초록

This paper develops an analytical framework by comparing two idiosyncratic national systems of innovation, namely Korea and China. Four generic institutions and their functions in the system are analyzed: government, science and technology policy, industry, research and development (R&D) activities, education system and human resource development, and the interaction and linkage among players. First, the study found that the role of government was decisive in guiding and promoting the technological development in both countries. Second, Korea’s innovation system is based on large firms and efficient interactions among players of the National System of Innovation (NSI) as well as high social commitment in education while Chinese economic structure promoted the development of low and medium technology oriented, scale intensive industries. Third, Korea pursues the idea of techno-nationalism in building its national capability of innovation, while China embraces an ideology of techno-hybrid regime attracting foreign direct investment and international joint venture as an important means of acquiring advanced technology. This paper argues, based on these contrasts, that the persistence of a strong role of government and existing institutional set-up rejects that the current convergence view of a single best organizational and policy structure for the construction of the NSI and national strategy of technology development is essential to be the best. In fact, it suggests a more viable alternative model of coping with a country-specific institutional arrangement in Korea and China.

키워드

Innovation System, Technology Policy, Institution, Korea, China

참고문헌(67)open

  1. [학술지] Arnold, D. J / 1998 / New Strategies in Emerging Markets / Sloan Management Review 40 (1) : 7 ~ 20

  2. [학술지] Bartholomew,S / 1997 / National Systems of Biotechnology Innovation: Complex Interdependence in the Global System / Journal of International Business Studies 21 : 241 ~ 266

  3. [기타] Capron, H / 2000 / The National Innovation System of Belgium: the Institutional Profile / CESIT discussion Papers : 2000 ~ 2001

  4. [학술지] Chang, P-L / 2004 / The Innovation Systems of Taiwan and China: a Comparative Analysis / Technovation 24 (7) : 529 ~ 539

  5. [학술지] Chang, S. J / 2006 / When and How Does Business Group Affiliation Promote Firm Innovation? A Tale of Two Emerging Economies / Organization Science 17 (5) : 637 ~ 656

  6. [학술지] Child, J / 2001 / China's Transition and its Implications for International Business / Journal of International Business Studies 32 : 5 ~ 21

  7. [단행본] Dosi, G / 1990 / The Economics of Technical Change and International Trade / New York University Press

  8. [단행본] Dodgson,M / 2000 / Policies for Science, Technology and Innovation in Asian Newly Industrializing Economies in Technology, Learning and Innovation: Experiences of Newly Industrializing Economies / Cambridge University Press

  9. [단행본] European Bank for Reconstruction and Development(EBRD) / 1998 / Transition Report / EBRD

  10. [단행본] Edquist,C / 1997 / System of Innovation: Technologies, Institutions and Organizations / Pinter

  11. [단행본] Freeman,C / 1987 / Technology Policy and Economic Performance, Lessons from Japan / Pinter

  12. [학술지] Freeman,C / 1995 / The National System of Innovation in Historical Perspective / Cambridge Journal of Economics 19 (1) : 5 ~ 24

  13. [기타] Freeman, C / 1988 / Structural Crises of Adjustment, Business Cycle and Investment Behaviour

  14. [단행본] Freeman, C / 1997 / The Economics of Industrial Innovation, Third edition / Pinter

  15. [단행본] Gu,S / 1999 / China’s Industrial Technology: Market Reform and Organizational Change / Routledge

  16. [단행본] Hall, P. A / 2001 / Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage / Oxford University Press

  17. [단행본] Hobday,M / 1994 / Innovation in East Asia: The Challenge to Japan / Edward Elgar

  18. [학술지] Hoskisson, R. E. / 2000 / Strategy in Emerging Economies / Academy of Management Journal 43 : 249 ~ 267

  19. [단행본] Hu,Z.J / 2000 / National Innovation System: a Theoretical Analysis and an International Comparison(in Chinese) / Social Science Literature Press

  20. [단행본] Jefferson, G. H / 1999 / Enterprise Reform in China: Ownership, Transition and Performance / Oxford University Press

  21. [단행본] KEDI(Korea Educational Development Institute) / 2007 / Statistics of Education / KEDI

  22. [단행본] Keller, W. W / 2002 / Crisis and Innovation in Asian Technology / University Press

  23. [단행본] Kim,E.M / 1997 / Big Business, Strong State: Collusion and Conflict in South Korean Development, 1960-1990 / State University of New York Press

  24. [보고서] Kim,S.R / 1996 / Korean System of Innovation and the Semiconductor Industry: a Governance Perspective

  25. [학술지] Kim,L / 1980 / Stages of Development of Industrial Technology in a Developing Country: a Model / Research Policy 9 : 254 ~ 277

  26. [단행본] Kim,L / 1997 / Imitation to Innovation: The Dynamics of Korea’s Technological Learning / Harvard Business School Press

  27. [단행본] Kim,L / 1999 / Learning and Innovation in Economic Development / Edward Elgar

  28. [학술지] Kim, L / 1992 / Technology Policy for Industrialization: An Integrative Framework and Korea’s Experience / Research Policy 21 : 437 ~ 452

  29. [단행본] Kim, L / 2000 / Technology, Learning and Innovation: Experiences of Newly Industrializing Economies / Cambridge University Press

  30. [학술지] Kogut,B / 1991 / Country Capabilities and the Permeabilities of Borders / Strategic Management Journal 12 : 33 ~ 47

  31. [단행본] KNSO(Korea National Statistical Office) / 2004 / International Statistic Yearbook / KNSO

  32. [단행본] Lall,S / 1996 / Learning from the Asian Tigers: Studies in Technology and Industrial policy / Macmillan

  33. [단행본] Lall,S / 2000 / Technological Change and Industrialization in the Asian Newly Industrializing Economies: Achievements and Challenges in Technology, Learning and Innovation: Experiences of Newly Industrializing Economies / Cambridge University Press

  34. [단행본] Lee,K / 1991 / Chinese Firms and the State in Transition: Property Rights and Agency Problems in the Reform era / M. E. Sharpe, Inc.

  35. [학술지] Lee, K / 2001 / Technological Regimes, Catching-up and Leapfrogging: Findings from the Korean Industries / Research Policy 30 : 459 ~ 483

  36. [단행본] Lee,W-Y / 2000 / The Role of Science and Technology Policy in Korea’s Industrial Development in Technology, Learning and Innovation: Experiences of Newly Industrializing Economies / Cambridge University Press

  37. [학술지] Lee, S. H / 2007 / Government Policy and Trajectories of Radical Rnnovation in Dirigiste States: A Comparative Analysis of National Innovation Systems in France and Korea / Technology Analysis & Strategic Management 19 (4) : 451 ~ 470

  38. [학술지] Lee, K / 2001 / Technological Regimes, Catching-up and Leapfrogging: Findings from the Korean Industries / Research Policy 30 : 459 ~ 483

  39. [기타] Li Ka-Shing Foundation / 2006 / The 5th Cheung Kong Scholars award Ceremony Held in Beijing / Li Ka-Shing Foundation: http://www.lksf.org

  40. [학술지] Liu, X / 2001 / Comparing Innovation Systems: a Framework and Application to China’s Transitional Context / Research Policy 30 : 1091 ~ 1114

  41. [단행본] Lundvall,B-A / 1992 / National Systems of Innovation / Pinter

  42. [학술지] Lundvall,B-A / 1998 / Why Study National Systems and National Styles of Innovation? / Technology Analysis and Strategic Management 10 : 407 ~ 421

  43. [단행본] Malerba,F / 2004 / Sectoral Systems of Innovation / Cambridge University Press

  44. [학술지] Metcalfe,J.S / 1995 / Technology Systems and Technology Policy in an Evolutionary Framework / Cambridge Journal of Economics 19 (1) : 25 ~ 46

  45. [보고서] MOST(Ministry of Science and Technology) / 2007 / Science and Technology Activity Report

  46. [단행본] Mowery, D. C / 1999 / Sources of Industrial Leadership: Studies of Seven Industries / Cambridge University Press

  47. [기타] MSTC(Ministry of Science and Technology of People's Republic of China) / Science and Technology Statistics Data Book / MSTC

  48. [단행본] Nelson,R.R / 1993 / National Innovation System:a Comparative Analysis / Oxford University Press

  49. [단행본] Nelson, R. R / 1993 / Technical Innovation and National Systems in National System of Innovation: a Comparative Study / Oxford University Press

  50. [단행본] OECD / 1992 / Technology and Economy:The key relationships / OECD

  51. [단행본] OECD / 1999 / Economic Surveys:Korea / OECD

  52. [단행본] OECD / 2004 / Science,Technology and Industry Outlook 2004 / OECD

  53. [단행본] OECD / 2005 / Main Science and Technology Indicators(MSTI) / OECD

  54. [단행본] OECD / 2008 / Science and Innovation:Country Nnotes / OECD

  55. [단행본] Ostry, S / 1995 / Techno-nationalism and Techno-globalism / Brookings Institution

  56. [학술지] Patel, P / 1994 / National Innovation Systems: Why They are Important, and How They Might be Measured and Compared / Economic Innovation and New Technology 3 : 77 ~ 95

  57. [학술지] Pavitt,K / 1984 / Sectoral Patterns of Technical Change: Towards a Taxonomy and a Theory / Research Policy 13 (6) : 343 ~ 373

  58. [단행본] Porter,M / 1990 / The Competitive Advantage of Nations / The Free Press

  59. [단행본] Powell, W. W / 1991 / The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis / University of Chicago Press

  60. [단행본] Saxenian,A / 1994 / Regional Advantage: Culture and Competition in Silicon Vally and Route 128 / Harvard University Press

  61. [단행본] Shi,Y / 1998 / Chinese Firms and Technology in the Reform era / Routledge

  62. [단행본] Schumpeter,J / 1912 / The Theory of Economic Development / Harvard Economic Studies

  63. [학술지] Senker,J / 1996 / National Systems of Innovation, Organizational Learning and Industrial Biotechnology / Technovation 16 : 219 ~ 229

  64. [기타] Suh,J / 2000 / Korea’s Innovation System: Challenges and New Policy Agenda / UNU/INTECH Discussion Papers #2000-4

  65. [보고서] Tse, David K / 1999 / New Ownership Forms in Transitional Economies: Emergence, Characteristics and Performance of China’s Joint Stock Companies

  66. [단행본] World Bank / 1993 / The East Asian Miracle: Economic Growth and Public Policy / Oxford University Press

  67. [학술지] Wright, M / 2005 / Strategy Research in Emerging Economies: Challenging the Conventional Wisdom / Journal of Management Studies 42 (1) : 1 ~ 33