초록

Phenomenal externalism has it that the phenomenal character of perceptual experience can be constitutively determined by things external to the perceiving subject. Although many contemporary philosophers of perception endorse such view, there is no consensus on the nature of the mind-independent properties that purport to determine the way things perceptually appear to the subject. In this paper, I will critically examine two views of appearance properties: (1) the parsimonious view and (2) the extravagant view. These views are intended to capture how things perceptually appear to the subject with their novel accounts of appearance properties, but both of them face some serious problems. At the end, I propose an extravagant view that is immune to these problems.

키워드

Perceptual Experience, Phenomenal Character, Phenomenal Externalism, Appearance Properties

참고문헌(28)open

  1. [학술지] Antony, Louise / 2011 / The Openness of Illusions / Philosophical Issues 21 : 25 ~ 44

  2. [학술지] Block, Ned / 1996 / Mental Paint and Mental Latex / Philosophical Issues 7 : 19 ~ 49

  3. [학술지] Brewer, Bill / 2006 / Perception and Content / European Journal of Philosophy 14 (2) : 165 ~ 181

  4. [단행본] Brewer, Bill / 2011 / Perception and Its Objects / Oxford University Press

  5. [인터넷자료] Byrne, Alex / “DON’T PANIC: Tye’s Intentionalist Theory of Consciousness.” In A Field Guide to the Philosophy of Mind symposium on Tye’s Consciousness, Color, and Content

  6. [학술지] Byrne, Alex / 2006 / Qualia Ain’t in the Head / Noûs 40 (2) : 241 ~ 255

  7. [단행본] Campbell, John / 2002 / Reference and Consciousness / Oxford University Press

  8. [단행본] Chalmers, David / 2010 / The Character of Consciousness / Oxford University Press

  9. [단행본] Chisholm, Roderik / 1957 / Perceiving: A Philosophical Study / Cornell University Press

  10. [학술지] Dretske, Fred / 1996 / Phenomenal Externalism or If Meanings Ain’t in the Head, Where Are Qualia / Philosophical Issues 7 : 143 ~ 158

  11. [단행본] Fish, William / 2009 / Perception, Hallucination, and Illusion / Oxford University Press

  12. [학술지] Genone, James / 2014 / Appearance and Illusion / Mind 123 (490) : 339 ~ 376

  13. [단행본] Hill, Christopher / 2009 / Consciousness / Cambridge University Press

  14. [단행본] Jackson, Frank / 1977 / Perception: A Representative Theory / Cambridge University Press

  15. [학술지] Levine, Joseph / 1983 / Materialism and Qualia: The Explanatory Gap / Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 64 (4) : 354 ~ 361

  16. [학술지] Logue, Heather / 2012 / Why Naïve Realism / Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 112 (part 2) : 211 ~ 237

  17. [단행본] Lycan, William / 1996 / Consciousness and Experience / MIT Press

  18. [학술지] Lycan, William / 2001 / The Case for Phenomenal Externalism / Noûs 35 (s15) : 17 ~ 35

  19. [학술지] Martin, M. G. F / 2002 / The Transparency of Experience / Mind & Language 17 (4) : 376 ~ 425

  20. [학술지] Martin, M. G. F / 2004 / The Limits of Self-Awareness / Philosophical Studies 120 (1/3) : 37 ~ 89

  21. [단행본] Martin, M. G. F / 2010 / What’s in a Look : 160 ~ 225

  22. [학술지] Nagel, Thomas / 1974 / What Is It Like to Be a Bat / The Philosophical Review 83 (4) : 435 ~ 450

  23. [단행본] Noë, Alva / 2006 / Action in Perception / MIT Press

  24. [학술지] Pautz, Adam / 2006 / Sensory Awareness Is Not a Wide Physical Relation: An Empirical Argument against Externalist Intentionalism / Noûs 40 (2) : 205 ~ 240

  25. [학술지] Pautz, Adam / 2007 / Intentionalism and Perceptual Presence / Philosophical Perspectives 21 (1) : 495 ~ 541

  26. [단행본] Russell, Bertrand / 1912 / The Problems of Philosophy /

  27. [학술지] Schellenberg, Susanna / 2008 / The Situation-Dependency of Perception / The Journal of Philosophy 105 (2) : 55 ~ 84

  28. [학술지] Travis, Charles / 2004 / The Silence of the Senses / Mind 113 (449) : 57 ~ 94