Abstract
The uncertainties surrounding global climate change provide ample evidence, if any were necessary, of the need for a whole-system view of the Earth. Arguably the most visible – and controversial – attempt to understand Earth as a system has been Lovelock's Gaia theory. Gaia has been a fruitful hypothesis generator, and has prompted many intriguing conjectures about how biological processes might contribute to planetary-scale regulation of atmospheric chemistry and climate. In many important cases, however, these conjectures are refuted by the available data. For example, Gaia theory predicts that the composition of the atmosphere should be tightly regulated by biological processes, but rates of carbon uptake into the biosphere have accelerated by only about 2% in response to the 35% rise in atmospheric CO2 since pre-industrial times. Gaia theory would predict that atmospheric CO2 should be more sensitively regulated by terrestrial ecosystem uptake (which is biologically mediated) than by ocean uptake (which is primarily abiotic), but both processes are about equally insensitive to atmospheric CO2 levels. Gaia theory predicts that biological feedbacks should make the Earth system less sensitive to perturbation, but the best available data suggest that the net effect of biologically mediated feedbacks will be to amplify, not reduce, the Earth system's sensitivity to anthropogenic climate change. Gaia theory predicts that biological by-products in the atmosphere should act as planetary climate regulators, but the Vostok ice core indicates that CO2, CH4, and dimethyl sulfide – all biological by-products – function to make the Earth warmer when it is warm, and colder when it is cold. Gaia theory predicts that biological feedbacks should regulate Earth's climate over the long term, but peaks in paleotemperature correspond to peaks in paleo-CO2 in records stretching back to the Permian; thus if CO2 is biologically regulated as part of a global thermostat, that thermostat has been hooked up backwards for at least the past 300 million years. Gaia theory predicts that organisms alter their environment to their own benefit, but throughout most of the surface ocean (comprising more than half of the globe), nutrient depletion by plankton has almost created a biological desert, and is kept in check only by the nutrient starvation of the plankton themselves. Lastly, where organisms enhance their environment for themselves, they create positive feedback; thus Gaia theory's two central principles – first, that organisms stabilize their environment, and second, that organisms alter their environment in ways that benefit them – are mutually inconsistent with one another. These examples suggest that the further development of Gaia theory will require more deliberate comparison of theory and data.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arens, N. C. and Jahren, A. H.: 2000, ‘Carbon Isotope Excursion in Atmospheric CO2 at the Cretaceous-Tertiary Boundary: Evidence from Terrestrial Sediments’, Palaios 15, 314–322.
Charlson, R. J., Lovelock, J. E., Andreae, M. O., and Warren, S. G.: 1987, ‘Oceanic Phytoplankton, Atmospheric Sulphur, Cloud Albedo and Climate’, Nature 326, 655–661.
Cox, P. M., Betts, R. A., Jones, C. D., Spall, S. A., and Totterdell, I. J.: 2000, ‘Acceleration of Global Warming Due to Carbon-cycle Feedbacks in a Coupled Climate Model’, Nature 408, 184–187.
Goodnight, C. J. and Stevens, L.: 1997, ‘Experimental Studies of Group Selection: What Do They Tell Us about Group Selection in Nature?’, Amer. Nat. 150, S59–S79.
Gorham, E.: 1991, ‘Biogeochemistry–its Origins and Development’, Biogeochemistry 13, 199–239.
Hamilton, W. D.: 1995, ‘Ecology in the Large: Gaia and Ghengis Khan’, J. Appl. Ecol. 32, 451–453.
Hardin, G.: 1968, ‘The Tragedy of the Commons’, Science 162, 1243–1248.
Hutchinson, G. E.: 1950, ‘Survey of Contemporary Knowledge of Biogeochemistry.-3. The Biogeochemistry of Vertebrate Excretion’, Bull. Amer. Museum Nat. Hist. 96, 1–553.
Hutchinson, G. E.: 1954, ‘The Biogeochemistry of the Terrestrial Atmosphere’, in Kuiper, G. P. (ed.), The Earth as a Planet, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 371–433.
Jahren, A. H., Arens, N. C., Sarmiento, G., Guerrero, J., and Amundson, R.: 2001, ‘Terrestrial Record of Methane Hydrate Dissociation in the Early Cretaceous’, Geology 29, 159–162.
Kamen, M. D.: 1946, ‘Survey of Existing Knowledge of Biogeochemistry. 1. Isotopic Phenomena in Biogeochemistry’, Bull. Amer. Museum Nat. Hist. 87, 110–138.
Kirchner, J. W.: 1989, ‘The Gaia Hypothesis: Can it Be Tested?’, Rev. Geophys. 27, 223–235.
Kirchner, J. W.: 1990, ‘Gaia Metaphor Unfalsifiable’, Nature 345, 470.
Kirchner, J. W.: 1991, ‘The Gaia Hypotheses: Are They Testable? Are They Useful?’, in Schneider, S. H. and Boston, P. J. (ed.), Scientists on Gaia, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, pp. 38–46.
Kirchner, J. W.: 2002, ‘The Gaia Hypothesis: Fact, Theory, and Wishful Thinking’, Clim. Change 52, 391–408.
Kirchner, J.W. and Roy, B. A.: 1999, ‘The Evolutionary Advantages of Dying Young: Epidemiological Implications of Longevity in Metapopulations’, Amer. Nat. 154, 140–159.
Kleidon, A.: 2002, ‘Testing the Effect of Life on Earth's Functioning: How Gaian is the Earth System?’, Clim. Change 52, 383–389.
Lashof, D. A.: 1989, ‘The Dynamic Greenhouse: Feedback Processes that May Influence Future Concentrations of Atmospheric Trace Gases in Climatic Change’, Clim. Change 14, 213–242.
Lashof, D. A., DeAngelo, B. J., Saleska, S. R., and Harte, J.: 1997, ‘Terrestrial Ecosystem Feedbacks to Global Climate Change’, Ann. Rev. Energy Environ. 22, 75–118.
Legrand, M., Feniet-Saigne, C., Saltzman, E. S., Germain, C., Barkov, N. I., and Petrov, V. N.: 1991, ‘Ice-core Record of Oceanic Emissions of Dimethylsulphide during the Last Climate Cycle’, Nature 350, 144–146.
Legrand, M. R., Delmas, R. J., and Charlson, R. J.: 1988, ‘Climate Forcing Implications from Vostok Ice-core Sulphate Data’, Nature 334, 418–420.
Lenton, T. M.: 1998, ‘Gaia and Natural Selection’, Nature 394, 439–447.
Lenton, T. M.: 2001, ‘The Role of Land Plants, Phosphorus Weathering and Fire in the Rise and Regulation of Atmospheric Oxygen’, Global Change Biol. 7, 613–629.
Lenton, T. M.: 2002, ‘Testing Gaia: The Effect of Life on Earth's Habitability and Regulation’, Clim. Change 52, 409–422.
Lenton, T. M. and von Bloh, W.: 2001, ‘Biotic Feedback Extends the Life Span of the Biosphere’, Geophys. Res. Lett. 28, 1715–1718.
Lenton, T. M. and Watson, A. J.: 2000, ‘Redfield Revisited 1. Regulation of Nitrate, Phosphate, and Oxygen in the Ocean’, Global Biogeochem. Cycles 14, 225–248.
Lenton, T. M. and Wilkinson, D. M.: 2003, ‘Developing the Gaia Theory: A Response to the Criticisms of Kirchner and Volk’, Clim. Change 58, this issue.
Lovelock, J. E.: 1983, ‘Daisy World: A Cybernetic Proof of the Gaia Hypothesis’, Coevolution Quarterly 38, 66–72.
Lovelock, J. E.: 1986, ‘Geophysiology: A New Look at Earth Science’, in Dickinson, R. E. (ed.), The Geophysiology of Amazonia: Vegetation and Climate Interactions, Wiley, New York, pp. 11–23.
Lovelock, J. E.: 1988, The Ages of Gaia, W. W. Norton, New York.
Lovelock, J. E.: 1990, ‘Hands Up for the Gaia Hypothesis’, Nature 344, 100–102.
Lovelock, J. E.: 1991, Gaia–The Practical Science of Planetary Medicine, Gaia Books, London.
Lovelock, J. E.: 1995, The Ages of Gaia, W. W. Norton, New York.
Lovelock, J. E.: 2000, Homage to Gaia: The Life of an Independent Scientist, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Lovelock, J. E. and Kump, L. R.: 1994, ‘Failure of Climate Regulation in a Geophysiological Model’, Nature 369, 732–734.
Lovelock, J. E. and Margulis, L.: 1974, ‘Atmospheric Homeostasis by and for the Biosphere: The Gaia Hypothesis’, Tellus 26, 2–9.
Lovelock, J. E. and Watson, A. J.: 1982, ‘The Regulation of Carbon Dioxide and Climate: Gaia or Geochemistry’, Planet. Space Sci. 30, 795–802.
Malthus, T. R.: 1798, An Essay on the Principle of Population as it Affects the Future Improvement of Society with Remarks on the Speculations of Mr. Godwin, M. Condorcet and Other Writers, J. Johnson, London.
Petit, J. R., Jouzel, J., Raynaud, D., Barkov, N. I., Barnola, J.-M., Basile, I., Bender, M., Chappellaz, J., Davisk, M., Delaygue, G., Delmotte, M., Kotlyakov, V. M., Legrand, M., Lipenkov, V. Y., Lorius, C., Pepin, L., Ritz, C., Saltzmank, E., and Stievenard, M.: 1999, ‘Climate and Atmospheric History of the Past 420,000 Years from the Vostok Ice Core, Antarctica’, Nature 399, 429–436.
Popper, K. R.: 1963, Conjectures and Refutations; The Growth of Scientific Knowledge, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
Retallack, G. J.: 2002, ‘Carbon Dioxide and Climate over the Past 300 Myr’, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London Series A 360, 659–673.
Schimel, D. S., House, J. I., Hibbard, K. A., Bousquet, P., Ciais, P., Peylin, P., Braswell, B. H., Apps, M. J., Baker, D., Bondeau, A., Canadell, J., Churkina, G., Cramer, W., Denning, A. S., Field, C. B., Friedlingstein, P., Goodale, C., Heimann, M., Houghton, R. A., Melillo, J. M., Moore, B., Murdiyarso, D., Noble, I., Pacala, S. W., Prentice, I. C., Raupach, M. R., Rayner, P. J., Scholes, R. J., Steffen, W. L., and Wirth, C.: 2001, ‘Recent Patterns and Mechanisms of Carbon Exchange by Terrestrial Ecosystems’, Nature 414, 169–172.
Schlesinger, W. H.: 1997, Biogeochemistry: An Analysis of Global Change, Academic Press, San Diego.
Schneider, S. H.: 2001, ‘A Goddess of Earth or the Imagination of a Man?’, Science 291, 1906–1907.
Sober, E. and Wilson, D. S.: 1998, Unto Others: The Evolution and Psychology of Unselfish Behavior, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Volk, T.: 1998, Gaia's Body: Toward a Physiology of Earth, Copernicus, New York.
Volk, T.: 2002, ‘Toward a Future for Gaia Theory’, Clim. Change 52, 423–430.
Watson, A. J. and Liss, P. S.: 1998, ‘Marine Biological Controls on Climate Via the Carbon and Sulphur Geochemical Cycles’, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London, Series B 353, 41–51.
Watson, A. J. and Lovelock, J. E.: 1983, ‘Biological Homeostasis of the Global Environment: The Parable of Daisyworld’, Tellus, Series B: Chem. Phys. Meterol. 35, 284–289.
Woodwell, G. M., Mackenzie, F. T., Houghton, R. A., Apps, M., Gorham, E., and Davidson, E.: 1998, ‘Biotic Feedbacks in the Warming of the Earth’, Clim. Change 40, 495–518.
Zachos, J., Pagani, M., Sloan, L., Thomas, E., and Billups, K.: 2001, ‘Trends, Rhythms, and Aberrations in Global Climate 65 Ma to Present’, Science 292, 686–693.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kirchner, J.W. The Gaia Hypothesis: Conjectures and Refutations. Climatic Change 58, 21–45 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1023494111532
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1023494111532