Abstract
Within the context of U.K. law, the right to respect for private life, articulated in Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, and acknowledged more opaquely in domestic legislation and case law, is one whose scope is unclear. Nowhere is this brought into sharper relief than in cases where conduct which manifests a person’s sexual identity, or concerns her intimate relations with others, is prima facie criminal. In this essay I attempt, through a discussion of cases in which injury is caused in the context of relationships experienced inter-subjectively as private, to explore the contexts in which the law is prepared to legitimate that inter-subjective experience, and where it is not. Using cases in which injury has been caused purposively (in S/M sex), and incidentally (through the reckless transmission of HIV during sexual intercourse), the essay argues that the law is prepared to respect the right to respect for private life only in so far as the private life concerned is one which reinforces traditional gender roles and relationship types; in short, a life that one would be prepared to live publicly.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
P. Alldridge (1993) ArticleTitle‘‘Sex, Lies and the Criminal Law’‘ Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly 44 250
Bamforth, N., “Sado-Masochism and Consent”, Criminal Law Rev (1994), 661
C. Bessant (2004) ArticleTitle‘‘Domestic Violence Law – Punishment or Protection?’‘ Family Law 34 750
Bingham, T., “Should there be a Law to Protect Rights of Personal Privacy?”, European Human Rights Law Review (1996), 450
P Birkinshaw (1996) Freedom of Information: The Law, the Practice and the Ideal EditionNumber2 Butterworths London
S.B. Boyd (Eds) (1997) Challenging the Public/Private Divide: Feminism, Law, and Public Policy University of Toronto Press Toronto
S.H. Bronnit (1992) ArticleTitle‘‘Criminal Liability for the Transmission of HIV/AIDS’‘ Criminal Law Journal 16 85
Bronnit, S.H., “The Direction of Rape Law in Australia: Toward a Positive Consent Standard”, Criminal Law Journal (1994a), 249
Bronnit, S.H., “Spreading Disease and the Criminal Law”, Criminal Law Review (1994b), 21
P Cane (2002) Responsibility in Law and Morality Hart Publishing Oxford
J. Chalmers (2002) ArticleTitle‘‘Criminalizing HIV Transmission’‘ Journal of Medical Ethics 28 160 Occurrence Handle10.1136/jme.28.3.160 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD38zgtFaqug%3D%3D Occurrence Handle12042400
R. Clayton H Tomlinson (2000/2003) The Law of Human Rights Oxford University Press Oxford
J. Conaghan (1996) ArticleTitle‘‘Gendered Harm and the Law of Tort’‘ Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 16 407 Occurrence Handle10.1093/ojls/16.3.407
J. Conaghan (2002) ArticleTitle‘‘Law, Harm and Redress: A Feminist Perspective’‘ Legal Studies 22 IssueID3 319
M Dan-Cohen (2002) Harmful Thoughts: Essays on Law, Self and Morality Princeton University Press Princeton
Dine, J. & Watt, B., “The Transmission of Disease During Consensual Sexual Activity and the Concept of Associative Autonomy”, Web Journal of Current Legal Issues 4 (1998)
Dwyer, J., “Legislating A.I.D.S. Away: The Limited Role of Legal Persuasion in Minimizing the Spread of HIV”, Journal of Contemporary Health Law and Policy (1993), 167
R Elliott (1997) Criminal Law and HIV/A.I.D.S.: Final Report Canadian HIV/A.I.D.S. Legal Network and Canadian A.I.D.S. Society Montreal
Friedman, M., “Autonomy and Social Relationships”, in Feminists Rethink the Self, D.T. Meyers (ed.) (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1997)
Gostin, L., “The Politics of A.I.D.S.: Compulsory State Powers, Public Health and Civil Liberties”, Ohio State Law Journal (1989), 1017
R. Graycar (1987–1988) ArticleTitle‘‘Review of Katherine O’Donovan, Sexual Divisions in Law’‘ Journal of Family Law 26 265
K., Greene V.J., Derlega G.A. Yep S Petronio (2003) Privacy and Disclosure of HIV in Interpersonal Relationships: A Sourcebook for Researchers and Practitioners Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Mahwah, NJ
Hall, R. & Longstaff, L., “Defining Consent”, New Law Journal (1997), 840
J.C Inness (1992) Privacy, Intimacy and Isolation Oxford University Press New York
R. Klitzman R Bayer (2003) Mortal Secrets: Truth and Lies in the Age of A.I.D.S. Johns Hopkins University Press Baltimore
N Lacey (1998) Unspeakable Subjects Hart Publishing Oxford
G.T. Laurie (1991) ArticleTitle‘‘A.I.D.S. and Criminal Liability Under Scots Law’‘ Journal of the Law Society of Scotland 36 312
Z. Lazzarini et al. (2002) ArticleTitle‘‘Evaluating the Impact of Criminal Laws on HIV Risk Behavior’‘ Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 30 239
Lynch, A., “Criminal Liability for Transmitting Disease”, Criminal Law Review (1978), 612
C MacKinnon (1987) Feminism Unmodified Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
N. Naffine (1994) ArticleTitle‘‘Possession: Erotic Love in the Law of Rape’‘ Modern Law Review 57 10
J. Nedelsky (1989a) ArticleTitle‘‘Reconceiving Autonomy: Sources, Thoughts and Possibilities’‘ Yale Journal of Law and Feminism 1 7
J. Nedelsky (1989b) ArticleTitle‘‘Law, Boundaries and the Bounded Self’‘ Representations 30 162
Nedelsky, J., “Reconceiving Rights as Relationship”, Review of Constitutional Studies (1993), 1
Neill, B., “Privacy: A Challenge for the Next Century”, in Protecting Privacy, ed. B. Markesinis (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999)
E Neill (2001) Rites of Privacy and the Privacy Trade: On the Limits of Protection for the Self McGill-Queen’s University Press Montreal and Kingston
K O’Donovan (1985) Sexual Divisions in Law Weidenfeld and Nicolson London
F. Olsen (1985) ArticleTitle‘‘The Myth of State Intervention in the Family’‘ University of Michigan Law Review 18 835
Ormerod, D.C., & Gunn, M.J., “Criminal Liability for the Transmission of H.I.V”, Web Journal of Current Legal Issues 1 (1996)
F., Schoeman (Eds) (1984) Philosophical Dimensions of Privacy Cambridge University Press Cambridge
K.J.M. Smith (1991) ArticleTitle‘‘Sexual Etiquette, Public Interest and the Criminal Law’‘ Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly 42 309 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DyaK3MXlsFSrtL8%3D
Spencer, J.R., “Liability for Reckless Infection: Part 1”, New Law Journal (2004a), 384
Spencer, J.R., “Liability for Reckless Infection: Part 2”, New Law Journal (2004b), 448
Spencer, J.R., “Reckless Infection in the Court of Appeal: R v. Dica”, New Law Journal (2004c), 762
K.M. Sullivan M.A. Field (1988) ArticleTitle‘‘A.I.D.S. and the Coercive Power of the State’‘ Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review 23 139 Occurrence Handle11658994
Temkin, J. & Ashworth, A., “The Sexual Offences Act 2003: (1) Rape, Sexual Assault and the Problems of Consent”, Criminal Law Review (2004), 328
Urban Walker, M., “Picking up Pieces: Lives, Stories and Integrity”, in Feminists Rethink the Self, ed. D.T. Meyers (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1997)
Weait, M.J., “Fleshing it Out”, in Law and the Senses, eds. L. Flynn & L. Bentley (London: Pluto Press, 1996)
M.J. Weait (2001) ArticleTitle‘‘Taking the Blame: Criminal Law, Social Responsibility and the Sexual Transmission of HIV’‘ Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 23 441 Occurrence Handle10.1080/09649060110079837
Weait, M.J., “Dica: Knowledge, Consent and the Transmission of HIV”, New Law Journal (2004), 826
M.J. Weait (2005) ArticleTitle‘‘Criminal Law and the Sexual Transmission of HIV: R v. Dica’‘ Modern Law Review 68 IssueID1 120 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1468-2230.2005.00531.x
R. West (1988) ArticleTitle‘‘Jurisprudence and Gender’‘ University of Chicago Law Review 55 1
R West (1997) Caring for Justice New York University Press, 1997) New York
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Weait, M. Harm, Consent and the Limits of Privacy. Feminist Legal Stud 13, 97–122 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10691-005-1458-1
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10691-005-1458-1