Abstract
This study examined the correlation of echocardiography (ECHO) and Cardiac Magnetic Resonance (CMR) in the assessment of aortic valve regurgitation (AR) in children and young adults with congenital heart disease. We hypothesized that qualitative ECHO assessment correlates insufficiently with quantitative CMR data and compared subjective ECHO evaluations with objective measurement of regurgitant fractions (RF) by CMR. Patients who had both ECHO and CMR assessments of AR within 60 days of each other were included. The qualitative ECHO assessment (mild, moderate, severe) of AR and left ventricular dimension at end diastole were recorded. RF was quantified by CMR using phase-contrast velocity mapping. Repeat ECHO review and grading of AR was performed by a blinded single reader in a randomly chosen subgroup of patients. In 43 patients studied, statistical significance was observed in the CMR-RF between mild and moderate, and between mild and severe ECHO grades. There was significant overlap of objective RF between subjective grades. Mild ECHO AR corresponded to an RF (%) of 0–29, moderate 1–40, and severe 5–58. Overlap was more significant at moderate and severe grades. Results were similar in the group in whom a single reader interpreted the ECHO assessment. In conclusion, results derived from a real-life multiple-reader ECHO laboratory showed inconsistencies in ECHO grading of AR, with a wide range of objectively measured RF within a given ECHO grade. ECHO is less reliable in identifying more severe AR, often overestimating severity. Quantitative CMR is a potentially useful supplement to ECHO for management decisions and assessments of medical and surgical therapies in children and young adults with AR.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aurigemma G, Reichek N, Schiebler M, Axel L (1991) Evaluation of aortic regurgitation by cardiac cine magnetic resonance imaging: planar analysis and comparison to Doppler echocardiography. Cardiology 78:340–347
Chatzimavroudis GP, Oshinski JN, Franch RH, Walker PG, Yoganathan AP, Pettigrew RI (2001) Evaluation of the precision of magnetic resonance phase velocity mapping for blood flow measurements. J Cardiovasc Magn Reson 3:11–19
Gelfand EV, Hughes S, Hauser TH, Yeon SB, Goepfert L, Kissinger KV, Rofsky NM, Manning WJ (2006) Severity of mitral and aortic regurgitation as assessed by cardiovascular magnetic resonance: optimizing correlation with Doppler echocardiography. J Cardiovasc Magn Reson 8:503–507
Glockner JF, Johnston DL, McGee KP (2003) Evaluation of cardiac valvular disease with MR imaging: qualitative and quantitative techniques. Radiographics 23:e9
Grothoff M, Spors B, Abdul-Khaliq H, Gutberlet M (2008) Evaluation of postoperative pulmonary regurgitation after surgical repair of tetralogy of Fallot: comparison between Doppler echocardiography and MR velocity mapping. Pediatr Radiol 38:186–191
Grothues F, Moon JC, Bellenger NG, Smith GS, Klein HU, Pennell DJ (2004) Interstudy reproducibility of right ventricular volumes, function, and mass with cardiovascular magnetic resonance. Am Heart J 147:218–223
Hundley WG, Li HF, Willard JE, Landau C, Lange RA, Meshack BM, Hillis LD, Peshock RM (1995) Magnetic resonance imaging assessment of the severity of mitral regurgitation: comparison with invasive techniques. Circulation 92:1151–1158
Ley S, Eichhorn J, Ley-Zaporozhan J, Ulmer H, Schenk JP, Kauczor HU, Arnold R (2007) Evaluation of aortic regurgitation in congenital heart disease: value of MR imaging in comparison to echocardiography. Pediatr Radiol 37:426–436
Li W, Davlouros PA, Kilner PJ, Pennell DJ, Gibson D, Henein MY, Gatzoulis MA (2004) Doppler-echocardiographic assessment of pulmonary regurgitation in adults with repaired tetralogy of Fallot: comparison with cardiovascular magnetic resonance imaging. Am Heart J 147:165–172
Lorenz CH (2000) The range of normal values of cardiovascular structures in infants, children, and adolescents measured by magnetic resonance imaging. Pediatr Cardiol 21:37–46
Miyake Y, Hozumi T, Mori I, Sugioka K, Yamamuro A, Akasaka T, Homma S, Yoshida K, Yoshikawa J (2002) Automated quantification of aortic regurgitant volume and regurgitant fraction using the digital colour Doppler velocity profile integration method in patients with aortic regurgitation. Heart 88:481–484
Norton KI, Tong C, Glass RB, Nielsen JC (2006) Cardiac MR imaging assessment following tetralogy of fallot repair. Radiographics 26:197–211
Ohnishi S, Fukui S, Kusuoka H, Kitabatake A, Inoue M, Kamada T (1992) Assessment of valvular regurgitation using cine magnetic resonance imaging coupled with phase-compensation technique: comparison with Doppler color flow mapping. Angiology 43:913–924
Pearlman AS, Scoblionko DP, Saal AK (1983) Assessment of valvular heart disease by Doppler echocardiography. Clin Cardiol 6:573–587
Perry GJ, Helmcke F, Nanda NC, Byard C, Soto B (1987) Evaluation of aortic insufficiency by Doppler color flow mapping. J Am Coll Cardiol 9:952–959
Pflugfelder PW, Landzberg JS, Cassidy MM, Cheitlin MD, Schiller NB, Auffermann W, Higgins CB (1989) Comparison of cine MR imaging with Doppler echocardiography for the evaluation of aortic regurgitation. Am J Roentgenol 152:729–735
Powell AJ, Maier SE, Chung T, Geva T (2000) Phase-velocity cine magnetic resonance imaging measurement of pulsatile blood flow in children and young adults: in vitro and in vivo validation. Pediatr Cardiol 21:104–110
Reimold SC, Maier SE, Aggarwal K, Fleischmann KE, Piwnica-Worms D, Kikinis R, Lee RT (1996) Aortic flow velocity patterns in chronic aortic regurgitation: implications for Doppler echocardiography. J Am Soc Echocardiogr 9:675–683
Semelka RC, Tomei E, Wagner S, Mayo J, Caputo G, O’Sullivan M, Parmley WW, Chatterjee K, Wolfe C, Higgins CB (1990) Interstudy reproducibility of dimensional and functional measurements between cine magnetic resonance studies in the morphologically abnormal left ventricle. Am Heart J 119:1367–1373
Søndergaard L, Lindvig K, Hildebrandt P, Thomsen C, Ståhlberg F, Joen T, Henriksen O (1993) Quantification of aortic regurgitation by magnetic resonance velocity mapping. Am Heart J 125:1156–1164
Teague SM, Heinsimer JA, Anderson JL, Sublett K, Olson EG, Voyles WF, Thadani U (1986) Quantification of aortic regurgitation utilizing continuous wave Doppler ultrasound. J Am Coll Cardiol 8:592–599
Thomas JD (2002) Doppler echocardiographic assessment of valvar regurgitation. Heart 88:651–657
Varaprasathan GA, Araoz PA, Higgins CB, Reddy GP (2002) Quantification of flow dynamics in congenital heart disease: applications of velocity-encoded cine MR imaging. Radiographics 22:895–905
Weber OM, Higgins CB (2006) MR evaluation of cardiovascular physiology in congenital heart disease: flow and function. J Cardiovasc Magn Reson 8:607–617
Yamachika S, Reid CL, Savani D, Meckel C, Paynter J, Knoll M, Jamison B, Gardin JM (1997) Usefulness of color Doppler proximal isovelocity surface area method in quantitating valvular regurgitation. J Am Soc Echocardiogr 10:159–168
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding authors
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kutty, S., Whitehead, K.K., Natarajan, S. et al. Qualitative Echocardiographic Assessment of Aortic Valve Regurgitation with Quantitative Cardiac Magnetic Resonance: A Comparative Study. Pediatr Cardiol 30, 971–977 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00246-009-9490-6
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00246-009-9490-6