Published online Aug 01, 2018.
https://doi.org/10.3346/jkms.2018.33.e235
An Outbreak of Scombroid Fish Poisoning Associated with Consumption of Yellowtail Fish in Seoul, Korea
Abstract
Background
In November 2016, an outbreak of scombroid fish poisoning occurred among elementary school students in Seoul, Korea. An epidemiological investigation was conducted to identify the cause and source of the illness.
Methods
A case-control study was conducted among school members who had eaten lunch in the school. The histamine level in the suspect food item (yellowtail steak) was measured.
Results
Fifty-five (5.4%) of 1,017 school members who consumed fish for lunch fell ill. The principal symptoms were flushing (100%) and headache (72.7%); the median incubation period was 40 minutes. All had consumed yellowtail steak (odds ratio, 9.24; 95% confidence interval, 1.22–69.91). Leftover steak had an elevated histamine level (293 mg/kg), higher than the allowed 200 mg/kg.
Conclusion
An outbreak of scombroid fish poisoning was confirmed; this is the first such report in Korea. Detailed food safety guidelines must be established.
Graphical Abstract
INTRODUCTION
Scombroid fish poisoning is a foodborne disease associated with ingestion of histamine-contaminated fish of the Scombroidae family (e.g., tuna, sardines, and mackerel).1 Histamine is generated by bacteria from free histidine in fish that is not kept refrigerated.2 Scombroid fish poisoning is characterized by allergic reactions including flushing, headache, dizziness, abdominal cramps, and palpitations developing within 20–30 minutes of ingestion; most symptoms resolve within 6–8 hours.3 As fish consumption has increased, outbreaks of scombroid fish poisoning have become common in many countries.4 However, this is the first reported outbreak in Korea.
On November 3, 2016, an emergency medical dispatch team (summoned by a school by calling “119”) informed a regional Public Health Center that a large number of elementary school students had been transferred to several hospitals because of acute symptoms. An outbreak control team found that most students had experienced flushing and headache within 2 hours of eating lunch at their elementary school and reported the situation to the Department of Public Health of the Seoul Metropolitan Government. Histamine poisoning was suspected because of the rapid onset of allergic symptoms. An epidemiological investigation was quickly mounted.
METHODS
Epidemiological investigation
A case-control study was conducted among school members who had eaten lunch in the school. A case was defined as flushing accompanied by symptoms, such as headache, rash, a sense of warmth, chill, and gastrointestinal symptoms (nausea, abdominal pain, diarrhea, and vomiting). For every case, we randomly selected three school members who did not report symptoms after lunch (controls). All cases and controls completed questionnaires exploring demographic characteristics, food items consumed at lunch, and (for cases), symptoms and onset times. Rectal swabs were taken from 63 symptomatic children and 7 food handlers. Samples of food served over the 2 preceding days (including the offending lunch) were collected, and serving utensils were swabbed. Microbiological tests were performed by the Seoul Institute of Health and the Environment. Efforts were made to isolate Salmonella, Shigella, Staphylococcus aureus, Vibrio species, Listeria monocytogenes, Yersinia enterocolitica, Bacillus cereus, pathological Escherichia coli, Clostridium perfringens, and Campylobacter jejuni. Additionally, polymerase chain reactions seeking genomic material of viral pathogens, including rotavirus, norovirus, adenovirus, astrovirus, and sapovirus were performed. Histamine levels in leftover yellowtail fish steak (suspected food item) was measured via high-performance liquid chromatography (using a fluorescence detection method) by the Gyeongin Regional Office of Food and Drug Safety.
Statistical analysis
The relationship between consumption of certain food items and illness was assessed by calculating odds ratios (ORs) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) with the aid of SPSS software (Version 20.0; IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). A P value ≤ 0.05 was considered to reflect significance.
Ethics statement
This study was not subject to Institutional Review Board review. It was the result of an epidemiological investigation conducted by the local government in accordance with Article 18 of the Act on the Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases.
RESULTS
Epidemiological investigation
Of the 1,017 school members (932 students and 85 teachers and other employees) who consumed the suspect lunch, 55 (54 students and 1 teacher) fit the case definition, and 171 controls were randomly selected (168 students and 3 teachers). The attack rate was 5.4% and most cases were higher-grade students (Table 1). The reason why cases were concentrated in the higher grades could be as follows. Canteen food was cooked at a food service facility and delivered to the classroom where the students had lunch. The food was distributed starting from the upper grades and the students started to experience symptoms quickly, so distribution and consumption may have been stopped before reaching the lower grades. In addition, teachers ate after students were fed, so there were few symptomatic teachers. The major symptoms were flushing (100%) and headache (72.7%), and the incubation period was 10–520 minutes (median: 40 minutes). Of all those who fell ill, 38 (69.1%) reported symptom onset within 1 hour of lunch, and 47 (85.5%) reported symptom onset within 2 hours (Fig. 1). All symptomatic students were managed at medical centers and recovered within a few hours.
Table 1
Characteristics of cases (n = 55)
Fig. 1
Time before symptom onset of scombroid fish poisoning by 30-minutes intervals (n = 55).
Lunch featured steamed rice with glutinous millet, seaweed/beef soup, yellowtail steak, sweet-and-sour mushrooms, Korean cabbage (kimchi), and milk. Only the yellowtail steak was significantly associated with illness (OR, 9.24; 95% CI, 1.22–69.91) (Table 2). Kimchi (OR, 1.96; 95% CI, 0.23–16.67), seaweed/beef soup (OR, 1.88; 95% CI, 0.62–5.72), sweet-and-sour mushrooms (OR, 0.96; 95% CI, 0.09–9.46), milk (OR, 0.96; 95% CI, 0.18–4.91), and steamed rice with glutinous millet (not applicable) were not significantly associated with illness.
Table 2
Relationship between consumption of food items and illness
The histamine concentration was 293 mg/kg in leftover yellowtail steak, higher than the concentration allowed by the Korean Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (KMFDS; 200 mg/kg). All microbiological analyses of food items and utensils were negative. Of a total of 70 rectal swabs (63 from symptomatic students, 7 from food handlers), 3 were positive for enteropathogenic E. coli (EPEC), and 1 was positive for Salmonella infantis. All four cases reported flushing and headache within 1 hour after eating lunch; two of the EPEC cases reported sensations of warmth and chilling; two of the EPEC cases and the S. infantis case reported nausea, and one EPEC case reported abdominal pain. The bacteria were not considered to have caused the outbreak because the major symptoms were allergic in nature and of short duration.
Traceback information indicated that the yellowtail was processed and frozen at a manufacturing company in Busan and sent to the school under refrigeration by the supplier. The fish was stored in a refrigerator until it was grilled, sauced, and served. The Busan Regional Office of Food and Drug Safety, which determined the histamine concentration in the remaining yellowtail steaks at the suppliers (before it was sold), reported that the histamine levels in the samples were elevated above the standard.
DISCUSSION
Histamine can be rapidly produced in fish stored at ≥ 20°C, and elevated levels of histamine (> 200 mg/kg) have been reported after food storage for > 15 hours at 20°C–35°C.5 Histamine is heat-stable (thus not destroyed by cooking); it is essential for maintaining the cold chain.6 The histamine level in fresh fish is < 0.1 mg/kg7; however, most outbreaks have been associated with fish histamine levels ≥ 200 mg/kg and often > 500 mg/kg,8 although some outbreaks were associated with levels < 200 mg/kg.9, 10, 11
The present outbreak of food poisoning was caused by histamine contamination; the histamine level in leftover yellowtail steak was > 200 mg/kg, and the cases exhibited the classic symptoms of scombroid fish poisoning. However, the 2017 Korean Guideline for Food Safety Regulation indicates that if consumption of histamine-contaminated food results in an outbreak, this is not an outbreak of food poisoning, as the latter is defined as an incident caused by bacteria, viruses, protozoa, natural compounds (vegetable, animal, and fungal toxins), certain chemicals (hazardous food additives, residual pesticides, metal compounds, and verdigris, lead, and arsenic from cooking utensils and packaging), and some other substances, such as methanol. Thus, scombroid fish poisoning could not be considered as a food poisoning although histamine is a recognized chemical poison. The current protocol for the prevention and management of scombroid fish poisoning clearly requires review.
In the USA, the Food and Drug Administration requires that histamine concentrations (an indicator of decomposition) to not exceed 50 mg/kg, and the European Union stipulates that levels not exceed 100 mg/kg.12 The New Zealand cutoff is 200 mg/kg in fish or fish products,13 which is the same as in Korea.14 When histamine levels exceed these standards in fish or fish products before shipment or distribution, these items are discarded. In this outbreak, the levels in the leftover yellowtail steak were 293 mg/kg. In addition, the levels were above the standard in fish obtained from the supplier. The raw material and processed product were not left in the manufacturing company. According to the guidelines, the histamine test for the safe management of fishery products only applies to domestic fishery products at the pre-distribution stage (production and processing) and imported fishery products at the distribution stage; in addition, yellowtail fish are not included in the items to be inspected for histamine contamination. Therefore, the fish in this outbreak had already been distributed in domestic fishery products, and further testing was not conducted. Because yellowtail fish is a major food item in Korea, it is necessary to supplement the Korean Food Standards Codex so that histamine test items include yellowtail fish.
In this outbreak, the epidemic curve showed that the onset time in several students was longer than 2 hours after eating lunch. This may be because they slept after eating lunch and only noticed the symptoms after awakening. A similar observation was previously reported.6 This can be explained by the fact that the lunch was discontinued because of the outbreak and the asymptomatic students were instructed to return home early on the day of the outbreak. Compared to previous reports, the attack rate in the present outbreak was very low, perhaps because the other outbreaks were associated with histamine levels > 500 mg/kg.3 Moreover, yellowtail is rarely associated with scombroid fish poisoning.4 All previous outbreaks of scombroid fish poisoning have occurred in countries other than Korea. Many countries continuously monitor such outbreaks and institute control measures when high histamine levels are detected in fish products.13, 15 In Korea, it is necessary to improve the monitoring system so that outbreaks of scombroid poisoning are reported to the public health authorities.
Food poisoning caused by microorganisms or toxics is distinct from foodborne infectious disease, which has a longer incubation period and can be communicated to other people.16 However, the initial symptoms may not be distinguishable by public health field workers and a common investigative approach is needed. As soon as the causative agent is identified or suspected, appropriate measures should be taken to prevent further cases. In Korea, the administrative responsibilities for foodborne disease outbreak control are shared by the KMFDS and Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (KCDC). KMFDS restricts the distribution of contaminated food and enhances safety management. If an infectious disease is involved, KCDC conducts contact monitoring and patient management to prevent the spread of the infection.
In conclusion, we report the first outbreak of scombroid fish poisoning in Korea. In recent years, domestic consumption of fish products has increased, and scombroid fish products are supplied to school cafeterias. Therefore, all outbreaks of scombroid fish poisoning must be promptly reported and investigated and detailed food safety regulations are required.
Disclosure:The authors have no potential conflicts of interest to disclose.
Author Contributions:
Conceptualization: Kang CR, Cho SI.
Data curation: Kim YY.
Formal analysis: Kang CR.
Writing - original draft: Kang CR.
Writing - review & editing: Lee JI, Joo HD, Jung SW, Cho SI.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We are grateful to all members of the outbreak control team of Seongbuk-gu Public Health Center in Seoul for their epidemiological investigation.
References
-
Tortorella V, Masciari P, Pezzi M, Mola A, Tiburzi SP, Zinzi MC, et al. Histamine poisoning from ingestion of fish or scombroid syndrome. Case Rep Emerg Med 2014;2014:482531
-
-
Bremer P, Fletcher G, Osborne C. In: Scombrotoxin in Seafood. Christchurch: New Zealand Institute for Crop & Food Research Limited; 2003.
-
-
Gilbert RJ, Hobbs G, Murray CK, Cruickshank JG, Young SE. Scombrotoxic fish poisoning: features of the first 50 incidents to be reported in Britain (1976–9). BMJ 1980;281(6232):71–72.
-
-
William Reed Business Media Ltd. [Updated 2017]. [Accessed August 15, 2017].https://www.foodqualitynews.com/Article/2017/08/08/Multiple-
EU- countries- report- outbreaks- caused- by- histamine.
-
-
Fletcher GC, Albert M. In: Research of Relevance to Histamine Poisoning in New Zealand: a Review. Auckland: Plant & Food Research; 2010.
-
-
Ministry of Food and Drug Safety. Guideline for the Food Safety Regulation. Osong: Ministry of Food and Drug Safety; 2017.
-
-
Bang JH, Kim HB. Diagnosis and clinical features of food poisoning. J Korean Med Assoc 2007;50(7):592–599.
-
MeSH Terms
Figures
1 / 1
Tables
1 / 2
