internals to allow for coating processes involving coating solutions with high solid content (Porter, 2006). In this study we focus on pan coaters.

Although coating processes have been used for many decades, there are still serious challenges, as there is a lack of understanding of how material and operating parameters impact product quality and cause problems, such as chipping (i.e., films become chipped due to attrition), blistering (i.e., local formation of blisters due to entrapment of gas), cratering (i.e., penetration of the coating solution into the bulk of the tablet causing crater-like structures), pitting (i.e., pits occur on the surface due to overheating of the tablet and partial melting), picking (i.e., parts of the film are removed due to sticking to other wet tablets), blushing (i.e., formation of spots due to phase-transitions of the polymer film), blooming (i.e., plasticizer concentrates at the surface, leading to a change of appearance), film cracking (i.e., cracking of the film upon cooling due to high stresses) and many others. Quite often, poor scale-up of the process and/or insufficient process understanding is the cause of such production problems and batch failures Pandey et al. (2006a). Although the reasons for these manufacturing problems are more or less understood, it is still a challenge to predict the occurrence of such effects for new systems.

Therefore, in our work we focus on a basic understanding of the film formation process on single tablets, with the goal of being able to predict the impact of material and operation parameters on the film quality. The current study is a first step in this direction. We investigate the spray fluid dynamics and the film formation of a glycerin–water mixture on two different tablet shapes, i.e., a sphere and a biconvex tablet, held in one position. Our analysis is based on a rigorous computational model that uses well established physical submodels for momentum, heat and mass transfer. Thus, we are able to predict the transient development of the mean film thickness of a wetting coating solution on arbitrarily shaped surfaces. Our main objective is to provide, for the first time, a science-based and quantitative understanding of which physicochemical parameters influence the uniformity of the coating layer on a single tablet. This knowledge is the key for the design, optimization and the rational scale-up of such processes and can form the basis for further studies on rotating tablets or whole tablet beds.

Section snippets

Spray system

A modern coating system is conceptually shown in Fig. 1, where the coating suspension is sprayed on top of a moving bed of the solid dosage form. The spray guns are usually mounted on an arm inside the pan and are directed towards the tablet bed. As the bed is moving, a tablet spends a fraction of a second in the spraying zone. The wet surface of the tablet needs to be dried to avoid sticking of the tablet to neighboring tablets, leading to manufacturing problems such as picking. However, too

Objectives

Currently, the optimization of industrial coaters is mostly done by means of experimental and empirical analysis. State-of-the-art computational approaches include the use of Discrete Elements Method (DEM) , which already represents a consolidated practice in particle technology. However, current studies lack a detailed description of the film formation process on individual tablets or granules as only statistical tools for the film deposition on the tablet surface are used. Such an approach

Model and numerical solution

In this section we present the 3D model used for the numerical analysis of the spray and the wall film. We adopted the 3D-CFD code AVL FIRE v2008 to simulate the dynamics of the coating spray and the film evolution on the tablet. We treat the coating process as a gas–liquid multiphase flow with deposition of a liquid film on the surface. For the description of the gas flow around the object to be coated we used the Reynolds averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) equations including an appropriate

Base case definition

As mentioned above, our goal was to investigate the influence of different operating parameters on the film formation on coated tablets. In order to define a realistic base set of parameters for our simulations, experimental investigations of a spray gun via Phase Doppler Anemometry (PDA) technique have been performed (for the technique refer to Hirleman (1996), the measurements have been performed by us at Duesen-Schlick GmbH, Germany). This experimental method is capable of simultaneously

Conclusions and outlook

In this work we have analyzed the process of tablet spraying, as well as wetting, by means of a multiphase CFD solver. Sophisticated models for the gas flow, droplet motion, as well as for the flow of the liquid film on two different objects, i.e., a sphere and a convex tablet, have been developed. Using these models we have performed a detailed variation study and analyzed the impact of the system properties on quality attributes of the resulting liquid film. Our variation study has been

Nomenclature

    Latin symbols

    A

    area (m2)

    BM,j, BT

    spalding mass and heat transfer number (dimensionless)

    k

    constant (dimensionless)

    cp

    specific heat capacity at constant pressure (J/kg K)

    d

    particle diameter (m)

    D

    diameter (m)

    F

    force (N)

    FM,j, FT

    mass and temperature correction functions (dimensionless)

    fR

    fractional residence time (dimensionless)

    g

    gravitational acceleration (m/s2)

    h

    specific enthalpy (J/kg)

    k

    thermal conductivity (W/(m K))

    km

    mass transfer coefficient (m/s)

    L

    latent heat (J/kg)

    L

    characteristic length, length of the spray zone (m)

    m

Acknowledgement

We thank the reviewers for their extremely helpful comments with respect to tablet flow and droplet spreading on surfaces.

References (54)

  • P. Pandey et al.

    Simulation of particle movement in a pan coating device using discrete element modeling and its comparison with video-imaging experiments

    Powder Technology

    (2006)
  • A.M. Peres et al.

    Thermodynamic properties of sugars in aqueous solutions: correlation and prediction using a modified UNIQUAC model

    Fluid Phase Equilibria

    (1996)
  • A.M. Peres et al.

    A modified UNIFAC model for the calculation of thermodynamic properties of aqueous and non-aqueous solutions containing sugars

    Fluid Phase Equilibria

    (1997)
  • S. Sandadi et al.

    In situ, near real-time acquisition of particle motion in rotating pan coating equipment using imaging techniques

    Chemical Engineering Science

    (2004)
  • S. Tobiska et al.

    A simple method for evaluating the mixing efficiency of a new type of pan coater

    International Journal of Pharmaceutics

    (2001)
  • S. Tobiska et al.

    Coating uniformity and coating efficiency in a Bohle Lab-Coater using oval tablets

    European Journal of Pharmaceutics and Biopharmaceutics

    (2003)
  • Abramzon, B., Sirignano, W.A., 1988. Droplet vaporization model for spray combustion calculations. AIAA 26th Aerospace...
  • M. Attarakih et al.

    Dynamic modeling of a packed-bed glycerol–water distillation column

    Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research

    (2001)
  • Aulton, M.E., Twitchell, A.M., Hogan, J.E., 1986. Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference on Pharmaceutical...
  • AVL GmbH, 2008. FIRE v2008 User...
  • C. Bindschaedler et al.

    Theoretical concepts regarding the formation of films from aqueous microdispersions and application to coating

    Labo-pharma, Problemes et Techniques

    (1983)
  • Brenn, G., Deviprasath, L.J., Durst, F., 2003. Computations and experiments on the evaporation of multi-component...
  • T. Cebeci et al.

    Momentum Transfer in Boundary Layers

    (1977)
  • D.H.T. Chen et al.

    Isobaric vapor–liquid equilibria for systems glycerol–water and glycerol–water saturated with sodium chloride

    Journal of Chemical and Engineering Data

    (1970)
  • Cole, G., Hogan, J., Aulton, M., 1995. Pharmaceutical Coating Technology. Informa HealthCare,...
  • Dubey, A., Portillo, P.M., Muzzio, F.J., 2008. Study of tablet coating thickness uniformity using LIBS, DEM and...
  • Edelbauer, W., Suzzi, D., Sampl, P., Tatschl, R., Krueger, C., Weigand, B., 2006. New concept for simultaneous coupling...
  • Cited by (71)

    • A coarse-grained parcel method for heat and mass transfer simulations of spray coating processes

      2022, Advanced Powder Technology
      Citation Excerpt :

      For this purpose, various spray models have been used in DEM simulations. The most common are the pre-defined spray zone approach [19,24], the ray-tracing method [26,27], the discrete droplet method [28,29] and an Eulerian deposition method [30]. Although all of these models could be applied “inline” (i.e., during a multi-physics simulation), or during post-processing, an inline spray model is necessary if simultaneous momentum, heat and mass transfer should be modeled.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text