Published online : 30 May 2022
Article Outline
Scroll to top
Data Release
MODIRISK: Mosquito vectors of disease, collection, monitoring and longitudinal data from Belgium
 Views 312
 Downloads 68
Review History
Download PDF

Cite this article as... 

Wim Van Bortel, Veerle Versteirt, Wouter Dekoninck, Thierry Hance, Dimitri Brosens, Guy Hendrickx, MODIRISK: Mosquito vectors of disease, collection, monitoring and longitudinal data from BelgiumGigabyte, 2022  https://doi.org/10.46471/gigabyte.58

 Copy citation
Gigabyte
Gigabyte
2709-4715
GigaScience Press
Sha Tin, New Territories, Hong Kong SAR
Data description
Mosquito-borne diseases are prime candidates as (re-)emerging vector-borne diseases in Europe. Knowledge of the taxonomic and functional biodiversity of both endemic and invasive mosquito species, as well as the factors driving changes, was missing in Belgium. Acquiring this knowledge is an essential step towards understanding the current risk and preparing action plans for future threats.
Context
The MODIRISK project was established with objectives to:
(1)
Create an inventory of endemic and invasive mosquito species in Belgium, considering environmental and taxonomic elements of biodiversity (the ‘Collection dataset’)
(2)
Assess the population dynamics of selected endemic and invasive mosquito species and their interrelationships (the ‘Longitudinal dataset’)
(3)
Model mosquito biodiversity distribution at a 1-km resolution, (the ‘Inventory’)
(4)
Disseminate project outputs.
The three datasets, which originated during the MODIRISK project (Figure 1), were standardized to Darwin Core [1] and published by the Royal Belgian Institute for Natural Sciences (RBINS) through the Integrated Publishing Toolkit (IPT) [2] of the Belgian node of the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF).
Figure 1.
Overview of the MODIRISK data. Map of Belgium with red dots showing collection locations of Culicidae in the RBINS collection (the ‘Collection dataset’); blue dots represent Inventory collection locations (the ‘Inventory dataset’); and black dots represent locations of collections in the ‘Longitudinal study’ dataset.
Methods
During the first phase of the project (2007–2008), the focus was on inventory activities; setting up laboratory experiments to study life history traits of Culex pipiens in relation to temperature, and the first selection of models based on the field results. During the second phase of the project (2009–2010), the focus was on spatial model building and validation, the longitudinal study, and the dynamics of selected indigenous and invasive species found during the first-phase inventory and on more population genetics-driven research.
Thus, three different datasets were developed during the MODIRISK project: the ‘Collection’ dataset [3, 4], dealing with both historic and recent Culicidae specimens, the ‘Inventory’ dataset [5], dealing with the current inventory of Culicidae in Belgium, and the ‘Longitudinal study’ dataset [6], dealing with questions about risk assessment, outbreaks, and possible distribution.
These three datasets are closely linked, but are published as three different Darwin Core archives. The Inventory dataset ‘MODIRISK: Monitoring of Mosquito Vectors of Disease (Inventory)’ was first published in 2013 (occurrence core), while the Collection dataset (occurrence core) and the longitudinal study (event core) were published in 2017.
The project was coordinated by the Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp, Belgium.
The Collection dataset [3, 4]
In the early 1900s, Maurice Goetghebuer and Michel Bequaert collected many mosquitos from all over Belgium and established on of the most representative and richest collections of Belgian Diptera. These are preserved at RBINS [7]. The RBINS Culicidae collection comprises four parts: a general Belgian collection, the Goetghebeur subcollection, the Becquart subcollection, and a subcollection of unidentified specimens known as the ‘supplements’ (Figure 2). The Bequaert subcollection was mainly collected between 1912 and 1958, and comprises 135 voucher specimens. The Goetghebuer subcollection was collected between 1909 and 1946 (mainly between the period 1910–1930), and comprises 268 specimens. In the general Belgian collection, there are 241 specimens present, all collected between 1878 and 1967 (mainly between 1880 and 1925). The supplements comprise the largest subcollection, with 737 specimens collected between 1892 and 2005 (mainly during 1920–1960).
Figure 2.
The RBINS Culicidae collection. Map of Belgium with red dots showing collection locations of Culicidae in the RBINS collection (the ‘Collection dataset’).
All 1381 specimens (24 species) in the RBINS collections were re-identified and digitized during the MODIRISK project. Furthermore, all voucher specimens from the available collections were re-identified at the species level [8]. Seventy seven percent of the specimens were collected between 1910 and 1960, with most specimens collected between 1940 and 1950. The intensity of research and mosquito-sampling fluctuated during this period, as revealed by the number of voucher specimens per decade (Figure 3). The oldest specimens (collected in 1878) are deposited in the general Belgian collection. In this collection, 16 species were discovered; in the Bequaert, Goetghebuer and in the supplements collections, respectively, 18, 21 and 20 species were counted. Culex pipiens and Culiseta annulata were the most abundant recorded species present in the collection (Figure 4), as were many voucher specimens of Aedes punctor. 1374 records were published on the GBIF repository. 7 Records were left out because those specimens originated from outside Belgium and missed coordinates.
Figure 3.
RBINS collection: distribution of voucher specimens through time.
Figure 4.
RBINS collection: species and the number of specimens available.
For more information on the RBINS collection, please see Dekoninck et al. 2011 [9] and 2013 [10].
The Inventory dataset
The Culicidae Inventory dataset [5] (Figure 5) was created during a cross-sectional field survey from May till October 2007 and 2008 (inventory) and from August till October 2009 and May till August 2010 (validation), using a network of CO2-baited Mosquito Magnet Liberty Plus (MMLP) traps (Woodstream Corp., Lancaster, PA, USA), throughout Belgium in three key habitats (urban, agriculture and nature) [11]. Each location was sampled only once for 1 week. Twenty-nine mosquito species were identified to the species level (Figure 6).
Figure 5.
The Inventory dataset. Map of Belgium with blue dots representing Inventory collection locations (the ‘Inventory dataset’).
Figure 6.
The morphological identifications and the number of individuals (grey) and the number of records (blue) in the inventory dataset.
For more information on the Inventory dataset, please see Versteirt et al. 2009 [12], 2011 [13], 2012 [14], 2013 [11], and 2015 [15].
The Longitudinal dataset [6]
During the longitudinal study, four sites (Maasmechelen, Ruiselede, Torhout, and Natoye) were sampled thoroughly, with each study site comprising different localities (Figure 7). Each locality was sampled with a minimum of six traps: three types, two of each type, namely MMLP traps, BG Sentinel (Biogents, Regensburg, Bayern, Germany) and CDC Gravid (CDC; J.W. Hock, Gainsville, FL, USA) traps. MMLP traps were used during the inventory, BG Sentinels were used specifically to attract invasive Aedes species and Gravid traps were used for Culex species. The sites were sampled 14 times, once every 2 weeks between 20 April and 5 October 2009. In total, 36,387 adult mosquitoes (‘individualCount’) were collected in 651 occurrence records at the four sites (Figure 8).
Figure 7.
Longitudinal monitoring. Map of Belgium showing sites and subsites chosen for the Longitudinal study. MA1: Maasmechelen site 1; MA2: Maasmechelen site 2; NT1: Natoye site 1; NA2: Natoye site 2; RL01: Ruiselede site 1; TH2: Torhout site 2.
Figure 8.
The morphological identifications and the number of individuals (grey) and the number of records (blue) in the longitudinal dataset.
The Maasmechelen (MA) study site
The area surveyed was an old sand quarry near Hoge Kempen national park and the Maasmechelen industrial park, where several recycling companies are located. One site, MA1, was the initial reference site, a small mixed forest fragment with birch, oak and pine next to the industrial zone. The other subsite, MA2, was on the opposite side of the road, in a narrow strip of mixed forest adjacent to a large nature reserve (heath). Land cover is largely mixed small forest, moorland, sand quarry, and a large industrial zone.
The Natoye (NT) study site
The population of Aedes japonicus at Natoye was surveyed by researchers from the Catholic University of Louvain (Université Catholique de Louvain; UCL). Two Belgian second-hand tire companies located in the village of Natoye (Namur) were surveyed. Sites were named Natoye1 (NT1) and Natoye 2 (NT2). The companies import mainly tires for trucks and heavy vehicles originating from various European countries. Tires are stacked outside, and many are exposed to rainfall, so often contain water and organic material such as decomposing leaves. Land cover around Natoye 1 consists largely of deciduous forests, gardens and cultivated fields, while around Natoye 2 it is mostly gardens, cultivated fields and meadows.
The Ruiselede (RL) and Torhout (TH) study sites
Mosquitos were sampled mosquitoes at two different localities in Western Flanders with the same ecoclimatic region, during one complete active season from May until October. At Torhout near Groenhove forest complex, two urban–rural landscapes were sampled (TH1 and TH2), while at Ruislede, Vorte Bossen, two natural landscape sites were sampled (RL01 and RL02).
For more information on the Longitudinal dataset, please see Damiens et al. 2014 [16], Dekoninck et al. 2011 [17], and Versteirt et al. 2012 [14].
Taxonomic coverage of the three datasets
Morphological identification of Culicidae was done mainly using an electronic [8] and a paper identification key [18]. If a sample was too damaged for accurate morphological identification, sp. was used to describe the level of identification. In the period 2000–2009, substantial changes were proposed for the Aedini tribe taxonomy, which resulted in almost tripling the number of genera in the entire Culicidae family. A recent publication [19] proposed to return to the taxonomy from before 2000, restoring a classification system useful for the operational community. This dataset was built during 2000–2009, using the available taxonomies at that time, resulting in the consequent use of the genus Ochlerotatus (Now Aedes) in the dataset.
Geographic coverage of the three datasets
Belgium is a small country in Western Europe. To the west, its 70 km coastline fronts the North Sea; to the north lies the Netherlands; to the east, Germany, and to the south, France and Luxembourg. Biogeographically, the fauna of eastern Belgium belongs to the Central European province of the Eurasian (Palearctic) region. By contrast, the rest of the country primarily consists of an Atlantic fauna (Atlantic Biogeographical Region) (Figure 9).
Figure 9.
Biogeographical areas of Belgium.
Politically and geographically, the country is divided into three parts: Flanders, Wallonia and the Brussels Capital Region. In Flanders (13,522 km2 with a population of about 6 million people), to the north, soils are mainly sandy to loamy. The Brussels Capital Region is a small region (162 km2) entirely situated in the sandy loam area. In Wallonia (17,006 km2 and about 3.5 million people), to the south, soils and habitats are more diverse, ranging from forests to rocky and calcareous grasslands on loam and chalky soils. Eastern Wallonia, near the German border, includes the Hautes Fagnes, a large area of bogs and peat.
Belgian has a temperate maritime climate that is influenced by the North Sea and the Atlantic Ocean with substantial precipitation in all seasons. Belgium has a temperate maritime climate characterised by moderate temperatures, prevailing southerly to westerly winds, abundant cloud cover and frequent precipitation. Summers are relatively cool and humid and winters relatively mild and rainy.
Geographical method
Collection dataset (1878–2007)
The Universal Transverse Mercator Projection (UTM), an adaptation of the standard Mercator projection, uses a two-dimensional Cartesian coordinate system to identify locations on the surface of the Earth [20].
Figure 10.
The Universal Transverse Mercator Projection 5   km grid of Belgium (Figure 10).
The Inventory dataset (2007–2010)
The 971 selected sample sites have exact GPS coordinates. Cross-sectional field surveys were conducted during the first phase of the project to create an inventory of Culicidae. Using the NGI (National Geographic Institute) CORINE land cover (2000) map classification [21], three strata were aggregated: urban, rural and natural. In each stratum, random points were assigned, amounting to 971 selected sampling points. The number of points assigned for each Corine land cover aggregated class was proportional to its total surface in Belgium. For details of the sampling design, see Versteirt et al. 2011 [13] and 2013 [11].
The Longitudinal study (2009)
All the selected sampling sites have exact GPS coordinates.
The overall distribution of the mosquito records over time is illustrated in Figure 11.
Figure 11.
Distribution of occurrences of all three datasets through time (red: Culicidae collection; blue: Inventory; black = Longitudinal study).
Data validation and quality control
To assure the quality of morphological identifications, a random sample (10%) of the identified mosquitoes collected through the MODIRISK project (Inventory and Longitudinal datasets) was re-identified by an external expert. The re-identification of the RBINS collections done during the MODIRISK project was also checked by an external expert.
Members of the An. maculipennis complex were further identified to species level using PCR of the ITS2 region [22].
Dataset description
Occurrence data from the MODIRISK database are extracted, standardized, and published as three separate Darwin Core archives: the Collection, the Inventory and the Longitudinal study. The main rationale behind this is that these different datasets are built for their own specific purpose and differ in sampling protocols and methods. Together these datasets represent a complete overview of the data collected during the MODIRISK project. We made the data available to GBIF to make future use, such as Species Distribution Modelling, possible.
The Darwin Core terms in the dataset at the time of publication can be found here [23].
Darwin core data structure
Collection dataset
Occurrence core
Id; type; language; license; rightsHolder; accessRights; institutionCode; collectionCode; datasetName; ownerInstitutionCode; basisOfRecord; occurrenceID; catalogNumber; recordedBy; sex; lifeStage; preparations; disposition; eventDate; year; month; day; countryCode; stateProvince municipality; locality; verbatimCoordinates; verbatimLatitude; verbatimLongitude; decimalLatitude; decimalLongitude; geodeticDatum; georeferenceRemarks; identifiedBy; scientificNameoriginalNameUsage; kingdom; genus; specificEpithet; nomenclaturalCode
Object name: Darwin Core Archive MODIRISK:RBINS Diptera: Culicidae Collection
Character encoding: UTF-8
Format name: Darwin Core Archive format
Format version: 1.12
Last Publication date of data: 2021-03-25
Language: English
Licences of use: CC0 1.0 Universal (CC0 1.0) Public Domain Dedication
Metadata language: English
Date of metadata update: 2022-02-27
Hierarchy level: Dataset
Inventory dataset
Occurrence core
id; type; license; institutionCode; basisOfRecord; dynamicProperties; occurrenceID; individualCount; sex; samplingProtocol; eventDate; year; verbatimEventDate; habitat; continent; country; countryCode; stateProvince; municipality; locality; locationRemarks; decimalLatitude; decimalLongitude; geodeticDatum; identifiedBy; scientificName; genus; specificEpithet
Object name: Darwin Core Archive MODIRISK: Monitoring of Mosquito Vectors of Disease (inventory)
Character encoding: UTF-8
Format name: Darwin Core Archive format
Format version: 3.6
Last Publication date of data: 2022-02-28
Language: English
Licences of use: CC0 1.0 Universal (CC0 1.0) Public Domain Dedication
Metadata language: English
Hierarchy level: Dataset
Longitudinal-study
Event core
id; type; language; license; rightsHolder; accessRights; datasetIDinstitutionCode; datasetName; ownerInstitutionCode; eventID; parentEventID; samplingProtocol; eventDate; year; month; day; verbatimEventDate; eventRemarks; countryCode; municipality; locality; verbatimLatitude; verbatimLongitude; decimalLatitude; decimalLongitude; geodeticDatum
Occurrence extension
Id; type; language; license; rightsHolder; accessRights; institutionCode; datasetName; ownerInstitutionCode; basisOfRecord; occurrenceID; individualCount; eventID; parentEventID; samplingProtocol; eventDate; verbatimEventDate; eventRemarkscountryCode; municipality; locality; verbatimLatitude; verbatimLongitude; decimalLatitude; decimalLongitude; geodeticDatum; scientificName; kingdom; genus; specificEpithet; nomenclaturalCode
Object name: Darwin Core Archive MODIRISK:Monitoring of Mosquito Vectors, Longitudinal study
Character encoding: UTF-8
Format name: Darwin Core Archive format
Format version: 1.1
Last Publication date of data: 2022-02-28
Language: English
Licences of use: CC0 1.0 Universal (CC0 1.0) Public Domain Dedication
Metadata language: English
Hierarchy level: Dataset
Data Availability
This data paper is linked with three MODIRISK mosquito related datasets: the Collection [4], Inventory [5], and Longitudinal study datasets [6]. The database server uses Windows Server 2003 SBS R2 as the operating system, and is running IIS with PHP for site development, MS SQL Server for database development and SQL Server Mobile Tools to allow remote access from a PDA. Three types of MODIRISK forms were prepared by the MODIRISK coordinator and adapted during a group session: the field form, morphological identification form, and mosquito storage form. Based on these, relevant tables were developed by Avia-GIS [24], implemented in the database, and transferred to the web server.
The data are published under a Creative Commons CC0 waiver and we kindly ask you to notify the corresponding authors of the respective dataset if you use the data, especially for research purposes.
Editor’s note
This paper is part of a series of Data Release articles working with GBIF and supported by the Special Programme for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases (TDR), hosted at the World Health Organization [25].
Declarations
List of abbreviations
UTM: Universal Transverse Mercator.
Ethical approval
Not applicable.
Consent for publication
Not applicable.
Competing Interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Funding
The project ‘Mosquito vectors of disease: spatial biodiversity, drivers of change, and risk’ was funded by Belspo, under the Science for Sustainable Development projects SD/BD/04B and SD/BD/04D [2628].
Authors’ contributions
Principal investigators: Wouter Dekoninck; Wim Van Bortel; Veerle Versteirt
Resource contact, resource creator, point of contact: Wouter Dekoninck; Wim Van Bortel; Veerle Versteirt
Metadata provider: Dimitri Brosens
Content providers: Wouter Dekoninck; Wim Van Bortel; Veerle Versteirt
Processors: Dimitri Brosens.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank everybody who contributed to the creation of these datasets and paper, including the Belgian Biodiversity Platform [29], and GBIF [30]. Special thanks to the to Annemie Van Ranst, Bram Wellekens, Cleo Pandelaers, Rien Dekeyzer, Marijke Wouters, Stefan Kerkhof and Charlotte Sohier without whom the field work would not been done so smoothly. Special gratitude to Thomas Little for checking the English language.
References
1WieczorekJ, BloomD, GuralnickR Darwin Core: an evolving community-developed biodiversity data standard. PLoS One, 2012; 7: e29715.
2RobertsonT, DoringM, GuralnickR The GBIF integrated publishing toolkit: facilitating the efficient publishing of biodiversity data on the internet. PLoS One, 2014; 9: e102623.
3DekoninckW, VersteirtV, Van BortelW. MODIRISK:RBINS Diptera: Culicidae collection. v1.6. Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences. Dataset/Occurrence. 2017; https://doi.org/10.15468/3in3fb.
4DekoninckW, VersteirtV, BrosensD MODIRISK:RBINS Diptera: Culicidae collection. Version 1.17. Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences. Occurrence dataset. 2022; https://doi.org/10.15468/3in3fb.
5VersteirtV, DekoninckW, Van BortelW MODIRISK: monitoring of mosquito vectors of disease (inventory). Version 3.13. Belgian Biodiversity Platform. Occurrence dataset. 2022; https://doi.org/10.15468/4fidg2.
6DekoninckW, VersteirtV, Van BortelW MODIRISK: Monitoring of Mosquito Vectors, Longitudinal study. Version 1.21. Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences. Sampling event dataset. 2022; https://doi.org/10.15468/rwsozv.
7GrootaertP, De BruynL, De MeyerM. Catalogue of the Diptera of Belgium, Brussel. 1991.
8SchaffnerF, AngelG, GeoffroyB The Mosquitoes of Europe. An Identification and Training Programme. 2001; ISBN: 2-7099-1485-9.
9DekoninckW, De KeyserR, HendrickxF Mosquito (Culicidae) voucher specimens in the RBINS collection: remnants of a past glory or hidden treasure? Eur. Mosq. Bull., 2011; 29: 1321.
10DekoninckW, HendrickxF, VersteirtV Changes in species richness and spatial distribution of mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae) inferred from museum specimen records and a recent inventory: a case study from Belgium suggests recent expanded distribution of arbovirus and malaria vectors. J. Med. Entomol., 2013; 50: 237243.
11VersteirtV, BoyerS, DamiensD Nationwide inventory of mosquito biodiversity (Diptera: Culicidae) in Belgium, Europe. Bull. Entomol. Res., 2013; 103: 193203.
12VersteirtV, SchaffnerF, GarrosC Introduction and establishment of the exotic mosquito species Aedes japonicus japonicus (Diptera: Culicidae) in Belgium. J. Med. Entomol., 2009; 46: 14641467.
13VersteirtV, De ClercqE, DekoninckW Mosquito vectors of disease: spatial biodiversity, drivers of change, and risk. Final Report. Belspo, Brussels, Belgium. 2011.
14VersteirtV, De ClercqEM, FonsecaDM Bionomics of the established exotic mosquito species Aedes koreicus in Belgium, Europe. J. Med. Entomol., 2012; 49: 12261232.
15VersteirtV, NagyZT, RoelantsP Identification of Belgian mosquito species (Diptera: Culicidae) by DNA barcoding. Mol. Ecol. Res., 2015; 15: 449457.
16DamiensD, AyrinhacA, Van BortelW Invasive process and repeated cross-sectional surveys of the mosquito Aedes japonicus japonicus establishment in Belgium. PLoS One, 2014; 9: e89358.
17DekoninckW, HendrickxF, Vasn BortelW Human-induced expanded distribution of Anopheles plumbeus, experimental vector of West Nile virus and a potential vector of human malaria in Belgium. J. Med. Entomol., 2011; 48(4): 924928. doi:10.1603/me10235.
18BeckerN, PetricD, ZgombaM Mosquitoes and Their Control. Springer, Heidelberg, 2010; doi:10.1007/978-3-540-92874-4.
19WilkersonRC, LintonYM, FonsecaDM Making mosquito taxonomy useful: a stable classification of tribe aedini that balances utility with current knowledge of evolutionary relationships. PLoS One, 2015; 10: e0133602.
20StottPH. The UTM grid reference system. IA J. Soc. Ind. Archeol., 1977; 3(1): 114. http://www.jstor.org/stable/40967933.
21National Geographic Institute. CORINE land cover 2018 Belgium. Data.gov.be. 2021; https://data.gov.be/en/dataset/ad1ad903-f45d-43b0-8ced-d3c0e376efee.
22MarinucciM, RomiR, ManciniP Phylogenetic relationships of seven palearctic members of the maculipennis complex inferred from ITS2 sequence analysis. Insect. Mol. Biol., 1999; 8: 469480.
23Core terms defined by Darwin Core. http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/terms/.
25Vectors of human disease series. GigaByte. 2022; https://doi.org/10.46471/GIGABYTE_SERIES_0002.
27Belgian Science Policy (Belspo). MODIRISK. Mosquito vectors of disease: spatial biodiversity, drivers of change, and risk. http://www.belspo.be/belspo/ssd/science/projects/MODIRISK_en.pdf.
28VersteirtV, De ClercqE, DekoninckW Mosquito vectors of disease: spatial biodiversity, drivers of change, and risk. Final Report. Brussels : Belgian Science Policy (Research Programme Science for a Sustainable Development). 2009; http://www.belspo.be/belspo/ssd/science/Reports/FinalReport_MODIRISK%20ML.pdf.
29Belgian Biodiversity Platform for Science, Policy, and Practice. https://www.biodiversity.be/.
30Global Biodiversity Information Facility. https://www.gbif.org/.