Abstract
Up to this point, Max Laue’s academic career had followed a direct course. At Munich, he had become eligible to receive an appointment to a professorship. His chances were good, because there were very few younger theoretical physicists who had studied under various academic teachers and were as versed as Laue in tackling unresolved problems, as his publications demonstrated. Moreover, the Ludwig Maximilian University in Munich had a chair in Theoretical Physics. Around 1910 this was not yet the rule at German universities. The leaders in this field were Berlin, Göttingen, and Munich, and Laue’s contributions to the field were well known. The chairholder in theoretical physics at Munich, Arnold Sommerfeld (Fig. 5.1), was an outstanding academic teacher (Eckert 2013: Chap. 6). After completing his studies in mathematics at Göttingen, he had begun his career as an academic teacher at the Mining Academy in Clausthal. He had then followed a call to the polytechnic in Aachen, where he was more of a mathematician—with research on the theory of gyroscopes and contributions to statics—than a physicist (Klein and Sommerfeld 1965). In 1900, at Röntgen’s instigation, he had been appointed to the chair in the field of theoretical physics at the Ludwig Maximilian University in Munich, which had been vacated by Ludwig Boltzmann in order to return home to Vienna. Sommerfeld mainly studied the nature of X-rays and relativity theory. Sommerfeld’s institute had its own workshop and mechanic, which meant experimental research was possible there.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
Sommerfeld was already working on the nature of X-rays at the Bergakademie in Clausthal, albeit without being able to come up with any clear results (Sommerfeld 1899). Other research on the same topic by M. Maier from slightly earlier appeared in the same issue on p. 57.
- 2.
Planck’s correspondence with Lorentz reveals how difficult it was for physicists to understand what radiation was. On 16 Jun. 1909 Planck wrote to Lorentz: “But now to radiation. That it doesn’t work without the assumption of light quanta hν, on that we do agree (in contrast to Jeans). That furthermore light quanta can’t possibly retain their individuality while propagating in the free aether, you have explained so convincingly in the second part of your letter that I believe there can be no doubt about that either. The whole of optics, especially the theory of interference and refraction and diffraction, would have to be overturned if one wanted to ascribe specific existence to light quanta in the free aether.” AMPG, V rep. 11 no. 568, orig. emphasis.
Paul Peter Ewald described a lecture at the colloquium prior to Laue’s appointment to Munich on ‘The behavior of light waves at the focal point.’ He thought that was a prerequisite for Laue’s move from Berlin to Munich. See Ewald (1968).
- 3.
Laue to Wien, Munich, 3 Apr. 1909. DMA, NL 056/409-452 and HUA, UKP, L 51, vol. 4.
- 4.
STAM, marriage register, Standesamt München I, 1189/1910. Laue’s handwritten communication to the university rectorate reads: “Daughter of the late Captain Erwin Freiherr Milkau and his wife Emmy, née Degen.” See also HUA, UKP, L 51 and LMUA, PA E-II, 2224.
- 5.
Hermann (1994: 157). At the end of 1908 Einstein received an inquiry from the Hirzel publishing house in Leipzig. He agreed at first but later retracted again: “Unfortunately it is quite impossible for me to write that book, because it is impossible for me to find the time for it.” Comp. Fölsing (2004: 262). There aren’t any files at Friedrich Vieweg & Sohn from this period. Very likely, several physicists were invited by this publisher to write a book on relativity. Who suggested Laue is no longer ascertainable. For remarks by Laue about relativity see Staley (2008).
- 6.
The place of origin of the research is indicated as the Institute for Theoretical Physics in Munich and dated March 1912.
- 7.
Röntgen (1895: 141): “Now it has been known for a long time that, in addition to transverse light oscillations, longitudinal oscillations can also occur in the aether and, in the opinion of various physicists, must occur. Obviously, their existence has not yet been proven and therefore their properties have not yet been experimentally investigated. Shouldn’t these new rays be longitudinal swinging motions of the aether? I must confess that during the course of the investigations I have become more and more attached to this thought and thus also permit myself to express this conjecture here, although I am very well aware that the explanation given still requires further substantiation”.
- 8.
Peter Paul Koch built a recording microphotometer at the Physical Institute in Munich to conduct objective analysis of the results (Wolfke 1912). However, those measurements of the diffraction recordings yielded no clear proof of any wavelike character either. Potential fluorescence radiation due to the metallic slit emitting radiation upon irradiation was not discussed.
- 9.
- 10.
- 11.
Laue to Sommerfeld, no location, 3 Aug. 1920. DMA, NL 056 (former shelfmark HS 1977-28/A 197). Related letters from Laue indicate how offended he was.
- 12.
The archives of the Royal Institution of Great Britain in London have letters from William Lawrence Bragg on the timing of the joint research beginning in the summer of 1912: W.L. Bragg to John Desmond Bernal, 30 Oct. 1942. RI MS WlB/49b/42p.; W.L. Bragg to Lord Rayleigh, 9 Sep. 1942. RI MS, WLB/49b/36: 1.
- 13.
Betrifft Gesuch des Herrn Prof. Dr. v. Laue. GSta PK, I HA, Rep. 76, Kultusministerium, Va, Sekt. 2, Tit IV, no. 68 D, vol. 1, fol. 208.
References
Authier, André. 2013. Early Days of X-Ray Crystallography. Oxford: Univ. Press
Barkla, Charles G. 1908. Der Stand der Forschung über die sekundäre Röntgenstrahlung. Jb. Radioakt. Electr. 5: 246–324
Boeters, Karl E., and Jost Lemmerich, eds. 1979. Gedächtnisausstellung zum 100. Geburtstag von Albert Einstein, Otto Hahn, Max von Laue, Lise Meitner in der Staatsbibliothek Berlin Preußischer Kulturbesitz. Exhibition catalogue. Berlin: Staatsbibliothek Preußischer Kulturbesitz
Born, Max. 1912. M. Laue. Das Relativitätsprinzip. Phys. Z. 13: 175 f. (book review)
Bragg, W. H. 1911. Corpuscular radiation. Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science. 80th Meeting at Portsmouth, 31 Aug.–7 Sept. 1911: 340 f.
Budde, E. 1911. Zur Theorie des Michelsonschen Versuches. Phys. Z. 12: 979–991.
Eckert, Michael. 2012. Disputed discovery: The beginnings of X-ray diffraction in crystals in 1912 and its repercussions. Z. Kristall. 227: 29
Eckert, Michael. 2013. Arnold Sommerfeld. Atomphysiker und Kulturbote 1868–1951. Eine Biographie. Göttingen: Wallstein
Eckert, Michael, and W. Pricha. 1984. Die ersten Briefe Albert Einsteins an Arnold Sommerfeld. Erstveröffentlichung von bisher unbeachteten Briefen. Phys. Bl. 2: 29–34
Einstein, Albert. 1993. The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein. Vol. 5: The Swiss Years, Correspondence 1902–1914. Edited by Martin J. Klein, A.J. Kox, and Robert Schulmann. Princeton: Univ. Press
Ewald, Paul Peter. 1968. Erinnerungen an die Anfänge des Münchener Physikalischen Kolloquiums. Phys. Bl. 24: 538–542
Ewald, Paul Peter. 1979. Max v. Laue – Mensch und Werk. Memorial address held in Berlin on 2 March 1979. Phys. Bl. 8: 337–349
Fölsing, Albrecht. 2004. Albert Einstein. Eine Biographie. 6th ed. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp
Friedrich, Walter. 1912. Räumliche Intensitätsverteilung der X-Strahlen, die von einer Platinantikathode ausgehen. Ann. Phys. 12: 377–430
Friedrich, Walter. 1922. Die Geschichte der Auffindung der Röntgenstrahlinterferenzen. In Zehn Jahre Laue-Diagramm. Naturw. 16: 363–366
Friedrich, W., P. Knipping u. M. Laue. 1912. Interferenz-Erscheinungen bei Röntgenstrahlen. Sb. Bayer. Akad. Wiss., math.-phys. class 1912: 303–322, 363–373
Haga, Herman, and Cornelis H. Wind. 1903. Die Beugung der Röntgenstrahlen. Ann. Phys. 2: 305–312
Hartmann, Hans. 1952. Schöpfer des neuen Weltbildes. Große Physiker unserer Zeit. Bonn: Athenäum-Verlag
Hermann, Armin. 1994. Einstein. Der Weltweise und sein Jahrhundert. Eine Biographie. Munich, Zurich: Piper
Hildebrandt, Gerhardt, and Wilhelm Treue, eds. 1987. Berlinische Lebensbilder. Vol. 1: Naturwissenschaftler. Einzelveröffentlichungen der Historischen Kommission zu Berlin, no. 60. Berlin: Colloquium-Verlag
Ioffe, Abram F. 1967. Begegnung mit Physikern. Basel: Teubner
Klein, Felix, and Arnold Sommerfeld. 1965. Über die Theorie des Kreisels. 4 issues, 1897–1910. Reprinting of the original editions from 1897, 1898, 1903, and 1910. Stuttgart: Teubner
Kubbinga, Henk. 2012. Crystallography from Haüy to Laue: controversies on the molecular and atomistic nature of solids. Z. Crystall. 227: 1–26
Laue, Max. 1907. Die Mitführung des Lichtes durch bewegte Körper nach dem Relativitätsprinzip. Ann. Phys. 10: 989 f.
Laue, Max. 1909a. Zur Thermodynamik der Gitterbeugung. Ann. Phys. 12: 225–239
Laue, Max. 1909b. Thermodynamische Betrachtungen über die Beugung der Strahlung. Phys. Z. 32: 807
Laue, Max. 1910a. Zur Thermodynamik der Beugung. Ann. Phys. 3: 547–558
Laue, Max. 1910b. Die Wärmestrahlung in absorbierenden Körpern. Ann. Phys. 10: 1085–1094
Laue, Max. 1910c. Ist der Michelsonversuch beweisend? Ann. Phys. 11: 186–191
Laue, Max. 1911a. Das Relativitätsprinzip. Die Wissenschaft – Sammlung naturwissenschaftlicher und mathematischer Einzeldarstellungen, No. 38. Braunschweig: Vieweg; 2nd exp. edition 1913
Laue, Max. 1911b. Zur Diskussion über den starren Körper in der Relativitätstheorie. Phys. Z. 12: 85–87
Laue, Max. 1911c. Zur Dynamik der Relativitätstheorie. Ann. Phys. 8: 524–542
Laue, Max. 1911d. Über einen Versuch zur Optik bewegter Körper. Sb. Math.-Phys. Kl. Bayer. Akad. Wiss. 1911: 62, 405
Laue, Max. 1911e. Zwei Einwände gegen die Relativitätstheorie und ihre Widerlegung. Phys. Z. 13: 118
Laue, Max. 1911f. Bemerkungen zum Hebelgesetz in der Relativitätstheorie. Phys. Z. 12: 1008 ff.
Laue, Max. 1912a. Zur Theorie des Michelsonschen Versuches. Phys. Z. 13: 501–506. Budde’s reply is on p. 825
Laue, Max. 1912b. Zur Theorie des Versuches von Trouton und Noble. Ann. Phys. 7: 370–384
Laue, Max. 1912c. Eine quantitative Prüfung der Theorie für die Interferenzerscheinungen bei Röntgenstrahlen. Sb. Bayer. Akad. Wiss., math.-phys. class, 1912: 363–373
Laue, Max. 1913a. Wellenoptik. In Sommerfeld (1913): 362–373
Laue, Max. 1913b. Eine quantitative Prüfung der Theorie für die Interferenzerscheinungen bei Röntgenstrahlen. Ann. Phys. 10: 989–1002
Laue, Max. 1921. Die Relativitätstheorie. Vol. 1: Das Relativitätsprinzip der Lorentztransformation. 4th exp. Edition, Braunschweig: Vieweg
Laue, Max von. 1961a. Gesammelte Schriften und Vorträge. 3 vols, Braunschweig: Vieweg
Laue, Max von. 1961b. Mein physikalischer Werdegang. Eine Selbstdarstellung. In Laue 1961a, 3: V–XXXIV
Laue, Max, and F. F. Martens. 1907. Beiträge zur Metalloptik I. Über die polarisation der von glühenden Metallen seitlich emittierten Strahlung. Dt. Phys. Ges. 5: 522
Mehra, Jagdish. 1975. The Solvay Conferences on Physics. Aspects of the Development of Physics since 1911. Dordrecht, Boston: Reiche
Michelson, Albert Abraham. 1903. Light Waves and Their Uses. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press
Morley, Edward W., and Dayton C. Miller. 1905. On the theory of experiments to detect aberrations of the second degree. Phil. Mag. 9: 669–680
Planck, Max. 1937. Zur 25-jährigen Jubiläum der Entdeckung von W. Friedrich, P. Knipping und M. v. Laue. Verh. Dt. Phys. Ges. 18th ser., 3: 77
Röntgen, W. Conrad. 1895. Über eine neue Art von Strahlen. Sitzungsberichte der Physikalisch-Medicinische Gesellschaft zu Würzburg 1895: 132–141
Santesson, Carl Gustav. 1920. Les Prix Nobel en 1914–1918. Stockholm: Norstedt & Söner
Sommerfeld, Arnold. 1899. Theoretisches über die Beugung der Röntgenstrahlen. Phys. Z. 1: 105
Sommerfeld, Arnold. 1909. Über die Verteilung der Intensität bei der Emission der Röntgenstrahlen. Phys. Z. 19: 969
Sommerfeld, Arnold. 1912. Über die Beugung der Röntgenstrahlen. Ann. Phys. 8: 473–506
Sommerfeld, Arnold, ed. 1913. Encyclopädie der mathematischen Wissenschaften mit Einschluss ihrer Anwendungen. Vol. 5 in 3 parts: Physik. Leipzig: Teubner
Sommerfeld, Arnold. 2000. Arnold Sommerfeld. Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel 1892 bis 1918, Vol. 1. Edited by Michael Eckert and Karl Märker. Berlin: Verlag für Geschichte der Naturwissenschaften und Technik
Staley, Richard. 2008. Einstein’s Generation. The Origins of the Relativity Revolution. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press
Tobies, Renate. 2010. Morgen möchte ich wieder 100 herrliche Sachen ausrechnen. Iris Runge bei Osram und Telefunken. With a foreword by Helmut Neunzert. Stuttgart: Steiner
Trouton, Frederick T., and Henry R. Noble. 1903. The forces acting on a charged condenser moving through Space. Proc. Roy. Soc. 72: 132
Walter, Bernhard, and Robert W. Pohl. 1908. Zur Frage der Beugung der Röntgenstrahlen. Ann Phys. 4: 715–724
Wolfke, Mieczyslaw. 1912. Über die Abbildung eines durchlässigen Gitters. Ann. Phys. 4: 797–811
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2022 Basilisken-Presse, Natur+Text GmbH
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Lemmerich, J. (2022). Private Lecturer at the University of Munich. In: Max von Laue. Springer Biographies. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-94699-9_5
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-94699-9_5
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-030-94698-2
Online ISBN: 978-3-030-94699-9
eBook Packages: Physics and AstronomyPhysics and Astronomy (R0)