Interaction between structural, statistical, and covariate models in population pharmacokinetic analysis

Abstract

The influence of the choice of pharmacokinetic model on subsequent determination of covariate relationships in population pharmacokinetic analysis was studied using both simulated and real data sets. Simulations and data analysis were both performed with the program NONMEM. Data were simulated using a two-compartment model, but at late sample times, so that preferential selection of the two-compartment model should have been impossible. A simple categorical covariate acting on clearance was included. Initially, on the basis of a difference in the objective function values, the two-compartment model was selected over the one-compartment model. Only when the complexity of the one-compartment model was increased in terms of the covariate and statistical models was the difference in objective function values of the two structural models negligible. For two real data sets, with which the two-compartment model was not selected preferentially, more complex covariate relationships were supported with the one-compartment model than with the two-compartment model. Thus, the choice of structural model can be affected as much by the covariate model as can the choice of covariate model be affected by the structural model; the two choices are interestingly intertwined. A suggestion on how to proceed when building population pharmacokinetic models is given.