Theory and MethodologyAn evaluation of vendor selection models from a total cost of ownership perspective
Introduction
In the literature Dickson, 1966, Weber et al., 1991 several dimensions are mentioned that are important for the multiple objective vendor selection decision. These include net price, quality, delivery, performance history, capacity, communication system, service, geographical location, etc. The problem is how to select suppliers that perform optimally on the desired dimensions. The published vendor selection decision models formulate answers to this multiple objective problem. Some authors propose linear weighting models in which suppliers are rated on several criteria and in which these ratings are combined into a single score. Others propose mathematical programming formulations in which quantifiable criteria are taken into account. Some approach the problem on an item-by-item basis, others consider it a multiple item decision. Only a few authors incorporate the multi-period inventory management issue into the supplier selection decision Bender et al., 1985, Degraeve and Roodhooft, 1999b, Ronen and Trietsch, 1988.
No research has been done on how to compare these different approaches to vendor selection and to find out the “best” way to handle the decision. The problem is to find a basis for comparison that is theoretically sound. In this paper we propose the concept of Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) to compare the relative efficiency of different vendor selection decision models. The Total Cost of Ownership quantifies all costs associated with the purchasing process throughout the entire value chain of the firm. We apply each of the vendor selection models proposed in the literature to a real life data set describing the purchasing problem of ball bearings at Cockerill Sambre. Subsequently, we calculate the TCO of the resulting solutions, i.e. choices of what to buy from whom and when. In this way, we are able to evaluate and compare the existing vendor selection models from a TCO perspective.
The contribution of this paper is fourfold. First, we present a literature review and classification of published vendor selection models. Second, these models are evaluated from a TCO perspective. Third, the application and evaluation of the different vendor selection models is done using a real life data set describing the purchasing problem of ball bearings at Cockerill Sambre. The data consist of information on various criteria other than the traditional quality, time and quantity discount parameters. Fourth, several conclusions will be drawn regarding the efficiency of the different kinds of vendor selection models.
The rest of the paper is organised as follows. In Section 2, we explain the TCO perspective from which the evaluation will be made and all parameters associated with it. We discuss the classification of the vendor selection models in Section 3. In Section 4 we describe the real life case used to evaluate the published vendor selection models. In Section 5 the results of the comparison will be discussed. Finally, we will draw conclusions and make suggestions for future research in Section 6.
Section snippets
The total cost of ownership approach
The TCO quantifies all costs associated with the purchasing process throughout the entire value chain of the firm. The cost of the acquisition and subsequent use of an item or service that is to be purchased is determined. The approach goes beyond price to consider all costs over the items’ entire life such as those related to service, quality, delivery, administration, communication, failure, maintenance, etc. Ellram, 1994, Ellram, 1995b, Ellram, 1995a. The analysis of costs throughout the
Classification of vendor selection decision models
As reported in Table 1, a distinction can be made between single item (Timmerman, 1986, Gregory, 1986, Nydick and Hill, 1992, Barbarosoglu and Yazgaç, 1997, Willis et al., 1993, Li et al., 1997, Soukoup, 1987, Thompson, 1990, Monczka and Trecha, 1988, Smytka and Clemens, 1993, Chaudhry et al., 1993, Weber and Current, 1993, Pan, 1989) and multiple item models Grando and Sianesi, 1996, Turner, 1988, Current and Weber, 1994, Akinc, 1993, Sadrian and Yoon, 1994, Rosenthal et al., 1995, Benton, 1991
The problem of purchasing ball bearings at Cockerill Sambre
We study the procurement of ball bearings at Cockerill Sambre S.A., a Belgian multinational company in the steel industry with external purchases approaching £0.6 billion annually accounting for more than 70% of total costs. Management wants to improve the efficiency of the purchasing process and to reconsider the sourcing strategies for different product groups. Our case study refers to the ball bearings, a product selected for study by the purchasing managers of the firm and a business of
Results of comparison from a total cost of ownership perspective
In Table 2, we summarise the resulting TCO for the solutions of the different vendor selection models. The second and third column, respectively, state the inventory management and order splitting assumption, if applicable. The fourth column gives the TCO in percentages of the results of the TCO minimising Degraeve and Roodhooft (1999a) model. The fifth, sixth and seventh column give the three components of the TCO, namely supplier level cost, order level cost and unit level cost in
Conclusions and suggestions for future research
Given the TCO perspective, several conclusions can be drawn from Table 2. First, multiple item mathematical programming models are always performing better than single item rating models. Single item models fail to take into account the interdependencies that could exist among the different products. A supplier can be offering a larger discount based on total sales volume, irrespective of the product mix. Order level costs could be minimised by combining orders for several products into one
References (44)
Selecting a set of vendors in a manufacturing environment
Journal of Operations Management
(1993)- et al.
Vendor selection with price breaks
European Journal of Operational Research
(1993) - et al.
Application of facility location modelling constructs to vendor selection problems
European Journal of Operational Research
(1994) - et al.
Improving the efficiency of the purchasing process using total cost of ownership information: The case of heating electrodes at Cockerill Sambre S.A
European Journal of Operational Research
(1999) - et al.
Vendor selection and evaluation: an activity based costing approach
European Journal of Operational Research
(1997) - et al.
A multiobjective approach to vendor selection
European Journal of Operational Research
(1993) - et al.
Vendor selection criteria and methods
European Journal of Operational Research
(1991) - et al.
Non cooperative negotiation strategies for vendor selection
European Journal of Operational Research
(1998) - et al.
Determination of paths to vendor market efficiency using parallel co-ordinates representation: A negotiation tool for buyers
European Journal of Operational Research
(1996) - Barbarosoglu, G., Yazgaç, T., 1997. An application of the analytic hierarchy process to the supplier selection problem....
Improving purchasing productivity at IBM with a normative decision support system
Interfaces
Quantity discount decisions under conditions of multiple items, multiple suppliers and resource limitations
International Journal of Production Research
Measuring the cost of ownership
Journal of Cost Management
A total cost/value model for supply chain competitiveness
Journal of Business Logistics
Determining sourcing strategies: A decision model based on activity and cost driver information
Journal of the Operational Research Society
A mathematical programming approach for procurement using activity based costing
forthcoming in Journal of Business Finance and Accounting
An analysis of vendor selection systems and decisions
Journal of Purchasing
Total Cost Modeling in Purchasing
Activity-based costing and total cost of ownership: A critical linkage
Journal of Cost Management, winter
Total cost of ownership an analysis approach for purchasing
Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics
Purchasing: The cornerstone of the total cost of ownership concept
Journal of Business Logistics
Supply management: A vendor rating assessment
CEMS Business Review
Cited by (341)
Pyrometallurgical recycling of different lithium-ion battery cell systems: Economic and technical analysis
2023, Journal of Cleaner ProductionThe current role of management accounting: paradigm shift and future challenges
2024, Journal of Accounting and Organizational ChangeSmart semiconductor manufacturing for pricing, demand planning, capacity portfolio and cost for sustainable supply chain management
2024, International Journal of Logistics Research and ApplicationsMultiple Items Supplier Selection, Economic Lot-sizing, and Order Allocation Under Quantity Discount: A Genetic Algorithm Approach
2023, Journal of Optimization in Industrial EngineeringAdditive Manufacturing of Slow-Moving Automotive Spare Parts: A Supply Chain Cost Assessment
2023, Journal of Manufacturing and Materials Processing