Abstract
Monitoring is a crucial component of conservation in marine protected areas (MPAs) as it allows managers to detect changes to biodiversity and to infer cause of change. However, the complexities of sampling designs and associated statistical analyses can impede implementation of monitoring by managers. Two monitoring frameworks commonly used in marine environments are statistical testing and parameter estimation. For many managers these two approaches fail to help them detect change and infer causation for one or more reasons: the complexity of the statistical test, no decision-making structure and a sampling design that is suboptimal. In collaboration with marine park rangers in Egypt, we instigated a monitoring framework to detect impacts by snorkelers in a pragmatic but scientifically rigorous way. First, we used a literature review to define causal criteria to facilitate inference. This was essential because our sampling design was suboptimal due to a lack of baseline data and there was only one impact site. Second, we established a threshold level of coral damage that if exceeded would trigger management to reduce the impact of snorkelers. This provided a clear decision-making structure. Third, we estimated effect sizes with confidence intervals to detect change. For the field managers, this approach to detection was easier to understand than assessing a null hypothesis and provided critical information for decision making. At no stage during the short study period did snorkelers cause damage that exceeded the threshold and thus mitigation was not required. In situations of technical and financial constraints this framework will increase the implementation of effective impact monitoring for many activities in MPAs and enhance management of marine biodiversity.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abdulla, A. (2000). The role of science within environmental management: A case study of marine impact monitoring associated with the Great Barrier Reef marine park authority. MSc. Thesis, James Cook University of North Queensland.
Abdulla, A., Gomei, M., Maison, E., & Piante, C. (2008). Status of marine protected areas in the Mediterranean Sea. Malaga: IUCN Technical Series.
Alder, J. (1996). Have tropical marine protected areas worked? An initial analysis of their success. Coastal Management, 24, 97–114.
Allison, W. R. (1996). Snorkeler damage to reef corals in the Maldive Islands. Coral Reefs, 15, 215–218.
Anderson, M. J. (2001). A new method for non-parametric multivariate analysis of variance. Austral Ecology, 26, 32–46.
Andrew, N. E., & Mapstone, B. D. (1987). Sampling and the description of spatial pattern in marine ecology. Oceanography and Marine Biology Annual Review, 25, 39–90.
Barker, N. H. L., & Roberts, C. M. (2004). Scuba diver behaviour and the management of diving impacts on coral reefs. Biological Conservation, 120, 481–489.
Bence, J. R., Stewart-Oaten, A., & Schroeter, S. C. (1996). Estimating the size of an effect from a before-after-control-impact paired series design. In R. J. Schmitt, & C. W. Osenberg (Eds.), Detecting ecological impacts: Concepts and applications in coastal habitats. San Diego: Academic Press.
Benedetti-Cecchi, L. (2001). Beyond BACI: Optimization of environmental sampling designs through monitoring and simulations. Ecological Applications, 13, 783–799.
Beyers, D. W. (1998). Causal inference in environmental impact studies. Journal of the North American Benthological Society, 17, 367–373.
Buckley, R., Robinson, J., Carmody, J., & King, N. (2008). Monitoring for management of conservation and recreation in Australian protected areas. Biodiversity and Conservation, 17, 3589–3606.
Campbell, R. A., Mapstone, B. D., & Smith, A. D. (2001). Evaluating large-scale experimental designs for management of coral trout on the Great Barrier Reef. Ecological Applications, 11, 1763–1777.
Clarke, K. R. (1993). Non-parametric multivariate analyses of changes in community structure. Australian Journal of Ecology, 18, 117–143.
Clarke, K. R., Somerfield, P. J., Airoldi, L., & Warkwick, R. M. (2006). Exploring interactions by second-stage community analyses. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 338, 179–192.
Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioural sciences (2nd ed.). Hillsdale: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Connell, J. H., Hughes, T. P., & Wallace, C. C. (1997). A 30-year study of coral abundance, recruitment and disturbance at several scales in space and time. Ecological Monographs, 67, 461–488.
Connell, J. H., & Sousa, W. P. (1983). On the evidence needed to judge ecological stability or persistence. American Naturalist, 121, 789–824.
Cumming, G., & Finch, S. (2005). Inference by eye; confidence intervals and how to read pictures of data. American Psychologist, 60, 170–180.
Day, J. C. (2002). Zoning—lessons from the Great Barrier Reef marine park. Ocean and Coastal Management, 45, 139–156.
De Fontaubert, A. C., Downes, D. R., & Agardy, T. S. (1996). Biodiversity in the seas: Implementing the convention on biological diversity in marine and coastal habitats. Gland: IUCN.
Di Stefano, J. (2004). A confidence interval approach to data analysis. Forest Ecology and Management, 187, 173–183.
Downes, B. J., Barmuta, L. A., Fairweather, P. G., Faith, D. P., Keough, M. J., Lake, P. S., et al. (2002). Monitoring ecological impacts: Concepts and practice in flowing waters. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Fabricius, K. E., & De’ath, G. (2004). Identifying ecological change and its causes: A case study on coral reefs. Ecological Applications, 14, 1448–1465.
Field, S. A., O’Connor, P. J., Tyre, A. J., & Possingham, J. P. (2007). Making monitoring meaningful. Austral Ecology, 32, 485–491.
Fowler, J., Cohen, L., & Jarvis, P. (1998). Practical statistics for field biology (2nd ed.). Chichester: Wiley.
Fox, D. R. (2001). Environmental power analysis—a new perspective. Environmetrics, 12, 437–449.
Francis, J., Nilsson, A., & Waruinge, D. (2002). Marine protected areas in the eastern African region: How successful are they? Ambio, 31, 503–511.
Green, H. G. (1979). Sampling design and statistical methods for environmental biologists. Canada: Wiley.
Halpern, B. S., & Warner, R. R. (2003). Matching marine reserve design to reserve objectives. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B: Biological Sciences, 270, 1871–1878.
Harriott, V. J. (2002). Marine tourism impacts and their management on the Great Barrier Reef. Townsville: CRC Reef Research Centre, CRC Reef Research Centre Technical Report No 46.
Hatcher, B. G., Johannes, R. E., & Robertson, A. I. (1989). Review of research relevant to the conservation of shallow tropical marine ecosystems. Oceanography Marine Biological Annual Review, 27, 337–414.
Hawkins, J. P., & Roberts, C. M. (1994). The growth of coastal tourism in the Red Sea: Present and future effects on coral reefs. Ambio, 23, 503–508.
Hill, A. B. (1965). The environment and disease: Association or causation? Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 58, 295–300.
Hocking, M., Stolton, S., & Dudley, N. (2000). Evaluating effectiveness: A framework for assessing the management of protected areas. Gland: IUCN.
Johnson, D. H. (1999). The insignificance of statistical significance testing. Journal of Wildlife Management, 63, 763–772.
Keough, M. J., & Mapstone, B. D. (1995). Protocols for designing marine ecological monitoring programs associated with BEK Mills. Canberra: CSIRO, Tech. Report No. 11, National Pulp Mills Research Program.
Keppel, G. (1991). Design and analysis: A researcher’s handbook. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Liddle, M. J., & Kay, A. M. (1987). Resistance, survival and recovery of trampled corals on the Great Barrier Reef. Biological Conservation, 42, 1–18.
Loya, Y. (1976). Skeletal regeneration in a Red Sea scleractinian coral population. Nature, 261, 491–492.
Manly, B. F. J. (2001). Statistics for environmental science and management. Boca Raton: Chapman and Hall/CRC.
Marion, J. L., & Rogers, C. S. (1994). The applicability of terrestrial visitor impact management strategies to the protection of coral reefs. Ocean and Coastal Management, 22, 153–163.
Marsh, H. (1995). The limits of detectable change. In G. C. Grigg, P. T. Hale, & D. Lunney (Eds.), Conservation through sustainable use of wildlife (pp. 122–130). Brisbane: University of Queensland.
Marshall, N. A., & Abdulla, A. (2009). Socio-economic and institutional challenges to establishment of marine protected areas in the southern and eastern mediterranean. Gland: IUCN Technical Series.
Marshall, P. (2000). Skeletal damage in reef corals: Relating resistance to colony morphology. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 200, 177–189.
McArdle, B. H. (1996). Levels-of-evidence in studies of competition, predation and disease. New Zealand Journal of Ecology, 20, 7–15.
McDonald, T. L., Erickson, W. P., & McDonald, L. L. (2000). Analysis of count data from before-after control-impact studies. Journal of Agricultural, Biological and Environmental Statistics, 5, 262–279.
McNeill, S. E. (1994). The selection and design of marine protected areas: Australia as a case study. Biodiversity and Conservation, 3, 586–605.
Meyer, C. G., & Holland, K. N. (2008). Spatial dynamics and substrate impacts of recreational snorkelers and SCUBA divers in Hawaiian marine protected areas. Journal of Coastal Conservation, 12, 209–216.
Musso, B. M., & Inglis, G. J. (1998). Developing reliable coral reef monitoring programs for marine tourism operators and community volunteers. Townsville: CRC Reef Research Centre, Technical Report No. 24.
Oliver, J. (1995). Is the ‘limit of acceptable change’ concept useful for environmental managers?: A case study from the Great Barrier Reef marine park. In G. C. Grigg, P. T. Hale & D. Lunney (Eds.), Conservation through sustainable use of wildlife (pp. 131–139). Brisbane: University of Queensland.
Osenberg, C. W., & Schmitt, R. J. (1996). Detecting ecological impacts caused by human activities. In R. J. Schmitt, & C. W. Osenberg (Eds.), Detecting ecological impacts: Concepts and applications in coastal habitats. San Diego: Academic Press.
Perry, J. N. (1986). Multiple-comparison procedures: A dissenting view. Journal of Economic Entomology, 79, 1149–1155.
Plathong, S., Inglis, G. J., & Huber, M. E. (2000). Effects of self-guided snorkelling trails in a tropical marine park. Conservation Biology, 14, 1821–1830.
Pomeroy, R. S., Parks, J. E., & Watson, L. M. (2007). How is your MPA doing? A guidebook of natural and social indicators for evaluating marine protected area management effectiveness. Gland: IUCN.
Pomeroy, R. S., Watson, L. M., Parks, J. E., & Cid, G. A. (2005). How is your MPA doing? A methodology for evaluating the management effectiveness of marine protected areas. Ocean and Coastal Management, 48, 485–502.
Preen, A. (1998). Marine protected areas and dugong conservation along Australia’s Indian Ocean coast. Journal Environmental Management, 22, 173–181.
Riegl, B., & Velimirov, B. (1991). How many damaged corals in Red Sea reef systems? A quantitative survey. Hydrobiologia, 216(217), 249–256.
Rodgers, K., Cox, E., & Newtson, C. (2003). Effects of mechanical fracturing and experimental trampling on Hawaiian corals. Environmental Management, 31, 377–384.
Rouphael, A. B., & Hanafy, M. (2007). An alternative management framework to limit the impact of SCUBA divers on coral assemblages. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 15, 91–103.
Rouphael, A. B., & Inglis, G. J. (2002). Increased spatial and temporal variability in coral damage caused by recreational scuba diving. Ecological Applications, 12, 422–440.
Russ, G. R., & Alcala, A. C. (1989). Effects of intense fishing pressure on an assemblage of coral reef fishes. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 56, 13–27.
Salm, R. V., & Clark, J. R. (2000). Marine and coastal protected areas: A guide for planners and managers. Gland: International Union for the Conservation of Nature.
Stankey, G. H., Cole, D. N., Lucas, R. C., Petersen, M. E., & Frissell, S. S. (1985). The limits of acceptable change (LAC) system for wilderness planning. Ogden: USDA Forest Service Intermountain Forest and Range Experiment Station, General Technical Report INT-176.
Stewart-Oaten, A. (1996). Goals in environmental monitoring. In R. J. Schmitt, & C. W. Osenberg (Eds.), Detecting ecological impacts: Concepts and applications in coastal habitats. San Diego: Academic Press.
Suter, G. W. (1996). Abuse of hypothesis testing statistics in ecological risk assessment. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment, 2, 331–347.
Tabata, R. (1989). The use of nearshore dive sites by recreational dive operators in Hawaii. Coastal Zone, 89, 2865–2875.
Underwood, A. J. (1989). The analysis of stress in natural population. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 37, 51–78.
Underwood, A. J. (1993). The mechanics of spatially replicated sampling programs to detect environmental impacts in a variable world. Australian Journal of Ecology, 18, 99–116.
Underwood, A. J. (1996). On beyond BACI: Sampling designs that might reliably detect environmental disturbance. In R. J. Schmitt, & C. W. Osenberg (Eds.), Detecting ecological impacts: Concepts and applications in coastal habitats. San Diego: Academic Press.
Underwood, A. J. (1997). Experiments in ecology: Their logical design and interpretation using analysis of variance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Underwood, A. J. (2000). Importance of experimental design in detecting and measuring stresses in marine populations. Journal of Aquatic Ecosystem Stress and Recovery, 7, 3–24.
Underwood, A. J., & Chapman, M. G. (1999). Problems and practical solutions for quantitative assessment of biodiversity of invertebrates in coastal habitats. In W. Ponder, & D. Lunney (Eds.), The other 99%. The conservation and biodiversity of invertebrates (pp. 19–25). Mosman: Royal Zoological Society of New South Wales.
Wonnacott, T. (1987). Confidence intervals or hypothesis testing? Journal of Applied Statistics, 14, 195–201.
Yoccoz, N. G. (1991). Use, overuse and misuse of significance testing in evolutionary biology and ecology. Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America, 72, 106–111.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rouphael, A.B., Abdulla, A. & Said, Y. A framework for practical and rigorous impact monitoring by field managers of marine protected areas. Environ Monit Assess 180, 557–572 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-010-1805-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-010-1805-9