Abstract
This paper examines the shortcomings in the UK government’s Brexit negotiation strategy which reflected Prime Minister Theresa May’s weak political leadership which focused on securing the short-term political survival of her government amidst turbulent and fractious domestic politics, over negotiations with the EU27. Brexit negotiations were poorly planned, and the UK government was woefully unprepared. Brexit also threatened a serious re-opening of old wounds in Northern Ireland, as debate grows around the prospect of a united Ireland inside the EU. UK politics is in turmoil and in a chronic crisis. What route the Brexit saga takes next is uncertain. But the crossroads is approaching – either the UK leaves by 31 January 2020 with no deal or passes the deal the Boris Johnson has negotiated with the EU27. The Brexit process has revealed the weakness of Westminster’s insular politics seemingly incapable of running a modern economy and society. Westminster’s politics are becoming more not less dysfunctional. The phenomenon of British exceptionalism towards the EU is set to take a new dramatic turn, while the UK’s chaotic political divisions will not disappear any time in the foreseeable future. The result of the 12 December 2019 General Election may even complicate the Brexit Conundrum.
References
Bank of England. 2019. “Financial Stability Report.” Financial Policy Committee (45).Search in Google Scholar
BBC News. 2019a. “Brexit Bill ‘in limbo’ as MPs Reject Timetable.” 22 October.Search in Google Scholar
BBC News. 2019b. Brexit: Boris Johnson Defeated as MPs Take Control, 4 September.Search in Google Scholar
BBC News. 2019c. “Liam Fox Criticises Boris Johnson’s Brexit Plan.” 23 June.Search in Google Scholar
BBC News. 2019d. “In Full: Theresa May’s Brexit Delay Request to EU’s Donald Tusk.” 20 March.Search in Google Scholar
BBC News. 2018e. “Brexit: David Davis’ Resignation Letter and May’s Reply in Full.” 9 July.Search in Google Scholar
BBC News. 2018f. “In Full: Theresa May’s Speech on Future UK-EU Relations.” 2 March.Search in Google Scholar
Bloom, Nicholas, Philip Bunn, Scarlet Chen, Paul Mizen, Pawel Smietanka, Greg Thwaites, and Garry Young. 2019. “Brexit and Uncertainty: Insights From the Decision Maker Panel.” Working Paper No. 780, Bank of England Staff.10.2139/ssrn.3335270Search in Google Scholar
Breinlich, Holger, Elsa Leromain, Dennis Novy, and Thomas Sampson. 2019. “Voting with Their Money: Brexit and Outward Investment by UK Firms.” Working Paper No. 775, July, Munich, Germany: CESifo.10.2139/ssrn.3426939Search in Google Scholar
Carroll, Rory. 2018. “Karen Bradley Admits Ignorance of Northern Ireland Politics.” 7 September, Guardian.Search in Google Scholar
Carroll, Rory, and Lisa O’Carroll. 2019. “No Deal Brexit a Political and Economic Threat, Ireland Warns.” The Guardian. 9 July.Search in Google Scholar
Clarke, Harold, Matthew Goodwin, and Paul Whiteley. 2017. Brexit: Why Britain Voted to Leave the European Union, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/9781316584408Search in Google Scholar
Confederation of British Industry. 2019 (July). “What Comes Next? The Business Analysis of No Deal Preparations.” Brexit and EU Negotiations, CBI.Search in Google Scholar
Connelly, Tony. 2019. “No Deal Brexit Could Cause Free Trade Issues for the UK- Varadkar.” RTE News. 24 January.Search in Google Scholar
Cox, Michael, Michael Burleigh, Adrian Guelke, and Paul Gillespie. 2019. Ireland-UK Relations and Northern Ireland After Brexit. 2nd ed. May, LSE IDEAS Strategic Update.Search in Google Scholar
Department for Exiting the European Union. 2018. “The Future Relationship Between the United Kingdom and the European Union.” 12 July.Search in Google Scholar
Doyle, Oran. 2019. “Northern Ireland Border Poll Must Avoid Pitfalls of Brexit Referendum.” LSE Brexit. 1 July.Search in Google Scholar
Elgot, Jessica. 2019. “Brexit: John Bercow Rules Out Third Meaningful Vote on Same Deal.” The Guardian. 18 March.Search in Google Scholar
Emmerson, Carl. 2019. “Christine Farquharson and Paul Johnson, Green Budget.” 8 October.10.1920/re.ifs.2018.0152Search in Google Scholar
European Commission. 2019. “State of Play of Preparations of Contingency Measures for the Withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union.” 12 June.Search in Google Scholar
European Council. 2018. “Agreement on the Withdrawal of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland from the European Union and the European Atomic Energy Community, as Endorsed by Leaders at a Special Meeting of the European Council.” 25 November.Search in Google Scholar
European Council. 2019a. “Special Meeting of the European Council (Art. 50) – Conclusions.” 10 April.Search in Google Scholar
European Council. 2019b. “European Council (Art. 50) Conclusions.” 21 March.Search in Google Scholar
Government of Ireland. 2019. “Preparing for the Withdrawal of the United Kingdom From the European Union.” Contingency Action Plan Update, July.Search in Google Scholar
HM Government. 2017a. “Northern Ireland and Ireland Position Paper.” 16 August.Search in Google Scholar
HM Government. 2017b. “Future Customs Arrangements.” 15 August.Search in Google Scholar
HM Government White Paper. 2017c. “The United Kingdom’s Exit From, and New Partnership With, The European Union.” 2 February.Search in Google Scholar
HM Government White Paper. 2018. “The Future Relationship between the United Kingdom and the European Union.” 12 July.Search in Google Scholar
HM Government. 2019a. “European Union Withdrawal Act (No 2).” 9 September.Search in Google Scholar
HM Government. 2019b. “Technical Advisory Group on Alternative Arrangements to the Backstop Established.” 20 June.Search in Google Scholar
Hopkins, Nick, and Rowena Mason. 2016. “What Theresa May Really Thinks About Brexit Shown in Leaked Recording.” The Guardian, 26 October.Search in Google Scholar
Hughes, Laura, and George Parker. 2019. “MPs Deliver Brexit Day Blow to Theresa May.” Financial Times, 29 March.Search in Google Scholar
IMF. 2019 (April ). “Growth Slowdown, Precarious Recovery.” World Economic Outlook.Search in Google Scholar
Jones, Emily, and Calum Miller. 2019. “The Brexit Impossibility Triangle.” Project Syndicate. 12 April.Search in Google Scholar
Leahy, Pat. 2019. “Irish Times Poll: Northern Ireland Voters Do Not Want DUP-Tory Brexit.” Irish Times. 7 March.Search in Google Scholar
Lynch, Suzanne. 2019. “Hard Border a Roadblock to US-UK Trade Deal, Congressman Says.” Irish Times. 14 March.Search in Google Scholar
May, Theresa. 2017. “The Government’s Negotiating Objectives for Exiting the EU.” Lancaster House, London. 17 January.Search in Google Scholar
McDonald, Dearbhail. 2019. “Irish Peace is too Precious to be Squandered by the Brexit Ultras.” The Guardian. 2 August.Search in Google Scholar
Mctague, Tom. 2019a. “Boris Johnson Meets His Destiny.” The Atlantic. 22 July.Search in Google Scholar
Mctague, Tom. 2019b. “How the UK Lost the Brexit Battle.” Politico. 2 April.Search in Google Scholar
Minford, Patrick. 2019. “Why a US-UK Trade Deal Ought to Mean Us finally Getting Some Sense From Brussels.” Brexit Central. 28 July.Search in Google Scholar
Mudge, Rob. 2019. “Boris Johnson’s Clowning Glory.” Deutsche Welle. 23 July.Search in Google Scholar
Murphy, Mary C. 2018. Europe and Northern Ireland’s Future: Negotiating Brexit’s Unique Case. London: Agenda Publishing.10.2307/j.ctv5cg7x3Search in Google Scholar
NIESR. 2019. “Monetary and Fiscal Options in the Event of a ‘No-Deal’ Brexit” will be Published in the National Institute Economic Review No. 249, August.10.1177/002795011924900103Search in Google Scholar
Office for Budget Responsibility. 2019. “Fiscal Risks Report.” July.Search in Google Scholar
O’Reilly, Seamus. 2019. “Leo Varadkar Looks Like an Adult Because the UK is Acting Like a Spoilt Toddler.” The Guardian. 31 July.Search in Google Scholar
Parker, George. 2019. “Lib Dems Seize Brecon Seat in setback for Boris Johnson.” Financial Times. 2 August.Search in Google Scholar
Parker, George. 2019. “Lib Dems Seize Brecon Seat in setback for Boris Johnson.” Financial Times. 2 August.Search in Google Scholar
Parker, George, and Alex Barker. 2019. “Boris Johnson, Brussels, and the Battle for Brexit.” Financial Times. 26 July.Search in Google Scholar
Partington, Richard. 2019. “Bank of England Warns No-Deal Brexit Could Trigger Economic Shock.” The Guardian. 12 July.Search in Google Scholar
Payne, Sebastian. 2017. “Theresa May and the Election That Got Away.” Financial Times. 8 December.Search in Google Scholar
Pickard, Jim. 2019. “Geoffrey Cox Disputes Boris Johnson’s No Deal Tariff Claim.” Financial Times. 23 June.Search in Google Scholar
Rankin, Jennifer, and Rowena Mason. 2019. “Boris Johnson Gets His Deal and a Slap on the Back in Brussels.” The Guardian. 17 October.Search in Google Scholar
Rogers, Sir Ivan. 2017. “The Inside Story of How David Cameron Drove Britain to Brexit.” Oxford Prospect/Hertford lecture at Hertford College. 24 November.Search in Google Scholar
RTE News. 2019. “Pelosi Warns UK Over Any Weakening of Good Friday Agreement.” 15 April.Search in Google Scholar
Ryan, John. 2016. “A British Exit Would Harm the EU’s Global Credibility – and it Could Rip Apart the Conservatives, too.” LSE Brexit. 26 February.Search in Google Scholar
Sheridan, Gavin. 2019. “How Britain’s Dark History with Ireland Haunts Brexit.” New Statesman. 18 February.Search in Google Scholar
Shipman, Tim. 2016. “All Out War: The Full Story of How Brexit Sank Britain’s Political Class.” London: Harper Collins.Search in Google Scholar
Simons, Ned. 2019. “No-Deal Brexit Would Be ‘Instantaneous Shock’ To UK Economy, Bank of England Warns.” Huffington Post. 1 August.Search in Google Scholar
Smith, David. 2019. “Trump Hails ‘Good Man’ Boris Johnson and Says of UK: They Like Me Over There.” The Guardian. 23 July.Search in Google Scholar
Sparrow, Andrew. 2019a. “Chance of No-Deal Brexit Has ‘Significantly Increased’, Says EU – as it Happened.” The Guardian. 12 March.Search in Google Scholar
Sparrow, Andrew. 2018b. “May Survives Confidence Vote With a Majority of 83 – as it Happened.” The Guardian. 12 December.Search in Google Scholar
Sparrow, Andrew. 2018c. “May Roundly Condemned by MPs After Delaying Brexit Vote to Seek Fresh Backstop Assurances – as it Happened.” The Guardian. 10 December.Search in Google Scholar
Starmer, Keir. 2018. “EU: Future Relationship White Paper.” 12 July.Search in Google Scholar
Stewart, Heather, and Daniel Boffey. 2019. “May Asks for Brexit Extension to 30 June as Tusk Offers up to a Year.” 5 April.Search in Google Scholar
Stewart, Heather, Jessica Elgot, and Peter Walker. 2019. “Theresa May Survives Vote, but Britain Remains in Brexit Deadlock.” The Guardian. 17 January.Search in Google Scholar
The Independent. 2016. “Theresa May’s Keynote Speech at Tory Conference in Full.” 5 October.Search in Google Scholar
The UK in a Changing Europe. 2019. “The Economic Impact of Boris Johnson’s Brexit Proposals.” 13 October.Search in Google Scholar
Thimont Jack, Maddy. 2019. “A New Prime Minister Intent on No Deal Brexit Can’t be Stopped by MPs.” Institute of Government. 22 May.Search in Google Scholar
UK Parliament. 2019. “Commons Votes to Reject Government’s EU Withdrawal Agreement.” 29 March.Search in Google Scholar
Walker, Peter, and Jessica Elgot. 2019. “Sinn Féin: Vote on Irish Reunification Must Follow No-Deal Brexit.” The Guardian. 1 August.Search in Google Scholar
Welle, Deutsche. 2019. “Donald Tusk: EU Agrees to Delay Brexit Until January 31.” 28 October.Search in Google Scholar
Whysall, Alan. 2019. “A Northern Ireland Border Poll.” The Constitution Unit, Department of Political Science, University College London. March.Search in Google Scholar
© 2019 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
