Abstract
It is frequently claimed that green algae are intrinsically more productive, often by orders of magnitude, than higher plants commonly grown as crops for food. There is no firm evidence for this belief. On the contrary, there is much experience which shows that algae are not more but less productive. Under optimal conditions, all green organisms photosynthesize at the same rate in low light and, whilst commonly cultivated ‘sun’ species show some differences in rate in full light, these do not translate into widely different rates of accumulation of biomass. Accordingly, irrespective of crop, one acre of land, pond or bioreactor, can annually yield about enough biomass to fuel one motor vehicle or meet the calorific requirement of several people. This amount of biomass is not sufficient to make other than a very small contribution to our present road transport requirements and yet contributes significantly to global food shortages and rising prices. Reliable evidence also suggests that, if all of the inputs are taken into account, the net energy gain of liquid biofuels, derived either from algae or terrestrial crops, is either very modest or non-existent and will therefore bring about little or no sparing of carbon dioxide emissions.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Barber J, Archer MD (2004) ‘Photosynthesis and photoconversion. In: Series on Photoconversion of Solar Energy - Vol.2 Molecular to Global Photosynthesis. Archer MD. Barber J (eds). Imperial College, UK. pp 1-41.
Baldry CW, Bucke C, Walker DA (1966) Temperature and photosynthesis. I Some effects of temperature on carbon dioxide fixation by isolated chloroplasts. Biochim Biophys Acta 126:207–213. doi:10.1016/0926-6585(66)90056-2
BBC News Channel (2009) Go-ahead for new Heathrow runway http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7829676.stm
Belay A (1997) Mass culture of Spirulina outdoors – The Earthrise Experience. In: Vonshak A (ed) Spirulina platensis (Arthrospira): Physiology, Cell-biology and Biotechnology. Taylor & Francis, London UK, pp 131–158
Benemann J (2007) An in-depth look at biofuels from algae. http://biopact.com/2007/01/in-depth-look-at-biofuels-from-algae.html http://www.theoildrum.com/node/2541 Accessed September 2008
Benemann J (2008) Opportunities & challenges in algae biofuels production' http://www.oilgae.com/blog/2008/09/dr-john-r-benemann-new-white-paper.html
Benemann J (2009) Microalgae biofuels: a brief introduction. www.adelaide.edu.au/biogas/renewable/biofuels_introduction.pdf
Benemann JR, Oswald WJ (1996), Systems and economic analysis of microalgae ponds for conversion of CO2 to biomass. Final report. US DOE http://www.osti.gov/bridge/servlets/purl/493389-FXQyZ2/webviewable/493389.pdf Accessed September 2008
Bjorkman O, Demmig B (1987) Photon yield of O2 evolution and chlorophyll fluorescence characteristics at 77 K among vascular plants of diverse origins. Planta 170:489–504. doi:10.1007/BF00402983
Boardman NK (1980) Energy from the biological conversion of solar energy. Philos Trans R Soc Lond A 295:477–489. doi:10.1098/rsta.1980.0144
Boeing 747-400(2009) http://www.boeing.com/commercial/747family/pf/pf_facts.html
Briggs M (2004) Widescale biodiesel production from algae http://www.unh.edu/p2/biodiesel/article_alge.html Accessed September 2008
British Potato Council (2007) Provisional estimate of GB potato supply for http://www.potato.org.uk/media_files/MIS_reports_2006_07/supply2007.pdf Accessed September 2008
Bullard MJ (2004) 'Photoconversion and energy crops' Pages 453-519 In:Photoconversion of Solar Energy, Vol.2 Molecular to Global Photosynthesis. Archer MD, Barber J (eds). Imperial College, UK. p 189-220
Carse M (2007) Quoted in business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/industry_sectors/natural_resources/article2917931.ece
Dale. BE (2007)‘The Cost of Biofuels’ in Chemical & Engineering News ISSN 0009-2347 http://pubs.acs.org/cen/coverstory/85/8551cover.html
Dyer G (2006) How Long Can the World Feed Itself? http://www.energybulletin.net/node/21736 Accessed September 2008
Edwards GE, Walker DA (1983) C3, C4, Mechanisms, and Cellular and Environmental Regulation of Photosynthesis. Blackwell, Oxford, pp 1–542
Edwards GE, Walker DA, (2004) ‘Photosynthetic Carbon Assimilation’ In Series on Photoconversion of Solar Energy - Vol.2 Molecular to Global Photosynthesis (189-220) Editors MD Archer & J Barber. Imperial College, UK
Delieu T, Walker DA (1981) Polarographic measurement of photosynthetic O2 evolution by leaf discs. New Phytol 89:165–175
Emerson R (1929) Photosynthesis as a function of light intensity and of temperature. J.Gen Physiol 12:623–639
GreenFuels Online (2007 ) Growth Rates of Emission-Fed Algae Show Viability of New Biomass Crop http://www.greenfuelsonline.com/gf_files/Greenfuels Growth Rates.pdf
Gressel J (2008) Transgenics are imperative for biofuel crops. Plant Sci 174:246–263
Haverkort AJ (1990) Ecology of potato cropping systems in relation to latitude and altitude. Agric Syst 32:251–272
Hodge, N (2008) Investing in Algae Biofuel http://www.greenchipstocks.com/report/investing-in-algae-biofuel/109 Accessed September 2008
Huntley ME, Redalje D (2007) CO2 mitigation and renewable oil from photosynthetic microbes: a new appraisal. Mitig Adapt Strat Glob Change 12:573–608
Johnston M, Foley JA, Holloway T, Kucharik C, Monfreda,C (2009) Resetting global expectations from agricultural biofuels. Env Res Lett 4: doi:10.1088/1748-9326/4/1/014004
Kania S & Giacomelli, G, (2000) Solar radiation availability for plant growth in Arizona controlled environment agriculture. http://ag.arizona.edu/CEAC/research/archive/solar-radiation_kania.pdf. Accessed March-August 2008
Labate CA, Adcock MD, Leegood RC (1990) Effects of temperature on the regulation of photosynthetic carbon assimilation in leaves of maize and barley. Planta 181:547–554
Larson ED (2000) In memory of Professor David Hall. Energy for Sustainable Development 4:5–6
Leach G (1975) Energy and food production. Food Policy 1:62–73
Long SP, Zhu X, Naidu SL, Ort DR (2006) Can improvement in photosynthesis increase crop yields? Plant cell environ 29:315–330
Longhurst A, Sathyendranath S, Platt T, Caverhill C (1995) An estimate of global primary production in the ocean from satellite radiometer data. J Plankton Res 17:1245–1271
National Farmers Union U.K. (2006) UK biofuels - land required to meet RTFO 2010. http://www.nfuonline.com/x9763.xml. Accessed September 2008
Nielsen ES (1957) The chlorophyll content and the light utilization in communities of plankton algae and terrestrial higher plants. Physiol Plant 10:1009–1021
Noctor G, Foyer CH (1999) Homeostasis of adenylate status during photosynthesis in a fluctuating environment J. Exp. Bot. 51:347–356
Ort D, Long SP (2003) Converting Solar Energy into Crop Production. In Plants, Genes, and Crop Biotechnology (240-269). Edited by Chrispeels MJ, Sadava DE. Jones and Bartlett Publisher International
Pimentel D, Pimentel,M (1990) Land, energy and water: the constraints governing ideal U.S. population size. http://dieoff.org/page136.htm. Accessed March-August 2008
Pimentel D, Patzek TW (2005) Ethanol production using corn, switchgrass, and wood; biodiesel production using soybean and sunflower. Nat Resour Res 14:65–76
Pimentel D, Patzek TW (2007) Ethanol production: Energy and economic issues related to U.S. and Brazilian Sugarcane Natural Resources Research, In: Biofuels, Solar and wind as renewable systems. Pimentel D. (ed) Springer, Berlin. P 357-371.
Pirt SJ (1986) The thermodynamic efficiency (quantum demand) and dynamics of photosynthetic growth. New Phytol 102:3–37
Potatoes (2007) This article may be downloaded from www.pan-europe.info/Resources/Reports/Potato_production_review.pdf. Accessed September 2008
Pulz, O (2007) Growth Rates of Emission-Fed Algae Show Viability of New Biomass Crop. http://www.greenfuelonline.com/gf_files/GreenFuel Growth Rates.pdf. Accessed May 2009
Radmer R, Kok B (1977) Photosynthesis: limited yields, unlimited dreams. BioScience 27:599–605
Rao KK (1999) Obituary: David Hall, Professor of Biology, King’s College London. Photosynth Res 62:117–119
Rice-Davies M (1963) <en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandy_Rice-Davies>
Robert Hill Institute at Sheffield, http://www.shef.ac.uk/rhi/about-rhi.html
Rosenberg JN, Oyler GA, Wilkinson L, Betenbaugh MJ (2008) A green light for engineered algae: redirecting metabolism to fuel a biotechnology revolution. Curr Opin Biotechnol 19:1–7
Roy Soc Policy Document (2008 ) Sustainable biofuels: prospects and challenges. http://royalsociety.org/document.asp?latest=1&id=7366.
Sachs J , von (1887) ‘Periodic variations in growth’ In Lectures on the Physiology of Plants. Tr. by H. Marshall Ward. (532-569) Oxford, Clarendon Press
Salassi, ME (2007) The Economic Feasibility of Ethanol Production from Sugar Crops. Louisiana Agriculture Magazine Winter Issue. http://www.bae.lsu.edu/en/communications/publications/agmag/Archive/2007/Winter/The+Economic+Feasibility+of+Ethanol+Production+from+Sugar+Crops.htm. Accessed September 2008
Sears.J (2006) “Algae are the fastest-growing organisms on the planet”. http://www.ecosherpa.com/green-energy/algae-biofuel-revisitedagain/, http://www.energysavingtrust.org.uk/fleet/news/dailynews/index.cfm/Scientists-work-to-turn-algae-into-biofuel/?mode=view&articleid=18005564. Accessed September 2008
Seaton GGR, Walker DA (1990) Chlorophyll fluorescence as a measure of photosynthetic carbon assimilation. Proc Roy.Soc.B 242:29–35
Sheehan, J., Dunahay, T., Benemann, J., Roessler, P. Weissman, J. (1998). Look Back at the U.S. Department of Energy's Aquatic Species Program: Biodiesel from Algae; Close-Out Report. 325 pp.; NREL Report No. TP-580-24190
Spalding MH, Edwards GE, Ku MSB (1980) Quantum requirement for photosynthesis in Sedum praealtum during two phases of crassulacean acid metabolism. Plant Physiology 66:463–465
Squatriglia C (2008) Virgin Atlantic Biofuel Flight - Green Breakthrough or Greenwash? http://blog.wired.com/cars/2008/02/virgin-atlantic.html
US Department of Agriculture (2005) Malaysia: Palm Oil Yields Surprisingly High: http://www.fas.usda.gov/pecad2/highlights/2005/06/palm_23June05/index.htm. Accessed September 2008
Vonshak A, Sivak MN, Walker DA (1989) Use of a solid support in the study of photosynthetic activity of Spirulina platensis. J Appl Phycol 1:131–136
Vonshak A, Chanawongse L, Bunnag B, Tanticharoen M (1996) Light acclimation and photoinhibition in three Spirulina platensis (Cyanobacteria) isolates. J Appl Phycol 8:35–40
Walker DA (1987) The use of the oxygen electrode and fluorescence probes in simple measurements of photosynthesis. pp 1-145 Oxygraphics Limited, Sheffield,U.K. http://openlibrary.org/b/OL22490865M, http://www.shef.ac.uk/library/libdocs/use.pdf. Accessed September 5, 2008
Walker DA (1989) Automated measurement of leaf photosynthetic O2 evolution as a function of photon flux density. Phil Trans R Soc Lond B 323:313–326
Walker DA (1992a) Energy, Plants and Man. , 2Oxygraphics, Brighton, p 277
Walker DA (1992b) Excited leaves. Tansley Review 36. New Phytol 121:325–345
Walker DA (1995) Manipulating photosynthetic metabolism to improve crops: an inversion of ends and means. J.Exp.Bot 46 Special Issue 1253-1259
Walker DA (1997) Tell me where all past years are. Photosynth Res 51:1–26
Walker DA (2000) Like clockwork. Oxygraphics, Sheffield, p 129
Walker DA, (2008) ‘A New Leaf in Time’ http://www.shef.ac.uk/library/libdocs/alit.pdf
Walker DA, Osmond B (1986) Measurement of photosynthesis in vivo with a leaf disc electrode: correlations between light dependence of steady-state photosynthetic O2 evolution and chlorophyll a fluorescence transients. Proc R Soc B 227:267–280
Weissman JC, Goebel RP, Benemann JR (1988) Photobioreactor design: comparison of open ponds and tubular reactors. Bioeng Biotech 31:336–344
Wikipedia Oil Palms http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_palm. Accessed September 2008
Wikipedia (2009) Net Energy Gain. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_energy_gain
Zhu X, Long SP, Ort DR (2008) Converting solar energy into crop production. Curr Opin Biotechnol 19:153–159
Acknowledgments
I am most grateful to John Benemann, Anton Haverkort, Ulrich Heber, and Avigad Vonshak, for advice and much needed criticism.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Invited paper presented at the 3rd Congress of the International Society for Applied Phycology, Galway.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Walker, D.A. Biofuels, facts, fantasy, and feasibility. J Appl Phycol 21, 509–517 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10811-009-9446-5
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10811-009-9446-5