Abstract
Corneal inlays and onlays represent a means of providing patients with permanent refractive error correction. As an alternative to conventional spectacles and contact lens, these techniques are less invasive compared with laser-based refractive surgery and are reversible. In this review, we provide a brief overview of the anatomic microstructure of the human cornea, indicating the primary physiological function for each component. Next, the wide range of biomaterials used as corneal inlays and onlays are considered, from synthetic polymers to biological components derived from the extracellular matrix. The limitations and challenges associated with the most common materials are discussed as is the need to improve their properties to achieve long-term, complication-free intraocular implantation. Finally, the prospect of applying tissue engineering strategies is noted for its potential to generate autologous corneal tissue that could be implanted as the optimal inlay or onlay materials.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Whitcher JP, Srinivasan M, Upashyay MP. Corneal blindness: a global perspective. Bull World Health Organ, 2001, 79: 214–221
Sweeney DF, Vannas A, Hughes TC, Evans MD, McLean KM, Xie RZ, Pravin VK, Prakasam RK. Synthetic corneal inlays. Clin Exp Optom, 2008, 91: 56–66
Xie RZ, Stretton S, Sweeney DF. Artificial cornea: towards a synthetic onlay for correction of refractive error. Biosci Rep, 2001, 21: 513–536
Sweeney DF. The Max Schapero Memorial Award Lecture 2004: contact lenses on and in the cornea, what the eye needs. Optom Vis Sci, 2006, 83: 133–142
Solomon KD, Fernandez de Castro LE, Sandoval HP, Bartholomew LR, Vroman DT. Refractive surgery survey 2003. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2004, 30: 1556–1569
Kugler LJ, Wang MX. Lasers in refractive surgery: history, present, and future. Appl Opt, 2010, 49: F1–9
Solomon KD, Fernandez de Castro LE, Sandoval HP, Biber JM, Groat B, Neff KD, Ying MS, French JW, Donnenfeld ED, Lindstrom RL. LASIK world literature review: quality of life and patient satisfaction. Ophthalmology, 2009, 116: 691–701
Evans MD, McLean KM, Hughes TC, Sweeney DF. A review of the development of a synthetic corneal onlay for refractive correction. Biomaterials, 2001, 22: 3319–3328
Carlsson DJ, Li F, Shimmura S, Griffith M. Bioengineered corneas: how close are we? Curr Opin Ophthalmol, 2003, 14: 192–197
Esquenazi S, Bui V, Bibas O. Surgical correction of hyperopia. Surv Ophthalmol, 2006, 51: 381–418
Lindstrom RL, Macrae SM, Pepose JS, Hoopes PC, Sr. Corneal inlays for presbyopia correction. Curr Opin Ophthalmol, 2013, 24: 281–287
Kim P, Sutton GL, Rootman DS. Applications of the femtosecond laser in corneal refractive surgery. Curr Opin Ophthalmol, 2011, 22: 238–244
Germain L, Carrier P, Auger FA, Salesse C, Guerin SL. Can we produce a human corneal equivalent by tissue engineering? Prog Retin Eye Res, 2000, 19: 497–527
Ruberti JW, Zieske JD. Prelude to corneal tissue engineering-gaining control of collagen organization. Prog Retin Eye Res, 2008, 27: 549–577
Hanna C, Bicknell DS, O’Brien JE. Cell turnover in the adult human eye. Arch Ophthalmol, 1961, 65: 695–698
Dua HS, Gomes JA, Singh A. Corneal epithelial wound healing. Br J Ophthalmol, 1994, 78: 401–408
Schermer A, Galvin S, Sun TT. Differentiation-related expression of a major 64K corneal keratin in vivo and in culture suggests limbal location of corneal epithelial stem cells. J Cell Biol, 1986, 103: 49–62
Gipson IK, Spurr-Michaud SJ, Tisdale AS. Anchoring fibrils form a complex network in human and rabbit cornea. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci, 1987, 28: 212–220
Gipson IK, Spurr-Michaud S, Tisdale A, Keough M. Reassembly of the anchoring structures of the corneal epithelium during wound repair in the rabbit. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci, 1989, 30: 425–434
Gipson IK. The Cornea. Scientific Foundation and Clinical Practice. Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1994
Hayashi S, Osawa T, Tohyama K. Comparative observations on corneas, with special reference to Bowman’s layer and Descemet’s membrane in mammals and amphibians. J Morphol, 2002, 254: 247–258
Anseth A. Studies on corneal polysaccharides. III. Topographic and comparative biochemistry. Exp Eye Res, 1961, 1: 106–115
Anseth A. Glycosaminoglycans in the developing corneal stroma. Exp Eye Res, 1961, 1: 116–121
Anseth A. Glycosaminoglycans in corneal regeneration. Exp Eye Res, 1961, 1: 122–127
Anseth A, Laurent TC. Studies on corneal polysaccharides. I. Separation. Exp Eye Res, 1961, 1: 25–38
Laurent TC, Anseth A. Studies on corneal polysaccharides. II. Characterization. Exp Eye Res, 1961, 1: 99–105
Hassell JR, Birk DE. The molecular basis of corneal transparency. Exp Eye Res, 2010, 91: 326–335
Axelsson I, Heinegard D. Fractionation of proteoglycans from bovine corneal stroma. Biochem J, 1975, 145: 491–500
Meek KM, Leonard DW. Ultrastructure of the corneal stroma: a comparative study. Biophys J, 1993, 64: 273–280
Maurice DM. The structure and transparency of the cornea. J Physiol, 1957, 136: 263–286
Hart RW, Farrell RA. Light scattering in the cornea. J Opt Soc Am, 1969, 59: 766–774
Benedek GB. Theory of transparency of the eye. Appl Opt, 1971, 10: 459–473
Pinnamaneni N, Funderburgh JL. Concise review: stem cells in the corneal stroma. Stem Cells, 2012, 30: 1059–1063
Yee RW, Matsuda M, Schultz RO, Edelhauser HF. Changes in the normal corneal endothelial cellular pattern as a function of age. Curr Eye Res, 1985, 4: 671–678
Maurice DM. The location of the fluid pump in the cornea. J Physiol, 1972, 221: 43–54
Bonanno JA. Identity and regulation of ion transport mechanisms in the corneal endothelium. Prog Retin Eye Res, 2003, 22: 69–94
Barraquer JI. Modification of refraction by means of intracorneal inclusions. Int Ophthalmol Clin, 1966, 6: 53–78
McCarey BE. Current status of refractive surgery with synthetic intracorneal lenses: barraquer lecture. Refract Corneal Surg, 1990, 6: 40–46
McCarey BE. Refractive keratoplasty with synthetic lens implants. Int Ophthalmol Clin, 1991, 31: 87–99
McCarey BE, McDonald MB, van Rij G, Salmeron B, Pettit DK, Knight PM. Refractive results of hyperopic hydrogel intracorneal lenses in primate eyes. Arch Ophthalmol, 1989, 107: 724–730
McCarey BE, Storie BR, van Rij G, Knight PM. Refractive predictability of myopic hydrogel intracorneal lenses in nonhuman primate eyes. Arch Ophthalmol, 1990, 108: 1310–1315
Kaufman HE. The correction of aphakia. XXXVI Edward Jackson memorial lecture. Am J Ophthalmol, 1980, 89: 1–10
McDonald MB, Klyce SD, Suarez H, Kandarakis A, Friedlander MH, Kaufman HE. Epikeratophakia for myopia correction. Ophthalmology, 1985, 92: 1417–1422
Werblin TP, Kaufman HE. Epikeratophakia: the surgical correction of aphakia. II. Preliminary results in a non-human primate model. Curr Eye Res, 1981, 1: 131–137
Werblin TP, Klyce SD. Epikeratophakia: the surgical correction of aphakia. I. Lathing of corneal tissue. Curr Eye Res, 1981, 1: 123–129
Hicks CR, Fitton JH, Chirila TV, Crawford GJ, Constable IJ. Keratoprostheses: advancing toward a true artificial cornea. Surv Ophthalmol, 1997, 42: 175–189
Chirila TV, Hicks CR, Dalton PD. Artificial cornea. Prog Polym Sci, 1998, 23: 447–473
Rao GN, Ganti S, Aquavella JV. Specular microscopy of corneal epithelium after epikeratophakia. Am J Ophthalmol, 1987, 103: 392–396
Rodrigues M, Nirankari V, Rajagopalan S, Jones K, Funderburgh J. Clinical and histopathologic changes in the host cornea after epikeratoplasty for keratoconus. Am J Ophthalmol, 1992, 114: 161–170
Yamaguchi T, Koenig SB, Kimura T, Werblin TP, McDonald MB, Kaufman HE. Histological study of epikeratophakia in primates. Ophthalmic Surg, 1984, 15: 230–235
Dupont D, Gravagna P, Albinet P, Tayot JL, Romanet JP, Mouillon M, Eloy R. Biocompatibility of human collagen type IV intracorneal implants. Cornea, 1989, 8: 251–258
Kornmehl EW, Bredvik BK, Kelman CD, Raizman MB, DeVore DP. In vivo evaluation of a collagen corneal allograft derived from rabbit dermis. J Refract Surg, 1995, 11: 502–506
Thompson KP, Hanna K, Waring GO, 3rd, Gipson I, Liu Y, Gailitis RP, Johnson-Wint B, Green K. Current status of synthetic epikeratoplasty. Refract Corneal Surg, 1991, 7: 240–248
Thompson KP, Hanna KD, Gipson IK, Gravagna P, Waring GO, 3rd, Johnson-Wint B. Synthetic epikeratoplasty in rhesus monkeys with human type IV collagen. Cornea, 1993, 12: 35–45
Wichterle O, Lím D. Hydrophilic gels for biological use. Nature, 1960, 185: 117–118
Chirila TV. An overview of the development of artificial corneas with porous skirts and the use of PHEMA for such an application. Biomaterials, 2001, 22: 3311–3317
Dohlman CH, Refojo MF, Rose J. Synthetic polymers in corneal surgery. I. Glyceryl methacrylate. Arch Ophthalmol, 1967, 77: 252–257
Imagawa N, Kamiyama R. Experimental study of intralamellar implantation—evaluation of hydroxyethyl-methacrylate polymer. Nihon Ganka Gakkai Zasshi, 1979, 83: 1043–1054
McCarey BE, Andrews DM. Refractive keratoplasty with intrastromal hydrogel lenticular implants. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci, 1981, 21: 107–115
McCarey BE, Andrews DM, Hatchell DL, Pederson H. Hydrogel implants for refractive keratoplasty: corneal morphology. Curr Eye Res, 1982, 2: 29–38
Myung D, Koh W, Bakri A, Zhang F, Marshall A, Ko J, Ko J, Noolandi J, Carrasco M, Cochran JR, Frank CW, Ta CN. Design and fabrication of an artificial cornea based on a photolithographically patterned hydrogel construct. Biomed Microdevices, 2007, 9: 911–922
Binder PS. Hydrogel implants for the correction of myopia. Curr Eye Res, 1982, 2: 435–441
Sendele DD, Abelson MB, Kenyon KR, Hanninen LA. Intracorneal lens implantation. Arch Ophthalmol, 1983, 101: 940–944
Werblin TP, Patel AS, Barraquer JI. Initial human experience with Permalens myopic hydrogel intracorneal lens implants. Refract Corneal Surg, 1992, 8: 23–26
Werblin TP, Peiffer RL, Binder PS, McCarey BE, Patel AS. Eight years experience with Permalens intracorneal lenses in nonhuman primates. Refract Corneal Surg, 1992, 8: 12–22
McDonald MB, McCarey BE, Storie B, Beuerman RW, Salmeron B, van Rij G, Knight PM. Assessment of the long-term corneal response to hydrogel intrastromal lenses implanted in monkey eyes for up to five years. J Cataract Refract Surg, 1993, 19: 213–222
Beekhuis WH, McCarey BE, van Rij G, Waring GO, 3rd. Complications of hydrogel intracorneal lenses in monkeys. Arch Ophthalmol, 1987, 105: 116–122
McCarey BE, Lane SS, Lindstrom RL. Alloplastic corneal lenses. Int Ophthalmol Clin, 1988, 28: 155–164
Ruckhofer J, Bohnke M, Alzner E, Grabner G. Confocal microscopy after implantation of intrastromal corneal ring segments. Ophthalmology, 2000, 107: 2144–2151
Ruckhofer J, Stoiber J, Alzner E, Grabner G. One year results of European multicenter study of intrastromal corneal ring segments. Part 2: complications, visual symptoms, and patient satisfaction. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2001, 27: 287–296
Linebarger EJ, Song D, Ruckhofer J, Schanzlin DJ. Intacs: the intrastromal corneal ring. Int Ophthalmol Clin, 2000, 40: 199–208
Hicks CR, Crawford GJ, Dart JK, Grabner G, Holland EJ, Stulting RD, Tan DT, Bulsara M. AlphaCor: Clinical outcomes. Cornea, 2006, 25: 1034–1042
Trinkaus-Randall V, Wu XY, Tablante R, Tsuk A. Implantation of a synthetic cornea: design, development and biological response. Artif Organs, 1997, 21: 1185–1191
Myung D, Farooqui N, Waters D, Schaber S, Koh W, Carrasco M, Noolandi J, Frank CW, Ta CN. Glucose-permeable interpenetrating polymer network hydrogels for corneal implant applications: a pilot study. Curr Eye Res, 2008, 33: 29–43
Myung D, Farooqui N, Zheng LL, Koh W, Gupta S, Bakri A, Noolandi J, Cochran JR, Frank CW, Ta CN. Bioactive interpenetrating polymer network hydrogels that support corneal epithelial wound healing. J Biomed Mater Res A, 2009, 90: 70–81
Hartmann L, Watanabe K, Zheng LL, Kim CY, Beck SE, Huie P, Noolandi J, Cochran JR, Ta CN, Frank CW. Toward the development of an artificial cornea: improved stability of interpenetrating polymer networks. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater, 2011, 98: 8–17
Tan XW, Hartman L, Tan KP, Poh R, Myung D, Zheng LL, Waters D, Noolandi J, Beuerman RW, Frank CW, Ta CN, Tan DT, Mehta JS. In vivo biocompatibility of two PEG/PAA interpenetrating polymer networks as corneal inlays following deep stromal pocket implantation. J Mater Sci Mater Med, 2013, 24: 967–977
Chirila TV. First development of a polyurethane keratoprosthesis and its Australian connection: an unbeknown episode in the history of artificial cornea. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol, 2006, 34: 485–488
Evans MD, Dalton BA, Steele JD. Persistent adhesion of epithelial tissue is sensitive to polymer topography. J Biomed Mater Res, 1999, 46: 485–493
Evans MD, Taylor S, Dalton BA, Lohmann D. Polymer design for corneal epithelial tissue adhesion: pore density. J Biomed Mater Res A, 2003, 64: 357–364
Sianesi D, Marchionni G, Pasquale RJ. Organofluorine Chemistry: Principles and Commercial Applications. New York: Plenum Press, 1994
Capporiccio G, Corti C, Soldini S, Carniselli G. Perflurpolyether fluids for vaccum technologies. Ind Eng Chem Prod Res Rev, 1982, 21: 515–519
Moulder JF, Hammond IJS, Smith KL. Using angle-resolved ESCA to characterize Winchester disks. Appl Surf Sci, 1986, 25: 446–454
Legeais JM, Werner LP, Legeay G, Briat B, Renard G. In vivo study of a fluorocarbon polymer-coated intraocular lens in a rabbit model. J Cataract Refract Surg, 1998, 24: 371–379
Legeais JM, Rossi C, Renard G, Salvoldelli M, D’Hermies F, Pouliquen YJ. A new fluorocarbon for keratoprosthesis. Cornea, 1992, 11: 538–545
Legeais JM, Renard G, Parel JM, Savoldelli M, Pouliquen Y. Keratoprosthesis with biocolonizable microporous fluorocarbon haptic. Preliminary results in a 24-patient study. Arch Ophthalmol, 1995, 113: 757–763
Legeais JM, Renard G. A second generation of artificial cornea (Biokpro II). Biomaterials, 1998, 19: 1517–1522
Rice DE, Ihlenfeld JV. Ophthalmic device comprising a polymer of telechelic perfluoropolyether. US Patent 4818801, 1989
Evans MD, Prakasam RK, Vaddavalli PK, Hughes TC, Knower W, Wilkie JS, McLean KM, Johnson G, McFarland GA, Xie RZ, Sweeney DF. A perfluoropolyether corneal inlay for the correction of refractive error. Biomaterials, 2011, 32: 3158–3165
Xie RZ, Evans MD, Bojarski B, Hughes TC, Chan GY, Nguyen X, Wilkie JS, McLean KM, Vannas A, Sweeney DF. Two-year preclinical testing of perfluoropolyether polymer as a corneal inlay. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci, 2006, 47: 574–581
Evans MD, Chaouk H, Wilkie JS, Dalton BA, Taylor S, Xie RZ, Hughes TC, Johnson G, McFarland GA, Griesser HH, Steele JG, Meijs GF, Sweeney DF, McLean KM. The influence of surface topography of a porous perfluoropolyether polymer on corneal epithelial tissue growth and adhesion. Biomaterials, 2011, 32: 8870–8879
Evans MD, Xie RZ, Fabbri M, Bojarski B, Chaouk H, Wilkie JS, McLean KM, Cheng HY, Vannas A, Sweeney DF. Progress in the development of a synthetic corneal onlay. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci, 2002, 43: 3196–3201
Sweeney DF, Keay L, Carnt N, Holden BA. Practitioner guidelines for continuous wear with high Dk silicone hydrogel contact lenses. Clin Exp Optom, 2002, 85: 161–167
Hudges TC, Chan GYN. Design principles of synthetic inlays and onlays. Mater Forum, 2001, 25: 216–245
Evans MDM, Sweeney DF. Synthetic Corneal Implants. Cambridge, UK: Woodhead Publishing Ltd, 2010
Patel S, Marshall J, Fitzke FW 3rd. Refractive index of the human corneal epithelium and stroma. J Refract Surg, 1995, 11: 100–105
Sweeney DF, Xie RZ, O’Leary DJ, Vannas A, Odell R, Schindhelm K, Cheng HY, Steele JG, Holden BA. Nutritional requirements of the corneal epithelium and anterior stroma: clinical findings. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci, 1998, 39: 284–291
Xie RZ, Sweeney DF, Griesser HJ, Tout S, Cheng HY, Steele JG. A thin glycoprotein coating of a synthetic lenticule does not cause nutritional deficiency of the anterior cornea. Curr Eye Res, 1999, 18: 335–341
Chaouk H, Wilkie JS, Meijs GF. New porous perfluoropolyether membranes. J Appl Polym Sci, 2001, 80: 1756–1763
Xie RZ, Sweeney DF, Griesser HJ, Steele JG. Effects of surface topography on corneal epithelialization in vivo: a preliminary study. Aust N Z J Ophthalmol, 1998, 26 Suppl 1: S47–49
Steele JG, Johnson G, McLean KM, Beumer GJ, Griesser HJ. Effect of porosity and surface hydrophilicity on migration of epithelial tissue over synthetic polymer. J Biomed Mater Res, 2000, 50: 475–482
Fitton JH, Dalton BA, Beumer G, Johnson G, Griesser HJ, Steele JG. Surface topography can interfere with epithelial tissue migration. J Biomed Mater Res, 1998, 42: 245–257
Dalton BA, McFarland CD, Gengenbach TR, Griesser HJ, Steele JG. Polymer surface chemistry and bone cell migration. J Biomater Sci Polym Ed, 1998, 9: 781–799
Rafat M, Li F, Fagerholm P, Lagali NS, Watsky MA, Munger R, Matsuura T, Griffith M. PEG-stabilized carbodiimide crosslinked collagen-chitosan hydrogels for corneal tissue engineering. Biomaterials, 2008, 29: 3960–3972
Merrett K, Liu W, Mitra D, Camm KD, McLaughlin CR, Liu Y, Watsky MA, Li F, Griffith M, Fogg DE. Synthetic neoglycopolymer-recombinant human collagen hybrids as biomimetic crosslinking agents in corneal tissue engineering. Biomaterials, 2009, 30: 5403–5408
Liu W, Merrett K, Griffith M, Fagerholm P, Dravida S, Heyne B, Scaiano JC, Watsky MA, Shinozaki N, Lagali N, Munger R, Li F. Recombinant human collagen for tissue engineered corneal substitutes. Biomaterials, 2008, 29: 1147–1158
Liu W, Deng C, McLaughlin CR, Fagerholm P, Lagali NS, Heyne B, Scaiano JC, Watsky MA, Kato Y, Munger R, Shinozaki N, Li F, Griffith M. Collagen-phosphorylcholine interpenetrating network hydrogels as corneal substitutes. Biomaterials, 2009, 30: 1551–1559
Duan X, McLaughlin C, Griffith M, Sheardown H. Biofunctionalization of collagen for improved biological response: scaffolds for corneal tissue engineering. Biomaterials, 2007, 28: 78–88
Deng C, Li F, Hackett JM, Chaudhry SH, Toll FN, Toye B, Hodge W, Griffith M. Collagen and glycopolymer based hydrogel for potential corneal application. Acta Biomater, 2010, 6: 187–194
Ahn JI, Kuffova L, Merrett K, Mitra D, Forrester JV, Li F, Griffith M. Crosslinked collagen hydrogels as corneal implants: effects of sterically bulky vs. non-bulky carbodiimides as crosslinkers. Acta Biomater, 2013, 9: 7796–7805
Fagerholm P, Lagali NS, Merrett K, Jackson WB, Munger R, Liu Y, Polarek JW, Söderqvist M, Griffith M. A biosynthetic alternative to human donor tissue for inducing corneal regeneration: 24-month follow-up of a phase 1 clinical study. Sci Transl Med, 2010, 2: 46ra61
Fagerholm P, Lagali NS, Carlsson DJ, Merrett K, Griffith M. Corneal regeneration following implantation of a biomimetic tissue-engineered substitute. Clin Transl Sci, 2009, 2: 162–164
Wu J, Du Y, Watkins SC, Funderburgh JL, Wagner WR. The engineering of organized human corneal tissue through the spatial guidance of corneal stromal stem cells. Biomaterials, 2012, 33: 1343–1352
Wu J, Du Y, Mann MM, Yang E, Funderburgh JL, Wagner WR. Bioengineering organized, multilamellar human corneal stromal tissue by growth factor supplementation on highly aligned synthetic substrates. Tissue Eng Part A, 2013, 19: 2063–2075
Karamichos D, Guo XQ, Hutcheon AE, Zieske JD. Human corneal fibrosis: an in vitro model. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci, 2010, 51: 1382–1388
Karamichos D, Hutcheon AE, Zieske JD. Transforming growth factor-β3 regulates assembly of a non-fibrotic matrix in a 3D corneal model. J Tissue Eng Regen Med, 2011, 5: e228–238
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wu, J., Funderburgh, J.L. & Wagner, W.R. Biomaterials for refractive correction: corneal onlays and inlays. Sci. China Chem. 57, 501–509 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11426-014-5083-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11426-014-5083-1