Abstract
This experiment was undertaken to investigate the effect of sensory modality (vision vs. audition) and of visual status (early blind vs. sighted) on susceptibility to the vertical-horizontal illusion. Early blind volunteers and blindfolded sighted subjects explored variants of the vertical-horizontal illusion using a device that substituted audition for vision, whereas sighted subjects from an independent group inspected the same stimuli visually. Sensitivity to the vertical-horizontal illusion, including an illusion of moderate strength when using the sensory substitution device, was observed only in the two sighted groups. The existence of an illusion effect when using such a device supports the idea of a visual perception provided by sensory substitution, whereas the attenuation of the vertical-horizontal illusion strength is consistent with the visual field shape theory (Künnapas, 1955a). The absence of the illusion effect in early blind subjects suggests that the sensory experience influences the nature of perception and that the visual experience plays a crucial role in the vertical-horizontal illusion, in accordance with the size-constancy scaling theory (Gregory, 1963).
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Amedi, A., Malach, R., Hendler, T., Peled, S., &Zohary, E. (2001). Visuo-haptic object-related activation in the ventral visual pathway.Nature Neuroscience,4, 324–330.
Amedi, A., Raz, N., Pianka, P., Malach, R., &Zohary, E. (2003). Early “visual” cortex activation correlates with superior verbal memory performance in the blind.Nature Neuroscience,6, 758–766.
Appelle, S., &Gravetter, F. (1985). Effect of modality-specific experience on visual and haptic judgment of orientation.Perception,14, 763–773.
Arditi, A., Holtzman, J. D., &Kosslyn, S. M. (1988). Mental imagery and sensory experience in congenital blindness.Neuropsychologia,26, 1–12.
Arno, P., Capelle, C., Wanet-Defalque, M.-C., Catalan-Ahumada,M., &Veraart, C. (1999). Auditory coding of visual patterns for the blind.Perception,28, 1013–1029.
Arno, P., De Volder, A. G., Vanlierde, A., Wanet-Defalque, M.-C., Streel, E., Robert, A., et al. (2001). Occipital activation by pattern recognition in the early blind using auditory substitution for vision.NeuroImage,13, 632–645.
Arno, P., Vanlierde, A., Streel, E., Wanet-Defalque, M.-C., Sanabria-Bohórquez, S., &Veraart, C. (2001). Auditory substitution of vision: Pattern recognition by the blind.Applied Cognitive Psychology,15, 509–519.
Büchel, C., Price, C., Frackowiak, R. S. J., &Friston, K. (1998). Different activation patterns in the visual cortex of late and congenitally blind subjects.Brain,121, 409–419.
Burtt, H. E. (1917). Tactual illusions of movement.Journal of Experimental Psychology,2, 371–385.
Capelle, C., Trullemans, C., Arno, P., &Veraart, C. (1998). A realtime experimental prototype for enhancement of vision rehabilitation using auditory substitution.IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering,45, 1279–1293.
Cheng, M.-F. (1968). Tactile-kinesthetic perception of length.American Journal of Psychology,81, 74–82.
Coren, S., &Girgus, J. S. (1978).Seeing is deceiving: The psychology of visual illusions. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Day, R. H. (1972). Visual spatial illusions: a general explanation.Science,175, 1335–1340.
Day, R. H., &Wong, T. S. (1971). Radial and tangential movement directions as determinants of the haptic illusion in an L figure.Journal of Experimental Psychology,87, 19–22.
Deregowski, J., &Ellis, H. D. (1972). Effect of stimulus orientation upon haptic perception of the horizontal-vertical illusion.Journal of Experimental Psychology,95, 14–19.
Fick, A. (1852). Erörterung eines physiologisch-optischen Phänomens.Zeitschrift für rationelle Medizin,2, 83–94.
Finger, F. W., &Spelt, D. K. (1947). The illustration of the horizontal-vertical illusion.Journal of Experimental Psychology,37, 243–250.
Fisher, G. H. (1970). An experimental and theoretical appraisal of the perspective and size-constancy theories of illusions.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,22, 631–652.
Frisby, J. P., &Davies, I. R. L. (1971). Is the haptic Müller-Lyer a visual phenomenon?Nature,231, 463–465.
Gentaz, E., &Hatwell, Y. (2004). Geometrical haptic illusions: The role of exploration in the Müller-Lyer, vertical-horizontal, and Delboeuf illusions.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,11, 31–40.
Girgus, J. S., &Coren, S. (1975). Depth cues and constancy scaling in the horizontal-vertical illusion: The bisection error.Canadian Journal of Psychology,29, 59–65.
Gregory, R. L. (1963). Distortion of visual space as inappropriate constancy scaling.Nature,199, 678–680.
Gregory, R. L., & Wallace, J. G. (1963). Recovery from early blindness: A case study.Experimental Psychology Society Monographs, No. 2.
Hanley, C., &Zerbolio, D. J. (1965). Developmental changes in five illusions measured by the up-and-down method.Child Development,36 437–452.
Harris, V. A., Hayes, W., &Gleason, J. M. (1974). The horizontal-vertical illusion: Binocular and dichoptic investigations of bisection and verticality components.Vision Research,14, 1323–1326.
Heller, M. A. (2000a). Les illusions perceptives haptiques. In Y. Hatwell, A. Streri, & E. Gentaz (Eds.),Toucher pour connaître: Psychologie cognitive de la perception tactile manuelle (pp. 163–174). Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
Heller, M. A. (2000b).Touch, representation, and blindness. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Heller, M. A., Calcaterra, J. A., Burson, L. L., &Green, S. L. (1997). The tactual horizontal-vertical illusion depends on radial motion of the entire arm.Perception & Psychophysics,59, 1297–1311.
Heller, M. A., Calcaterra, J. A., Tyler, L. A., &Burson, L. L. (1996). Production and interpretation of perspective drawings by blind and sighted people.Perception,25, 321–334.
Heller, M. A., &Joyner, T. D. (1993). Mechanisms in the haptic horizontal-vertical illusion: Evidence from sighted and blind subjects.Perception & Psychophysics,53, 422–428.
Kennedy, J. M., Gabias, P., &Nicholls, A. (1991). Tactile pictures. In M. A. Heller & W. Schiff (Eds.),The psychology of touch (pp. 263–299). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Kennedy, J. M., &Juricevic, I. (2003). Haptics and projection: Drawings by Tracy, a blind adult.Perception,32, 1059–1071.
Künnapas, T. M. (1955a). An analysis of the “vertical-horizontal illusion.”Journal of Experimental Psychology,49, 134–140.
Künnapas, T. M. (1955b). Influence of frame size on apparent length of a line.Journal of Experimental Psychology,50, 168–170.
Künnapas, T. M. (1957a). Interocular differences in the vertical-horizontal illusion.Acta Psychologica,13, 253–259.
Künnapas, T. M. (1957b). Vertical-horizontal illusion and surrounding field.Acta Psychologica,13, 35–42.
Künnapas, T. M. (1957c). The vertical-horizontal illusion and the visual field.Journal of Experimental Psychology,53, 405–407.
Künnapas, T. M. (1959). The vertical-horizontal illusion in artificial visual fields.Journal of Psychology,47, 41–48.
Lessard, N., Paré, M., Lepore, F., &Lassonde, M. (1998). Early-blind human subjects localize sound sources better than sighted subjects.Nature,395, 278–280.
Millar, S., &Al-Attar, Z. (2000). Vertical and bisection bias in active touch.Perception,29, 481–500.
Millar, S., &Al-Attar, Z. (2002). The Müller-Lyer illusion in touch and vision: Implications for multisensory processes.Perception & Psychophysics,64, 353–365.
Obonai, T. (1954). Induction effects in estimates of extent.Journal of Experimental Psychology,47, 57–60.
O’Regan, J. K., &Noë, A. (2001). A sensorimotor account of vision and visual consciousness.Behavioral & Brain Sciences,24, 939–1031.
Prather, S. C., Votaw, J. R., &Sathian, K. (2004). Task-specific recruitment of dorsal and ventral visual areas during tactile perception.Neuropsychologia,42, 1079–1087.
Prinzmetal, W., &Gettleman, L. (1993). Vertical-horizontal illusion: One eye is better than two.Perception & Psychophysics,53, 81–88.
Rauschecker, J. P. (1995). Compensatory plasticity and sensory substitution in the cerebral cortex.Trends in Neurosciences,18, 36–43.
Renier, L., Collignon, O., Poirier, C., Tranduy, D., Vanlierde, A., Bol, A., et al. (2005). Cross-modal activation of visual cortex during depth perception using auditory substitution of vision.NeuroImage,26, 573–580.
Renier, L., Collignon, O., Tranduy, D., Vanlierde, A., & De Volder, A. G. (2003, May).Depth perception with a sensory substitution system in early blind subjects. Annual Meeting of the Belgian Psychological Society, Brussels.
Renier, L., Laloyaux, C., Collignon, O., Tranduy, D., Vanlierde, A., Bruyer, R., &De Volder, A. G. (2005). The Ponzo illusion with auditory substitution of vision in sighted and early-blind subjects.Perception,34, 857–867.
Révész, G. (1950).Psychology and art of the blind (H. A. Wolff, Trans.). London: Longmans, Green.
Rice, C. E. (1969). Perceptual enhancement in the early blind?Psychological Record,19, 1–14.
Robinson, J. O. (1998).The psychology of visual illusion. London: Hutchinson. (Original work published 1972)
Röder, B., Teder-Sälejärvi, W., Sterr, A., Rösler, F., Hillyard, S. A., &Neville, H. G. (1999). Improved auditory spatial tuning in blind humans.Nature,400, 162–166.
Sadato, N., Pascual-Leone, A., Grafman, J., Deiber, M. P., Ibanez, V., &Hallett, M. (1998). Neural networks for Braille reading by the blind.Brain,121, 1213–1229.
Sathian, K., Zangaladze, A., Hoffman, J. M., &Grafton, S. T. (1997). Feeling with the mind’s eye.NeuroReport,8, 3877–3881.
Tausch, R. (1954). Optische Täuschungen als artifizielle Effekte der Gestaltungsprozesse von Grössen- und Formenkonstanz in der natürlichen Raumwahrnehmung [Optical illusions as artificial effects of size and shape figuration in natural spatial perception].Psychologische Forschung,24, 299–348.
Thiéry, A. (1896). Über geometrisch-optische Täuschungen.Philosophische Studien,12, 67–126.
Veraart, C., De Volder, A. G., Wanet-Defalque, M.-C., Bol, A., Michel, C., &Goffinet, A. M. (1990). Glucose utilization in human visual cortex is abnormally elevated in blindness of early onset but decreased in blindness of late onset.Brain Research,510, 115–121.
von Collani, G. (1979). An analysis of illusion components with L and T figures in active touch.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,31, 241–248.
von Collani, G. (1985). The horizontal-vertical illusion in photographs of concrete scenes with and without depth information.Perceptual & Motor Skills,61, 523–531.
Wanet-Defalque, M.-C., Veraart, C., De Volder, A. [G.], Metz, R., Michel, C., Dooms, G., &Goffinet, A. (1988). High metabolic activity in the visual cortex of early blind human subjects.Brain Research,446, 369–373.
Weeks, R., Horwitz, B., Aziz-Sultan, A., Tian, B., Wessinger, C. M., Cohen, L. G., et al. (2000). A positron emission tomographic study of auditory localization in the congenitally blind.Journal of Neuroscience,20, 2664–2672.
Wong, T. S. (1977). Dynamic properties of radial and tangential movements as determinants of the haptic horizontal-vertical illusion with an L figure.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception & Performance,3, 151–164.
Zhang, M., Weisser, V. D., Stilla, R., Prather, S. C., &Sathian, K. (2004). Multisensory cortical processing of object shape and its relation to mental imagery.Cognitive, Affective, & Behavioral Neuroscience,4, 251–259.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This study was supported by FRSM Grants 3.4547.00 and 3.4505.04 (Belgium) and European Commission Quality of Life Contract No. QLG3-CT-2000-01797
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Renier, L., Bruyer, R. & De Volder, A.G. Vertical-horizontal illusion present for sighted but not early blind humans using auditory substitution of vision. Perception & Psychophysics 68, 535–542 (2006). https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03208756
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03208756