Issue 4, 1997

Molecular mechanics calculations on imine and mixed-ligand systems of CoIII, NiII and CuII

Abstract

The force field for the cellular ligand field stabilisation energy/molecular mechanics (CLFSE/MM) method has been applied to 28 transition-metal complexes. Computed and experimental structures are compared for 12 ML x Cl 6- x species (M = Co III or Ni II ; L = amine donor; x = 6 or 4), 12 MA x B 6- x compounds (M = Ni II or Cu II ; A = imine, B = amine; x = 6, 4 or 3), one five-co-ordinate copper(II) imine–amine complex and three four-co-ordinate copper(II) imine and imine–amine molecules. For π-bonding ligands a stronger donor interaction is associated with a larger positive value of the CLF e π parameter but, due to the use of a crystal field type barycentre, the CLFSE actually goes up. The CLFSE thus has the wrong form for treating the π contributions to bond stretching and distance-dependent e π parameters are inappropriate. However, the desired bond lengths can be obtained by modifying the Morse function and e σ terms. The π contribution to the L–M–L angle bending operates in the correct sense but is small and can also be accommodated by altering the magnitude of e σ . For asymmetric π interactions (e πx ≠ e πy ) there is no effect on the M–L torsional potential for low-spin d 6, high-spin d 8 and d 9 configurations where the π-symmetry d orbitals are completely filled. Hence, only the σ-bonding contributions to the CLFSE are retained. This approach still gives good agreement with experimental structures, even for formally π-bonding ligands, with average root-mean-square errors in M–L lengths and L–M–L angles of about 0.02 Å and 3° for Co III , Ni II and four co-ordinate Cu II , excluding [Cu(bipy) 2 ] 2+ (bipy = 2,2′-bipyridyl), and about 0.05 Å and 4° respectively for six-co-ordinate Cu II , excluding [Cu(terpy) 2 ] 2+ (terpy = 2,2′∶6′,2″ -terpyridyl). The subtle interplay between the axial Ni–Cl and equatorial Ni–N distances in trans-[NiN 4 Cl 2 ] macrocyclic species is reproduced for the first time by an MM-based approach. However, the model appears to give relatively poor agreement for [Cu(bipy) 2 (NH 3 )] 2+ , [Cu(terpy) 2 ] 2+ and [Cu(bipy) 2 ] 2+ . For the five-co-ordinate complex this is due to the intrinsic plasticity of five-co-ordinate copper(II) species. The energy difference between the limiting trigonal-bipyramidal and square-pyramidal geometries is only a few kcal mol -1 . For [Cu(terpy) 2 ] 2+ the limiting geometries of tetragonally elongated and compressed octahedra are also within a few kcal mol -1 although the present set of parameters overestimates the ligand contribution and predicts a compressed geometry. The calculated structure of [Cu(bipy) 2 ] 2+ is too flat but for four-co-ordinate species it is shown, using [CuCl 4 ] 2- as an example, that there are several ways to induce a tetrahedral distortion. The most satisfactory method is to include charges on Cu and the ligand donors whereupon the geometries of [CuCl 4 ] 2- and [Cu(bipy) 2 ] 2+ distort to the required flattened tetrahedral structures.

Article information

Article type
Paper

J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1997, 537-546

Molecular mechanics calculations on imine and mixed-ligand systems of CoIII, NiII and CuII

R. J. Deeth and V. J. Paget, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1997, 537 DOI: 10.1039/A606381K

To request permission to reproduce material from this article, please go to the Copyright Clearance Center request page.

If you are an author contributing to an RSC publication, you do not need to request permission provided correct acknowledgement is given.

If you are the author of this article, you do not need to request permission to reproduce figures and diagrams provided correct acknowledgement is given. If you want to reproduce the whole article in a third-party publication (excluding your thesis/dissertation for which permission is not required) please go to the Copyright Clearance Center request page.

Read more about how to correctly acknowledge RSC content.

Spotlight

Advertisements