A RUMBLING: truth itself has appeared among humankind in the very thick of their flurrying metaphors.
Abstract
Using the example of psychosomatic diagnosis, I argue that the clinical context has unique epistemological constraints that limit the certainty of diagnosis and so make meaning indeterminate for sufferer and healer. As a result, forms of clinical truth are borrowed from the therapeutic context to create and authorize meanings for ambiguous or ill-defined conditions and inchoate suffering. Diagnostic interpretation is concerned with classification and legitimation through the production of authoritative truth. In contrast, therapeutic interpretation is fundamentally concerned with the pragmatic problem of “how to continue” and hence, with the improvisation of meaning. These different ends give rise to tensions and contradictions in psychosomatic theory and practice. While authority is necessary to provide a structure on which variations of meaning can be improvised, authoritative meanings may also restrict the possibilities for invention by clinician and patient. The goal of patient and physician is to create enough certainty to diminish the threat of the inchoate while preserving enough ambiguity to allow for fresh improvisation. Accounts of illness meaning must recognize the interdependence of normative rigidity and metaphoric invention.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
American Psychiatric Association 1987 Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (3 revised ed.). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.
Barlow, D.H., and M. Hersen 1973 Single-case Experimental Design. Archives of General Psychiatry 29:319–325.
Brody, E.B., and J.F. Tormey 1980 Clinical Psychoanalytic Knowledge—An Epistemological Inquiry. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, Autumn 143–159.
Bruner, J. 1990 Acts of Meaning. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Chodoff, P. 1982 Hysteria and Women. American Journal of Psychiatry 139:545–551.
Cohen, S., A.J. Tyrrell, and A.P. Smith 1991 Psychological Stress and Susceptibility to the Common Cold. New England Journal of Medicine 325: 606–612.
Engel, G. 1970 Conversion Symptoms.In Signs and Symptoms: Applied Pathologic Physiology and Clinical Interpretation. C.M. MacBryde and R.S. Blacklow, eds. Philadelphia: Lippincott. Pp. 650–668.
Feinstein, A.R. 1987 Clinimetrics. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Ford, C.V., B.H. King, and M.H. Hollender 1988 Lies and Liars: Psychiatric Aspects of Prevarication. American Journal of Psychiatry 145(5): 554–562.
Frank, J.D. 1973 Persuasion and Healing: A Comparative Study of Psychotherapy (Revised ed.) Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Friedman, H.S., and S. Booth-Kewley 1987 The “Disease-prone Personality”: A Meta-analytic View of the Construct. American Psychologist 42(6): 539–555.
Freud, S. 1959 Fragment of an Analysis of a Case of Hysteria (1905).In Collected Papers. J. Strachey, ed., pp. 13–146. New York: Basic Books.
Gellner, E. 1985 The Psychoanalytic Movement. London: Paladin Books.
Groesbeck, C.J. 1975 The Archetypal Image of the Wounded Healer. Journal of Analytical Psychology 20(2): 122–145.
Grünbaum, A. 1986 Précis of The Foundations of Psychoanalysis: A Philosophical Critique. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 9(2): 217–284.
Habermas, J. 1990 Moral Consciousness and COmmunicative Action. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Hamburger, Michael, Jr. 1988 Poems of Paul Celan. New York: Persea Books.
Helman, C.G. 1985 Psyche, Soma and Society: The Social Construction of Psychosomatic Disease. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 9:1–26.
Howard, G.S. 1991 Culture Tales: A Narrative Approach to Thinking, Cross-cultural Psychology, and Psychotherapy. American Psychologist 46(3): 187–197.
Kilhstrom, J.F., and I.P. Hoyt 1990 Repression, Dissociation, and Hypnosis.In Repression and Dissociation: Implications for Personality Theory, Psychopathology, and Health. J.L. Singer, ed.. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Pp.181–208.
Kirmayer, L.J. 1987 Languages of Suffering and Healing: Alexithymia as a Social and Cultural Process. Transcultural Psychiatric Research Review 24: 119–136.
0 1988 Mind and Body as Metaphors: Hidden Values in Biomedicine.In Biomedicine Examined. M. Lock and D. Gordon, eds., pp. 57–92. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
0 1990 Resistance, Reactance and Reluctance to Change: A Cognitive Attributional Approach to Strategic Interventions. Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy 4(2): 83–104.
0 1992 The Body's Insistence on Meaning: Metaphor as Presentation and Representation in Illness Experience. Medical Anthropology Quarterly 6(4): 323–346.
0 1993 Healing and the Invention of Metaphor: The Effectiveness of Symbols Revisited. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 17(2): 161–195.
Kleinman, A. 1986 Social Origins of Distress and Disease. New Haven: Yale University Press.
0 1988a The Ilness Narratives. New York: Basic Books.
0 1988b Rethinking Psychiatry. New York: Free Press.
Lazarus, R., and S. Folkman 1984 Stress, Appraisal and Coping. New York: Springer.
Lesser, I.M., and B.Z. Lesser 1983 Alexithymia: Examining the Development of a Psychological Concept. American Journal of Psychiatry 140(10): 1305–1308.
Lown, B., R.A. Desilva, P. Reich, and B.J. Murawski 1980 Psychophysiologic Factors in Sudden Cardiac Death. American Journal of Psychiatry 137(11): 1325–1335.
Lynn, S.J., J.W. Rhue, and J.R. Weekes 1990 Hypnotic Involuntariness: A Social Cognitive Analysis. Psychological Review 97(2): 169–184.
McAdams, D.P. 1989 The Development of a Narrative Identity.In Personality Psychology: Recent Trends and Emerging Directions. D.M. Buss and N. Cantor, ed. New York: Springer-Verlag. Pp.160–174.
McDougall, J. 1985 Theaters of the Mind: Illusion and Truth on the Psychoanalytic Stage. New York: Basic Books.
0 1989 Theaters of the Body: A Psychoanalytic Approach to Psychosomatic Illness. New York: W.W. Norton & Co.
Mishler, E. 1984 The Discourse of Medicine. New Jersey: Ablex Publishing Co.
Nadelson, T. 1979 The Munchausen Spectrum: Borderline Character Features. General Hospital Psychiatry 2: 11–17.
Nisbett, R.E., and T.D. Wilson 1977 Telling More Than We Can Know: Verbal Reports on Mental Processes. Psychological Review 84(3): 231–259.
Norman, D.A. 1981 Categorization of Action Slips. Psychological Review 88(1): 1–15.
Poole, G.D., and K.D. Craig 1992 Judgments of Genuine, Suppressed, and Faked Facial Expressions of Pain. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 63(5): 797–805
Popper, K. 1957 The Poverty of Historicism. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Read, S.J. 1983 Once is Enough: Causal Reasoning from a Single Instance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 45(2): 323–334.
Eiley, T.L., and A. Roy, eds. 1982 Pseudoseizures. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins.
Rogers, R. 1988 Current Status of Clinical Methods.In Clinical Assessment of Malingering and Deception. R. Rogers, ed., pp. 293–308. New York: Guilford.
Sackeim, H.A., J.W. Nordlie, and R.C. Gur 1979 A Model of Hysterical and Hypnotic Blindness: Cognition, Motivation, and Awareness. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 88(5): 474–489.
Sackett, D.L., R.B. Haynes and P. Tugwell 1985 Clinical Epidemiology: A Basic Science for Clinical Medicine. Boston: Little, Brown and Company.
Scheff, T.J. 1979 Catharsis in Healing, Ritual and Drama. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Slavney, P.R. 1990 Perspectives on Hysteria. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Spence, D.P. 1982 Narrative Truth and Historial Truth: Meaning and Interpretation in Psychoanalysis. New York: W.W. Norton.
0 1983 Narrative Persuasion. Psychoanalysis and Contemporary Thought 6(3): 457–481.
Taussig, M.T. 1980 Refication and the Consciousness of the Patient. Social Science and Medicine 14 B: 3–13.
Wallace, E.R., IV 1988 What is “Truth”? Some Philosophical Contributions to Psychiatric Issues. American Journal of Psychiatry 145(2): 137–147.
Ware, N.C. and A. Kleinman 1992 Culture and Somatic Experience: The Social Course of Illness in Neurasthenia and Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. Psychosomatic Medicine 54: 546–560.
Wittgenstein, L. 1958 Philosophical Investigations (Third ed.). New York: MacMillan Co.
Young, A. 1982 Rational Men and the Explanatory Model Approach. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 6: 57–71.
0 1990 Moral Conflicts in a Psychiatric Hospital Treating Combat-Related PTSD.In Social Science Perspectives on Medical Ethics. G. Weiss, ed. Dordrecht: Kluwer, pp. 65–82.
0 1993 A Description of How Ideology Shapes Knowledge of A Mental Disorder.In Knowledge, Power and Practice: The Anthropology of Medicine and Everyday Life. S. Lindenbaum and M. Lock, eds. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kirmayer, L.J. Improvisation and authority in illness meaning. Cult Med Psych 18, 183–214 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01379449
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01379449