Abstract
In this study, historic data from airborne campaigns more or less coincident with in situ sampling points in four different coastal areas were used to test the validity and robustness of semi-empirical coastal colour algorithms developed during a separate Dutch coastal water research program. Three different remote sensing devices were used for this exercise which could all simulate the spectral bands from either the satellite borne SeaWiFS or MERIS sensor. An inter-comparison is made between the results after applying SeaWiFS and MERIS ratio or multiple regression algorithms for total suspended matter and chlorophyll-a concentrations. For total suspended matter the SeaWiFS ratio algorithm generated the most consistent and reproducible results and gave good estimates within the measured range. The ratio and multiple regression algorithms for chlorophyll resulted in uncertainties; in particular the MERIS algorithms gave poor coherence. Although no specific algorithm was found that uniformly generates good estimates compared to the in situ data, one key observation of the study has been the unreliability of single point measurements of water quality parameters from a ship to validate a spatially detailed or track data set. This problem is particularly apparent in the dynamically active and spatially varied coastal zone where rapid changes in particulate and dissolved matter can occur within small time scales. Within this study no thorough validation could be made due to the limited number of quasi-simultaneously collected ship and airborne data. The setup of a dedicated validation experiment to test the validity of coastal colour algorithms is emphasized. The viable way forward is in long term measurements of parameters from buoys or repeat transects.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Althuis IJA, Vogelzang J, Wernand MR, Shimwell SJ, Gieskes WWC, Warnock RE, Kromkamp J, Wouts R and Zevenboom W (1996a) On the colour of Case 2 waters: Particulate Matter North Sea. Part I: Results and conclusions. Beleids Commissie Remote Sensing Report, NRSP-2, 95-21A, p. 163
Althuis IJA, Vogelzang J, Wernand MR, Shimwell SJ, Gieskes WWC, Warnock RE, Kromkamp J, Wouts R and Zevenboom W (1996b) On the colour of Case 2 waters: Particulate Matter North Sea. Part II: Instruments, methods and database. Beleids Commissie Remote Sensing Report, NRSP-2, 95-21B p. 73
Austin RW (1980) Gulf of Mexico, ocean colour surface-truth measurements. Boundary-Layer Meteor 18: 269-285
Dekker AG, Malthus TJ, Wijnen MM and Seyan E (1992) Remote sensing as a tool for assessing water quality in Loosdrecht lakes. Hydrobiologia 233: 137-159
Fischer J (1985) On the information content of multi-spectral radiance measurements over an ocean. Int J Remote Sensing 6(5).
Gitelson AA, Garbuzov G, Szilagyi F, Mittenzwey KH, Karnieli A and Kaiser A (1993) Quantitative remote sensing methods for real-time monitoring of inland waters quality. Int J Remote Sensing 14(7): 1269-1295
Gieskes WWC and Kraay GW (1975) The phytoplankton spring bloom in Dutch coastal waters of the North Sea. Neth J Sea Res 9(2): 166-169
Gieskes WWC and Kraay GW (1986) Analysis of phyto-plankton pigments by HPLC before, during, and after mass occurrence of the microflagellate corybellus during the spring bloom in the open North Sea in 1983. Marin Biol 92: 45-52
Gower JFR, Lin S and Borstad G (1984) The information content of different optical spectral ranges for remote chlorophyll estimation in coastal waters. Int J Remote Sensing 5(2): 349-364
Hinton JC (1991) Application of eigenvector analysis to remote sensing of coastal water quality. Int J Remote Sensing 12(7): 1441-1460
Kirk JTO (1994) Light and photosynthesis in aquatic ecosystems. Cambridge University Press, 2nd edition, p. 508
Kromkamp J and Peene J (1995) Possibility of net phytoplankton primary production in the turbid Schelde Estuary (SW Netherlands). Mar Ecol Progr Series 121: 249-259
Mantoura RFC and Llewellyn CA (1983) The rapid determination of algal chlorophyll and carotenoid pigments and their breakdown products in natural waters by reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. Anal Chim Acta 151: 297-314
Marees G and Wernand MR (1991) Interpretation of optical remote sensing data over coastal waters. Beleids Commissie Remote Sensing Report No. 91-27, p. 105
Milton EJ (1987) Principles of Field Spectroscopy. Int J Remote Sensing 8(12): 1807-1827
Morel A and Gordon HR (1980) Report of the working group on water color. Boundary Layer Meteor 18: 343-355
Mittenzwey KH, Ullrich S, Gitelson A and Kondratiev KY (1992) Determination of chlorophyll a of inland waters on the basis of spectral reflectance. Limnol and Oceanography 37: 147-149
Sathyendranath S, Prieur L and Morel A (1989) A three-component model of ocean colour and its application to remote sensing of phytoplankton pigments in coastal waters. Int J Remote Sensing 10(8): 1373-1394
Schiebe FR, Harrington JA and Ritchie JC (1992) Remote sensing of suspended sediments: the Lake Chicot, Arkansas project. Int J Remote Sensing 13: 1487-1509
Strickland JDH and Parsons TR (1972) A practical handbook of seawater analysis. Fisheries Research Board of Canada, 310 p
Visser M (1993) Thesis University of Utrecht: On the transport of fine sediment in the Netherlands coastal zone. Koninklijke Bibliotheek, Den Haag, ISBN 90-393-0129-8
Wernand MR, Spitzer D (1987) Processing of airborne CORSAIR. Proceedings of the joint workshop on remote sensing of the sea. Nasril Hadjar, Mawardi Nur, Hamzah Sidik and Aries Fonda Endy. Indonesian National Institute of Aeronautics and Space (LAPAN). Ref. Publ. TKH 8705, 153-166
Wernand MR, Shimwell SJ and de Munk JC (1997) A simple method of full spectrum reconstruction by a five-band approach for ocean colour applications. Int J Remote Sensing 18(9): 1977-1986
Wilson, A.K (1995) NERC Scientific Services Airborne Remote Sensing Facility User Guide Handbook. Remote Sensing Appl Devel Unit, p. 56
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wernand, M., Shimwell, S., Boxall, S. et al. Evaluation of specific semi-empirical coastal colour algorithms using historic data sets. Aquatic Ecology 32, 73–91 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009946501534
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009946501534