Abstract
This chapter focuses on representations of those practising Western medicine in British India. It reads the Indian Medical Gazette and Indian Medical Record, alongside journals published in the metropole, to scrutinise the depiction of a set of distinct (but sometimes overlapping) professional groups: ‘official’ and ‘independent’ medical men; practitioners of Indian and Anglo-Indian descent; and medical women. In this context, medical identities intersected with ideas about race, ethnicity, and gender. Meanwhile, in popular fiction for the British reading public, Henry Martineau Greenhow and Arthur Conan Doyle variously portrayed colonial medical men as imperial heroes or ambivalent and even villainous figures. Reflecting on competing constructions of practice in India, the chapter reveals the aspirations and anxieties that underpinned overarching images of British medicine’s imperialist mission.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
Harvey, ‘The Medical Profession’, 1.
- 2.
Andrews and Sutphen, ‘Introduction’, 6.
- 3.
Crozier, Practising Colonial Medicine, 2.
- 4.
Spivak, ‘Can the Subaltern Speak?’, 76.
- 5.
For consistency, this chapter employs the historical place names that feature in the primary sources.
- 6.
Arnold, Colonizing the Body, 12.
- 7.
Harrison, Public Health, 15.
- 8.
Arnold, Colonizing the Body.
- 9.
Pati and Harrison, ‘Introduction’, 2.
- 10.
Johnson and Khalid, Public Health.
- 11.
Finkelstein and Peers, ‘“Great System of Circulation”’, 9-13.
- 12.
‘Nova et Vetera’, 679. There were also medical journals printed in other languages, such as the Hindustani Hyderabad Medical Journal (1855-60).
- 13.
Initially the enterprise of one man, the IMR was relatively short-lived. It ceased publication with Wallace’s death, but was periodically revived in the first half of the twentieth century. ‘Nova et Vetera’, 679.
- 14.
Heath, Purifying Empire, 157.
- 15.
In the main text I refer to the journals as the Gazette and the Record to distinguish more easily between them. Endnotes use the acronyms IMG and IMR to provide a simple but comprehensive reference.
- 16.
‘Ourselves’, 1.
- 17.
Fitzpatrick, ‘Tense Networks’, iii.
- 18.
Harrison, Public Health, 7.
- 19.
‘Medical Administration’, 276.
- 20.
Harrison, Public Health, 31.
- 21.
Crowther and Dupree, Medical Lives, 298.
- 22.
Bynum, ‘The Rise of Science’, 232.
- 23.
‘Competitive Examination’, 544.
- 24.
Seton and Gould, Indian Medical Service, 1.
- 25.
For an overview, see Pati and Harrison, ‘Introduction’, 3.
- 26.
‘The First Annual General Meeting’, 53.
- 27.
It was instituted first in Bombay before being extended to other Presidencies in 1914.
- 28.
Ayurveda, thought to have originated in Buddhist monasteries in India, became absorbed into the Hindu tradition. Yunani was a Graeco-Arabic system of medicine, brought into India with Islam during the medieval period. Lal, ‘“The Ignorance of Women”’, 14.
- 29.
Hart, Medical Profession in India, 5.
- 30.
Said, Orientalism, 3.
- 31.
Hart, Medical Profession in India, 11.
- 32.
Sehrawat, Colonial Medical Care, xxxii; Pati and Harrison, ‘Introduction’, 11.
- 33.
‘The Indian Medical Congress’, 162.
- 34.
Arnold, Colonizing the Body, 9.
- 35.
In the late 1880s, the Lancet carried an occasional column entitled ‘India (From a Correspondent)’, and between 1898 and 1934 it featured another called ‘Notes from India’.
- 36.
‘The Medical Profession in India’, 3 Mar. 1877, 278.
- 37.
‘The Medical Profession in India’, 9 Jun. 1877, 729.
- 38.
‘The Medical Profession in India’, 15 Sept. 1877, 396.
- 39.
‘Professional Co-operation’, 6.
- 40.
‘Professional Co-operation’, 6.
- 41.
‘Reviews and Notices: The Indian Medical Gazette’, 808.
- 42.
‘Ourselves’, 1.
- 43.
‘Ourselves’, 1.
- 44.
Bynum, ‘The Rise of Science’, 232.
- 45.
‘Reviews and Notices of Books: Our Library Table’, 640.
- 46.
‘Britannicus’, ‘Correspondence’, 406.
- 47.
‘The First Annual General Meeting’, 53.
- 48.
‘Independent Medical Practice’, 438.
- 49.
‘Indian Medical Service Reform’, 422.
- 50.
‘Independent Medical Practice’, 437-8.
- 51.
Chatterjee, ‘Correspondence’, 350.
- 52.
‘A Bid for Popularity’, 261.
- 53.
‘Government Support’, 284-7.
- 54.
‘Government Support’, 284, 287.
- 55.
‘The Indian Medical Service’, 11-12.
- 56.
‘The Political Power’, 1102.
- 57.
‘Reviews and Notices: The Indian Medical Gazette’, 808.
- 58.
‘Vaccination in Bengal’, 55.
- 59.
‘The Indian Medical Service’, 12.
- 60.
[Editorial], 1.
- 61.
‘Ourselves’, 2.
- 62.
‘Professional Co-operation’, 6.
- 63.
‘Ourselves’, 1-2.
- 64.
Crowther and Dupree, Medical Lives, 304.
- 65.
‘Reviews and Notices: The Indian Medical Gazette’, 808.
- 66.
‘Clinical Reports in India’, 293.
- 67.
‘Medical Writers in India’, 100-1.
- 68.
See, for example, ‘Annotations: Medical Essays’, 487; ‘Medical Details in Lay Papers’, 1231-2. For more on the profession’s attempt to ‘regulate and manage the circulation of medical knowledge among the general public’ in Britain, see Frampton, ‘“A Borderland”’, 319.
- 69.
[Editorial], 1.
- 70.
Harrison, Public Health, 7-8.
- 71.
‘The Indian Medical Service’, 12.
- 72.
‘1875’, 19.
- 73.
‘Ourselves’, 2.
- 74.
‘Business Notices’, ii.
- 75.
‘Comments and News: The “Indian Medical Record”’, 18.
- 76.
‘Professional Etiquette Disregarded’, 68-9.
- 77.
‘Our Sub-Assistant Surgeons’, 76.
- 78.
‘Our Sub-Assistant Surgeons’, 76.
- 79.
‘1875’, 20.
- 80.
‘1875’, 20.
- 81.
Harrison, Public Health, 31-2.
- 82.
Neelameghan, Development of Medical Societies.
- 83.
‘Comments and News: Indians and the IMS’, 638-9.
- 84.
Mullick, ‘Correspondence’, 1106.
- 85.
Wallace, ‘Correspondence’, 585-6.
- 86.
Wallace, ‘Correspondence’, 585.
- 87.
Harvey, ‘The Indian Medical Service’, 721.
- 88.
‘European Interests’, 44.
- 89.
‘Female Medical Practitioners’, 116.
- 90.
Balfour and Young, Work of Medical Women, 15-16.
- 91.
Balfour and Young, Work of Medical Women, 25-6, 23.
- 92.
Hoggan, Medical Women for India, 1.
- 93.
Open University, ‘National Indian Association’.
- 94.
Balfour and Young, Work of Medical Women, 37.
- 95.
Sehrawat, Colonial Medical Care, xxxvi, 106.
- 96.
Hassan, Diagnosing Empire, 78, 67.
- 97.
Barham, ‘Child Marriage in India’, 122-3.
- 98.
‘Women Doctors for India’, 184-5.
- 99.
‘Women Doctors for India’, 185.
- 100.
Spivak, ‘Can the Subaltern Speak?’, 102.
- 101.
‘Women Doctors for India’, 184-5.
- 102.
Sehrawat, Colonial Medical Care, 22.
- 103.
‘Current Medical Topics’, Feb. 1884, 54.
- 104.
‘Current Medical Topics: Lady Dufferin’s Scheme’, 212-13.
- 105.
‘Current Medical Topics: Female Medical Students’, 246.
- 106.
‘Current Medical Topics: Countess of Dufferin’s Fund’, 248.
- 107.
Sehrawat, ‘Feminising Empire’, 67.
- 108.
‘Our Picture Gallery’, 334.
- 109.
‘Medical Extracts’, 37.
- 110.
‘The Viceroy’, 336.
- 111.
Jayawardena, The White Woman’s Other Burden, 87. Child marriage and the age of consent were also covered in the medical press. See, for example, ‘Child-Wives’, 272-3.
- 112.
‘Clinical Reports in India’, 293.
- 113.
Dissent, ‘A Mirror of Hospital Practice’; Bonnar, ‘A Mirror of Practice’.
- 114.
‘Reporter’, ‘Correspondence’, 673.
- 115.
Sehrawat, ‘Feminising Empire’, 68.
- 116.
These concerns led to the movement’s expansion and reorganisation. The Women’s Medical Service was established in 1914 under the auspices of the Dufferin Fund, with improved conditions of service. Balfour and Young, Work of Medical Women, 50-2.
- 117.
‘The Viceroy’, 336.
- 118.
‘Female Medical Aid’, 226.
- 119.
‘Unpopularity’, 158.
- 120.
‘The Dufferin Hospital’, 664.
- 121.
‘The Dufferin Hospital’, 664.
- 122.
Sehrawat, Colonial Medical Care, xxxvi.
- 123.
‘Reporter’, ‘Correspondence’, 673.
- 124.
Hoggan, Medical Women for India, 2.
- 125.
Scott, The Surgeon’s Daughter, 165.
- 126.
Orr, ‘Sir Ronald Ross’.
- 127.
‘Obituary: Henry Martineau Greenhow’, 1694.
- 128.
[Gregg], ‘Indian Mutiny in Fiction’, 224, 218.
- 129.
Chakravarty, Indian Mutiny, 221.
- 130.
‘Books and Authors’, 836.
- 131.
‘Fiction’, 325.
- 132.
Greenhow, Brenda’s Experiment, 86. Hereafter cited in the text.
- 133.
‘The Physician as a Moralist’, 96.
- 134.
Merriman, Flotsam, 146.
- 135.
Fluet, ‘“Distinct Vocations”’, 136; McClure, Late Imperial Romance, 11.
- 136.
Conan Doyle, ‘The Speckled Band’, 168-9. Hereafter cited in the text.
- 137.
Fluet, ‘“Distinct Vocations”’, 154, 151, 153.
- 138.
Fluet, ‘“Distinct Vocations”’, 146, 141.
- 139.
Conan Doyle, ‘Brown Hand’, 499. Hereafter cited in the text.
- 140.
Briefel, Racial Hand, 2.
- 141.
Briefel, Racial Hand, 36, 38.
- 142.
Briefel, Racial Hand, 40.
- 143.
Fluet, ‘“Distinct Vocations”’, 131.
- 144.
For an overview of postcolonial criticism of The Moonstone see Pykett, Authors in Context, 223-4.
Bibliography
‘1875’. IMG. 1 January 1876: 19-23.
Andrews, Bridie and Mary P. Sutphen, eds. ‘Introduction’. In Medicine and Colonial Identity, 1-13. London: Routledge, 2003.
‘Annotations: Medical Essays for Lay Readers’. Lancet. 5 October 1878: 487.
Arnold, David. Colonizing the Body: State Medicine and Epidemic Disease in Nineteenth-Century India. California: University of California Press, 1993.
Balfour, Margaret I. and Ruth Young. The Work of Medical Women in India. London: Oxford University Press, 1929.
Barham, C.N. ‘Child Marriage in India’. Westminster Review 135 (1891): 113-23.
‘A Bid for Popularity’. IMR. 16 October 1893: 261.
Bonnar, Miss K. ‘A Mirror of Practice: Ovarian Tumour in a Girl Thirteen Years Old’. IMR. 30 January 1901: 110-1.
‘Books and Authors. By Paper Knife’. Hearth and Home. 9 April 1896: 836.
Briefel, Aviva. The Racial Hand in the Victorian Imagination. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015.
‘Britannicus’. ‘Correspondence: The Indian Medical Association’. IMR. 16 December 1893: 406-7.
‘Business Notices’. IMR. 1 January 1895: ii.
Bynum, W.F. ‘The Rise of Science in Medicine, 1850-1913’. In The Western Medical Tradition: 1800-2000, eds. Bynum, Anne Hardy, Stephen Jacyna, Christopher Lawrence, and E.M. Tansey, 111-239. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.
Chakravarty, Gautam. The Indian Mutiny and the British Imagination. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005.
Chatterjee, B.B. ‘Correspondence: Government Ignores the Certificates of Private Practitioners’. IMR. 1 May 1895: 350.
‘Child-Wives’. IMG. September 1890: 272-3.
‘Clinical Reports in India’. IMR. 16 October 1897: 293.
‘Comments and News: The “Indian Medical Record” is Ten Years Old’. IMR. 3 January 1900: 18.
‘Comments and News: Indians and the IMS’. IMR. 12 June 1901: 638-9.
‘Competitive Examination for the Public Services’. Lancet. 8 April 1876: 544.
Conan Doyle, Arthur. ‘The Speckled Band’. In The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, 165-90. London: Penguin, 1981.
———. ‘The Story of the Brown Hand’. Strand Magazine 17 (May 1899): 499-508.
Crowther, M. Anne and Marguerite W. Dupree. Medical Lives in the Age of Surgical Revolution. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007.
Crozier, Anna. Practising Colonial Medicine: The Colonial Medical Service in British East Africa. London: IB Tauris, 2007.
‘Current Medical Topics’. IMG. February 1884: 53-4.
‘Current Medical Topics: Countess of Dufferin’s Fund’. IMG. August 1886: 248.
‘Current Medical Topics: Female Medical Students in Madras’. IMG. August 1886: 246.
‘Current Medical Topics: Lady Dufferin’s Scheme at Madras’. IMG. July 1886: 212-13.
Dissent, Florence. ‘A Mirror of Hospital Practice: Two Cases of Large Uterine Polypus’. IMG. December 1891: 367.
‘The Dufferin Hospital for Indian Women in Calcutta. How to Reach the Purda Woman’. IMR. 19 June 1901: 663-4.
[Editorial]. IMG. 1 January 1866: 1.
‘European Interests in the Medical Reform Question in India’. IMR. 16 January 1896: 44-5.
‘Female Medical Aid for Women’. IMR. 1 April 1893: 226.
‘Female Medical Practitioners Under the Dufferin Fund’. IMR. 16 August 1893: 116.
‘Fiction’. Speaker. 21 March 1896: 324-5.
Finkelstein, David and Douglas M. Peers, eds. ‘“A Great System of Circulation”: Introducing India into the Nineteenth-Century Media’. In Negotiating India in the Nineteenth-Century Media, 1-22. Basingstoke, Hampshire: Macmillan, 2000.
‘The First Annual General Meeting of the Indian Medical Association’. IMR. 16 January 1895: 52-4.
Fitzpatrick, Kieran. ‘Tense Networks: Exploring Medical Professionalization, Career Making and Practice in an Age of Global Empire, Through the Lives and Careers of Irish Surgeons in the Indian Medical Service, c. 1850-1920’. PhD diss., University of Oxford, 2016.
Fluet, Lisa J. ‘“Distinct Vocations” and the Anglo-Indian in Sherlock Holmes’ England’. Victorian Review 24 (Winter 1998): 130-62.
Frampton, Sally. ‘“A Borderland in Ethics”: Medical Journals, the Public, and the Medical Profession in Nineteenth-Century Britain’. In Science Periodicals in Nineteenth-Century Britain: Constructing Scientific Communities, ed. by Gowan Dawson, Bernard Lightman, Sally Shuttleworth and Jonathan R. Topham, 311-36. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2020.
‘Government Support to Indian Medical Journals’. IMR. 1 November 1893: 284-7.
Greenhow, Henry Martineau. Brenda’s Experiment. London: Jarrold, 1896.
[Gregg, Hilda]. ‘The Indian Mutiny in Fiction’. Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine 161 (February 1897): 218-31.
Harrison, Mark. Public Health in British India: Anglo-Indian Preventive Medicine, 1859-1914. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994.
Hart, Ernest. The Medical Profession in India: Its Position and its Work. Calcutta: Thacker, Spink, 1894.
Harvey, Robert. ‘The Indian Medical Service’. BMJ. 14 September 1901: 720-2.
———. ‘The Medical Profession and its Work in India, Past, Present and Future’. IMR. 1 January 1895: 1-7.
Hassan, Narin. Diagnosing Empire: Women, Medical Knowledge, and Colonial Mobility. Farnham: Ashgate, 2011.
Heath, Deana. Purifying Empire: Obscenity and the Politics of Moral Regulation in Britain, India and Australia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010.
Hoggan, Frances Elizabeth. Medical Women for India. Bristol: J.W. Arrowsmith, 1882.
‘Independent Medical Practice in India and the Indian Medical Service’. BMJ. 24 February 1912: 437-8.
‘The Indian Medical Congress’. Lancet. 19 January 1895: 162.
‘The Indian Medical Service’. IMR. 1 February 1890: 11-12.
‘Indian Medical Service Reform’. IMR. 16 June 1896: 422.
Jayawardena, Kumari. The White Woman’s Other Burden: Western Women and South Asia During British Rule. London: Routledge, 1995.
Johnson, Ryan and Amna Khalid, eds. Public Health in the British Empire: Intermediaries, Subordinates, and the Practice of Public Health, 1850-1960. New York: Routledge, 2012.
Lal, Maneesha. ‘“The Ignorance of Women is the House of Illness”: Gender, Nationalism, and Health Reform in Colonial North India’. In Medicine and Colonial Identity, ed. by Bridie Andrews and Mary P. Sutphen, 14-40. London: Routledge, 2003.
McClure, John A. Late Imperial Romance. London: Verso, 1994.
‘Medical Administration in India’. BMJ. 25 February 1882: 275-6.
‘Medical Details in Lay Papers’. Lancet. 28 November 1891: 1231-2.
‘Medical Extracts: Zenana Medical Work in India’. IMR. 1 March 1890: 37.
‘The Medical Profession in India: From our own Correspondent’. BMJ. 3 March 1877: 278-9.
———. 9 June 1877: 729.
———. 15 September 1877: 396-7.
‘Medical Writers in India and the Daily Press’. IMR. 26 July 1899: 100-1.
Merriman, Henry Seton. Flotsam, The Study of a Life. London: Longmans, Green, 1896.
Mullick, Sarat K. ‘Correspondence: The Indian Medical Profession’. Lancet. 13 April 1901: 1105-6.
Neelameghan, Arashanapalai. Development of Medical Societies and Medical Periodicals in India, 1780-1920. Calcutta: Indian Association of Special Libraries and Information Centres, 1963.
‘Nova et Vetera: Seventy-Fifth Anniversary of the Indian Medical Gazette’. BMJ. 3 May 1941: 679.
‘Obituary: Henry Martineau Greenhow’. BMJ. 14 December 1912: 1694.
Open University. ‘National Indian Association’. Making Britain: Discover How South Asians Shaped the Nation, 1870-1950. Accessed 4 January 2015. http://www.open.ac.uk/researchprojects/makingbritain/content/national-indian-association
Orr, Charlotte Elizabeth. ‘Sir Ronald Ross (1857-1932): The Literary Self-Fashioning of a Colonial Medico-Scientific Researcher’. PhD diss., University of Glasgow, 2020.
‘Our Picture Gallery: Miss Florence Dissent’. IMR. 1 May 1895: 334.
‘Our Sub-Assistant Surgeons’. IMG. 1 April 1871: 75-6.
‘Ourselves’. IMR. 1 January 1890: 1-2.
Pati, Biswamoy and Mark Harrison, eds. ‘Introduction’. In Health, Medicine and Empire: Perspectives on Colonial India, 1-36. London: Sangam, 2001.
‘The Physician as a Moralist’. IMR. 1 August 1895: 96-7.
‘The Political Power and Uses of the Medical Services in India’. Lancet. 17 October 1896: 1102.
‘Professional Co-operation’. IMG. 1 January 1866: 6-7.
‘Professional Etiquette Disregarded in India’. IMG. 1 March 1866: 68-9.
Pykett, Lyn. Authors in Context: Wilkie Collins. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005.
‘Reporter’. ‘Correspondence: Dufferin Victoria Hospital for Indian Women’. IMR. 19 June 1901: 673.
‘Reviews and Notices: The Indian Medical Gazette’. BMJ. 20 June 1874: 808-9.
‘Reviews and Notices of Books: Our Library Table: The Medical Register’. Lancet. 19 March 1892: 640.
Said, Edward W. Orientalism. London: Penguin, 2003.
Scott, Walter. The Surgeon’s Daughter and Castle Dangerous. London: Marcus Ward, 1879.
Sehrawat, Samiksha. Colonial Medical Care in North India: Gender, State, and Society, c. 1840-1920. New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2013.
———. ‘Feminising Empire: The Association of Medical Women in India and the Campaign to Found a Women’s Medical Service’. Social Scientist 41.5-6 (May-June 2013): 65-81.
Seton, B.G. and J. Gould. The Indian Medical Service. London: W. Thacker, 1912.
Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty. ‘Can the Subaltern Speak?’. In Colonial Discourse and Post-Colonial Theory, ed. by P. Williams and L. Chrisman, 66-111. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf, 1993.
‘Unpopularity of the Calcutta Zenana Hospital’. IMR. 1 September 1893: 158.
‘Vaccination in Bengal’. IMG. 1 March 1871: 54-5.
‘The Viceroy and the Dufferin Fund’. IMR. 15 March 1899: 335-6.
Wallace, James R. ‘Correspondence: The Anglo-Indian Problem’. IMR. 13 June 1900: 585-6.
‘Women Doctors for India’. IMG. 1 July 1882: 184-5.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2021 The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Moulds, A. (2021). The Colonial Practitioner in British India. In: Medical Identities and Print Culture, 1830s–1910s. Palgrave Studies in Literature, Science and Medicine. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-74345-1_6
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-74345-1_6
Published:
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-030-74344-4
Online ISBN: 978-3-030-74345-1
eBook Packages: Literature, Cultural and Media StudiesLiterature, Cultural and Media Studies (R0)