Abstract
This paper explains and implements a portfolio-based framework for analyzing the progression and consequences of disruptions to small-region economies. The first section discusses the underlying relationship between hazards, events, protection, disruptions, and disasters in regional economic systems. Such systems typically are adaptive in that they constantly adjust their levels and patterns of protection and compensation to changes in the frequency and magnitude of disruptions. The section explains how portfolio theory may be re-conceptualized to address policy choices related to the above issues. The second section explains conceptual issues in defining variables and specifying the production function balancing performance and protection. This function in turn defines the optimal expenditure for each actor against which their risk-tolerance is measured. Potential “tipping points” from singularly large or cascaded shocks, including disruptions from “lumpy” investment, suggest disaster-mitigating strategies that maximize societal utility or reduce tendencies to major disaster. In the third section, this theory is implemented empirically as a computer simulation model for a stylized open economy driven by tourism and oil refining. The simulations show how the potential for major disruptions varies with policy, increasing rapidly with the risk-propensity of policy makers. They also suggest how appropriate regional economic policy, notably rebalancing and export portfolio and rescheduling major investments, might reduce the likelihood of such events.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams J (1995) Risk. UCL Press, London
Allen P (1994) Evolutionary complex systems: models of technology change. In: Ledesdorf L, van der Besselaar P (op cit)
Anderson P, Arrow K, Pines D (1998) The economy as an evolving complex system. Addison-Wesley, Reading
Arthur W (1988) Self-reinforcing mechanisms in economics. In: Anderson P, Arrow K, Pines D (op cit)
Awerbuch S, Berger M (2003) Applying portfolio theory to EU electricity planning and policy-making. International Energy Agency, EET/2003/03, Paris
Barth J, Kraft J, Weist P (1973) A portfolio theoretic approach to industrial diversification and regional employment. J Reg Sci 15(1): 9–15
Baum S, Carlson R, Jucker J (1978) Some problems in applying the continuous portfolio selection model to the discrete capital budgeting problem. J Financ Quant Anal 13(2): 333–344
Board J, Sutcliffe C (1991) Risk and income tradeoffs in regional policy: a portfolio theoretic approach. J Reg Sci 3(2): 191(20)
Cole S (1985) The tragedy of Aruba: lessons for small island development. Antillien Rev 5(2): 9–14
Cole S (1987) The economic costs of plant closure. Proj Appraisal 2(1): 61–64
Cole S, Pantoja E, Razak V (1993) Social Accounting for Disaster Preparedness and Recovery. National Center for Earthquake Engineering Research, Buffalo. NCEER-93-0002
Cole S (1995) Lifelines and Livelihood: A Social Accounting Matrix Approach to Calamity Preparedness. J Contingencies Crisis Manage 3:4. Reprinted in Kunreuther and Rose (op cit)
Cole S (1997) Input–output forecasts and empirical testing: the economic impact of the Ravenscraig steelworks shutdown. Reg Sci Rev 17: 21–44
Cole S (1998) Decision support for calamity preparedness. In: Shinozuka M, Rose A, Eguchi R (op cit)
Cole S (2002) Water resources in China’s Yellow River Delta: an application of social–environmental accounting, and multi-criteria scenario analysis. In: Chatterji M et al (op cit)
Cole S (2004a) Performance and protection in an adaptive transaction model. Disaster Prev Manage 13(3): 4
Cole S (2004b) Geohazards in social systems: an insurance matrix approach. In: Okuyama Y, Chang S (op cit)
Cole S, Razak V (2004) A Framework for sustainable tourism in Aruba. Final Report. Ministry of Tourism and Infrastructure. Prepared for 3rd National Tourism Conference, November
Chatterji M, Arlosorof S, Guha G (2002) Conflict management of water resources. Ashgate, Aldershot
Cuny F (1983) Disasters and development. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Cutter S (1993) Living with risk. Arnold, London
Ehrlich I, Becker G (1972) Market insurance, self insurance, and self protection. J Polit Econ 80(4): 623–48
Funtowicz S, Ravetz J (1994) Emergent complex systems. Futures 26(6): 568–583
Green G (2004) The evaluation of vulnerability to flooding. Disaster Prev Manage 13(4): 323–329
Hewitt K, Burton I (1971) The hazardness of place. A regional ecology of hazardous events. Department of Geography, University of Toronto
Jensen M, Bak P, Bohr T (1984) Transition to chaos by interaction of resonances in disipative systems. Phys Rev A 30: 1960–1969
Jones B (1981) Planning for the Reconstruction of Earthquake-Stricken Communities. PRC-US Joint Workshop, Beijing (cited in Cole 2004a)
Kunreuther H, Pauly M (2003) Neglecting disaster: why don’t people insure against large losses. Wharton School
Kunreuther H, Rose A (2004) The economics of natural hazards, international library of critical writings in economics. Elgar, Cheltenham
Ledesdorf L, van der Besselaar P (1994) Evolutionary economics and chaos theory: new directions in technology studies. Pinter, London
Louberge H, Schlesinger H (1999) Optimal catastrophe insurance with multiple catastrophes. International Center for Financial Asset Management and Engineering. Research Paper 7, University of Alabama
Lundberg D, Krisnamoorthy M, Stavenga M (1995) Tourism economics. Wiley, New York
Markowitz H (1959) Portfolio selection: the efficient diversification of investments. Wiley, New York
MacPherson A, McConnell J, Vance A, Vanchan V (2006) The impact of U.S. Government anti-terrorism policies on Canada-U.S. cross-border commerce. Canada-United States Trade Center, University at Buffalo
Okuyama Y, Chang S (2004) Modeling spatial and economic impacts of disasters. Advances in science. Springer, Heidelberg
Okuyama Y, Hewings G, Sonis M (2004) Measuring economic impacts of disasters: inter-regional input–output using the sequential inter-industry model. In: Okuyama Y, Chang S (op cit)
Rose A, Guha G (2004) Computable general equilibrium modeling of electric utility lifeline losses from eartquakes. In: Okuyama Y, Chang S (op cit)
Shinozuka M, Chang S (2004) Disaster resilience in power networks. In: Okoyama Y, Chang S (op cit)
Shinozuka M, Rose A, Eguchi R (1998) Engineering and socioeconomic impacts of earthquakes. MCEER, Buffalo
Siegel P, Johnson T, Alwang J (1995) Regional economic diversity and diversification: seeking a framework for analysis. Growth Change 26(2): 261–284
Smith K (1996) Environmental disaster: assessing risk and reducing disaster. Routledge, New York
Sternberg E, Lee G (2006) Meeting the challenge of facility protection for homeland security. J Homeland Secur Emerg Manage 3(1): 1–19
Sveen T, Weinke L (2005) Is lumpy investment really irrelevant for the business cycle? Working Paper. Norges Bank, Oslo
Tierney K, Lindell M, Perry R (2002) Facing the unexpected: disaster preparedness and response in the United States. John Henry Press, Washington
Thomas J (2002) Is lumpy investment relevant for the business cycle?. J Polit Econ 110(2): 508–533
Tobin G, Montz B (1997) Natural hazards: explanation and integration. Guildford Press, New York
Tonn B (2005) Imprecise probabilities and scenarios. Futures 37(8): 767–776
Twigg J (2001) Sustainable livelihoods and vulnerability to disasters. Disaster Mitigation Unit. Working Paper, 2/2001