Abstract
This article compares the mayoralties of the first two directly elected Mayors of London, Ken Livingstone and Boris Johnson. The position offers a commanding electoral platform, but few direct powers to lead a city widely regarded as ‘ungovernable’ (Travers 2004). The two mayors had some obvious points of comparison: both were party rebels, mavericks and skilled media operators. Both also used publicity to make up for weak powers, but courted controversy and faced charges of corruption and cronyism. Utilising Hambleton and Sweeting (2004), this article compares their mayoralties in terms of vision, leadership style and policies. Livingstone had a powerful vision that translated into clear policy aims, while Johnson's time as Mayor was more cautious, shaped by a desire for higher office. In terms of style, Livingstone built coalitions but proved divisive, whereas Johnson retained remarkable levels of popularity. Where Livingstone bought experience and skill, Johnson delegated. In policy terms, the two Mayors found themselves pushed by their institutional powers towards transport and planning while struggling with deeper issues such as housing. Livingstone introduced the radical congestion charge and a series of symbolic policies. Johnson was far more modest, championing cycling, the 2012 Olympics and avoiding difficult decisions. The two used their office to negotiate, but also challenge, central government. Livingstone’s rebel mayoralty was a platform for personalised change, but Johnson’s one was for personal ambition.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Acuto, M. 2013. City leadership in global governance. Global Governance 19 (2): 481–498.
Ayres, S. 2014. Place-based leadership: Reflections on scale, agency and theory. Regional Studies, Regional Science 1 (1): 21–24.
BBC. 2013. Has London’s congestion charge worked? http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-21451245. Accessed 13 April 2017.
BDonline. 2016. Boris Johnson: Assessing his legacy. http://www.bdonline.co.uk/boris-johnson-assessing-his-legacy/5081178.article. Accessed 13 April 2016.
Beer, A., and T. Clower. 2014. Mobilizing leadership in cities and regions. Regional Studies, Regional Science 1 (1): 5–20.
Blakeley, G., and B. Evans. 2017. To gain legitimacy new metro-mayors must improve turnout and diversity. http://speri.dept.shef.ac.uk/2017/05/11/to-gain-legitimacy-new-metro-mayors-must-improve-turnout-and-diversity. Accessed 19 May 2017.
Blick, A., and P. Dunleavy. 2017. Audit 2017: How democratic is the devolved government of London? http://www.democraticaudit.com/2017/06/22/audit-2017-how-democratic-is-the-devolved-government-of-london/. Accessed 19 November 2017.
Bogdanor, V. 2017. The case for new power. In Neo-localism: Rediscovering the nation, ed. L. Booth-Smith. London: Localis.
Budd, L., and A. Sancino. 2016. A framework for city leadership in multilevel governance settings: The comparative contexts of Italy and the UK. Regional Studies, Regional Science’. 3 (1): 129–145.
Carmona, M. 2012. The London way: The politics of London’s strategic design. Architectural Design 82 (1): 36–43.
Carvel, J. 1984. Citizen Ken. London: Chatto and Windus.
Centre for Cities. 2017. Mayoral elections briefing. http://www.centreforcities.org/event/mayoral-elections-press-briefing. Accessed 19 May 2017.
Centre for Cities. 2017. 5 reflections on the metro mayor manifestos. http://www.centreforcities.org/blog/5-reflections-metro-mayor-manifestos/. Accessed 17 November 2017.
Copus, C. 2004. Directly elected mayors: A tonic for local governance or old wine in new bottles? Local Government Studies 30 (4): 576–588.
Copus, C. 2009. English elected mayors: Developing a new form of local political leadership in England or moving on in the same old style. In Local political leadership in Europe: Town chief, city boss or loco president, ed. H. Reynaert, K. Steyvers, P. Delwit, and J. Pilet, 29–57. Vanden Broele: Brugge.
Copus, C. 2011. Elected mayors in English local government: Mayoral leadership and creating a new political dynamic. Lex Localis-Journal of Local Self Government 9 (4): 335–351.
Copus, C. 2013. Leading the localities: Executive mayors in English local governance. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Copus, C., A. Iglesias, M. Hacek, M. Illner, and A. Lidström. 2016. Have mayors will travel: Trends and developments in the direct election of the mayor: A five-nation study. In Local public sector reforms in times of crisis, ed. S. Kuhlmann, and G. Bouckaert, 301–315. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Crines, A.S. 2013. Why did Boris Johnson win the 2012 mayoral election? Public Policy and Administration Research 3 (9): 1–7.
Dommett, K., and M. Flinders. 2014. The politics and management of public expectations: Gaps, vacuums, clouding and the 2012 mayoral referenda. British Politics 9 (1): 29–50.
Dommett, K. 2015. Clown prince or party saviour? Exploring the oratory of Boris Johnson. In Orators in conservative party politics, ed. R. Hayton, and A. Crines, 166–181. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Edwards, G., and J. Isaby. 2008. Boris v. Ken: How Boris Johnson won London. London: Politico’s.
Elcock, H., and J. Fenwick. 2007. Comparing elected mayors. International Journal of Public Sector Management 20 (3): 226–238.
Evening Standard. 2007. Mayor attacks councils for ‘lack of affordable housing', 12 November 2007.
Fenwick, J., and H. Elcock. 2014. Elected mayors: Leading locally? Local Government Studies 40 (4): 581–599.
Financial Times. 2014. UK airports ‘Boris Island’ airport plan to be sunk by aviation commission, 1 September 2014.
Financial Times. 2016a. Farewell to a mayor long on charisma, short on detail, 29 April 2016.
Financial Times. 2016b. Zac v Sadiq: the race to become London’s next mayor. DATE.
Financial Times. 2017. A tough start tests the mettle of London mayor Sadiq Khan, 3 Oct 2017.
Fletcher, M. 2017. The joke’s over—how Boris Johnson is damaging Britain’s global stature. https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/uk/2017/11/joke-s-over-how-boris-johnson-damaging-britain-s-global-stature. Accessed 4 November 2017.
Gains, F., S. Greasley, P. John, and G. Stoker. 2007. Does leadership matter?. London: DCLG.
Gimson, A. 2016. Boris: The adventures of Boris Johnson. London: Simon and Schuster.
Gordon, I.R., and T. Travers. 2010. London: Planning the ungovernable city. City, Culture and Society 1 (2): 49–55.
Greasley, S., and G. Stoker. 2008. Mayors and urban governance: Developing a facilitative leadership style. Public Administration Review 68 (4): 722–730.
Hambleton, R. 2017a. Directly elected mayors: A route to progressive urban leadership? In Directly elected mayors in urban governance: Impact and practice, ed. D. Sweeting, 243–263. Bristol: Policy Press.
Hambleton, R. 2017b. We’re in danger of creating featherweight mayors, Local Government Chronicle, 6 May 2017.
Hambleton, R. 2015a. Place-based collaboration: Leadership for a changing world. Administration 63 (3): 5–25.
Hambleton, R. 2015b. Leading the inclusive city: Place-based innovation for a bounded planet. Bristol: Policy Press.
Hambleton, R., and D. Sweeting. 2004. U.S.-style leadership for English local government? Public Administration Review 64 (4): 474–488.
HC213. 2013. House of commons communities and local government committee: Post-legislative scrutiny of the Greater London Authority Act 2007 and the London Assembly. London: TSO.
Headlam, N., and P. Hepburn. 2017. What a difference a mayor makes: A case study of the Liverpool Mayoral model. Local Government Studies 43 (5): 731–751.
Hern, A. 2013. Boris’s vanity projects. http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2013/08/boriss-vanity-projects. Accessed 17 October 2017.
HMG. 2013. Government response to the communities and local government select committee report: Post-legislative scrutiny of the greater London Authority Act 2007 and the London assembly. London: TSO.
Holman, N., and A. Thornley. 2011. The reversal of strategic planning in London: The Boris effect with a focus on sustainability. Observatoire de la Société Britannique 11: 145–159.
Holman, N., and A. Thornley. 2015. Backlash in the London suburbs: The local-strategic tension in multilevel governance. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 33 (3): 496–511.
Hosken, A. 2008. Ken: The ups and downs of Ken Livingstone. London: Arcadia Books.
House of Commons Library. 2017. Metro-mayors and devolution deals. https://secondreading.uk/elections/metro-mayors-and-devolution-deals/. Accessed 19 October 2017.
House of Commons Library. 2016. Directly-elected mayors. London: TSO.
Huffington Post. 2017. What next for Ken Livingstone and Labour? 4 April 2017.
Independent. 2016. London mayoral elections 2016: An analysis of Boris Johnson’s record after eight years in office. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/london-mayoral-elections-2016-an-analysis-of-boris-johnson-s-record-after-eight-years-in-office-a7013971.html.
IPSOS/Mori. 2000. London’s choice poll. https://www.ipsos-mori.com/researchpublications/researcharchive/1491/Londons-Choice-Poll.aspx.
IPSOS/Mori. 2002. London survey shows increase in satisfaction with mayor’s performance. https://www.ipsos-mori.com/researchpublications/researcharchive/1269/London-Survey-shows-increase-in-satisfaction-with-Mayors-performance.aspx.
IPSOS/Mori. 2003. London mayor ratings. https://www.ipsos-mori.com/researchpublications/researcharchive/818/London-Mayor-Ratings.aspx.
IPSOS/Mori. 2006. Londoners’ attitudes towards the mayor and other issues. https://www.ipsos-mori.com/researchpublications/researcharchive/301/Londoners-Attitudes-Towards-The-Mayor-And-Other-Issues.aspx.
Johnson, J. 2008. The perfect political storm. The Political Quarterly 79 (3): 434–437.
Kenworthy, J. 2015. Affordable housing delivery in London: An analysis. http://www.bartonwillmore.co.uk/Knowledge/Blogs/Affordable-Housing-Delivery-in-London-an-analysis. Accessed 17 October 2017.
Leach, S., and D. Wilson. 2000. Local political leadership. Bristol: Bristol University Press.
Leape, J. 2006. The London congestion charge. Journal of Economic Perspectives 20 (4): 157–176.
Livingstone, K. 2004. The challenge of driving through change: Introducing congestion charging in central London. Planning Theory & Practice 5 (4): 490–498.
Livingstone, K. 2011. You can’t say that: Memoirs. London: Faber & Faber.
London Finance Commission. 2013. Raising the capital: The report of the London Finance Commission. London: LFC.
Mackie, P. 2005. The London congestion charge: A tentative economic proposal: A comment on the paper by Prud’homme and Bocajero. Transport Policy 12: 288–290.
Pimlott, B., and N. Rao. 2004. Governing London. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Prospect. 2016. Big question: Is the London housing crisis Boris Johnson’s fault? http://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/politics/big-question-is-the-london-housing-crisis-boris-johnsons-fault. Accessed 17 October 2017.
Purnell, S. 2012. Just Boris: A tale of blond ambition-a biography of Boris Johnson. London: Aurum Press Limited.
Rallings, C., M. Thrasher, and D. Cowling. 2014. Mayoral referendums and elections revisited. British Politics 9 (1): 2–28.
Shipman, T. 2016. All out war: The full story of how Brexit Sank Britain’s political class. London: William Collins.
Squires, P. 2009. The knife crime ‘epidemic’ and British politics. British Politics 4 (1): 127–157.
Sweeting, D. 2002. Leadership in urban governance: The mayor of London. Local Government Studies 28 (1): 3–20.
Sweeting, D. 2003. How strong is the mayor of London? Policy and Politics 31 (4): 465–478.
Sweeting, D. 2017. Introduction: directly elected mayors in urban governance. In Directly elected mayors in urban governance: Impact and practice, ed. D. Sweeting, 1–16. Bristol: Policy Press.
Sweeting, D., and R. Hambleton. 2015. Analysing change in urban political leadership: Does introducing a mayoral form of governance make a difference? In Urban Affairs Association annual conference, Miami, Florida, USA, April 8–11 2015. http://eprints.uwe.ac.uk/27666.
Syrett, S. 2006. Governing the global city: Economic challenges and London’s new institutional arrangements. Local Government Studies 32 (3): 293–309.
Terry, C. 2017. Who’s going to hold the new metro mayors to account? http://www.democraticaudit.com/2017/05/03/whos-going-to-hold-the-new-metro-mayors-to-account/. Accessed 17 October 2017.
Travers, T. 2002. Decentralization London-style: The GLA and London governance. Regional Studies 36 (7): 779–788.
Travers, T. 2004. The politics of London: Governing an ungovernable city. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Travers, T. 2008. The greater London authority, 2000 to 2008. In London government 50 years of debate: the contribution of LSE’s Greater London group ed. Kochan, B., 55–69. LSE London Development Workshops. London School of Economics and Political Science, LSE: London.
Travers, T. 2016. Next London Mayor can play key role in reversing decades of centralisation, 22 March 2016. http://www.centreforcities.org/blog/next-london-mayor-can-play-key-role-in-reversing-decades-of-centralisation/. Accessed 9 January 2018.
Travers, T., and C. Whitehead. 2010. A mayor and assembly for London: 10 years on. HEIF Paper: London School of Economics.
Whitehead, C. 2010. London’s housing: Surviving the crisis? In London: Coping with austerity: Review of housing, planning and public policy issues, eds. Scanlon, K. and Kochan, B., 83–97. London: London School of Economics.
Wilson, D., and C. Game. 2011. Local government in the United Kingdom. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Wood, M., J. Corbett, and M. Flinders. 2016. Just like us: Everyday celebrity politicians and the pursuit of popularity in an age of anti-politics. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations 18 (3): 581–598.
Yates, C. 2010. Spinning, spooning and the seductions of flirtatious masculinity in contemporary politics. Subjectivity 3 (3): 282–302.
Yates, C. 2012. Fatherhood, political culture and the new politics. Psychoanalysis 17 (2): 204–221.
Yates, C. 2014. Political sport and the sport of politics: A psycho-cultural study of play the antics of Boris Johnson and the London 2012 Olympic Games. Media and the inner world: Psycho-cultural approaches to emotion, media and popular culture, 34–50. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
YouGov. 2016. Mayor Boris: The public verdict. https://yougov.co.uk/news/2016/05/05/mayor-boris-public-verdict. Accessed 7 March 2017.
YouGov/Queen Mary University. 2017. London survey results. http://www.qmul.ac.uk/media/news/items/hss/200031.html. Accessed 19 October 2017.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Worthy, B., Bennister, M. & Stafford, M. Rebels Leading London: the mayoralties of Ken Livingstone and Boris Johnson compared. Br Polit 14, 23–43 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41293-017-0069-1
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41293-017-0069-1