Is temporary employment a cause or consequence of poor mental health? A panel data analysis
Introduction
Health and labour market status are intrinsically linked. Analyses of these links adopt two distinct perspectives: first, health impacts on employment and, second, employment impacts on health. Health status can be separated into two mutually inclusive parts: physical and mental health conditions. Although the exact proportions are controversial, the Mental Health Foundation (2014) argues that a quarter of people will experience a mental health condition at some point in their lives and around one in twelve people are affected by depression. This study assesses the relationship between mental health conditions and labour market transitions between permanent and temporary employment.
Although there are an increasing number of studies that focus on the link between health and employment, such as Pirani and Salvini (2015), dominant explanations of the impacts of health on employment typically focus on health as a medically classified condition (Oliver, 1990) and emphasise the effects of clinical factors on an individual's employment capabilities. When an individual is in employment but has a mental health condition they are known to be at risk of experiencing presenteeism, which is where an employee is unwell and remains in work but is less productive. Presenteeism can occur when people with poor mental health lack obvious outward signs and are reluctant to have to prove they are ill because of the resulting stigma (Lelliott et al., 2008). Mental health stigma includes the perception that individuals with mental health disorders are weak, flawed, dangerous and/or socially incompetent (Wahl, 2003) and the desire not to want to be thought of as having these characteristics can deter people from seeking or obtaining help (Hinshaw and Cicchetti, 2000). Chen et al. (2015) argue that rates of presenteeism vary with the perceived level of workplace support, with those feeling least supported having higher rates of presenteeism. Individuals with poor mental health are also known to be less likely to be in employment: in the UK in 2004, 74 percent of the working age population was in employment but the comparable figure for people considered disabled by a long term mental illness was only 21 percent (Social Exclusion Task Force, 2006).
A distinctly different literature emphasises the existence of the reverse association, i.e. that lower labour market status affects health. For instance, Silla et al. (2005) find that temporary workers experience relatively poor health outcomes and Martens et al. (1999) find that employees on temporary contracts, working irregular hours or working compressed working weeks report up to 40 percent more health complaints than those with non-flexible work schedules. However, Bardasi and Francesconi (2004) find no evidence that atypical employment is associated with adverse health consequences.
Hence the literature is divided on whether poor mental health affects labour market status or whether a poorer labour market status affects mental health. The literature is equally unclear about the links between mental health and changes in employment status. This article fills this gap in the literature by assessing whether deteriorating health status precedes labour market transitions or vice versa. In particular, it presents temporal relationships between poor mental health and transitions between permanent and temporary employment, and thereby assesses if poor mental health affects or is affected by this type of labour market transition. Although our focus is on the transition between permanent and temporary employment, our methodological approach could be applied to other transitions.
This article contributes to the literature in three ways. First, it presents an investigation into the associations between three indicators of mental health (psychological distress, psychological anxiety and life satisfaction), an overall indicator of general health and transitions between temporary and permanent employment. Second, we draw on data from the British Household Panel Survey (BHPS) to understand whether the link between employment type and health status is more of a causal outcome and/or a selection effect. If the temporarily employed are identified as having poorer mental health than those in permanent employment then it is consistent with two mutually inclusive possibilities: (i) temporary employment generates adverse mental health effects and/or (ii) a selection effect whereby individuals with below average mental health are drawn away from permanent and into temporary employment. This is a particularly pertinent issue as Virtanen et al.'s (2005) review of the empirical associations between temporary employment and psychological morbidity suggests that many results may be confounded by selection bias: if the selection effect is discovered to be more prominent relative to a causal effect then cross sectional studies that present estimates of a negative influence of temporary employment on mental health status may be reporting upwardly biased estimates.
A potential confounding issue is that mental health is associated with job satisfaction, with either lower job satisfaction deteriorating mental health or worsening mental health adversely affecting job satisfaction. We extend our analysis to examine the effect of job satisfaction on mental health and in mitigating any effect of employment type on mental health. This extension is conducive to policy recommendations as mental health conditions can rarely be directly affected by managers whereas job satisfaction often can.
Section snippets
Health and employment status
The literature documents the recent upsurge in and diverse range of temporary employment arrangements and the mechanisms through which workers end up in temporary employment (see for example De Cuyper et al., 2008). These mechanisms are varied and heterogeneous with some being free choice (De Jong et al., 2009) whereby workers choose temporary contracts due to preferable attributes, such as greater flexibility. People may end up in temporary employment because of a lack of suitable permanent
Data and descriptive analysis
We employ all 18 waves of the BHPS (1991–2008/2009), which is a nationally representative annual survey of more than 5000 households and approximately 10,000 individuals in the UK. The BHPS contains self-reported data on a range of topics. We use the original BHPS sample covering Great Britain which means that we exclude from our analysis the European Community Household Panel low income sub-sample from 1997 to 2001, the Scottish and Welsh booster samples added from 1999 onwards and the
Methodological approach
A standard procedure to determine whether health status differs between contract types is to estimate health equations that include dummy variables to identify the influence of contract type. Studies that employ this standard cross-sectional approach generally find that temporary contracts are negatively associated with mental health (e.g. Virtanen et al., 2005, Silla et al., 2005). However, cross-sectional estimates may be an amalgam of causal influences and selection effects. The latter can
Regression results
This section reports the results of regressions that use our four measures of health as dependent variables. All our ordered measures (psychological distress, life dissatisfaction and poor general health) are estimated using ordered logistic regressions while our dichotomous dependent variable (psychological anxiety) is estimated using a binary logistic model. In line with existing literature (Araya et al., 2001, Breslau et al., 2008, Lindstrom and Rosvall, 2012), all health equations include
Conclusion
Labour market status and mental health are related and existing research suggests that lower labour market status is correlated with poorer mental health (Silla et al., 2005, Martens et al., 1999). However, it is debateable whether poor mental health is associated with a subsequent transition from permanent into temporary employment, as evidenced by Wagenaar et al. (2012), or whether being in temporary employment deteriorates mental health, as substantiated by Robone et al. (2011). This article
Acknowledgements
The authors thank workshop and conference participants for their helpful feedback at the University of Coventry, Work, Employment and Society Conference 2013, Statistics NZ labour market workshop and the NZ Association of Economists conference.
References (41)
- et al.
Relationship between psychiatric symptomatology, work skills, and future vocational performance
Psychiatr. Serv.
(1995) - et al.
Common mental disorders in Santiago, Chile. Prevalence and socio-demographic correlates
Br. J. Psychiatr.
(2001) - et al.
The impact of atypical employment on individual wellbeing: evidence from a panel of British workers
Soc. Sci. Med.
(2004) - et al.
How do types of employment relate to health indicators? Findings from the second European survey on work conditions
J. Epidemiol. Community Health
(2000) - et al.
Temporary jobs: stepping stones or dead ends?
Econ. J.
(2002) - et al.
Mental disorders and subsequent educational attainment in a US national sample
J. Psychiatr. Res.
(2008) - et al.
Perceived workplace health support is associated with employee productivity
Am. J. Health Promot.
(2015) - et al.
Back to baseline Britain: adaptation in the British household panel survey
Economica
(2013) - et al.
Emerging trends in contingent work research
J. Manag.
(2004) - et al.
Temporary employment, job satisfaction and subjective well-being
Econ. Ind. Democr.
(2014)
Literature review of theory and research on the psychological impact of temporary employment: towards a conceptual model
Int. J. Manag. Rev.
Associations between contract preference and attitudes, well-being and behavioural intentions of temporary workers
Econ. Ind. Democr.
Motives for accepting temporary employment: a typology of temporary workers
Int. J. Manpow.
Health effects on labour market exits and entries
Labour Econ.
Flexible contracts and subjective well-being
Econ. Inq.
Job flexibility and job insecurity: the Dutch case
Eur. J. Work Organ. Psychol.
Stigma and mental disorder: conceptions of illness, public attitudes, personal disclosure, and social policy
Dev. Psychopathol.
Welfare states, flexible employment, and health: a critical review
Health Policy
Mental Health and Work
Marital status, social capital, economic stress, and mental health: a population-based study
Soc. Sci. J.
Cited by (44)
Does employability help to cope with job insecurity? An analysis of workers' well-being with Swiss panel data
2024, Research in Social Stratification and MobilityTemps dip deeper: Temporary employment and the midlife nadir in human well-being
2021, Journal of the Economics of AgeingCitation Excerpt :Using British panel data, Green and Heywood (2011) found, as a cross-sectional result, a negative association between being on a flexible (i.e. temporary) contract and life satisfaction, although when individual worker fixed effects were taken into account, they found no statistically significant relationship. However, as has been pointed out by Dawson et al. (2015) and Chadi and Hetschko (2016), when a worker changes contract type she often also changes company, working conditions and work culture too. If these are not controlled for (and information on work and corporate culture is rare in large socio-economic panel datasets) fixed effects estimates may not give an unbiased outcome.
Acute health shocks and labour market outcomes: Evidence from the post crash era
2020, Economics and Human BiologyThe reciprocal relationship between depressive symptoms and employment status
2019, Economics and Human BiologyTrajectories of insecurity: Young adults' employment entry, health and well-being
2019, Journal of Vocational BehaviorCitation Excerpt :At the individual level, we controlled for age at t1 to reduce confounding with education. Additionally, we controlled for baseline levels of self-rated health and life satisfaction one year prior to leaving education (t0), to account for health-based selection into different labor market states (Dawson et al., 2015; Paul & Moser, 2009). We conducted a latent class growth analysis (LCGA) to model trajectories of employment insecurity.
The impact of employment protection on health: Evidence from fixed-term contract workers in South Korea
2019, Social Science and MedicineCitation Excerpt :However, several studies comparing the health of temporary and permanent workers find a limited negative impact of temporary employment. For instance, Bardasi and Francesconi (2004) and Dawson et al. (2015) both use data from the British Household Panel Survey and argue that temporary employment is not causally associated with poor self-rated health. Similarly, Gebel and Voßemer (2014)Gebel and Voßemer (2014) empirically finds little difference in health benefits between temporary and permanent employment using German data.