Abstract
During the last two decades Indonesia has experienced immense forest and land fires. Often these fires are associated with extended drought and widespread use of fire to clear previously logged forest and other degraded land in preparation for oil palm, rubber, or pulpwood plantations. There are many reasons for the use of fire in land clearing activities, but probably the most important one is economics. There is still acceptance that fire is the cheapest, fastest, and most effective land clearing method with the added benefit of providing nutrients from ash residues.
This paper provides a review of existing information on the financial costs and benefits of using fire for land clearing in agriculture and forestry plantations as compared with zero-burning techniques. The findings indicate that the economic advantage of fire use varies widely and depends on many factors, such as soil fertility, vegetation density, labour cost, equipment and training costs, and the costs of fire management. For large-scale land clearing, the financial analysis of the costs and benefits of fire versus zero-burning shows that when applied to low-volume vegetation, zero-burning methods are not more expensive than burning – and may actually be more cost effective in the long term. This is the case for clearing oil palm or rubber plantations for replanting, low secondary vegetation, and heavily logged-over forest. Under high-volume forest conditions, burning remains less expensive because it is more difficult, time consuming, and costly to dispose of high volumes of piled wood mechanically.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
BAPPENAS (1999a) Planning for Fire Prevention and Drought Management Project. ADB TA 2999-INO. Final Report. Vol. 1: Planning for Fire Prevention and Drought Management. National Development Planning Agency, Jakarta, Indonesia
BAPPENAS (1999b) Planning for Fire Prevention and Drought Management Project. Volume 2: Causes, Extent, Impact and Costs of 1997/98 Fires and Drought. National Development Planning Agency, Jakarta, Indonesia
Bompard JM, Guizol P (1999) Land management in the province of South Sumatra, Indonesia. Fanning the flames: The Institutional Causes of Vegetation Fires, Palembang, Indonesia, Forest Fire Prevention and Control Project, European Union/Ministry of Forestry and Estate Crops.
Chandler C, Cheney P, Thomas P, Traband L, Williams D (1983) Fire in forestry, Vol. I. John Wiley and Sons, New York, USA
Darnoko D (2002) Eco-technology for oil palm biomass utilization, Paper presented at the Workshop Economic of Fire Use in Agriculture and Forest Plantations. Kuching, Malaysia
Fairhurst T (2002) Effect of fire and biomass removal on the monetary value of nutrient stocks contained in standing biomass. In: Gouyon A, Simorangkir D (eds) The Economics of Fire Use in Agriculture and Forestry: A Preliminary Review for Indonesia. Project FireFight South East Asia, Bogor, Indonesia
Focus on Finance (2001) Campaign case study: Dutch banks commit to forest conservation. Focus on Finance Newsletter
Glover D, Jessup T (1998) The Indonesian Fires and Haze of 1997: The Economic Toll. Economy and Environment Program for SE Asia and the World Wildlife Fund, Singapore and Jakarta
Glover D, Jessup T (1999) Indonesia's Fires and Haze: The Cost of Catastrophe. Institute of Southeast Asian Studies and International Development Research Centre. Singapore, Singapore and Canada
Gönner C (1998) Conflicts and Fire Causes in a Sub-District of Kutai, East Kalimantan, Indonesia. IFFM/GTZ, Samarinda, Indonesia
Gouyon A (1999a) The Sustainable Development of Tree Crops and the Prevention of Vegetation Fires in South Sumatra Province, Indonesia. Forest Fire Prevention and Control Project, South Sumatra Regional Forestry Office and European Union, Palembang, Indonesia
Gouyon A (1999b) Fire in the rubber jungle. Fire prevention and sustainable tree crop development in South Sumatra. International Forest Fire News 21:48–56
Gouyon A, Simorangkir D (2002) The Economics of Fire Use in Agriculture and Forestry: A Preliminary Review for Indonesia. Project FireFight South East Asia, Bogor, Indonesia
Hamilton A (1998) Financing the Asian palm oil industry through the current economics crisis and beyond. Proceedings of the 1998 International Oil Palm Conference, Nusa Dua, Bali, Indonesia, pp. 535–540
Hashim MT, Teoh CH, Kamarudzaman A, Ali AM (1993) Zero burning: an environmentally friendly replanting technique. Proceedings of the PORIM International Palm Oil Congress ‘Update and Vision’. Palm Oil Research Institute of Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Jamaludin N, Ariffin MP, Surip AR (1999) Zero burning in jungle to oil palm planting. Proceedings of the 1999 PORIM International Palm Oil Congress — Agriculture. Emerging Technologies and Opportunities in the Next Millennium. Palm Oil Research Institute of Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, pp. 243–251
Liang SM (2002) Fire: a burning issue in forest plantation. Paper presented at the Workshop Economic of Fire Use in Agriculture and Forest Plantations. Kuching, Malaysia
Loh HP, Sharma M (1999) The essential of oil palm replanting: united plantations' experience. The Planter 75:289–303
Mackensen J (1998) Untersuchung zur nachhaltigen Nährstoffversorgung in schnellwachsenden Plantagensystemen in Ost-Kalimantan, Indonesien: Ekologische und ökonomische Implikationen. Göttinger Beiträge zur Land- und Forstwirtschaft in den Tropen und Subtropen, Heft 127. Göttingen,Germany
Mackensen J (1999) Nutrient management for industrial tree plantations (HTI) in Indonesia. A practical guidance towards integrated nutrient management, TöB FTWF-17e. Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit, Eschborn, Germany
Mackensen J, Foelster H (1999) Study on Sustainable Nutrient Supply in Fast Growing Plantation: Ecological and Economic Implication in East Kalimantan, Indonesia, TöB FTWF-II/11e. Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit, Eschborn, Germany
Nicolas MVJ, Beebe GS (1999) The Training of Forest Firefighters in Indonesia, Forest Fire Prevention and Control Project and Integrated Forest Fire Management Project, European Union, GTZ and Ministry of Forestry and Estate Crops, South Sumatra Regional Forest Office Palembang and East Kalimantan Regional Forest Office Samarinda, Indonesia
Nicolas MVJ, Pansah H (2001) Indicative Budget for Fire Management in the Forest Concessions of Indonesia. South and Central Kalimantan Production Forest Project, Banjarbaru, European Union and the Ministry of Forestry, Jakarta, Indonesia
Nicolas MVJ, Faidil S, Pansah H (2001) Fire Management Planning: Assessment and Recommendations for P.T. Aya Yayang Indonesia. South and Central Kalimantan Production Forest Project, Banjarbaru, European Union and the Ministry of Forestry, Jakarta, Indonesia
Nursidiq (1992) Pertumbuhan Acacia mangium Willd dan Eucalyptus deglupta Blume pada lahan tidak dibakar dan dibakar di PT. ITCI Kenangan, Kabupaten Pasir. BSc Thesis, Fakultas Kehutanan, Universitas Mulawarman, Samarinda, Indonesia
Ooi LH, Goh TM, Ang BN, Tan KS (2001) A new method of clearing oil palms for replanting. In: Board MPO (ed.) Proceedings of the 2001 PORIM International Palm Oil Congress (Agriculture). MPOB, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, pp. 150–159
Pritchett WL, Fisher RF (1987) Properties and Management of Forest Soils, Second Edition. John Wiley and Sons, New York, USA
Project FireFight South East Asia (2002) Burning Issues No. 3: ‘Zero Burning’: A Viable Option? Project FireFight South East Asia, Bogor, Indonesia
Project FireFight South East Asia (2003) Convicting Forest and Land Fire Offences: A Case Study of the Legal Process in Riau, Indonesia. Project FireFight South East Asia, Bogor, Indonesia
Sargeant H (2001) Vegetation Fires in Sumatra, Indonesia. Oil Palm Agriculture in the Wetlands of Sumatra: Destruction or Development. Forest Fire Prevention and Control Project, European Union, Ministry of Forestry, South Sumatra, Indonesia
Simorangkir D, Mackensen J (2001) Petunjuk praktis pengelolaan unsur hara pada Hutan Tanaman Industri (HTI). Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit, Eschborn, Germany
Simorangkir D, Moore P, Haase N, Ng G (2003) Land Clearing on Degraded Lands for Plantation Development. Report of the Workshop Economic of Fire Use in Agriculture and Forest Plantations, Kuching, Malaysia
Suyanto Chokkalingam U, Wibowo P (2004) Kebakaran di Lahan Rawa/Gambut di Sumatera: Masalah dan Solusi. Prosiding Semiloka, Palembang, Indonesia
Thandapani PU (2002) Developing oil palm on peat in Sarawak: zero burning technique. Paper presented at the Workshop Economic of Fire Use in Agriculture and Forest Plantations, Kuching, Malaysia
World Bank (2001) Indonesia: Environment and Natural Resource Management in a Time of Transition. World Bank, Washington, DC, USA
Yow TK, Jamaluddin N (2001) Replanting policies and strategies in Golden Hope. In: Board MPO (ed.) Proceedings of the 2001 PORIM International Palm Oil Congress (Agriculture). MPOB, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, pp. 289–294
Zulnerlin, Ibrahim AF (1999) Experience in zero burning in plantations of P.T. P.P. London Sumatra Indonesia Tbk. In: Board MPO (ed.) Proceedings of the 1999 PORIM International Palm Oil Congress (Agriculture). MPOB, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, pp. 55–63
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Simorangkir, D. Fire use: Is it really the cheaper land preparation method for large-scale plantations?. Mitig Adapt Strat Glob Change 12, 147–164 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11027-006-9049-2
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11027-006-9049-2