Abstract
Introduction
National guidance in most medical specialties supports the full and open disclosure of diagnoses to patients.
Results
Surveys show that most patients want to know their diagnosis, whether it is medical or psychiatric, and a substantial proportion want to know detailed prognostic information. In the past, oncologists have been criticised for failing to reveal a diagnosis of cancer to patients in a sensitive and timely manner. Over the last 30 years, there is evidence that this practice has improved. Yet, clinicians still have difficulty when the diagnosis is not certain, when the prognosis is unfavourable, and when relatives request “not to tell.” All of these influences are present in mental health settings.
Discussion
Psychiatrists and general practitioners may be equally reluctant to reveal difficult diagnoses and prognoses of conditions such as schizophrenia and dementia. The reluctance to reveal a difficult diagnosis may be a routine, but little acknowledged the aspect of medical care that should be incorporated into undergraduate and postgraduate education and openly discussed during peer group supervision.
References
Fallowfield L, Jenkins V (2004) Communicating sad, bad, and difficult news in medicine. Lancet 363:312–319
Thorne SE, Bultz BD, Baile WF (2005) Is there a cost to poor communication in cancer care?: a critical review of the literature. Psycho-Oncology 14(10):875–884
Fothergill A, Edwards D, Burnard P (2004) Stress, burnout, coping and stress management in psychiatrists: findings from a systematic review. Int J Soc Psychiatry 50(1):54–65
Travado L, Grassi L, Gil F, Ventura C, Martins C (2005) Physician–patient communication among Southern European cancer physicians: the influence of psychosocial orientation and burnout. Psycho-Oncology 14(8):661–670
Panagopoulou E, Kersbergen B, Maes S (2002) The effects of emotional (non-) expression in (chronic) disease: a meta-analytic review. Psychol Health 17(5):529–545
Eidinger RN, Schapira DV (1984) Cancer patients’ insight into their treatment, prognosis, and unconventional therapies. Cancer 53:2736–2740
Mackillop WJ, Stewart WE, Ginsburg AD, Stewart SS (1988) Cancer patients’ perceptions of their disease and its treatment. Br J Cancer 58:355–358
Sapir R, Catane R, Kaufman B, Isacson R, Segal A, Wein S, Cherny NI (2000) Cancer patient expectations of and communication with oncologists and oncology nurses: the experience of an integrated oncology and palliative care service. Support Care Cancer 8(6):437–438 (November)
Goncalves F, Marques A, Rocha S, Leitao P, Mesquita T, Moutinho S (2005) Breaking bad news: experiences and preferences of advanced cancer patients at a Portuguese oncology centre. Palliat Med 19(7):526–531
Green BN, Johnson CD, Adams A (2001) Writing narrative literature reviews for peer-reviewed journals: secrets of the trade. J Sports Chiropr Rehabil 15(1):5–19 (March)
World Psychiatric Association (1983) The declaration of Hawaii http://www.codex.uu.se/texts/hawaii.html (accessed 15 January 2007)
Department of Health (1992) The patient’s charter. Department of Health, London
Nandhra H et al (2004) Doctors’ and patients’ experience of copying letters to patients. Psychiatric Bull 28:40–42
Jefford M, Tattersall MNH (2002) Informing and involving cancer patients in their own care. Lancet Oncol 3:629–637
National Institute for Clinical Excellence (2004) Improving supportive and palliative care for adults with cancer. National Institute for Clinical Excellence, London
National Council For Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services (2003) Breaking bad news...regional guidelines. Department of Health, Social Services and Public Safety, Belfast (February)
Okamura H, Uchitomi Y, Sasako M, Eguchi K, Kakizoe T (1998) Guidelines for telling the truth to cancer patients. Jpn J Clin Oncol 28(1):1–4
Fearnley K, McLennan, J, Weaks D (1997) The right to know? Sharing the diagnosis of dementia. Alzheimer Scotland Action on Dementia, Edinburgh
Pratt R, Wilkinson H (2001) ‘Tell me the truth’: the effect of being told the diagnosis of dementia from the perspective of the person with dementia. Mental Health Foundation, London
Royal College of Psychiatrists (2005) Forgetful but not forgotten: assessment and aspects of treatment of people with dementia by a specialist old age psychiatry service. Royal College of Psychiatrists, UK (Council Report CR119, April)
Department of Health (2001) National service framework for older people. Department of Health, London
Alzheimer Society of Canada (1997) Tough issues: ethical guidelines of the Alzheimer society of Canada. Alzheimer Canada, Toronto
Alzheimer’s Disease Association (2001) Ethical issues in Alzheimer’s disease. Alzheimer Disease Association, Chicago, Il
National Institute of Clinical Excellence (2002) Schizophrenia core interventions in the treatment and management of schizophrenia in primary and secondary care (pre-publication draft). National Institute of Clinical Excellence, London
Goodwin GM (2003) Evidence-based guidelines for treating bipolar disorder: recommendations from the British Association for Psychopharmacology. J Psychopharmacol 17(2):149–173
Mystakidou K, Parpa E, Tsilika E et al (2004) Cancer information disclosure in different cultural contexts. Support Care Cancer 12:147–154
Miyashita M, Hashimoto S, Kawa M, Shima Y, Kawagoe H, Hase T, Shinjo Y, Suemasu K (2006) Attitudes toward disease and prognosis disclosure and decision making for terminally ill patients in Japan, based on a nationwide random sampling survey of the general population and medical practitioners. Palliat Support Care 4(4):389–398
Jenkins V, Fallowfield L, Saul J (2001) Information needs of patients with cancer: results from a large study in UK cancer centres. Br J Cancer 84:48–51
Blackhall LJ, Murphy ST, Frank G, Michel V, Azen S (1995) Ethnicity and attitudes towards patient autonomy. JAMA 274:820–825
Roy R, Symonds RP, Kumar DM, Ibrahim K, Mitchell AJ, Fallowfield L (2005) The use of denial in an ethnically diverse British cancer population. A cross-sectional study. Br J Cancer 92(8):1393–1397
Oken D (1961) What to tell cancer patients. A study of medical attitudes. JAMA 175:1120–1128
Novack DH, Plumer R, Smith RL, Ochitill H, Morrow GR, Bennett JM (1979) Changes in physicians’ attitudes toward telling the cancer patient. JAMA 241:897–900
Kelly WD, Friesen SR (1950) Do cancer patients want to be told? Surgery 27:822–826
Estape J, Palombo H, Hernandez E, Daniels M, Estape T, Grau JJ, Vinolas N, Mane JM (1992) Cancer diagnosis disclosure in a Spanish hospital. Ann Oncol 3:451–454
Dossios Th, Markopoulos Ch, Vlachos I, Liatsos P (1986) Aspects of Greek doctors on the subject if the cancer patient should know his disease. Hellenic Armed Forces Med Rev 20:309–315
Gotay CG (1996) Cultural variation in family adjustment to cancer. In: Baider L, Cooper LC, Kaplan De-Nour A (eds) Cancer and the family. Wiley, New York, pp 31–49
Holland JC, Geary N, Marchini A, Tross S (1987) An international survey of physician attitudes and practice in regard to revealing the diagnosis of cancer. Cancer Investig 5:151–154
Li S, Chou LJ (1997) Communication with the cancer patient in China. Ann N Y Acad Sci 809:243–248
Al-Ahwal M (1998) Cancer patients awareness of their disease and prognosis. Ann Saudi Med 18:187–189
El-Chazzali S (1997) Is it wise to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth to cancer patients? Ann N Y Acad Sci 809:97–108
Tan TK, Teo FC, Wong K, Lim HL (1993) Cancer: to tell or not to tell? Singap Med J 34:202–203
Uchitomi Y, Yamawaki S (1997) Truth-telling practice in cancer care in Japan. Ann N Y Acad Sci 809:290–299
Elwyn TS, Fetters MD, Gorenflo DW, Tsuda T (1998) Cancer disclosure in Japan: historical comparisons, current practices. Soc Sci Med 46(9):1151–1163
Horikawa N, Yamazaki T, Sagawa M, Nagata T (2000) Changes in disclosure of information to cancer patients in a general hospital in Japan. Gen Hosp Psych 22:37–42
Hagerty RG, Butow PN, Ellis PM et al (2005) Communicating with realism and hope: incurable cancer patients’ views on the disclosure of prognosis. J Clin Oncol 23(6):1278–1288
Hagerty RG, Butow PN, Ellis PM, Dimitry S, Tattersall MHN (2005) Communicating prognosis in cancer care: a systematic review of the literature. Ann Oncol 16(7):1005–1053
Lobb EA, Kenny DT, Butow PN et al (2001) Women’s preferences for discussion of prognosis in early breast cancer. Health Expect 4:48–57
Culha Atesci F, Baltalarli B, Oguzha-noglu K et al (2004) Psychiatric morbidity among cancer patients and awareness of illness. Support Care Cancer 12:161–167
Lamont EB, Christakis NA (2001) Prognostic disclosure to patients with cancer near the end of life. Ann Intern Med 134:1096–1105
Gattellari M, Voigt KJ, Butow PN et al (2002) When the treatment goal is not cure: are cancer patients equipped to make informed decisions? J Clin Oncol 20:503–513
Costantini M, Morasso G, Montella M, Borgia P, Cecioni R, Beccaro M, Sguazzotti E, Bruzzi P (2006) Diagnosis and prognosis disclosure among cancer patients. Results from an Italian mortality follow-back survey. Ann Oncol 17(5):853–859 (May)
Horikawa N, Yamazaki T, Sagawa M, Nagata T (1999) The disclosure of information to cancer patients and its relationship to their mental state in a consultation-liaison psychiatry setting in Japan. Gen Hosp Psych 21:368–373
Baile WF, Lenzi R, Parker PA, Buckman R, Cohen L (2002) Oncologists’ attitudes toward and practices in giving bad news: an exploratory study. J Clin Oncol 20:2189–2196
The AM, Hak T, Koeter G et al (2000) Collusion in doctor–patient communication about imminent death: an ethnographic study. BMJ 321(7273):1376–1381
Lamont EB, Christakis NA (2003) Complexities in prognostication in advanced cancer “to help them live their lives the way they want to”. JAMA 2901:98–102
Helft PR (2005) Necessary collusion: prognostic communication with advanced cancer patients. J Clin Oncol 23:3146–3150
Fallowfield LJ, Jenkins VA, Beveridge HA (2002) Truth may hurt but deceit hurts more: communication in palliative care. Palliat Med 16:297–303
Shilling V, Jenkins V, Fallowfield L (2003) Factors affecting patient and clinician satisfaction with the clinical consultation: can communication skills training for clinicians improve satisfaction? Psycho-Oncology 12(6):599–611 (September)
Christakis NA, Lamont EB (2000) Extent and determinants of error in doctors’ prognoses in terminally ill patients: prospective cohort study. BMJ 320:469–472
Kutner JS, Steiner JF, Corbett KK et al (1999) Information needs in terminal illness. Soc Sci Med 48:1341–1352
Phungrassami T, Sriplung H, Roka A, Mintrasak E, Peerawong T, Aegem U (2003) Disclosure of a cancer diagnosis in Thai patients treated with radiotherapy. Soc Sci Med 57:1675–1682
Hagerty RG, Butow PN, Ellis PA, Lobb EA, Pendlebury S, Leighl, N, Goldstein D, Lo SK, Tattersall MHN (2004) Cancer patient preferences for communication of prognosis in the metastatic setting. J Clin Oncol 22:1721–1730
Fried TR, Bradley EH, John O’Leary J (2003) Prognosis communication in serious illness: perceptions of older patients, caregivers, and clinicians. J Am Geriatr Soc 51:1398–1403
Ozdogan M, Samur M, Bozcuk HS, Coban E, Artac M, Savas B, Kara A, Topcu Z, Sualp Y (2004) “Do not tell”: what factors affect relatives’ attitudes to honest disclosure of diagnosis to cancer patients? Support Care Cancer 12(7):497–502
Elwyn TS, Fetters MD, Sasakic H, Tsudad T (2002) Responsibility and cancer disclosure in Japan. Soc Sci Med 54:281–293
Clayton JM, Butow PN, Arnold RM, Tattersall MH (2005) Fostering coping and nurturing hope when discussing the future with terminally ill cancer patients and their caregivers. Cancer 103(9):1965–1975 (May 1)
Gordon EJ, Daugherty CK (2003) ‘Hitting you over the head’: oncologists’ disclosure of prognosis to advanced cancer patients. Bioethics 17:142–168
Maguire P (1999) Improving communication with cancer patients. Eur J Cancer 35(10):1415–1422
Friedrichsen M, Milberg A (2006) Concerns about losing control when breaking bad news to terminally ill patients with cancer: physicians’ perspective. J Palliat Med 9(3):673–682
Bamford C, Lamont S, Eccles M, Robinson L May C, Bond J (2004) Disclosing a diagnosis of dementia: a systematic review. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 19:151–169
Erde EL, Nadal EC, Scholl TO (1988) On truth telling and the diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease. J Fam Pract 26:401–406
Pinner G, Bouman WP (2003) Attitudes of patients with mild dementia and their carers towards disclosure of the diagnosis. Int Psychogeriatr 15(3):279–288 (September)
Elson P (2006) Do older adults presenting with memory complaints wish to be told if later diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease? Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 21:419–425
MetLife Foundation. (2006) Alzheimer’s survey: what America thinks. http://www.metlife.com/WPSAssets/20538296421147208330V1FAlzheimersSurvey.pdf (accessed 17th January 2007)
Husband HJ (2000) Diagnostic disclosure in dementia—an opportunity for intervention. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 15:544–547
Cantegreil-Kallen I, Lieberherr D, Garcia A et al (2004) La détection de la maladie d’Alzheimer: résultats d’une enquête auprès des médecins du réseau Sentinelles. Rev Med Interne 25(8):548–555
Marzanski M (2000) Would you like to know what is wrong with you? On telling the truth to patients with dementia. J Med Ethics 26:108–113
Pratt R, Wilkinson H (2001) ‘Tell me the truth’—the effect of being told the diagnosis of dementia from the perspective of the person with dementia. Mental Health Foundation, London
Holroyd S, Turnbull Q, Wolf AM (2002) What are patients and their families told about the diagnosis of dementia? Results of a family survey. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 17(3):218–221 (March)
Maguire CP, Kirby M, Coen R, Coakley D, Lawlor BA, O’Neill D (1996) Family members’ attitudes toward telling the patient with Alzheimer’s disease their diagnosis. BMJ 313:529–530
Barnes RC (1997) Telling the diagnosis to patients with Alzheimer’s disease: relatives should act as proxy for patient. BMJ 314:375–376
Pucci E, Belardinelli N, Borsetti G, Guiliani G (2003) Relatives’ attitudes towards informing patients about the diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease. J Med Ethics 29:51–54
Shergill SS, Barker D, Greenberg M (1998) Communication of psychiatric diagnosis. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 33:32–38
Bayle FJ, Chauchot F, Maurel M, Ledoriol AL, Gerard A, Pascal JC, Azorin JM, Olie JP, Loo H (1999) Survey on the announcement of schizophrenia diagnosis in France. Encéphale 25:603–611
Clafferty RA, McCabe W, Brown KW (2001) Conspiracy of silence? Telling patients with schizophrenia their diagnosis. Psychiatri Bull 25:336–339
Cody M, Beck C, Shue VM, Pope S (2002) Reported practices of primary care physicians in the diagnosis and management of dementia. Aging Ment Health 6:72–76
Downs M, Cook A, Rae C, Collins KE (2000) Caring for patients with dementia: the GP perspective. Aging Ment Health 4:301–304
Cahill S, Clark M, Walsh C, O’Connel H, Lawlor B (2006) Dementia in primary care: the first survey of Irish general practitioners. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 21(4):319–324
Cantegreil-Kallen I, Turbelin C, Olaya E, Blanchon T, Moulin F, Rigaud AS, Flahault A (2005) Disclosure of diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease in French general practice. Am J Alzheimer’s Dis Other Dement 20(4):228–232
Gilliard J, Gwilliam C (1996) Sharing the diagnosis: a survey of memory disorders clinics, their policies on informing people with dementia and their families, and the support they offer. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 11:1001–1003
De Lepeleire J, Buntinx F, Aertgeerts B (2004) Disclosing the diagnosis of dementia: the performance of Flemish general practitioners. Int Psychogeriatr 16(4):421–428
Rice K, Warner N (2004) Breaking the bad news: what do psychiatrists tell patients with dementia about their illness? Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 9(6):467–471
Vernooij-Dassen MJF, Moniz-Cook ED, Woods RT et al (2005) Factors affecting timely recognition and diagnosis of dementia across Europe: from awareness to stigma. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 20(4):377–386
Wittchen HU, Pittrow D (2002) Prevalence, recognition and management of depression in primary care in Germany: the depression study. Hum Psychopharmacol Clin Exp 17:S1–S11
Kirmayer, LJ Groleau D, Looper KJ, Dominicé M (2004) Explaining medically unexplained symptoms. Can J Psychiatry 49:663–672
Rocamora JF, Benadhira R, Saba G, Stamatadis L, Kalalaou K, Dumortier G, Plaze M, ubriot-Delmas B, Glikman J, Januel D (2005) Schizophrenia diagnostic announcement in a French psychiatric unit. Encéphale 31:449–455
Brodaty H, Howarth GC, Mant A, Kurrle SE (1994) General practice and dementia. A national survey of Australian GPs. Med J Aust 160:10–14
Renshaw J, Scurfield P, Cloke L, Orrell M (2001) General practitioners’ view on the early diagnosis of dementia. Br J Gen Pract 51:37–38
Rice K, Warner N (1994) Breaking the bad news: what do psychiatrists tell patients with dementia about their illness? Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 9:467–471
Downs M, Clibbens R, Rae C, Cook A, Woods R (2002) What do general practitioners tell people with dementia and their families about the condition? A survey of experiences in Scotland. Dementia 1:47–58
Wolff LE, Woods JP, Reid J (1995) Do general practitioners and old age psychiatrists differ in their attitudes to dementia? Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 10:63–69
Paccaloni M, Moretti F, Zimmermann C (2005) Giving information and involving in treatment: what do psychiatrists think? A review. Epidemiol Psichiatr Soc 14:198–216
Tang ST, Lee SYC (2004) Cancer diagnosis and prognosis in Taiwan: patient preferences versus experiences. Psycho-Oncology 13:1–13
Keating DT, Nayeem K, Gilmartin JJ, O’Keeffe ST (2005) Advance directives for truth disclosure. Chest 128:1037–1039
Chapple A, Ziebland S, McPherson A (2004) Stigma, shame, and blame experienced by patients with lung cancer: qualitative study. BMJ 328:1470
Husband HJ (1999) The psychological consequences of learning a diagnosis of dementia: three case examples. Aging Ment Health 3:179–183
Carstairs GM, Early DF, Rollin HR et al (1985) Informing relatives about schizophrenia. Bull R Coll Psychiatr 9:59–60
Lin CC, Tsay HF (2005) Relationships among perceived diagnostic disclosure, health locus of control, and levels of hope in Taiwanese cancer patients. Psycho-Oncology 14(5):376–385
Holroyd S, Snustad DG, Chalifoux ZL (1996) Attitudes of older adults’ on being told the diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease. J Am Geriatr Soc 44:400–403
Jha A, Tabet N, Orrell M (2001) To tell or not to tell—comparison of older patients’ reaction to their diagnosis of dementia and depression. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 16:879–885
Turnbull Q, Wolf AM, Holroyd S (2003) Attitudes of elderly subjects towards ‘truth telling’ for the diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease. J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol 16:90–93
Dautzenberg PLJ, van Marum RJ, van der Hammen R, Paling HA (2003) Patients and families desire a patient to be told the diagnosis of dementia: a survey by questionnaire on a Dutch memory clinic. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 18:777–779
Vassilas CA, Donaldson J (1998) Telling the truth: what do general practitioners say to patients with dementia or terminal cancer? Br J Gen Pract 48:1081–1082
Buckman R (1984) Breaking bad news: why is it still so difficult? BMJ 288:1597–1599
Kirsten L, Butow P, Price M, Hobbs K, Sunquist K (2006) Who helps the leaders? Difficulties experienced by cancer support group leaders. Support Care Cancer 14(7):770–778
Parle M, Maguire P, Heaven C (1997) The development of a training model to improve health professionals’ skills, self-efficacy and outcome expectancies when communicating with cancer patients. Soc Sci Med 44(2):231–240
Merckaert I, Libert Y, Razavi D (2005) Communication skills training in cancer care: where are we and where are we going? Curr Opin Oncol 17(4):319–330
Gysels M, Richardson A, Higginson IJ (2004) Communication training for health professionals who care for patients with cancer: a systematic review of effectiveness. Support Care Cancer 12(10):692–700
Hamadeh GN, Adib SM (1998) Cancer truth disclosure by Lebanese doctors. Soc Sci Med 47(9):1289–1294
Johnson H, Pinner G (2000) On telling the truth in Alzheimer’s disease: a pilot study of current practice and attitudes. Int Psychogeriatr 12:221–229
Tuckett AG (2004) Truth-telling in clinical practice and the arguments for and against: a review of the literature. Nurs Ethics 11:500–513
Thomas R, Kaminski E, Stanton E, Williams M (2004) Measuring information strategies in oncology—developing an information satisfaction questionnaire. Eur J Cancer Care 13(1):65–70
Carpenter B, Dave J (2004) Disclosing a dementia diagnosis: a review of opinion and practice, and a proposed research agenda. Gerontologist 44(2):149–158
Higuchi N (1992) The patient’s right to know of a cancer diagnosis: a comparison of Japanese paternalism and American self-determination. Washburn Law J 31:455–473
Acknowledgement
Thank you to the anonymous peer reviewers for their helpful comments during the preparation of this piece.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mitchell, A.J. Reluctance to disclose difficult diagnoses: a narrative review comparing communication by psychiatrists and oncologists. Support Care Cancer 15, 819–828 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00520-007-0226-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00520-007-0226-y