1. Introduction
Epithermal Au-Ag deposits on the Kamchatka Peninsula are important sources of precious metals. These deposits are located in volcanic belts extending along the subduction zone [
1,
2], and occur in a geodynamic setting of island arc [
3]. Among the aforementioned deposits stand out Asachinskoe, Ametistovoe, Ozernovskoe, Aginskoe, Rodnikovoe, Mutnovskoe, Maletoyvayam and others [
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11].
All these Au-Ag deposits, according to the classification of Corbett [
12], belong to the low-sulfidation (LS) or quartz-adularia type, except for the recently described Maletoyvayam deposit, which belongs to the high-sulfidation (HS) or quartz-alunite type [
13,
14,
15]. The Baranyevskoe Au-Ag epithermal deposit is of the LS type and estimated to be formed by near-neutral pH fluids [
16,
17]. It is located in the Kamchatka Peninsula, on the left bank of the Baranye stream (right tributary of the Balkhach River), approximately 60 km from the Milkovo village. The deposit was discovered in 1972 and, ever since, it has been explored by geologists of different mining companies (Koryakgeoldobycha CJSC, Kamchatka Gold OJSC, Kamchatka Gold Exploration LLC, etc.). The reserves of gold at the Baranyevskoe deposit are reported to be greater than 30 metric tons with an average grade of about 9 g/t [
18]. The composition of ores has been studied previously, and three main mineral associations were described: gold-quartz-carbonate-adularia, gold-ore stockworks and quartz combs or “brushes” [
19]; the composition of gold was compared with other deposits of the Balkhach ore cluster at Central Kamchatka [
20]. It was also identified three stages of ore formation corresponding to the (1) early gold-pyrite-quartz association in altered rocks located in the central part of the deposit, (2) gold-sulfosalt-quartz association, developed in the northeastern part of the deposit, and (3) gold-poor sulfide-quartz associated with late veins [
18]. The Baranyevskoe deposit is considered to be the prototype model for the abovementioned deposits of Kamchatka [
18]. Therefore, further studies on identification of typomorphic features of Au-Ag mineralization in different zones, compositions of noble metals and associated unusual minerals is suggested, in order to contribute to a better understanding of the genetic processes and ore formation mechanism of one of the leading gold deposits in the Central Kamchatka mining region. This study aims to investigate in more detail the mineralogical and geochemical features of the two main profitable associations (gold-pyrite-quartz and gold-sulfosalt-quartz) belonging to different stages of ore formation within different zones of the Baranyevskoe deposit. These features are generally considered very important aspects of gold metallogeny in constraining genetical-ore processes [
3].
3. Geological Settings
The Balkhach volcano-tectonic structure is located within the Neogene-Quaternary Central Kamchatka Volcanic Belt (CKVB), which extends for 800 km along the Main Kamchatka fault, striking north-east at its junction with the Sredinno-Kamchatka uplift composed by metamorphic rocks of different composition [
26]. The formation and development of the circular Balkhach volcano-tectonic structure, with a diameter of 22 km, is discussed in detail in [
18]. The ore cluster of the same name within this structure combines four deposits: Baranyevskoe, Zolotoe, Kungurtsevskoe and Uglovoe. The Aginsk volcano-tectonic structure, which includes the Aginskoe gold deposit, is located to the northwest of the Balkhach volcano-tectonic structure (
Figure 1). The Baranyevskoe deposit belongs to the Baranyevskoe ore field and the Kungurtsevskoe and Zolotoe deposits to the Zolotoe ore field (
Figure 2).
The stratigraphy of the Baranyevskoe ore field includes tuff of intermediate and mafic composition, basalt, trachyandesite, tuffaceous sandstone, tuffaceous siltstone (lower stratigraphical level); and effusive rocks and tuff of intermediate and mafic composition, andesite, basalt (upper structural level) (
Figure 2). Ages of deposits of the Zolotoe ore field are: Kungurtsevskoe—21 Ma [
20], Zolotoe—in the interval of 21.3–17.0 Ma, whereas the Baranyevskoe deposit, located in Late Miocene-Pliocene rocks, has an age interval of 3.9–2.4 Ma according to the K-Ar method [
27].
The Baranyevskoe deposit consists of a system of vein-veinlet and stockwork (veinlet-disseminated) ore-bearing structures in the zone of deep northeastern faulting (
Figure 3). The Rusty ore zone is located along the central fault NE-SW and is accompanied by zones of abundant apophyses: the “Central”, “Southern” and “Hanging”, along with others branches from the axial fault in the hanging wall [
18].
Quartz veins are accompanied by veinlet-disseminated stockworks, on top of which there is a 200-m interval of rocks with high profusion of weakly mineralized (less than 1 ppm Au) veinlets of carbonate and zeolite-carbonate compositions. On the other hand, the stockwork includes the rich vein-disseminated gold mineralization with an Au concentration up to 20 ppm, accompanied by metasomatic associations: pyrite-hematite-magnetite-sericite (alunite)-quartz in the central part of the stockwork and pyrite-sericite-illite-quartz at the periphery. Vuggy silica is common at deeper levels of stockworks [
18]. The proportion of mineralized veinlets overlapping disseminated mineralization increases to the southwest. Quartz veins in the hanging wall are also accompanied by Au-bearing metasomatites comprising quartz, adularia, hydromica, carbonate and clay minerals. Thus, the main ore bodies (zones) of the Baranyevskoe deposit, up to 20 m thick, are composed of: (a) thick quartz veins, (b) disseminated-vein halos, and (c) sulfidized hydrothermal-metasomatic rocks. Consequently, the ore bodies exhibit a ribbon-like shape with a length up to 1500 m, in which gold is unevenly distributed.
5. Discussion
Gold from the Baranyevskoye deposit is subdivided into two classes: the first includes a series of compositions related to low-grade gold and electrum with a fineness of (52–74 at. % Au) (
Figure 13). Sufficiently large grains (50–100 microns) are, as a rule, in association with pyrite and are characteristic of the early high-temperature stage. Similar compositions have been described for hypogenic gold at the Aginskoye deposit [
11]. The second class corresponds to high-grade gold (88–94 at. % Au) (
Figure 13), which, together with chalcopyrite and Bi-rich sulfosalts, compose the mineral association of the lower-temperature stage. However, it should be noted that high-grade gold is also rarely found in the early gold-pyrite-quartz association, being represented there only by thin worm-like veins included in low-grade gold (
Figure 8g).
Similar textures were previously described at the Aginskoye deposit [
11]. According to the authors, such high-grade gold is secondary in origin, formed during the oxidation of hypogenic gold by meteoric waters at the stage of hypergenesis. However, we consider that the formation of high-grade gold in the Baranyevskoe deposit is mainly due to a change in the physicochemical conditions and the composition of hydrothermal solutions. Andreeva and Kudaeva [
20], who previously studied the typomorphism of gold in the Balkhach ore cluster, noted that the grain size and fineness increase within the transition from quartz-carbonate-adularia stockwork rocks to carbonate rocks and quartz-carbonate-adularia veins. On the other hand, silver content in gold is considered as an indicator of the temperature regime during the formation of ores [
31]. The composition of native gold evolves from very high-grade gold to electrum and Hg-bearing gold in the Western Tuva deposits (Russia) [
32] as opposed to what is described in this study. Electrum is associated with pyrite at the Valunistoye deposit (Chukotka), and high-grade gold is found in the form of rims and veins in electrum, occurring later in the paragenesis [
33], as in our case. The Au-Ag-Cu system with reference to [
34] is shown in [
35]. Composition-temperature ranges in this isotherm reflect metastable equilibria. On one side of the triangle, there is a wide row of Au-Ag solid solutions below 300 °C isotherm. That is, alloys of different compositions can crystallize at the same temperature. Therefore, at temperatures corresponding to hydrothermal conditions, opposite trends of the variation in Ag content, in gold grains, are observed for different deposits.
Pyrite is one of the most important indicator minerals in studying the features of the genesis in ore deposits. The As concentration in the pyrite of the Baranyevskoe deposit (7.37 wt. %) exceeds the As in pyrite of numerous deposits, including the values in the Kumroch deposit, where pyrite contains up to 6.79 wt. % As [
36]. For instance, the content of As in pyrite at the Zaozigou Gold Deposit (Central China) is 4.1 wt. % [
37], it is 4.5 wt. % in pyrite of the Roudný deposit, Bohemian Massif [
38], while As in pyrite from El Valle gold deposit (Spain) is the most abundant (up to 9.5 wt. % As) [
39]. Therefore, it becomes evident that the solid solution of Au is dominated by arsenian pyrite in all these deposits. However, high As concentrations are characteristic only for certain areas of zoned pyrite. Compositional zoning of pyrites in gold deposits reflects the chemical evolution of ore bearing fluids. The relatively high activity of As and Au during crystallization of the early generation of pyrite allowed As-bearing pyrite to be precipitated as a consequence. This is consistent with the extremely high As concentration in the samples of the gold-pyrite-quartz association in the Northern Zone (
Table 6). The As-bearing pyrites were formed at temperatures of at least 320–330 ºC, based on arsenopyrite thermometers and fluid inclusion data [
38]. The variable amount of As in grains of pyrite reflects changes in physicochemical conditions (T,
fS
2,
fO
2, pH) and the composition of fluids, which, at the same time, determine the appearance of a concentration gradient on the pyrite growth surface [
40]. Pyrite and gold of low-grade composition in the early association are genetically linked with the Ag-Au minerals: acanthite, hessite, lenaite, petzite, utenbogardtite and Ag-sulfosalts: Ag
10(Sb,As)S
5 and Ag
17(Sb,As)
2(S, Se)
10.
An increase in copper concentration during the development of the ore-forming system led to the formation of a later gold ore association with the leading role of chalcopyrite, as well as other cuprous phases (bornite, chalcocite, geerite, native copper and Cu-Zn solid solutions). Simultaneously, there was an increase in the fineness of gold from 700–800‱ in the early association up to 900–950‱ in the late one, as well as an increase in the concentration of bismuth (leading to the formation of emplectite CuBiS2 or wittichenite Cu3BiS3); the concentration of tin in the ore-forming system was also increased, forming mawsonite Cu6Fe2SnS8.
Primary galena from hydrothermal deposits has been shown to contain anomalous and significant levels of Bi, Ag, Te, Se, Sb, Cu, Tl and Zn [
41]. Increased concentrations of Bi and Ag indicate the dissolution of the proportion of AgBiS
2 in galena [
42]. At the Baranyevskoe deposit, galena contains only traces of Au (up to 2.02 wt. %), and no other minor elements were found. It is assumed that a gold-bearing variety of galena contains probably microscopic or nano-inclusions of gold or gold-bearing-minerals (
https://www.mindat.org/min-26564.html, 11 October 2021). Au-bearing galena from the Baranyevskoe deposit is, however, found as inclusions in Au-Ag alloys. Then, it could be argued that gold content was measured from the matrix during the analysis. Firstly, however, the galena inclusions are large enough (10–20 microns) for correct analysis; secondly, they look absolutely homogeneous (
Figure 8b); and thirdly, Ag is absent in the analysis of galena, and it should have been captured together with Au. Therefore, Au-containing galena is a feature of the gold-pyrite-quartz association.
The tetrahedrite (Cu
10(Fe,Zn)
2Sb
4S
13)–tennantite (Cu
10(Fe,Zn)
2As
4S
13) solid-solution series (fahlore) is common, and widespread in Au-Ag epithermal ore deposits around the world [
43]. The role of sulfosalts in gold deposits is significant, since they are closely associated with native gold, and their study is considered to be very important in identifying the nature of gold mineralization. The rather significant variability in composition makes fahlores a useful indicator of ore-forming processes and fluid compositions during their development [
44].
Tetrahedrite of the Baranyevskoe deposit contains significant amounts of bismuth, which in some cases may dominate over arsenic Cu
12(Sb,Bi,As)
4S
13. A similar and even richer in bismuth (up to 22.17 wt. % Bi) tetrahedrite was described earlier in Schwarzwald ore district with 1.83 atoms per formula unit (
apfu) Bi [
44] compared to Baranievskoye, where 0.20–1.10
apfu Bi, based on 4 total
apfu (Sb+As+Bi) was established. However, the Bi-richest sulfosalts are also Pb-bearing [
45], whereas, in the herein investigated association, it lacks Pb-Bi fahlores. Only one grain of sulfosalt containing lead (Cu
3Fe
3PbS
7) was found. A feature of the gold-sulfosalt-quartz association of the Baranyevskoe deposit is the presence of the Te-free tetrahedrite-tennantite series, while Te-rich fahlore (goldfieldite) is characteristic in numerous epithermal deposits [
46], including the gold-forming stages of the Ozernovskoe and Aginskoe epithermal deposits in Kamchatka. Moreover, at the Aginskoe deposit, the Te-rich minerals (AuTe
2, PbTe, Ag
2Te, Ag
3AuTe
2) are rather common, while pyrite is subordinate [
8,
9,
11]. The presence of Bi-rich and, simultaneously, Te-poor varieties of sulfosalts is considered a typomorphic feature of the gold-sulfosalt-quartz association.
The increasing role of bismuth at the late gold stage (gold-sulfosalt-quartz association) expressed by the crystallization of bismuth-rich minerals—emplectite CuBiS
2, wittichenite Cu
3BiS
3, tetradymite Bi
2Te
2S, sulfosalt (Cu,Fe)Bi
5Te
5S
3—is consistent with the data of the chemical analysis of the ores from this association (
Table 6). Sulfosalts of copper, iron and tin—mawsonite Cu
6Fe
2SnS
8 and stannoidite Cu
8Fe
3Sn
2S
12—are also characteristic of the gold-sulfosalt-quartz association. These minerals indicate some enrichment in tin at a late stage in the development of the ore-forming system. Mawsonite Cu
6Fe
2SnS
8 has been identified in association with pyrite and tetrahedrite in a vein orebody, and its formation is related to interactions during the substitution of the tin-bearing famatinite by tetrahedrite [
47]. The gold-sulfosalt-quartz association identified in this study is in many respects similar to that from the Kairagach gold deposit, Uzbekistan, which is characterized by a Au-Sn-Bi-Se-Te geochemical profile; namely, it is comparable to the third generation of ore mineralization of Kairagach gold deposit: Bi-sulfosalts as well as native gold of high fineness, tetrahedrite-annivite series. These are characterized by high (up to 9 wt. %) content of Bi [
48].
The microthermometry study on fluid inclusions in quartz with the most abundant dissemination of chalcopyrite and sulfosalts grains (gold-sulfosalts-quartz association) revealed in the quartz aggregate, temperatures corresponding to a range of 299–226 °C. Similar temperatures of homogenization of primary inclusions were reported for the quartz of the Aginskoe deposit (LS type) 230–280 °C [
9], and were also established for the Rodnikovoe and Asachinskoe deposits in South Kamchatka [
6,
49,
50]. In addition, at the IS type field (Cesme Hafez, Iran) [
51], homogenization temperatures of primary inclusions are within the same range (140–280 °C). At the same time, it is well compatible with many HS type deposits, e.g., Maletoyvayam (255–245 °C) [
15].
The salinity range can be strongly influenced, on one hand, by mixing with meteoric water (dilution), or, on the other hand, by boil-off (concentrating) [
52,
53]. In general, the salinity of LS type deposits shows a wide range of values. The mineralization in LS type crystallizes, as a rule, from relatively dilute brines <5 wt. % NaCl eq. Aginskoye deposit is no greater than 2 wt. % NaCl equiv. [
9], as in the Juliet field (LS type), at the Okhotsk-Chukotka volcanic belt, the salinity of the inclusions is around 1.2–5.6 wt. % NaCl eq. [
54]. However, data from fluid inclusions, in quartz, associated with the main gold stage in HS type deposits—Mt Carlton, Lepanto, Agan, Mt Carlton, NE Australia, Danchenkovskoe, and Maletoyvayam [
15,
55,
56,
57,
58]—similarly indicate salinities up to 4.5 wt. % NaCl eq. In this respect, it becomes clear that the salinity of fluid inclusions is not necessarily related to the type of deposit, but rather depends on the conditions of ore deposition [
15].
Metallogenic specialization and Au/Ag Index of ore is fundamentally related to the host environment in which ore is formed [
59]. High values of this index (<50) are typical for deposits related to oceanic island arcs: Central Kamchatka—1.7; Fiji—4.9; Solomon Islands—2.6. The high ratios of Au/Ag (2.80–9.90), which characterize the Baraneyvskoe deposit, are a promising economic feature in predicting epithermal gold deposits [
59].
6. Conclusions
Two Au-forming associations are characteristic of the Baranyevskoye deposit:
1. Early gold-pyrite-quartz, characterized by the presence of low-grade gold and electrum (660–820‱) in association with pyrite, the grains of which often exhibit oscillatory zoning with As concentrations up to 7.37 wt. % in some areas. Accessory Au-Ag minerals: acanthite AgS
2, hessite AgTe
2, lenaite Ag(Fe,Cu)S
2, petzite Ag
3AuTe
2, utenbogardite Ag
3AuS
2, Au-bearing galena and Ag-Sb-As sulfosalts of unusual composition are found within this association, which is estimated to be formed in the temperature range of 320–330 °C according to [
38] based on arsenopyrite thermometers and fluid inclusions.
2. Late gold-sulfosalt-quartz association includes the high-grade gold (930–970‱) intergrown with chalcopyrite and tetrahedrite-tennantite solid-solutions, which are rather common. The specific compositions of the associated minerals are due to an increase in Cu, Bi and Sn in the primary ore-forming solutions: this assemblage is characterized by cuprous phases (bornite, chalcocite, heerite, native copper, Cu-Zn solid solutions), Bi-rich sulfosalts (aikinite PbCuBiS3, emplectite CuBiS2, witticenite Cu3BiS3) and also stannoidite Cu8Fe3Sn2S12 and mawsonite Cu6Fe2SnS8. Te-free and Bi-rich tetrahedrite-tennantite series of fahlores are, as well, typomorphic minerals of this association.
3. Fluid inclusions in quartz from the gold-sulfosalt-quartz association are characterized by homogenization in the temperature range of 226–298 °C, and salinity from 0.4 to 1.2 wt. % NaCl eq. The calculated pressures and depths of the gold-sulfosalt-quartz association formation were 2.6–8.3 MPa and 260–530 m, respectively.