초록
The paper demonstrates the potential contribution of integrating discursive and affective analytic regimes in framing the study of Southeast Asia. I examine the “emotional possibilities” available to migrants with particular focus on the experience of Filipino domestic helpers in Hong Kong thrown into relief in 2016 by news of maids falling to their deaths while cleaning windows of their employers’ above-ground apartments. First, I situate the study in recent calls for Critical Discourse Studies and Migration Studies to transcend foundational methodologies in their respective fields in order to apprehend formerly disregarded aspects of the human condition, including affect and emotion. I then briefly present the debate in the affective turn in social analysis, which has to do with rethinking the attachment of affect and discourse. My own inquiry is premised on the assertion that emotion is multidimensional. I specifically explore the usefulness of taking emotion as “affective-discursive practice” by focusing on an analysis of the appropriation of the victim role by foreign domestic helper employer groups that could be seen in pertinent news reports of selected online Hong Kong newspapers. In the end, I also emphasize the necessity of reflexivity in projects that take affect as central object of inquiry.
키워드
Emotion, affective-discursive analysis, Filipino, Hong Kong, victim
참고문헌(53)
-
[인터넷자료] Abuel, Noel / Pinay Nahulog sa Gusali / Abante News Online
-
[단행본] Aguilar Jr, Filomeno / 2014 / Migration Revolution: Philippine Nationhood and Class Relations in a Globalized Age / Ateneo de Manila University Press
-
[학술지] Aguilar Jr, Filomeno / 1996 / The Dialectics of Transnational Shame and National Identity / Philippine Sociological Review 44 (1–4) : 101 ~ 136
-
[인터넷자료] Alcid Mary Lou / Migrant Labour in Southeast Asia Country Study : The Philippines / Friedrich Ebert Stiftung
-
[학술지] Ali, Azham Md / 2011 / Quality in Qualitative Studies : The Case of Validity, Reliability and Generalizability / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 5 (1/2) : 25 ~ 64
-
[인터넷자료] Bello, Walden / Afterthoughts: Our Failed Labor-Export Policy
-
[학술지] Blommaert, Jan / 2000 / Critical Discourse Analysis / Annual Review of Anthropology 29 (2000) : 447 ~ 466
-
[학술지] Boccagni, Paolo / 2015 / Emotions on the Move: Mapping the Emergent Field of Emotion and Migration / Emotion, Space and Society 16 : 73 ~ 80
-
[학술지] Boellstorff, Tom / 2004 / Bodies of Emotion: Rethinking Culture and Emotion through Southeast Asia / Ethnos 69 (4) : 437 ~ 444
-
[인터넷자료] Bradsher, Keith / Hong Kong Court Denies Domestic Workers Residency / The New York Times
-
[단행본] Brooks, Ann / 2013 / Emotions in Transmigration: Transformation, Movement and Identity / Palgrave Macmillan
-
[학술지] Burkitt, Ian / 2012 / Emotional Reflexivity : Feeling, Emotion and Imagination in Reflexive Dialogues / Sociology 46 (3) : 458 ~ 472
-
[학술지] Burkitt, Ian / 1997 / Social Relationships and Emotions / Sociology 31 (1) : 37 ~ 55
-
[인터넷자료] Census and Statistics Department / Summary Results of the 2011 Population Census Announced. 2011 Hong Kong Population Census
-
[학술지] Chan, Joseph / 2007 / Media and Large-scale Demonstrations : The Pro-democracy Movement in Posthandover Hong Kong / Asian Journal of Communication 17 (2) : 215 ~ 228
-
[단행본] Constable, Nicole / 1997 / Maid to Order in Hong Kong: Stories of Filipina Workers / Cornell University Press
-
[단행본] Deleuze, Gilles / 1987 / A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia / University of Minnesota Press
-
[인터넷자료] / Foreign Domestic Workers in Hong Kong / South China Morning Post
-
[단행본] Fowler, Roger / 1991 / Language in the News: Discourse and Ideology in the Press / Routledge
-
[학술지] Good, Byron / 2004 / Rethinking"Emotions"in Southeast Asia / Ethnos 69 (4) : 529 ~ 533
-
[인터넷자료] / Hong Kong: The Facts / GovHK
-
[인터넷자료] Hong Kong Information Services Department / Helper contract revised / news.gov.hk
-
[단행본] Kress, Gunther / 2009 / Multimodality: A Social Semiotic Approach to Contemporary Communication / Routledge
-
[단행본] Kress, Guther / 2006 / Reading Images: The Grammar of Visual Design / Routledge
-
[학술지] Krzyżanowski, Michał / 2011 / Ethnography and Critical Discourse Analysis : Towards a Problem-Oriented Research Dialogue / Critical Discourse Studies 8 (4) : 231 ~ 238
-
[학술지] Krzyzanowski, Michał / 2016 / Theories and Concepts in Critical Discourse Studies : Facing Challenges, Moving Beyond Foundations / Discourse & Society 27 (3) : 253 ~ 261
-
[단행본] Laclau, Ernesto / 1985 / Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics / Verso
-
[인터넷자료] Leung, Stanley / “Heartbroken”: Domestic Worker Employer Group Decries Window Cleaning Ban / Hong Kong Free Press
-
[단행본] Machin, David / 2012 / How To Do Critical Discourse Analysis: A Multimodal Introduction / Sage Publications
-
[단행본] Massumi, Brian / 2002 / Parables for the Virtual: Movement, Affect, Sensation / Duke University Press
-
[학술지] Massumi, Brian / 1995 / The Autonomy of Affect / Cultural Critique, The Politi (31) : 83 ~ 109
-
[학술지] McConville, Alex / 2014 / "Hostility won’t deter me, says PM" : The Print Media, the Production of Affect and Waitangi Day / Space and Society 11 (2) : 1 ~ 18
-
[학술지] Parreñas, Rhacel / 2001 / Transgressing the Nation-State : The Partial Citizenship and"Imagined(Global)Community"of Migrant Filipina Domestic Workers / Signs : Journal of Women in Culture and Society 26 (4) : 1129 ~ 1154
-
[인터넷자료] Philippine Statistics Authority / 2014 Survey on Overseas Filipinos
-
[인터넷자료] POEA / POEA Annual Report 2011
-
[단행본] POEA / 2014 / POEA Annual Report 2014 / POEA
-
[인터넷자료] Public Evaluation on Media Credibility / Hong Kong
-
[학술지] Richard, Aneliese / 2009 / Economies of Affect / Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 15 (1) : 57 ~ 77
-
[학술지] San Juan Jr, Epifanio / 2009 / Overseas Filipino Workers : The Making of an Asian-Pacific Diaspora / The Global South 3 (2) : 99 ~ 129
-
[학술지] San Juan Jr, Epifanio / 2000 / Trajectories of the Filipino Diaspora / Ethnic Studies Report XVIII (2) : 229 ~ 238
-
[인터넷자료] Santos, Rudy / Envoy Wants Pinay Helpers Exempt from Window Cleaning / The Philippine Star
-
[학술지] Shenton, Andrew / 2004 / Strategies for Ensuring Trustworthiness in Qualitative Research Projects / Education for Information 22 : 63 ~ 75
-
[학술지] Skrbiš, Zlatko / 2008 / Transnational Families : Theorising Migration, Emotions and Belonging / Journal of Intercultural Studies 29 (3) : 231 ~ 246
-
[단행본] Sun, Wanning / 2009 / Maid in China: Media, Morality, and the Cultural Politics of Boundaries / Routledge
-
[단행본] Thrift, Nigel / 2008 / Non-representational Theory: Space, Politics and Affect / Routledge
-
[단행본] Van Dijk, Teun / 2009 / Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis / Sage Publications Ltd : 62 ~ 86
-
[단행본] van Leeuwen, Theo / 2003 / Framing and Perspectivising in Discourse / John Benjamins Publishing Co : 23 ~ 62
-
[단행본] van Leeuwen, Theo / 2008 / Discourse and Practice / Oxford University Press
-
[학술지] Wetherell, Margaret / 2013 / Affect and Discourse – What’s the problem? From Affect as Excess to Affective/discursive practice / Subjectivity 6 (2002) : 349 ~ 368
-
[단행본] Wetherell, Margaret / 2012 / Affect and Emotion: A New Social Science Understanding / Sage Publications
-
[학술지] Wetherell, Margaret / 2015 / Trends in the Turn to Affect : A Social Psychological Critique / Body and Society 21 (2) : 139 ~ 166
-
[학술지] Wetherell, Margaret / 2015 / Settling Space and Covering the Nation: Some Conceptual Considerations in Analysing Affect and Discourse / Emotion, Space and Society 16 : 56 ~ 64
-
[학술지] Zur, Ofer / 2008 / Rethinking ‘Don’t Blame the Victim’ : The Psychology of Victimhood / Journal of Couple and Relationship Therapy 4 (3–4) : 15 ~ 36