Regular ArticleModel Updating In Structural Dynamics: A Survey
Abstract
It is well known that finite element predictions are often called into question when they are in conflict with test results. The area known as model updating is concerned with the correction of finite element models by processing records of dynamic response from test structures. Model updating is a rapidly developing technology, and it is intended that this paper will provide an accurate review of the state of the art at the time of going to press. It is the authors' hope that this work will prove to be of value, especially to those who are getting acquainted with the research base and aim to participate in the application of model updating in industry, where a pressing need exists.
References (0)
Cited by (1681)
An iterative method for updating finite element models with connectivity constraints
2024, Mathematics and Computers in SimulationIt is well known that the analytical matrices arising from the discretization of distributed parameter systems using the finite element technique are usually symmetric and banded. How to preserve the coefficient matrices of the updated model being of the same band structure is an important yet difficult challenge for model updating in structural dynamics. In this paper, an iterative method for updating mass, damping and stiffness matrices simultaneously based on partial modal measured data is provided. By the method, the optimal updated matrices can be obtained within finite iteration steps by choosing a special kind of initial matrix triplet. The proposed approach not only preserves the physical connectivity of the original model, but also the updated model reproduces the measured modal data, which can be utilized for various finite element model updating problems. Numerical examples confirm the effectiveness of the introduced method.
Rotation of mode shapes in structural dynamics due to mass and stiffness perturbations
2024, Mechanical Systems and Signal ProcessingAccording to the structural dynamic modification theory, the perturbed mode shapes can be expressed as a linear combination of the unperturbed mode shapes through a transformation matrix . This matrix is proposed in this paper as a powerful technique to determine whether the discrepancies between two models can be attributed to differences in stiffness, in mass, or both. It is demonstrated that matrix becomes a rotation matrix when there are no mass discrepancies. In the case of mass discrepancies, or a combination of mass and stiffness differences, matrix can be decomposed into a product of a rotation matrix and a matrix containing information about the changes in scaling and in shear. The angle of rotation depends on the closeness of the modes, and large rotations can be obtained when the system presents closely spaced or repeated modes. The polar and the QR decompositions are used in this paper to factorize matrix as a product of two matrices, one of them being a rotation matrix. A new version of the modal assurance criterion (MAC), denoted in this paper as rotated MAC or ROTMAC, is proposed to detect mass discrepancies between two models. The equations and the conclusions derived in this paper have been validated through numerical simulations on a 2-degrees-of-freedom system and by correlating a numerical model and an experimental model of a square laminated glass plate.
Hierarchical Bayesian finite element model updating: Optimal weighting of modal residuals with application to FINO3 offshore platform
2024, Mechanical Systems and Signal ProcessingUpdating Finite Element (FE) models based on modal data has become a standard tool for condition monitoring and damage detection in structures. The basis of this approach is to minimize the discrepancy between the experimental and analytical modal frequencies and shapes through a particular loss function derived through deterministic or probabilistic methods. However, the weighting of modal features can affect the identified structural model parameters, which requires proper treatment. This paper revisits this problem by proposing a novel hierarchical Bayesian formulation, wherein the covariance matrix of modal residuals is identified from the data, leading to automated weighting of the modal residuals. As the calculation of the posterior distribution encounters computational overheads, an efficient Expectation-Maximization algorithm is proposed to approximate the optimal values of the parameters. Bayesian information criterion is employed to select the most plausible layout for the prediction errors covariance matrix. A new strategy is also established for handling dynamical modes with close modal frequencies. Finally, the proposed approaches are examined using simulated and real data from FINO3 offshore platform. As a result, reasonable estimations with desirable uncertainty bounds are acquired. Although the weighting of modal features varies on a case-to-case basis, it is observed that the proposed method might lead to non-trivial and interesting weighting factors according to the data-driven uncertainty of modal residuals.
On using autoencoders with non-standardized time series data for damage localization
2024, Engineering StructuresIn this paper, an autoencoder trained with non-standardized time series data and evaluated using covariance-based residuals for generally applicable unsupervised damage localization is investigated. Raw acceleration time series are used as the inputs for the autoencoder to give both these features: no loss of information and exploitation of the full potential of the neural network. When it comes to output-only and unsupervised structural health monitoring (SHM), data-driven models struggle to localize the positions of damage adequately or only work well in a small range of applications. Regarding neural networks, expertise is needed for the neural network dimensioning and understanding of structural dynamics, which increases the difficulty of the task. In order to simplify the process, an automated solution is provided to perform the neural architecture search, and principal component analysis (PCA) is used to find a good choice for the bottleneck dimension. As an extension of the model, the residuals between the original and reconstructed time series are evaluated using the covariance between each input signal and each residual time series, which results in improved indicators for damage localization. We demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed schemes for damage analysis in a series of simulations using a three-mass swinger, in which the autoencoder can localize the damage using varying excitation locations. The covariances’ evaluation indicates that they are more potent than using the reconstruction error. Finally, experimental validation is conducted using vibration test data from a lattice tower called Leibniz University Structure for Monitoring (LUMO) under ambient excitation. For each damage pattern, high sensitivity towards local stiffness is achieved. Additionally, the damage position indicators exhibit a clear decreasing trend as the distance from the damage increases. The autoencoders presented here with non-standardized time series and covariance-based evaluation of residuals lead to increased robustness and sensitivity regarding damage localization.
Virtual measurements for exterior vibro-acoustic problems using experimental modal models
2024, Mechanical Systems and Signal ProcessingThis paper presents a virtual sensor scheme for vibroacoustic radiation applications based on experimental modal state-space models and sparse measurements. A Kalman filter is used for the estimation combining data from the acoustical and the structural domain together with the numerical modal process model. It is proposed to use Gramians, as an energy-related measure of a system’s observability which enables assessing the observability of the coupled vibroacoustic system in the modal state-space domain and the physical state domain counterpart. This Gramian-based observability metric reveals modes or states of high observability, which ensure good estimation results in the subsequent estimation. The proposed method is validated using an industrial test setup for which, due to its high complexity, modelling with first-principle techniques is not feasible. The estimation results demonstrate improved performance compared to a pure forward use of the identified model, indicating the effectiveness of the virtual sensor approach. Additionally, the newly proposed Gramian-based observability criterion outperforms state-of-the-art metrics for sensor placement in terms of estimation accuracy for particular states of interest, as demonstrated in a sensor placement task. Overall, this paper provides a promising approach for virtual sensing for vibroacoustic applications, enabling accurate and efficient system monitoring and control.
Large-scale baseline model exploration from structural monitoring based on a novel information entropy-probability learning function
2024, Computers and StructuresIn this paper, an active learning framework for structural baseline model exploration is proposed based on the Kriging method. The framework is built to solve the problem that when the traditional Kriging approach needs to calibrate more structural parameters, the performance of Kriging predictors hinges very much upon the number of samples obtained from the finite element analysis. A novel information entropy-probability learning function is derived based on Bayesian inference and information entropy. To give a full picture, the uncertainties of different responses should also be quantified during the updating process. Then the effects of uncertainties are considered in both the learning function and objective function constructed from the posterior probabilities. The proposed algorithm is first verified experimentally by a two-span continuous beam considering different types of responses. The framework is then further improved for updating the baseline model of a cable-stayed bridge using field data. The active learning approach, as compared to the ordinary Kriging method, can achieve good performance without undue computational cost and the need for imposing weights on different responses. The proposed baseline model exploration method can be extensively applied to bridge engineering because it facilitates the calibration of numerical models using field measurements and response simulation of extreme loading with significant improvement in computational efficiency and performance of Kriging predictors.