Abstract
Purpose
To reduce the environmental impact of the building sector, environmental targets considering the full life cycle of buildings can be supportive. In recent years, various benchmarks based on Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) have been developed as part of regulations, labelling systems, sustainability rating tools and research studies. The objective of this paper is to critically analyse 23 existing benchmarking systems focusing on the benchmark methodology but also on the benchmark applications and communication.
Methods
The critical literature review consists of two parts. In a first part, the choices related to the assessment method, functional equivalent, definition of benchmark values, benchmark scope, benchmark applications and benchmark communication are compared. In the second part, benchmark values are compiled from literature and statistically analysed.
Results and discussion
The comparative analysis allows to identify the main approaches and methods used in benchmarking systems. For each evaluation aspect, the strengths and weaknesses of the various approaches are highlighted. The statistical analysis provides insight in the spread of benchmark values. Important variations are found between the literature sources which can be explained by differences in benchmark approach, scope, system boundaries and applications.
Conclusions
Based on the comparative analysis, recommendations are formulated for the development of LCA benchmarks for the building sector. The results of the statistical analysis furthermore provide reference values which can be used for the validation of future benchmarks. For global warming, the statistical values for the full life cycle impacts (i.e. embodied and operational impacts) range from about 15 up to 35 kg CO2 eq/m2.a.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allacker K (2010) Sustainable building, the development of an evaluation method. PhD dissertation, KU Leuven
Architectural Institute of Japan AIJ-LCA&LCW_ver.5.00 (n.d.-a)
Architectural Institute of Japan 2005 Industrial Input-Output Table (n.d.-b)
Association HQE (2012) Specific rules for the environmental assessment of buildings - version of June 2012 for the HQE Performance Pilot test 2012
Association HQE (2020) INIES database. www.inies.fr. Accessed 20 Jan 2020
Association P.E.P (2020) PEP ecopassport program. www.pep-ecopassport.org. Accessed 24 Jan 2020
BBSR (2020) eLCA. https://www.bauteileditor.de/. Accessed 22 Jan 2020
BMI (2015) Bilanzierungsregeln für die Erstellung von Ökobilanzen - version 2015
BMI (2020) ÖKOBAUDAT. www.oekobaudat.de/en. Accessed 22 Jan 2020
BMUB (2014) Bewertungssystem Nachhaltiges Bauen (BNB) - Neubau Laborgebäude - version 2014
BMUB (2015) Bewertungssystem Nachhaltiges Bauen (BNB) - Büro-und Verwaltungsgebäude - version 2015
BMUB (2017) Bewertungssystem Nachhaltiges Bauen (BNB) - Unterrichtsgebäude - version 2017
BRE (2018) Home Quality Mark ONE - Technical Manual - England, Scotland & Wales
BRE, AEC3, IES, WD Re-Thinking Ltd, Whole Life LTD (2020a) IMPACT compliant tools. http://www.impactwba.com/page.jsp?id=1. Accessed 22 Jan 2020
BRE, IES, Whole Life LTD, AEC3, WD Re-Thinking Ltd (2020b) IMPACT database. www.impactwba.com. Accessed 22 Jan 2020
Brejnrod KN, Kalbar P, Petersen S, Birkved M (2017) The absolute environmental performance of buildings. Build Environ 119:87–98. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2017.04.003
CEN (ed) (2012) EN 15978:2011 Sustainability of construction works - Assessment of environmental performance of buildings - Calculation method
CEN (ed) (2013) EN 15804:2012+A1 Sustainability of construction works - Environmental product declaration - Core rules for the product category of construction products
CEN (ed) (2019) EN 15804:2012+A2 Sustainability of construction works - Environmental product declaration - Core rules for the product category of construction products
Chandrakumar C, McLaren SJ, Dowdell D, Jaques R (2019) A top-down approach for setting climate targets for buildings: the case of a New Zealand detached house. IOP Conf Ser Earth Environ Sci 323:012183. https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/323/1/012183
CSTB (2020) ELODIE. https://logiciels.cstb.fr/batiments-et-villes-durables/performances-environnementales/elodie/. Accessed 17 Aug 2016
DGNB (2018) Life cycle assessments-a guide on using the LCA
DGNB (2020) ESUCO database
DGNB GmbH (2018) DGNB system - New buildings criteria set - version 2018
Ebert T, Essig N, Hauser G (2011) Green building certification systems: assessing sustainablility, international system comparison, economic impact of certifications. Edition Detail : Institut für international Architektur-Dokumentation, München
EC (2013) Open House - Assessment Guideline - Version 1.2 New Office Buildings
Ecoinvent centre (2020) Ecoinvent. www.ecoinvent.org. Accessed 20 Jan 2020
European Commission (2011) Communication from the European Commission - Roadmap to a Resource Efficient Europe
European Commission (2012) Communication from the European Commission - Innovating for Sustainable Growth: A Bio-economy for Europe
European Commission (2013) EeBGuide - Operational Guidance for Life Cycle Assessment Studies of the Energy Efficient Buildings Initiative, Online InfoHub. http://www.eebguide.eu/. Accessed 16 Mar 2017
European Commission (2018) Product Environmental Footprint Category Rules Guidance - Version 6.3
European Commission (2019) Energy efficiency in buildings. https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/topics/energy-efficiency/buildings. Accessed 2 Mar 2019
European Commission (2020) Long-term renovation strategies. https://ec.europa.eu/energy/topics/energy-efficiency/energy-efficient-buildings/long-term-renovation-strategies_en. Accessed 18 May 2020
European Union (2010) Directive 2010/31/EU on the energy performance of buildings
European Union (2015) Commision Directive (EU) 2015/996 of 19 May 2015 establishing common noise assessment methods according to Directive 2002/49/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council
Frischknecht R, Balouktsi M, Lützkendorf T, Aumann A, Birgisdottir H, Ruse EG, Hollberg A, Kuittinen M, Lavagna M, Lupišek A, Passer A, Peuportier B, Ramseier L, Röck M, Trigaux D, Vancso D (2019) Environmental benchmarks for buildings: needs, challenges and solutions—71st LCA forum, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Zürich, 18 June 2019. Int J Life Cycle Assess 24:2272–2280. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-019-01690-y
Ganassali S, Lavagna M, Campioli A (2016) LCA benchmarks in building’s environmental certification systems. Albufeira, Portugal
Gervasio H, Dimova S (2018a) Environmental benchmarks for buildings. EC-JRC, Ispra
Gervasio H, Dimova S (2018b) Model for Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) of buildings. EC-JRC, Ispra
HOINKA GMBH (2020) oekobilanz-bau.de. In: HOINKA. https://www.oekobilanz-bau.de/. Accessed 22 May 2020
Hollberg A, Lützkendorf T, Habert G (2019) Top-down or bottom-up?–how environmental benchmarks can support the design process. Build Environ 153:148–157. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2019.02.026
IBO (2020a) baubook eco2soft. https://www.baubook.info/eco2soft/. Accessed 22 Jan 2020
IBO (2020b) Baubook. www.baubook.info. Accessed 24 Jan 2020
ISO (ed) (2006a) Environmental management - Life cycle assessment - Requirements and guidelines (ISO 14044:2006)
ISO (ed) (2006b) Environmental management - Life cycle assessment - Principles and framework (ISO 14040:2006)
ISO (ed) (2017) ISO 21930 - Sustainability in buildings and civil engineering works - Core rules for environmental product declarations of construction products and services
JSBC, IBEC (2014) CASBEE for Building (New Construction) - Technical Manual (2014 Edition)
KBOB, eco-bau, IPB (2016) Données des écobilans dans la construction 2009/1:2016
König H (2008) Orientierungswerte für die Bewertung von Hochbauten erste Stufe: Bürogebäude
König H, De Cristofaro ML (2012) Benchmarks for life cycle costs and life cycle assessment of residential buildings. Build Res Inf 40:558–580. https://doi.org/10.1080/09613218.2012.702017
Landgraf B, Krimmling J, Müller H (2015) Entwicklung einer Methodik zur Festlegung von Benchmarks für LCA und LCC im Rahmen der BNB-Systementwicklung – BNB-Referenzmodell - Endbericht
Lasvaux S, Lebert A, Achim F, Grannec F, Hoxha E, Nibel S, Schiopu N, Chevalier J (2017) Towards guidance values for the environmental performance of buildings: application to the statistical analysis of 40 low-energy single family houses’ LCA in France. Int J Life Cycle Assess 22:657–674. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-016-1253-z
Lavagna M, Baldassarri C, Campioli A, Giorgi S, Dalla Valle A, Castellani V, Sala S (2018) Benchmarks for environmental impact of housing in Europe: definition of archetypes and LCA of the residential building stock. Build Environ 145:260–275. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2018.09.008
Lebert A, Lasvaux S, Grannec F, Nibel S, Achim F, Schiopu N (2013) Capitalisation des résultats de l’expérimentation HQE Performance - Analyse statistique - Action 22 - Rapport Final. CSTB, Paris
Lützkendorf T, Balouktsi M (2018) Principles for the development and use of benchmarks for life-cycle related environmental impacts of buildings. In: Life-cycle analysis and assessment in civil engineering-towards an integrated vision. CRC Press/Balkema, Ghent, pp 783–790
Mair am Tinkhof O, Strasser H, Prinz T, Herbst S, Schuster M, Tomschy R, Figl H, Fellner M, Ploß M, Roßkopf T (2017) Richt- und Zielwerte für Siedlungen zur integralen Bewertung der limaverträglichkeit von Gebäuden und Mobilitätsinfrastruktur in Neubausiedlungen. bmvit, Wien
Moschetti R, Mazzarella L, Nord N (2015) An overall methodology to define reference values for building sustainability parameters. Energy Build 88:413–427. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2014.11.071
PRé Consultants B.V. (2020) SimaPro. In: SimaPro. https://simapro.com/. Accessed 10 Sep 2019
Rasmussen FN, Birgisdottir H (2018) Life cycle assessment benchmarks for Danish office buildings. In: Life-cycle analysis and assessment in civil engineering-towards an integrated vision. CRC Press/Balkema, Ghent, pp 815–821
Rasmussen FN, Ganassali S, Zimmermann RK, Lavagna M, Campioli A, Birgisdóttir H (2019) LCA benchmarks for residential buildings in Northern Italy and Denmark–learnings from comparing two different contexts. Build Res Inf 47:833–849. https://doi.org/10.1080/09613218.2019.1613883
Ray-Jones A, Clegg D (1978) CI/SfB Construction Indexing Manual. RIBA Publications Ltd, London
République Française (2016) Référentiel “Energie-Carbone” pour les bâtiments neufs - Niveaux de performance “Energie-Carbone” pour les bâtiments neufs
République Française (2017) Référentiel “Energie-Carbone” pour les bâtiments neufs - Méthode d’évaluation de la performance énergétique et environnementale des bâtiments neufs
République Française (2019) List of software tools available E+/C-. http://www.batiment-energiecarbone.fr/en/list-of-software-tools-availablea20.html. Accessed 12 Nov 2020
Röck M, Saade MRM, Balouktsi M, Rasmussen FN, Birgisdottir H, Frischknecht R, Habert G, Lützkendorf T, Passer A (2020) Embodied GHG emissions of buildings–the hidden challenge for effective climate change mitigation. Appl Energy 258:114107. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2019.114107
RVO (2019) MilieuPrestatie Gebouwen. www.rvo.nl/onderwerpen/duurzaam-ondernemen/gebouwen/wetten-en-regels-gebouwen/nieuwbouw/milieuprestatie-gebouwen. Accessed 15 Nov 2019
SBi (2020) LCAbyg. https://lcabyg.dk/. Accessed 22 Jan 2020
SBK (2019) Bepalingsmethode Milieuprestatie Gebouwen en GWW-werken - versie 3.0
SBK (2020a) Validated tools for the Ducth LCA method. In: Natl. Milieu Database. https://milieudatabase.nl/milieuprestatie/rekeninstrumenten/. Accessed 20 Jan 2020
SBK (2020b) Nationale Milieudatabase. In: Natl. Milieudatabase. https://milieudatabase.nl/. Accessed 20 Jan 2020
Schlegl F, Gantner J, Traunspurger R, Albrecht S, Leistner P (2019) LCA of buildings in Germany: proposal for a future benchmark based on existing databases. Energy Build 194:342–350. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2019.04.038
SIA (2010) SIA 2032 - Graue Energie von Gebäude. Zurich
SIA (2017a) SIA 2040 - Energy Efficiency Path. Zurich
SIA (2017b) SIA - Effizienzpfad Energie - Korrigenda C1 zum Merkblatt SIA 2040:2017. Zurich
SIA (2018) Dokumentation D 0258 - Ergänzungen und Fallbeispiele zum Merkblatt SIA 2040:2017. Zurich
SIA (2020) Outil SIA 2040 relatif à la voie SIA vers l’efficacité énergétique. https://www.energytools.ch/index.php/fr/telecharger/logiciels/download/7-logiciels/67-tool-sia-2040-f. Accessed 22 Jan 2020
Simonen K, Rodriguez BX, De Wolf C (2017) Benchmarking the embodied carbon of buildings. Technol Des 1:208–218. https://doi.org/10.1080/24751448.2017.1354623
t.h.e. Software GmbH (2005) OGIP (Optimization of construction costs, energy consumption and environmental impact of buildings). http://www.the-software.de/
Thinkstep (2020a) GaBI software. www.gabi-software.com. Accessed 22 Jan 2020
Thinkstep (2020b) GaBi LCA Database. www.gabi-software.com/databases. Accessed 24 Jan 2020
Trigaux D, Allacker K, Debacker W (2019) Critical analysis of environmental benchmarks for buildings. IOP Conf Ser Earth Environ Sci 323: https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/323/1/012031
USGBC (2019) LEED v4 for Building Design and Construction
VITO, KU Leuven, TU Graz (2018) PEF4Buildings - Study on the application of the PEF Method and related guidance documents to a newly office building - Deliverable D4: Proposal for approach for benchmark and classes of performance for new office buildings
VTT (2012) Sustainability and performance assessment and benchmarking of building–final report. VTT Technology, Espoo
W/E adviseurs (2014) Onderzoek “Bepaling kwaliteitsniveaus milieuprestatie van woonfuncties.” Ministerie van Binnenlandse Zaken en Koningsrelaties, directie Bouwen, Utrecht
WEKA MEDIA (2020) LEGEP Software. www.legep.de. Accessed 23 Jul 2019
Zimmermann M, Althaus H-J, Haas A (2005) Benchmarks for sustainable construction. Energy Build 37:1147–1157. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2005.06.017
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by: Alexander Passer
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
ESM 1
(DOCX 241 kb)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Trigaux, D., Allacker, K. & Debacker, W. Environmental benchmarks for buildings: a critical literature review. Int J Life Cycle Assess 26, 1–21 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-020-01840-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-020-01840-7