Abstract
Autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) and osteochondral autograft transplantation (OAT or mosaicplasty) are two effective surgeries for the treatment of large cartilage defects for more than two decades. But there are always some controversies about which one has the better outcomes for the patients. The purpose of this meta-analysis is to compare the outcomes of these two surgeries and give an advice to the clinical practices. The literature search was performed on multiple electronic databases with specific included criteria. After the assessments, five Randomized controlled trials (level II) were included and two of them were in the same cohort. The continuous data of outcomes were categorized into ranked ones (excellent, good, fair and poor) for comparisons. In the six comparisons of excellent or good results and poor results, the outcomes of ACI were significantly better than OAT in only one comparison (RR 2.57, 95 % CI 1.09–6.07, P = 0.03) while others had no significant differences. We may reach a primary conclusion that there is no significant different outcome between ACI and OAT in a short-term follow-up but it may indicate that the patients with OAT may be more likely to have worse condition than that with ACI for a long-term period.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bedi A, Feeley BT, Williams RR (2010) Management of articular cartilage defects of the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Am 92:994–1009
Bekkers J, Inklaar M, Saris DB (2009) Treatment selection in articular cartilage lesions of the knee: a systematic review. Am J Sports Med 37:148S–155S
Bentley G, Biant LC, Carrington RW, Akmal M, Goldberg A, Williams AM, Skinner JA, Pringle J (2003) A prospective, randomised comparison of autologous chondrocyte implantation versus mosaicplasty for osteochondral defects in the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Br 85-B:223–230
Bentley G, Biant LC, Vijayan S, Macmull S, Skinner JA, Carrington RW (2012) Minimum ten-year results of a prospective randomised study of autologous chondrocyte implantation versus mosaicplasty for symptomatic articular cartilage lesions of the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Br 94-B:504–509
Brittberg M (2010) Cell carriers as the next generation of cell therapy for cartilage repair: a review of the matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation procedure. Am J Sports Med 38:1259–1271
Brittberg M, Lindahl A, Nilsson A, Ohlsson C, Isaksson O, Peterson L (1994) Treatment of deep cartilage defects in the knee with autologous chondrocyte transplantation. N Engl J Med 331:889–895
Chiang H, Jiang C (2009) Repair of articular cartilage defects: review and perspectives. J Formos Med Assoc 108:87–101
Chilelli BJ, Mastrocola MR, Gomoll AH (2014) Autologous chondrocyte implantation: surgical technique and outcomes. Oper Tech Orthop 24:246–252
Dozin B, Malpeli M, Cancedda R, Bruzzi P, Calcagno S, Molfetta L, Priano F, Kon E, Marcacci M (2005) Comparative evaluation of autologous chondrocyte implantation and mosaicplasty: a multicentered randomized clinical trial. Clin J Sport Med 15:220–226
Goyal D, Keyhani S, Goyal A, Lee EH, Hui JHP, Vaziri AS (2014) Evidence-based status of osteochondral cylinder transfer techniques: a systematic review of level I and II studies. Arthroscopy 30:497–505
Hangody L, Karpati Z (1994) New possibilities in the management of severe circumscribed cartilage damage in the knee. Magy Traumatol Ortop Kezseb Plasztikai Seb 37:237–243
Hangody L, Kish G, Karpati Z, Udvarhelyi I, Szigeti I, Bely M (1998) Mosaicplasty for the treatment of articular cartilage defects: application in clinical practice. Orthopedics 21:751–756
Harris JD, Siston RA, Brophy RH, Lattermann C, Carey JL, Flanigan DC (2011) Failures, re-operations, and complications after autologous chondrocyte implantation—a systematic review. Osteoarthr Cartil 19:779–791
Horas U, Pelinkovic D, Herr G, Aigner T, Schnettler R (2003) Autologous chondrocyte implantation and osteochondral cylinder transplantation in cartilage repair of the knee joint A prospective, comparative trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am 85-A:185–192
Huey DJ, Hu JC, Athanasiou KA (2012) Unlike bone, cartilage regeneration remains elusive. Science 338:917–921
Lim H, Bae J, Song S, Park Y, Kim S (2012) Current treatments of isolated articular cartilage lesions of the knee achieve similar outcomes. Clin Orthop Relat Res 470:2261–2267
Marlovits S, Zeller P, Singer P, Resinger C, Vecsei V (2006) Cartilage repair: generations of autologous chondrocyte transplantation. Eur J Radiol 57:24–31
Matsusue Y, Yamamuro T, Hama H (1993) Arthroscopic multiple osteochondral transplantation to the chondral defect in the knee associated with anterior cruciate ligament disruption. Arthroscopy 9:318–321
Perera JR, Gikas PD, Bentley G (2012) The present state of treatments for articular cartilage defects in the knee. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 94:381–387
Robert H (2011) Chondral repair of the knee joint using mosaicplasty. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res 97:418–429
Roberts S, Menage J, Sandell LJ, Evans EH, Richardson JB (2009) Immunohistochemical study of collagen types I and II and procollagen IIA in human cartilage repair tissue following autologous chondrocyte implantation. Knee 16:398–404
Smith GD, Knutsen G, Richardson JB (2005) A clinical review of cartilage repair techniques. J Bone Joint Surg Br 87:445–449
Stroh A, Johnson A, Mont M (2011) Surgical implants and technologies for cartilage repair and preservation of the knee. Expert Rev Med Devices 8:339–356
Vasiliadis HS, Wasiak J (2010) Autologous chondrocyte implantation for full thickness articular cartilage defects of the knee. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 10:CD003323
Acknowledgments
This study was supported by grants from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 81472079).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Zeng Li and Tianyi Zhu have contributed equally to this study.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Li, Z., Zhu, T. & Fan, W. Osteochondral autograft transplantation or autologous chondrocyte implantation for large cartilage defects of the knee: a meta-analysis. Cell Tissue Bank 17, 59–67 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10561-015-9515-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10561-015-9515-8