I. Introduction
The duties associated with elderly care are changing from being performed by the healthcare system to the elderly themselves interacting with social networks [12]. Increasingly, the location of care provision is moving from the hospital to the community [3]. The government of Korea has addressed this situation at the national level by establishing a new paradigm for the healthcare delivery system, called ‘community care’. The community-care system provides community residents with care services in the place where they have been living for their lifetime and provides them with appropriate residences, convalescence, care, and independent life so that they can still socialize with the members of their community [4].
The disabled and the elderly have unmet needs for health and social services [5], and allowing them to live in the community means that their needs have to be met based on appropriate assessments. However, this is hindered by healthcare professionals tending to focus on their medical needs, and social workers assessing mainly their social needs. This segmented approach results in community residents receiving provider-centered care services weighted toward either healthcare or social services [6]. The use of a comprehensive health and social-needs assessment (CHSNA) system based on information and communication technology (ICT) and designed to help service providers and community residents can improve the efficiency of the care process by enabling more accurate determination of needs, the identification of more suitable care plans, and the implementation of the best health and social services.
A comprehensive assessment tool is required for the assessment of specific health and social needs. The comprehensive International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and Health (ICF) is not associated with particular health problems or diseases, and it explains the related functioning perspectives from multiple viewpoints at the body, individual, and social levels [7]. Using this framework to design a CHSNA tool represents an affordable way to evaluate the diverse needs of community residents. We therefore developed a CHSNA system based on ICT using the ICF framework with the aim of improving health and social-care services.
II. Case Descriptions
1. Process of CHSNA System Development
The available literature and guidelines were analyzed and used to identify the components of the CHSNA system developed in this study. We only included articles published in peer-reviewed journals, guidelines, and government report written in English and Korean; therefore, conference proceedings, trial registries, theses, and dissertations were not involved. The publication date was limited to identify the recent relevant studies published since 2010. The initial search terms were ‘community care’, ‘integrated care’, and ‘aging in place’. The related terms were ‘visiting healthcare services’, ‘care management’, and ‘community health needs’. The electronic databases used were PubMed/MEDLINE, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, Google Scholar, and the National Assembly Library of Korea. The studies included the general process of community care services, care management and visiting healthcare services, and the instruments used in assessing the needs of community residents. In addition, we conducted a needs analysis for the target users—community residents, healthcare professionals, and social workers—using self-reported questionnaires and interview questions to determine the elements required in a comprehensive assessment system.
The CHSNA system aimed to utilize ICT to facilitate evaluations of the various needs of community residents and to improve the connection between healthcare and social services. The specific objectives were (1) to effectively enhance the assessment process with a user-friendly ICT design and (2) to allow community residents and healthcare professionals or social workers to share decision-making when assessing various needs and selecting the appropriate services.
The CHSNA system was developed mainly based on the ICF, which has complex interactions among its components (Figure 1). The items of the CHSNA system include various officially used instruments: (1) the World Health Organization (WHO) Disability Assessment Schedule II [8] and its Korean version [9], which are useful assessment instruments developed by the WHO to assess health and disability levels across cultures; (2) impairment questions based on the Multi-Country Survey Study [10] and WHO world health surveys [11], which aimed to obtain a better understanding of various dimensions of health and health systems and acquire comparable data among countries [12]; (3) a care management manual for Koreans; and (4) a community residents needs assessment for Koreans.
All items of the CHSNA system were mapped onto ICF components based on the available literature [13] and an expert consensus (Figure 2). Thirteen experts on medicine, nursing, public health, social welfare, and occupational therapy participated as the expert group. The algorithm of the CHSNA system was designed based on the care management of social workers and visiting healthcare services of the Ministry of Health and Welfare in Korea.
2. Implementation of CHSNA System
The initial version and final version of the system were tested by experts from nursing, social work, public health, medical engineering, computer science, and community residents in a city. They applied the system with PCs (laptop and desktops) and mobile devices (tablets and mobile phones). Their opinions formed the basis for several improvements to the system. They evaluated the system usability and design, and offered their opinions. The Institutional Review Board of Chungnam National University approved this study (IRB No. 201809-SB-128-01). All participants provided written consent before the tests were initiated.
3. Features and Advantages of CHSNA System
1) CHSNA system based on the ICF framework
The interface of the developed CHSNA system included the following three assessment steps (Table 1). All items of CHSNA were mapped to ICF codes, and the assessment results were expressed as ICF codes and the ICF framework automatically.
All of the developed items were validated by experts using the content validity index (CVI). The CVI values for the items ranged from 0.77 to 0.94. All items were mapped onto ICF codes, and the validity of the mapping was evaluated by experts.
2) Designing a user-centered CHSNA system
The CHSNA system presents user-friendly icons and images on the screen to help the users comprehend the meaning of the items. For example, a life and activity assessment is performed while showing various images that indicate each activity. The scores on Likert scales are indicated with common explanatory facial-expression icons. The health profiles are generated using text and also images, graphs, and an ICF model. This facilitates healthcare professionals, social workers, and community residents to share the assessment items and health profiles together through PC or mobile device screens.
3) Evaluation and improvement of the system
During a pretest of the first version of the system, the researchers noticed that the elderly participants experienced difficulties reading items on the screen, so this was addressed by making the text and images larger. The researchers also found that some words used in the system were difficult to understand for the general community residents, so this was addressed by inserting more rubrics to facilitate their understanding.
When the researchers implemented the pilot test of the final version, the healthcare professionals and social workers stated that the new assessment system simplified the assessment process in comparison to previous paper-based assessment processes. The community residents reported that they found it very convenient to be able to check their health and social needs comprehensively using a mobile phone, tablet, or laptop. One of the best aspects of the system was that they could see the assessment results on the screen immediately after completing the assessment process. The three experts from medical engineering and computer science who evaluated the appropriateness of the algorithms used to implement the CHSNA system considered the user interface, user experience, and system realization to be good.
III. Discussion
The CHSNA system was designed to evaluate the healthcare and social needs of community residents based on using an ICT-based system to help provide effective person-centered community care. We focused on making the system evidence-based, person-centered, and user-friendly during every step of its development and performed continuous evaluation to achieve this.
The researchers applied evidence-based knowledge by using the official ICF classification of the WHO [14] and reliable instruments. The assessment process using the CHSNA system and the obtained assessment results should enable healthcare professionals and social workers to implement evidence-based practice for community residents.
The researchers also included person-centered care (PCC) in the CHSNA system. The healthcare professionals, social workers, and community residents collaborated while assessing the needs of the community residents and planning care management by sharing the PC or mobile device screen. This will help to improve the quality of decision-making based on the preferences and values of community residents.
The CHSNA system has a user-friendly design. Based on self-reported questionnaires and focus-group interviews, the demands of the target users could be applied to the overall system design. The evidence for the successful design came from the target users providing positive feedback after they experienced using the system.
In conclusion, the CHSNA system is the first system developed using the ICF framework and based on ICT in Korea to help community residents, healthcare professionals, and social workers become involved in person-centered community care. This will help community residents comprehend their own unmet needs and participate in designing their own care plans with support from healthcare professionals and social workers.
PDF Links
PubReader
XML Download
Full text via DOI
Full text via PMC
Download Citation
