Abstract
The presence of variation in behavior on the between-individual level is considered the hallmark of personality. In contrast, behavioral syndromes are commonly recognized when documented on the phenotypic level, which is a mix of between-individual and residual (within-individual) correlations. Phenotypic and between-individual correlations need not align, and investigations on different levels of the same syndrome may hence lead to opposite inferences. Between-individual correlations, arguably, provide stronger evidence for an intrinsically determined behavioral syndrome than phenotypic correlations. We compiled 109 literature estimates of between-individual and phenotypic correlations between behaviors from 30 studies, performed on 22 species covering a wide range of taxa. Contrary to our expectation, the phenotypic correlation in behaviors was, on average, a reasonable predictor of the between-individual correlation in terms of magnitude and sign. Although our finding does not warrant the use of the phenotypic correlation as a suitable approximation of the between-individual correlation for any particular study, it does suggest that the phenotypic correlations used to infer the majority of behavioral syndromes to date have provided a reasonable characterization of syndrome associative strength.
Significance statement
Aspects of personality often correlate and are then said to form a behavioral syndrome. Syndromes are interesting because they signal that multiple behaviors may share causal drivers. Most syndromes to date are based on correlations of measured behaviors (phenotypes), but any pattern on the phenotypic level is likely influenced by uncontrolled associations between the focal behaviors which are expected to reduce the phenotypic correlation relative to the correlation on the underlying individual level. If so, behavioral ecologists may have underestimated the associative strength of behavioral syndromes. Based on over 100 published estimates of individual-level and phenotypic correlations between aspects of personality, we show that the phenotypic correlation provides a reasonable estimate of the magnitude and sign of individual-level correlations.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Araya-Ajoy YG, Dingemanse NJ (2014) Characterizing behavioural “characters”: an evolutionary framework. Proc R Soc B 281:20132645
Bell AM, Hankison SJ, Laskowski KL (2009) The repeatability of behavior: a meta-analysis. Anim Behav 77:771–783
Bierbach D, Sommer-Trembo C, Hanisch J, Wolf M, Plath M (2015) Personality affects mate choice: bolder males show stronger audience effects under high competition. Behav Ecol 26:1314–1325
Blumstein DT, Lea AJ, Olson LE, Martin JGA (2010) Heritability of anti-predatory traits: vigilance and locomotor performance in marmots. J Evol Biol 23:879–887
Boulton K, Couto E, Grimmer AJ, Early RL, Canario AVM, Wilson AJ, Walling CA (2015) How integrated are behavioral and endocrine stress response traits? A repeated measures approach to testing the stress-coping style model. Ecol Evol 5:618–633
Brommer JE (2013) On between-individual and residual (co) variances in the study of animal personality: are you willing to take the “individual gambit”? Behav Ecol Sociobiol 67:1027–1032
Careau V, Montiglio PO, Garant D, Pelletier F, Speakman JR, Humphries MM, Réale D (2015) Energy expenditure and personality in wild chipmunks. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 69:653–661
Cheverud JM (1988) A comparison of genetic and phenotypic correlations. Evolution 42:958–968
Class B, Kluen E, Brommer JE (2014) Evolutionary quantitative genetics of behavioral responses to handling in a wild passerine. Ecol Evol 4:427–440
Cordes N, Engqvist L, Schmoll T, Reinhold K (2014) Sexual signaling under predation: attractive moths take the greater risks. Behav Ecol 25:409–414
Diamond K, Trovillion D, Allen KE, Malela KM, Noble DA, Powell R, Eifler DA, Gifford ME (2014) Individual (co)variation of field behavior and locomotor performance in curly tailed lizards. J Zool 294:248–254
Dingemanse NJ, Dochtermann NA (2013) Quantifying individual variation in behaviour: mixed-effect modelling approaches. J Anim Ecol 82:39–54
Dingemanse NJ, Dochtermann NA (2014) Individual behaviour: behavioural ecology meets quantitative genetics. In: Charmantier A, Garant D, Kruuk LEB (eds) Quantitative genetics in the wild. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 54–65
Dingemanse NJ, Dochtermann NA, Nakagawa S (2012) Defining behavioural syndromes and the role of “syndrome deviation” in understanding their evolution. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 66:1543–1548
Dochtermann NA (2011) Testing Cheverud’s conjecture for behavioral correlations and behavioral syndromes. Evolution 65:1814–1820
Dosmann AJ, Brooks KC, Mateo JM (2015) Within-individual correlations reveal link between a behavioral syndrome, condition, and cortisol in free-ranging Belding’s ground squirrels. Ethology 121:125–134
Ferrari C, Pasquaretta C, Carere C, Cavallone E, von Hardenberg A, Réale D (2013) Testing for the presence of coping styles in a wild mammal. Anim Behav 85:1385–1396
Fisher DN, James A, Rodríguez-Muñoz R, Tregenza T (2015) Behaviour in captivity predicts some aspects of natural behaviour, but not others, in a wild cricket population. Proc R Soc B 282:20150708
Fresneau N, Kluen E, Brommer JE (2014) A sex-specific behavioral syndrome in a wild passerine. Behav Ecol 25:359–367
Garamszegi LZ, Eens M, Török J (2009) Behavioural syndromes and trappability in free-living collared flycatchers, Ficedula albicollis. Anim Behav 77:803–812
Garamszegi LZ, Markó G, Herczeg G (2012) A meta-analysis of correlated behaviours with implications for behavioural syndromes: mean effect size, publication bias, phylogenetic effects and the role of mediator variables. Evol Ecol 26:1213–1235
Garamszegi LZ, Markó G, Herczeg G (2013) A meta-analysis of correlated behaviors with implications for behavioral syndromes: relationships between particular behavioral traits. Behavioral Ecology 24:1068–1080
Geffroy B, Sadoul B, Bardonnet A (2015) Behavioural syndrome in juvenile eels and its ecological implications. Behaviour 152:147–166
Gifford ME, Clay TA, Careau V (2014) Individual (co)variation in standard metabolic rate, feeding rate, and exploratory behavior in wild-caught semiaquatic salamanders. Physiol Biochem Zool 87:384–396
Gilmour AR, Gogel BJ, Cullis BR, Thompson R, Butler D (2009) ASReml user guide release 3.0. VSN International Ltd, Hemel Hempstead, UK
Grafen A (1984) Natural selection, kin selection and group selection. In: Krebs JR, Davies NB (eds) Behavioural ecology: an evolutionary approach. Blackwell Scientific, Oxford
Hadfield JD (2010) MCMC methods for multi-response generalized linear mixed models: the MCMCglmm R package. J Stat Softw 33:1–22
Hall ML, van Asten T, Katsis AC, Dingemanse NJ, Magrath MJ, Mulder RA (2015) Animal personality and pace-of-life syndromes: do fast-exploring fairy-wrens die young? Front Ecol Evol 3:28
Han CS, Jäger HY, Dingemanse NJ (2016) Individuality in nutritional preferences: a multi-level approach in field crickets. Sci Rep 6:29071
Harrison PM, Gutowsky LFG, Martins EG, Patterson DA, Cooke SJ, Power M (2015) Personality-dependent spatial ecology occurs independently from dispersal in wild burbot (Lota lota). Behav Ecol 26:483–492
Horváth G, Martín J, López P, Garamszegi LZ, Bertók P, Herczeg G (2016) Blood parasite infection intensity covaries with risk-taking personality in male Carpetan rock lizards (Iberolacerta cyreni). Ethology 122:355–363
Kim SY, Velando A (2015) Phenotypic integration between antipredator behavior and camouflage pattern in juvenile sticklebacks. Evolution 69:830–838
Kluen E, Siitari H, Brommer JE (2014) Testing for between individual correlations of personality and physiological traits in a wild bird. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 68:205–213
Koolhaas JM, Korte SM, De Boer SF, Van Der Vegt BJ, Van Reenen CG, Hopster H, De Jong IC, Ruis MAW, Blokhuis HJ (1999) Coping styles in animals: current status in behavior and stress-physiology. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 23:925–935
Laskowski KL, Bell AM (2013) Competition avoidance drives individual differences in response to a changing food resource in sticklebacks. Ecol Lett 16:746–753
Lea AJ, Blumstein DT, Wey TW, Martin JGA (2010) Heritable victimization and the benefits of agonistic relationships. P Natl Acad Sci USA 107:21587–21592
Lynch M, Walsh B (1998) Genetics and analysis of quantitative traits. Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates
Mcevoy J, While GM, Sinn DL, Carver S, Wapstra E (2015) Behavioural syndromes and structural and temporal consistency of behavioural traits in a social lizard. J Zool 296:58–66
Niemelä PT, Lattenkamp EZ, Dingemanse NJ (2015) Personality-related survival and sampling bias in wild cricket nymphs. Behav Ecol 26:936–946
Réale D, Reader SM, Sol D, McDougall P, Dingemanse NJ (2007) Integrating temperament in ecology and evolutionary biology. Biol Rev 82:291–318
Réale D, Garant D, Humphries MM, Bergeron P, Careau V, Montiglio PO (2010) Personality and the emergence of the pace-of-life syndrome concept at the population level. Philos T Roy Soc B 365:4051–4063
Royauté R, Greenlee K, Baldwin M, Dochtermann NA (2015a) Behaviour, metabolism and size: phenotypic modularity or integration in Acheta domesticus? Anim Behav 110:163–169
Royauté R, Buddle CM, Vincent C (2015b) Under the influence: sublethal exposure to an insecticide affects personality expression in a jumping spider. Funct Ecol 29:962–970
Sanderson JL, Stott I, Young AJ, Vitikainen EI, Hodge SJ, Cant MA (2015) The origins of consistent individual differences in cooperation in wild banded mongooses, Mungos mungo. Anim Behav 107:193–200
Santostefano F, Wilson AJ, Araya-Ajoy YG, Dingemanse NJ (2016) Interacting with the enemy: indirect effects of personality on conspecific aggression in crickets. Behav Ecol 27:1235–1246
Searle SR (1961) Phenotypic, genetic, and environmental correlations. Biometrics 17:474–480
Sih A, Bell AM, Johnson JC, Ziemba RE (2004) Behavioral syndromes: an integrative overview. Q Rev Biol 79:241–277
Stein LR, Bell AM (2015) Consistent individual differences in paternal behavior: a field study of three-spined stickleback. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 69:227–236
Urszán TJ, Garamszegi LZ, Nagy G, Hettyey A, Török J, Herczeg G (2015) No personality without experience? A test on Rana dalmatina tadpoles. Ecol Evol 5:5847–5856
Westneat DF, Wright J, Dingemanse NJ (2015) The biology hidden inside residual within-individual phenotypic variation. Biol Rev 90:729–743
Zar JH (2010) Biostatistical analysis. Prenton Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ
Acknowledgements
We thank Alexander Weiss for an invitation which proved to be the initiation of this work. Two anonymous reviewers and the associate editor are thanked for constructive comments which clearly improved the paper.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
This work is a compilation of published work performed on animals, and the ethical considerations of working with experimental animals have been detailed in the original publications cited in this paper. This work does not include research on humans or primates.
Funding
The study was financially supported by funding from the Academy of Finland (to JEB) and the Graduate School in Biology, Geography and Geology (to BC).
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Communicated by N. A. Dochtermann
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Brommer, J.E., Class, B. Phenotypic correlations capture between-individual correlations underlying behavioral syndromes. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 71, 50 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-017-2278-4
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-017-2278-4