Abstract
Two major management philosophies of the 20th Century, scientific management and quality management, are often contrasted. Scientific management is seen as a system that focuses on task efficiencies whereas quality management is described as a collaborative, people-centered process approach to continuous improvement. This paper examines the ethical implications of these diverse approaches, particularly in the way information is used to decide which employees to lay off in times of economic difficulty. The paper uses case examples of quality management as teaching tools to place the conduct of managers within utilitarian, deontological and justice approaches to ethical decision making. Finally, it suggests that a third system, open-book management, may help deal with this ethical dilemma, though not without risk.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bowie, N.: 1998, 'A Kantian Theory of Meaningful Work', Journal of Business Ethics 17(9/10), 1083-1092.
Braverman, H.: 1974, Labor and Monopoly Capital (Monthly Review Press, New York).
Brown, M. G.: 1996, Baldrige Award Winning Quality: How to Interpret the Malcolm Baldrige Award Criteria, 6th Edition (ASQC Quality Press, Milwaukee).
Buchanan, J.: 1998, 'ESOPs: Want Employees to Think and Act Like Owners? Then Give Them Stock and Make Them Owners', Office Systems 15(12), 16-18.
Case, J.: 1995, Open-Book Management: The Coming Business Revolution (HarperCollins, New York).
Deming, W. E.: 1986, Out of the Crisis (MIT, Cambridge, MA).
Dugas, C.: 1996, 'AT&T's House of Cards, Long-Distance Firm Falls from the Pinnacle of Plastic', USA Today (September 27), 1B.
Edwards, R.: 1979, Contested Terrain: The Transformation of the Workplace in the 20th Century (Basic Books, New York).
Gendron, G.: 1998, 'The Numbers on Open-Book Management', Inc. 20(8), 11.
Johnson, P.: 1997, A History of the American People (HarperCollins, New York).
Kanigel, R.: 1997, The One Best Way: Frederick Winslow Taylor and the Enigma of Efficiency (Viking, New York).
Krishnan, R., A. B. Shani,R. M. Grant andR. Baer: 1993, 'In Search of Quality Improvement: Problems of Design and Implementation', Academy of Management Executive 7(4), 7-20.
Lewis, R. G. and D. H. Smith: 1994, Total Quality in Higher Education (St. Lucie Press, Delray Beach FL).
Locke, E.: 1982, 'The Ideas of Frederick W. Taylor: An Evaluation', Academy of Management Review 7, 14-24.
Mathews, J.: 1992, 'The Cost of Quality', Newsweek (Sept. 7), 48.
Maynard, M.: 1991, 'Glory and Pain of Taking the Prize’ USA Today (Oct. 10), 2B.
Morgan, R. B. and J. E. Smith: 1996, Staffing the New Workplace: Selecting and Promoting for Quality Improvement (ASQC Quality Press, Milwaukee).
Nadeau, S.: 1996, 'Motorola Sets First Layoffs in More Than a Decade', Reuters Financial Service (July 15).
Peery, Jr., N. S.: 1995, Business, Government and Society: Managing Competitiveness, Ethics and Social Issues (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ).
Pfeffer, J. and J. F. Veiga: 1999, 'Putting People First for Organizational Success', Academy of Management Executive 13(2), 37-48.
Raiborn, C. and D. Payne: 1996, 'TQM: Just What the Ethicist Ordered', Journal of Business Ethics 15(9), 963-972.
Steinert-Threlkeld, T.: 1993, 'TI to Eliminate 875 Employees Despite Profitable Year', Dallas Morning News (Feb. 2), 4D.
Taylor, F.: 1911, 'Speech to the New England Railroad Club’ (Oct. 10) (New England Railroad Club, Boston), 138-187.
Thompson, C. B.: 1940, 'The Taylor System in Europe', Advanced Management, Quarterly Journal of the Society for the Advancement of Management 5(4) (October-December), 171-176.
Walton, M.: 1986, The Deming Management Method (Perigee Books, New York).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kidwell, R.E., Scherer, P.M. Layoffs and Their Ethical Implications under Scientific Management, Quality Management and Open-Book Management. Journal of Business Ethics 29, 113–124 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006455228312
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006455228312