Published online Dec 31, 2018.
https://doi.org/10.11637/kjpa.2018.31.4.121
Analytical Review of the Forensic Anthropological Techniques for Stature Estimation in Korea
Abstract
Stature is one of the unique biological properties of a person, which can be used for identification of the individual. In this regard, statures are estimated for the unknown victims from crimes and disasters. However, the accuracy of estimates may be compromised by inappropriate methodologies and/or practices of stature estimation. Discussed in this study are the methodological issues related to the current practices of forensic anthropological stature estimation in Korea, followed by suggestions to enhance the accuracy of the stature estimates. Summaries of forensic anthropological examinations for 560 skeletal remains, which were conducted at the National Forensic Service (NFS), were reviewed. Mr. Yoo Byung-eun's case is utilized as an example of the NFS's practices. To estimate Mr. Yoo's stature, Trotter's (1970) femur equation was applied even though the fibula equation of a lower standard error was available. In his case report, the standard error associated with the equation (±3.8 cm) was interpreted as an ‘error range’, which gave a hasty impression that the prediction interval is that narrow. Also, stature shrinkage by aging was not considered, so the estimated stature in Mr. Yoo's case report should be regarded as his maximum living stature, rather than his stature-at-death. Lastly, applying Trotter's (1970) White female equations to Korean female remains is likely to underestimate their statures. The anatomical method will enhance the accuracy of stature estimates. However, in cases that the anatomical method is not feasible, the mathematical method based on Korean samples should be considered. Since 1980's, effort has been made to generate stature estimation equations using Korean samples. Applying the equations based on Korean samples to Korean skeletal remains will enhance the accuracy of the stature estimates, which will eventually increase the likelihood of successful identification of the unknowns.
Table 1
Previous research related to stature estimation using Korean samples. Notice that six studies presented equations by which Yoo's stature can be estimated.
Table 2
Stature estimates left femur equation and white female femur equation, followed by the differences between the estimates. Five different lengths of the hypothetic left femora were used.
References
-
National Forensic Service [Internet]. c2018 [cited 2018 Nov 30].Available from: http://www.nfs.go.kr/site/nfs/main.do.
-
-
Kim JH. Some arguments of the decision of admissibility over the scientific. Ilkam law review 2017;37:275–308.Korean.
-
-
Kim DI, Lee SS, Kim YS. Statistical analysis of bone elements excavated from the forensic context. Korean J Phys Anthropol 2010;23:1–8.Korean.
-
-
Jeong GR. In: Understanding the current state of human identification in Korea based on the records of forensic anthropology and forensic odontology analyses. Graduate school of the Catholic university. 2017.Master of Science dissertation. Korean.
-
-
Yang KM, Lee S, Lee HY. In: Autopsy report (2014-H-10839). National Forensic Service; 2014.Korean.
-
-
Trotter M. Estimation of stature from intact long limb bones. In: Stewart TD, editor. Personal identification in mass disasters. National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution: Washington DC; 1970. pp. 71-83.
-
-
Lee SS. In: Forensic odontology report (2014-H-10839). National Forensic Service; 2014.Korean.
-
-
Maijanen H. In: Stature estimation from skeletal elements: general problems and small solutions. University of Oulu, Finland; 2011.Doctoral dissertation.
-
-
Scientific Working Group for Forensic Anthropology (SWGANTH). Stature estimation (revision 1) [Internet]. SWGANTH; c2012 [cited 2018 Nov 30].Available from: http://www.swganth.org.
-
-
Jeong Y, Jantz LM. Caveats in using Trotter and Gleser's (1958) Asian equations for stature estimation. Korean J Phys Anthropol 2016;29:81–91.
-
-
Friedlaender JS, Costa PT Jr, Bosse R, Ellis E, Rhoads JG, Stoudt HW. Longitudinal physique changes among healthy White veterans at Boston. Hum Biol 1977;49:541–558.
-
-
Trotter M, Gleser G. The effect of ageing on stature. J Phys Anthropol 1951;9:311–324.
-
-
Borkan GA, Hults DE, Glynn RJ. Role of longitudinal change and secular trend in age differences in male body dimensions. Hum Biol 1983;55:629–641.
-
-
Cline MG, Meredith KE, Boyer JT, Burrows B. Decline of height with age in adults in a general population sample: estimating maximum height and distinguishing birth cohort effects from actual loss of stature with aging. Hum Biol 1989;61:415–425.
-
-
Giles E. Corrections for age in estimating older adults' stature from long bones. J Forensic Sci 1991;36:898–901.
-
-
Pablos A, Gomez-Olivencia A, Garcia-Perez A, Martinez I, Lorenzo C, Arsuaga JL. From toe to head: use of robust regression methods in stature estimation based on foot remains. Forensic Sci Int 2013;226:299.e1–299.e7.
-
-
Stewart TD, Kerley ER. In: Essentials of forensic anthropology: especially as developed in the United States. Springfield, Illinois: Charles C. Thomas; 1979.
-
-
Pearson K. Mathematical contributions to the theory of evolution. V. on the reconstruction of the stature of prehistoric races. Philos Trans R Soc Lond A 1899;192:169–244.
-
-
Fully G. Une nouvelle méthod de détermination de la taille. Annales de Médicine Légale, Criminologie, Police Scientifique et Toxicologie 1956;36:266–273.French.
-
-
Jeong Y, Jantz LM. Developing Korean-specific equations of stature estimation. Forensic Sci Int 2016;260:105.e1–105.e11.
-
-
Raxter MH, Ruff C, Azab A, Erfan M, Soliman M, El-Sawaf A. Stature estimation in ancient Egyptians: a new technique based on anatomical reconstruction of stature. Am J Phys Anthropl 2008;136:147–155.
-
-
Auerbach BM, Ruff C. Stature estimation formulae for indigenous North American populations. Am J Phys Anthropol 2010;141:190–207.
-
-
Dayal MR, Steyn M, Kuykendall KL. Stature estimation from bones of South African Whites. South African J Sci 2008;104:124–128.
-
-
Bidmos MA, Manger PR. New soft tissue correction factors for stature estimation: results from magnetic resonance imaging. Forensic Sci Int 2012;214:212.e1–212.e7.
-
-
Ruff C, Raxter MH, Auerbach BM. New soft tissue correction factors for stature estimation: results from magnetic resonance imaging. Forensic Sci Int 2012;214:212.e1–212.e7.
-
-
Kim KW, Kim SL, Ko HS, Oh WJ, Kim DH, Kim DY, et al. A study for the correlation between the body height and the maximum femoral length in the normal adult Korean. The Journal of the Korean orthopaedic association 1986;21:197–201.Korean.
-
-
Lee JH, Kim YS, Lee UY, Park DK, Jeong YK, Lee NS, et al. Stature estimation from partial measurements and maximum length of lower limb bones in Koreans. Australian J Forensic Sci 2014;46:330–338.
-
-
Terry RJ. On measuring and photographing the cadaver. Am J Phys Anthropol 1940;26:433–447.
-
-
Manouvrier L. Determination de la taille d'après les grands os des membres. Revue mensuelle de l'École d'anthropologie de Paris 1892;2:227–233.French.
-
-
Ruff C. Morphological adaptation to climate in modern and fossil hominids. Am J Phys Anthropol 1994;37 Suppl 19:S65–107.
-