The Long Road to the International Recognition of Economic and Social Rights: The Right to an Adequate Standard of Living
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.n11.3Keywords:
recognition, economic and social rights, right to an adequate standard of livingAbstract
A long road was necessary for economic and social rights to be internationally recognized. In fact, it was only after the Second World War that the protection of human rights, including economic and social rights, became one of the aims of the United Nations. Despite that, this legal protection was by no means made without controversies, especially when it comes to economic and social rights. The fact that most of the articles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights refer to civil and political rights corroborates these difficulties. Only articles 22 through 27 protected economic and social rights. The objective of this article is to shed some light into this process, as the Universal Declaration has been the foundation of the codification of the whole human rights system. Particular attention will be given to the discussions around the inclusion of article 25 that refers to the right to an adequate standard of living. It is interesting to analyze how this right was adopted during the process of elaboration of the Declaration, as it was then incorporated by so many texts and influenced the recognition of other rights. In fact, if today we are able to have autonomous rights to water, to health, to food, to housing and to education, it is thanks to the proclamation of the right to an adequate standard of living in the first place.
References
Añón, María José (2003): “El derecho a no padecer hambre y el derecho a la alimentación adecuada, dos caras de una misma moneda”, in Abramovich, Victor, M. J. Añón and Christian Courtis (eds.): Derechos Sociales Instrucciones de uso, Mexico DF: Doctrina Jurídica Contemporánea.
Benoît-Rohmer, Florence (2009): “France: The origins, with the prospect of increasing effect”, 60 Years of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Europe, Oxford, Intersentia
De Schutter, Olivier (2014): International Human Rights Law, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Eide, Asbjørn (2010): Freedom from Need , Stockholm, Volume 55, Scandinavian Studies in Law.
Glendon, Mary Ann (2003): “Forgotten Crucible: The Latin American Influence on the Universal Human Rights idea”, 16 Harvard Human Rights Journal.
Hannum, Hurst (1995): “The Status of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in National and International Law”, 25 Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law.
Hertig Randall, Maya (2013): “The history of international human rights law”, Research Handbook on Human Rights and Humanitarian Law (eds. Robert Kolb and Gloria Gaggioli), Northampton, Edward Elgar Publishing
Hobbins, A. J. (1989): René Cassin and the Daughter of Time: The First Draft of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Fontanus II.
Humphrey, John (1984): Human Rights and the United Nations: a great adventure, New York, Transnational Publishers
Lauren, Paul Gordon (2011): The Evolution of International Human Rights, Philadelphia, University of Pensylvania Press.
Lauterpacht, Hersch (1945): An International Bill of the Rights of Man, New York, Columbia University Press.
Morsink, Johannes (1999): The Universal Declaration of Human Rights - Origins, Drafting, and Intent, Philadelphia, University of Pensylvania Press.
O´Connell, Rory and Tom Obokata (2009): “The United Kingdom: Developing a Human Rights Culture”, 60 Years of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Europe, Oxford, Intersentia
Rosenman, Samuel (Ed.) (1950): The Public Papers & Addresses of Franklin D. Roosevelt, Vol XIII, New York, Harper.
Schabas, William A. (2013): The Universal Declaration of Human Rights – The travaux préparatoires, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Sohn, Louis B. And Thomas Buergenthal (1973): The United Nations as Protector of Human Rights, New York, Contemporary Legal Education Series
SSenyonjo, Manisuli (2011): Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Surrey, Ashgate Publishing Company.
Sudre, Frédéric (2008): Droit européen et international des droits de l´homme, Paris, Presses Universitaires de France
Wells, H. G. (1940): The Rights of Man, Harmondsworth, Penguin
Winter, Jay and Antoine Prost (2013): René Cassin and Human Rights: From the Great War to the Universal Declaration, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
United Nations (1945): Resolution E/20
United Nations (1941): The Atlantic Charter, available at: http://www.un.org/en/sections/history-united-nations-charter/1941-atlantic-charter/
United Nations (1946-947): The Yearbook of the United Nations, New York, United Nations Publications
United Nations (1943): United Nations Conference on Food and Agriculture, Final Act and Section Reports, Washington, Department of State Publication.
United Nations (1993): World Conference on Human Rights, doc. A/RES/48/121.
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1946): Draft Declaration on Human Rights and Letter of Transmittal/Cuban Legation, doc. E/HR/1
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1946): Statement of Essential Human Rights/Presented by the Delegation of Panama, Doc. E/HR/3
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1946): Proposal submitted by the American Federation of Labor to the Secretary General of the United Nations, doc. E/CT.2/2
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1947): Draft Declaration of the International Rights and Duties of Man, formulated by the Inter-American Juridical Committee, submitted by the Delegation of Chile, doc. E/CN.4/2.
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1947): Commission on Human Rights, Drafting Committee, First Session, Summary record of the first meeting, doc. E/CN.4/AC.l/SR.1.
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1947): Commission on Human Rights, Drafting Committee, First Session, Summary record of eighth meeting, doc. E/CN.4/A.C.2/SR.8.
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1947): Commission on Human Rights, Drafting Committee, International Bill of Rights, First Session, Summary record of fourteenth meeting, doc. E/CN.4/A.C.1/SR.14
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1947): Commission on Human Rights, Second Session, Summary Record of Fourtieth Meeting, doc. E/CN.4/A.C.2/SR.40.
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1948): Commission on Human Rights, Third Session, Summary Record of the Sixty-Sixth Meeting, doc. E/CN.4/A.C.2/SR.66.
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1947): Commission on Human Rights, Drafting Committee, Draft Outline of International Bill of Rights, doc. E/CN.4/AC.l/3
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1947): Commission on Human Rights, Drafting Committee, International Bill of Rights Documented Outline. Part 1, doc. E/CN.4/AC.l/3/Add. 1.
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1947): Commission on Human Rights, Drafting Committee, First Session, Report of the Drafting Committee to the Commission on Human Rights, doc. E/CN.4/21.
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1948): Commission on Human Rights, Third Session, Summary Record of the Seventy-First Meeting, doc. E/CN.4/SR.71.
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1948): Commission on Human Rights, Third Session, India and the United Kingdom: Proposed amendments to the draft Declaration on Human Rights, doc. E/CN.4/99.
United Nations, Economic and Social Council (1948): Commission on Human Rights, Third Session, Report of the Sub-Committee consisting of the representatives of France, India and the United Kingdom, on articles 25-26 of the draft Declaration on Human Rights, doc. E/CN.4/127.
United Nations (1941): The Yearbook of the United Nations 1946-1947, The Atlantic Charter. Available at: http://cdn.un.org/unyearbook/yun/chapter_pdf/1946-47YUN/1946-47_P1_SEC1.pdf
