Published online Jul 29, 2015.
https://doi.org/10.3349/ymj.2015.56.5.1365
Changes of Heart Rate Variability during Methylphenidate Treatment in Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder Children: A 12-Week Prospective Study
Abstract
Purpose
The aim of this study was to clarify the relationship between the autonomic nervous system and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) rating scales and to evaluate the usefulness of heart rate variability (HRV) as a psychophysiological biomarker for ADHD.
Materials and Methods
Subjects were recruited from outpatients in the Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry at the Korea University Medical Center from August 2007 to December 2010. Subjects received methylphenidate. Time- and frequency-domain analyses of HRV, the Korean ADHD rating scale (K-ARS), and computerized ADHD diagnostic system were evaluated before treatment. After a 12-week period of medication administration, we repeated the HRV measurements and K-ARS rating.
Results
Eighty-six subjects were initially enrolled and 37 participants completed the 12-week treatment and HRV measurements subsequent to the treatment. Significant correlations were found between the K-ARS inattention score and some HRV parameters. All of the HRV parameters, except the standard deviations of the normal-to-normal interval, very low frequency, and low frequency to high frequency, showed a significant positive correlation between baseline and endpoint measures in completers. High frequency (HF) and the square root of the mean squared differences of successive normal-to-normal intervals (RMSSD), which are related to parasympathetic vagal tone, showed significant decreases from baseline to endpoint.
Conclusion
The HRV test was shown to be reproducible. The decrease in HF and RMSSD suggests that parasympathetic dominance in ADHD can be altered by methylphenidate treatment. It also shows the possibility that HRV parameters can be used as psychophysiological markers in the treatment of ADHD.
INTRODUCTION
Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is one of the most prevalent disorders in child and adolescent psychiatry.1, 2 Symptoms include difficulty staying focused and paying attention, difficulty controlling behavior, and hyperactivity. With treatment, the symptoms of ADHD can be improved, leading to more productive lives for affected children. Methylphenidate is one of the most commonly used medications for ADHD treatment.
Mental effort has been described as energy mobilization for cognitive goals.3 The concept of mental effort can be defined as follows: 1) A response to high mental effort, which is not necessarily physically demanding, but which is nonetheless experienced as exhausting and stressful. 2) Compensation for a decrement in performance owing to the detrimental effects of stressors such as fatigue and sleep deprivation. Subjects need to exert extra effort in order to maintain optimal performance. This additional exertion is also referred to as mental effort. In other words, mental effort is the exertion necessary to regulate the subject's current state.4
Mental effort has been operationalized by the use of various indices of psychophysiological state, particularly cardiovascular measures, and previous studies have used cardiovascular activity to index mental effort.5, 6
When the efficiency of cognitive inhibition is compared between children with ADHD and healthy age-matched controls, children with ADHD were found to be capable of mental inhibition, but required more effort to do so.7 This also means that children with ADHD exert greater mental effort to maintain a particular performance level than healthy children do. Children diagnosed with ADHD show an appropriate capacity for cognitive inhibition; however, the regulation of response processes requires greater attention in children with ADHD than in healthy control children.8
Heart rate variability (HRV) is a simple and non-invasive method for evaluating autonomic nervous system. The heart rate of a healthy person changes continually via interactions between sympathetic and parasympathetic nerves, thereby maintaining somatic homeostasis.9 Measurement of HRV can be applied in adult medicine as a predictor of acute myocardial infarction risk and as an early indicator of diabetic neuropathy.10 HRV has also been used as a neuropsychological biomarker for the assessment of mental effort. Particularly, HRV indices of parasympathetic nervous system activity are known to be sensitive indicators of mental effort during computational tasks.11
Therefore, if mental effort is indeed associated with changes in HRV, it may be possible that using HRV as a biomarker can help physicians predict and evaluate the outcomes and status of children with ADHD. A number of previous studies have investigated the relationship between HRV parameters for autonomic function and ADHD measurements. A previous study indicated that there was decreased vagal tone with diminished HRV and higher heart rates in unmedicated children with ADHD. These parameters of autonomic activation seemed to be ameliorated by methylphenidate treatment.12 Another cross-sectional comparison of 19 children who were diagnosed as ADHD with 18 control subjects suggested that unmedicated, stimulant-free children with ADHD exhibit parasympathetic dominance of autonomic balance relative to control subjects.13 Nevertheless, there were no consistent findings on HRV parameters in children with ADHD in these previous studies.
Abnormal catecholaminergic functioning has been thought to be a major pathophysiological mechanism in ADHD. Underarousal of the sympathetic system has been proposed in children with ADHD. Psychostimulants that increase dopamine concentrations and the selective noradrenaline transporter inhibitor atomoxetine which increases noradrenaline levels, have been used in the treatment of ADHD by targeting the central nervous system.14, 15, 16 Small increases in mean heart rate and mean blood pressure have been reported for psychostimulants.17 Atomoxetine also could increase blood pressure by elevating noradrenaline concentrations in peripheral sympathetic neurons.18 However, the activity of the parasympathetic nervous system and the autonomic balance in ADHD have not been studied as extensively as the activity of sympathetic nervous system.
To the best of our knowledge, there have also been no prospective studies to systematically evaluate the changes of HRV parameters before and after methylphenidate treatments in children with ADHD. Thus, the aim of this study was to clarify the relationship between the autonomic nervous system and ADHD measurements and to evaluate the utility of HRV as a biomarker for therapeutic changes in ADHD.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Participants
Subjects were recruited from amongst outpatients who had been diagnosed by two experienced child psychiatrists in the Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry at the Korea University Medical Center from August 2007 to December 2010. All participants showed signs and symptoms of either inattention or hyperactivity-impulsivity or both according to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual-IV-Text Revision (DSM-IV-TR) criteria for ADHD. All the participants underwent physical examination, electrocardiogram, and laboratory analysis before entering the study. Information regarding medical and psychiatric comorbid disorders was also taken from medical charts, neuropsychological evaluation, and interview with participants' parents. Exclusion criteria included medical problems requiring special attention, such as cardiovascular disorders, as were learning disabilities or mental retardation. Subjects showing other psychiatric comorbidities were also excluded in order to focus on ADHD, although other psychiatric comorbidities are commonly diagnosed with this disorder. No psychotropic medications were permitted before the start of the study, and none of the participants had received any medication for at least two months prior to the initiation of the study. Subjects ranged in age from 6 to 12 years. A parent or legal guardian of the subjects provided informed consent. Methylphenidate medications were used in either immediate- or extended-release form. The equivalent dose was calculated from published literature.19, 20 The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Guro Hospital, Korea University Medical Center.
Clinical assessments
ADHD symptoms
We assessed the symptoms of ADHD using the Korean ADHD rating scale (K-ARS) and the computerized ADHD diagnostic system (ADS). The K-ARS was originally developed from the ADHD Rating Scale-IV21 and the reliability and validity of Korean version have been established. It was administered to parents or caregivers by the investigators.22 The K-ARS is composed of two subscales (inattention and hyperactivity-impulsivity), each of which is scored independently and rated on the following 4-point rating scale: 0=not present, 1=sometimes present, 2=often present, and 3=very often present. The maximum possible score for each subscale is 27, with the total maximum score being 54.9, 23 We investigated the correlation between ADHD symptoms expressed by K-ARS and HRV parameters, because we wished to investigate the relationship between the change of ADHD symptoms and HRV parameters.
The ADS is a standardized continuous performance test that is commonly used as a supplement for ADHD diagnosis and comprises both visual and auditory tasks. Participants performed visual tasks, with the major outcome variables being omission errors, commission errors, response times, and response variability. The omission and commission errors measure inattention and impulsivity, respectively. Patients with ADHD also tend to exhibit longer response times to a target and increased response variability. ADS test results are commonly expressed as t-scores relative to predetermined average scores.24 We also examined the correlation between ADS results and HRV parameters showing psychophysiological states at the baseline, as ADS assessments are widely used in clinics not only for categorical diagnosis of ADHD but also for assessing the continuous performance and the ADHD symptom profile.
Heart rate variability
Standard methods to measure HRV have been developed and have demonstrated pathophysiological correlation.10 The data collection and HRV analysis were performed with SA-2000E (Medicore Company, Seoul, Korea). The parameters measured in the evaluation of HRV were grouped into the time and frequency domains. In the time domain, the standard deviation of the normal-to-normal interval (SDNN) was used to estimate the long-term components of the HRV, and the square root of the mean squared differences of successive normal-to-normal intervals (RMSSD) was calculated by statistical time domain measurements. In the frequency domain, short-term recordings of 5 minutes were binned into the following frequency bands, as recommended by the Task Force of the European Society of Cardiology and the North American Society of Pacing and Electrophysiology:10 very low frequency (VLF) (0.00-0.04 Hz), low frequency (LF) (0.05-0.15 Hz), and high frequency (HF) (0.16-0.40 Hz) components.11 Initially in this study, VLF, LF, and HF power were recorded as absolute values. The total power (TP) and ratio of low frequency to high frequency (LF/HF) were calculated from the absolute values of LF and HF power as single number estimates9 that are considered to reflect simultaneous modulating effects on both the sympathetic and vagal systems.25 Since the absolute values of TP, VLF, LF, and HF power were skewed, power densities were transformed by taking their natural logarithms to allow parametric statistical comparisons that assume normal distributions.26
Short-term recording (5 min) of electrocardiograms and HRV parameters from a stationary position were used in this study.
Procedures
This study's subjects were all outpatients at Guro Hospital, Korea University Medical Center. None had received any medication for at least two months prior to beginning treatment in this study. Subjects were instructed to visit the outpatient clinic at Korea University Guro Hospital on a regular basis and received methylphenidate as part of their medical treatment. All subjects were evaluated for adverse events during each visit, and an interview with their care providers was conducted. At baseline, time- and frequency-domain analyses of HRV, K-ARS, and ADS were evaluated before starting medication. After a 12-week period of receiving the medication, endpoint HRV and ARS measurements were taken.
Statistical analysis
Clinical variables, such as K-ARS and HRV parameters, were compared between the baseline and endpoints using a paired samples t-test. Correlations between baseline and endpoint HRV parameters were investigated. Pearson's correlations were also used to determine the correlations between ADHD clinical variables and HRV parameters. All data analyses were performed using SPSS version 21.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA), and p≤0.05 was considered significant.
RESULTS
Eighty-six subjects were initially enrolled and 37 participants completed the 12-week treatment regimen. The mean age of all 86 participants [75 male (87.2%) and 11 female (12.8%)] was 8.17±2.06. Baseline demographic and psychometric variables from all participants and completers are presented in Table 1. The mean score of the K-ARS was 25.96±10.65 for all participants. Among the completers, the mean methylphenidate dose at the endpoint was 22.23±8.93 mg and the mean methylphenidate dose per unit weight was 0.70±0.20 mg/kg.
Table 1
Baseline Demographic/Clinical Characteristics of ADHD Participants and Completers
We investigated the correlations between the K-ARS variables and each HRV parameter at baseline in all participants (Table 2). Significant correlations were found between the K-ARS inattention score and some HRV parameters (mean heart rate: r=-0.277, HF: r=0.229, LF/HF: r=-0.250).
Table 2
Correlations between K-ARS Variables and HRV Parameters in All Participants (n=86)
When we examined the correlations between ADS variables and each HRV parameter, the only significant result was a negative correlation between commission errors and VLF (r=-0.235).
Next, we investigated the correlations between HRV parameters at baseline and at the endpoint of the 12-week treatment in completers. In the analysis of completers, all of the HRV parameters, except SDNN, VLF, and LF/HF, showed a significant positive correlation between baseline and endpoint measures (mean heart rate: r=0.394, RMSSD: r=0.546, TP: r=0.350, LF: r=0.324, HF: r=0.330).
For the completers, we also assessed the changes in K-ARS and HRV between the baseline and endpoint (Table 3). After treatment, all the K-ARS scores (inattention, hyperactivity-impulsivity, and total) decreased significantly from the baseline. This indicated that the participants showed a clinical improvement in ADHD symptoms. In addition, there was a significant increase in the mean heart rate from 86.38±11.15 to 93.54±15.60.
Table 3
Changes in K-ARS and HRV between the Baseline and Endpoint (12th Treatment Week) in Completers (n=37)
HF also showed a significant decrease from baseline (6.14±0.97) to endpoint (5.70±1.22). The HF component is known to be a quantitative marker of parasympathetic vagal tone.27 The RMSSD significantly decreased from baseline (47.65±25.12) to endpoint (38.88±17.94). The RMSSD is sensitive to high-frequency heart period fluctuations in the respiratory frequency range and has also been used as an index of vagal cardiac control.28
DISCUSSION
Several studies have investigated laboratory analyses to assess the potential differences between typically developing healthy children and ADHD groups. There are no characterized specific and definitive cognitive, metabolic, neurological, or biological markers for ADHD, although many diagnostic tools such as continuous performance test are applied for the diagnosis of ADHD. Accordingly, uncertainty exists for assessing symptoms changes in the disorder.29 The development of laboratory and psychophysiological measures for the assessment of symptom changes in ADHD would be helpful for both the understanding and the treatment of the essential underlying pathophysiological processes.
The central nervous system modulates the changes in autonomic nervous system activity in ADHD.30 Psychological state and processes are known to influence the autonomic nervous control of the cardiovascular system in patients with mental disorders. In mental disorders such as ADHD, psychological state also can influence HRV because the central nervous system modulates the autonomic nervous system, and cardiac function is sensitive to autonomic influences.31 Accordingly, a change in the mental disorder can also affect the autonomic nervous system and can thus affect HRV parameters, whether it is caused by treatment or not. Consequently, the HRV can be used as an index of central-peripheral neural feedback and CNS-ANS integration,32 and HRV analysis can show the possible links between mental processes and cardiac autonomic regulation.30 Accordingly, many studies have sought to identify specific electro-cortical and HRV indices of arousal, activation, and effort.4 In addition, these parameters related to state regulation can be measured reliably using cardiac measures as these are less sensitive to characteristic behaviors of children with ADHD (eye and body movement) rather than electro-cortical measures.33
The polyvagal theory proposed by Porges conceptualizes the vagal brake (i.e., the myelinated vagus, originating in the nucleus ambiguous) as an adaptive and dynamic neural physiological mechanism to foster interaction with the environment,30 and parasympathetic nervous system-linked cardiac activity can be associated with emotion,34 and also state regulation.35
We measured HRV in subjects completing our study two times (at baseline and after 12-weeks of treatment). The HRV parameters showed significant correlations with each other, except for SDNN, VLF, and LF/HF, although there was a 12-week interval between the administrations of each test. This shows that the HRV test is reproducible, despite the parameters being subject to change according to the participants' clinical status and various clinical conditions.
Spectral power in the HF band, has been reported to primarily reflect respiration-driven vagal modulation of sinus arrhythmia.36 Traditionally, HF indexes have been accepted measures of cardiac vagal tone. However, some recent studies have demonstrated that changes in this index do not necessarily show proportional changes in vagal tone. Recent studies also show that the HF component is related to both vagal tone and the magnitude of fluctuation in vagal traffic, although these relationships are non-linear.37
In a previous cross-sectional study, vagal reactivity was compared between 18 children with ADHD and 18 age-matched healthy subjects. The vagal reactivity, measured as percent change in the high frequency band in response to orthosis, was significantly higher in the ADHD group compared to controls.30
Negrao, et al.13 reported that stimulant-free children with ADHD have sympathetic underarousal and parasympathetic overarousal of the sympathovagal balance (i.e., a parasympathetic dominance of the autonomic balance) relative to healthy control subjects. They also showed that methylphenidate shifted the autonomic balance in children with ADHD towards normal levels, although methylphenidate was administered for a shorter period of only, but at least, 10 days and the duration of the trial was not controlled.
The HF component shows significant positive correlations with K-ARS inattention subscale scores, which decreased significantly after our 12-week treatment. The significant clinical improvements included decreases in all K-ARS scale scores: inattention, hyperactivity-impulsivity, and total scores. There was also a statistically significant decrease in the mean HF value, because there were significant clinical improvements. In addition, RMSSD, which is also known to be a measure of vagus-mediated control of the heart, decreased significantly after 12 weeks of treatment, compared with baseline.38 This study alone does not show whether changes in HRV parameters are related with clinical response, apart from the well-characterized methylphenidate effects on cardiovascular parameters. If we could compare the endpoint HRV parameters between children who responded to methylphenidate and those who did not, it would help answer to this question. However, we could not evaluate the endpoint HRV parameters in patients who dropped out of the study. Instead, we need to consider the results of Negrao's study on the comparison of baseline HRV parameters between stimulant-free children with ADHD and normal typically developing control subjects. There were significant differences between those two groups and stimulant-free children with ADHD showed greater values in HF and RMSSD parameters.13 This indicates that children with ADHD differ from normal controls in their preexisting HRV parameters irrespective of methylphenidate treatment, and HRV parameter differences might be related to the pathophysiologic mechanisms of ADHD itself. We suggest that the changes in HRV parameters after treatment in our study may have originated from the clinical response caused by the pathophysiologic mechanisms of ADHD rather than simply methylphenidate effects on cardiovascular parameters when considering the previous study result.13
This is in line with previous research suggesting that children with ADHD show parasympathetic dominance and that methylphenidate treatment changes this parasympathetic dominance into autonomic balance. The association between altered autonomic functioning and ADHD is established, but the role of the autonomic regulatory responses in ADHD is less well understood, and the mechanisms for these changes in parasympathetic dominance in ADHD remain unclear. The HRV parameters seem to act as a proxy for more central regulatory processes that cannot be measured non-invasively.39 Heart rate was increased after treatment in this study. This is likely due to the use of methylphenidate. Methylphenidate is known to raise heart rate, but it is not significantly associated with an increase in the short-term or mid-term risk of severe cardiac events when used to treat children.40
This study had some limitations. Among its most major is the lack of a control group and non-blinded study design. Without the ability to compare the findings to such a control group, we cannot draw conclusions about whether the change in parasympathetic dominance completely returns to the levels in healthy controls with methylphenidate treatment. Second, there were high dropout rates during this study and female participants were underrepresented in the completers group (male 34:female 3). This was because this study was strictly limited to patients who were medicated exclusively with methylphenidate, and all the patients who took other psychotropic medications were excluded. To avoid confusion in the interpretation, we limited to patients who took only the stimulant medication. Clinical decision-making was made on the basis of clinician's appraisal of the child's clinical status, response to the methylphenidate, and the experience of adverse events. When the child needed to receive an alternative psychotropic medication, the patient was excluded from the study. This contributed to the high dropout rate in this study. Third, the use of non-medicinal products including energy drinks that can affect the cardiovascular parameters were not screened in this study. However, when considering the age of participants (from 6 to 12 years), it is not common for children to consume energy drinks and the sale of energy drinks that contain high concentrations of caffeine is regulated in Korea. Nonetheless, to our knowledge, this is the first study to examine the relationship between HRV parameters and ADHD clinical variables prospectively in a controlled clinical trial.
In conclusion, the HRV test was shown to have repeatability, and decreases in HF and RMSSD suggested that parasympathetic dominance in ADHD can be changed by methylphenidate treatment. This study also revealed the possibility that HRV parameters can be used as a psychophysiological marker in the treatment of ADHD.
The authors have no financial conflicts of interest.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This research was financially supported by a Jun Sang-Bae Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Research grant from the Korean Foundation of Neuropsychiatric Research.
References
-
Mulder G. The concept and measurement of mental effort. In: Hockey RJ, Gaillard AWK, Coles MGH, editors. Energetics and human information processing. 1986. pp. 175-198.
-
-
Gaultney JF, Kipp K, Weinstein J, McNeill J. Inhibition and Mental Effort in Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. J Dev Phys Disabil 1999;11:105–114.
-
-
Task Force of the European Society of Cardiology and the North American Society of Pacing and Electrophysiology. Heart rate variability. Standards of measurement, physiological interpretation, and clinical use. Eur Heart J 1996;17:354–381.
-
-
Wilens TE. Mechanism of action of agents used in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. J Clin Psychiatry 2006;67 Suppl 8:32–38.
-
-
DuPaul GJ, Power TJ, Anastopoulos AD, Reid R. In: ADHD Rating Scale-IV: Checklists, Norms, and Clinical Interpretation. New York: Guilford Press; 1998.
-
-
So YK, Noh JS, Kim YS, Ko SG, Koh YJ. The reliability and validity of Korean parent and teacher ADHD Rating Scale. J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc 2002;41:283–289.
-
-
DuPaul GJ. Parent and Teacher Ratings of Adhd Symptoms: Psychometric Properties in a Community-Based Sample. J Clin Child Psychol 1991;20:245–253.
-
-
Shin MS, Cho S, Chun SY, Hong KE. A study of the development and standardization of ADHD diagnostic system. J Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2000;11:91–99.
-
-
Tonhajzerova I, Ondrejka I, Adamik P, Hruby R, Javorka M, Trunkvalterova Z, et al. Changes in the cardiac autonomic regulation in children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Indian J Med Res 2009;130:44–50.
-
-
Börger N, van der Meere J. Motor control and state regulation in children with ADHD: a cardiac response study. Biol Psychol 2000;51:247–267.
-
-
Task Force of the European Society of Cardiology and the North American Society of Pacing and Electrophysiology. Heart rate variability: standards of measurement, physiological interpretation and clinical use. Circulation 1996;93:1043–1065.
-
MeSH Terms
Tables
1 / 3
