Abstract
To account for the linear freedom of either in disjunction constructions, I expand upon the focus-based account of den Dikken (2006). Word order constraints, in contrast to movement rules or base-generation constraints, provide the mechanism for explaining the distributional data. I argue that all positional variability exhibited by either ultimately derives from a licensing construction that enables either to be shuffled about disjunct-internally, yet simultaneously prevents either from entering into linear precedence relations with disjunct-external constituents. Restrictions on the surface realization of either result from a linear precedence rule ordering either before the contrastive focus, language particular constraints on word order, and general constraints on coordinate ellipsis. Overall, this analysis presents an account of either … or constructions that introduces only a single linear precedence rule and a licensing construction for combining either with disjunctions to account for the data, relying on independently-motivated constraints to carry the rest of the analytical burden.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Beavers, John, and Ivan A. Sag. 2004. Coordinate ellipsis and apparent non-constituent coordination. In Proceedings of the HPSG04 conference, ed. Stefan Müller. Stanford: CSLI.
Büring, Daniel. 2006. Focus projection and default prominence. In The architecture of focus, eds. Valéria Molnár and Susanne Winkler. New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Chaves, Rui P. 2007. Coordinate structures—constraint-based syntax-semantics processing. PhD Thesis, University of Lisbon.
Chaves, Rui P. 2008. Linearization-based word-part ellipsis. Linguistics and Philosophy 31: 261–307.
Chaves, Rui P., and Ivan A. Sag. 2010. Left- and right-peripheral ellipsis in coordinate and non-coordinate structures (submitted).
Chomsky, Noam. 1957. Syntactic structures. The Hague: Mouton de Gruyter.
Chomsky, Noam. 1973. Conditions on transformations. In A Festschrift for Morris Halle, eds. Stephen Anderson and Paul Kiparsky, 232–286. New York: Holt, Reinhart & Winston.
Chomsky, Noam. 1986. Barriers. Cambridge: MIT Press.
De Kuthy, Kordula. 2002. Discontinuous NPs in German—a case study of the interaction of syntax, semantics and pragmatics, Stanford: CSLI.
De Kuthy, Kordula, and W. Detmar Meurers. 2003. The secret life of focus exponents, and what it tells us about fronted verbal projections. In Proceedings of the HPSG03 conference, ed. Stefan Müller. Stanford: CSLI.
den Dikken, Marcel. 2006. Either-float and the syntax of co-or-dination. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 24: 689–749.
Donohue, Catherine, and Ivan A. Sag. 2004. Domains in Warlpiri. Unpublished manuscript, Stanford University.
Dowty, David. 1995. Toward a minimalist theory of syntactic structure. In Discontinuous constituency, eds. H. Bunt and A. van Horck, 11–62. Berlin: Mouton.
Engdahl, Elisabeth, and Enric Vallduví. 1996. Information packaging in HPSG. In Edinburgh working papers in cognitive science, eds. Claire Grover and Enric Vallduví, Vol. 12 of Studies in HPSG, 1–31. Edinburgh: Center for Cognitive Science, University of Edinburgh.
Ernst, Thomas. 2002. Syntax of adjuncts. Port Chester: Cambridge University Press.
Ernst, Thomas. 2004. Principles of adverbial distribution in the lower clause. Lingua 114: 755–777.
Gazdar, Gerald, and Geoff Pullum. 1981. Subcategorization, constituent order, and the notion ‘head.’. In The scope of lexical rules, eds. Michael Moortgats, Harry van der Hulsts, and Teun Hoekstras. Dordrecht: Foris.
Han, Chung-hye, and Maribel Romero. 2004. The syntax of whether/Q …or questions: ellipsis combined with movement. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 22: 527–564.
Heim, Irene. 1997. Predicates or formulas? Evidence from ellipsis. Proceedings of SALT 7: 197–221.
Hendriks, Petra. 2001. Initial coordination and the law of coordination of likes. In Linguistics in the Netherlands 2001, eds. Ton van der Wouden and Hans Broekhuis, 127–138. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Hendriks, Petra. 2003. Either is a focus particle. Unpublished manuscript, University of Groningen.
Hendriks, Petra. 2004. Either, both and neither in coordinate structures. In The composition of meaning, eds. Alice ter Meulen and Werner Abraham. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Kathol, Andreas. 2000. Linear syntax. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kathol, Andreas, and Carl Pollard. 1995. Extraposition via complex domain formation. In Proceedings of the thirty-third annual meeting of the ACL. Boston: Association for Computational Linguistics.
Kiss, Katalin E. 1998. Identificational focus versus information focus. Language 74: 245–273.
Larson, Richard. 1985. On the syntax of disjunction scope. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 3: 217–264.
Maekawa, Takafumi. 2004. Constituency, word order, and focus projection. In Proceedings of the HPSG04 Conference, ed. Stefan Müller. Stanford: CSLI.
Martin, Andrea, and Brian McElree. 2008. A content-addressable pointer mechanism underlies comprehension of verb phrase ellipsis. Journal of Memory and Language 58: 879–906.
Miller, George A., and Noam Chomsky. 1963. Finitary models of language users. In Vol. 2 of Handbook of mathematical psychology, eds. Luce R. Duncan, Robert R. Bush, and Eugene Galanter, 419–492. New York: Wiley.
Pollard, Carl, Robert Kasper, and Robert Levine. 1994. Studies in constituent ordering: toward a theory of linearization in Head-driven Phrase Structure Grammar. Research proposal to the National Science Foundation.
Reape, Michael. 1990. Getting things in order. Paper presented at 1990 Tilburg Conference on Syntactic Discontinuity. Slightly revised version published as Reape, 1996.
Reape, Michael. 1996. Getting things in order. In Discontinuous constituency, eds. Harry Bunt and Arthur van Horck, 209–257. Berlin: Mouton.
Romero, Maribel, and Chung-hye Han. 2003. Focus, ellipsis and the semantics of alternative questions. Empirical Issues in Formal Syntax 4: 291–307.
Ross, John R. 1967. Constraints on variables in syntax. PhD Thesis, MIT.
Sag, Ivan A. 2010. Sign-based construction grammar: an informal synopsis. In Sign-based construction grammar, eds. Hans Boas and Ivan A. Sag. Stanford: CSLI.
Sag, Ivan A., Gerald Gazdar, Thomas Wasow, and Steven Weisler. 1985. Coordination and how to distinguish categories. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 3: 117–171.
Sag, Ivan A., Thomas Wasow, and Emily Bender. 2003. Syntactic theory: a formal introduction. Stanford: CSLI.
Schwarz, Bernhard. 1999. On the syntax of either …or. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 17: 339–370.
Selkirk, Lisa. 1995. Sentence prosody: intonation, stress, and phrasing. In The handbook of phonological theory, ed. John Goldsmith, 550–569. London: Blackwell.
van Oirsouw, Robert R. 1987. The syntax of coordination. London: Croom Helm.
Wexler, Kenneth, and Peter Culicover. 1980. Formal principles of language acquisition. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Wilder, Chris. 1997. Some properties of ellipsis in coordination. In Studies on universal grammar and typological variation, eds. Alexiadou Artemis and T. Alan Hall. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Yatabe, Shuichi. 2001. Linearization-based syntax and semantics: an overview. Conference handbook 19: the nineteenth national conference of the English Linguistic Society in Japan, 192–197.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0), which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
About this article
Cite this article
Hofmeister, P. A linearization account of either … or constructions. Nat Lang Linguist Theory 28, 275–314 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11049-010-9090-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11049-010-9090-4