Clinical ReviewSystematic review of the different aspects of primary snoring
Introduction
The first major classification of sleep disorders, namely the diagnostic classification of sleep and arousal disorders, was published in 1979 [1]. It organised sleep disorders into symptomatic categories, forming the basis of current classification systems. This classification attempted to describe the snoring phenomenon but provided no operational definition of primary snoring (PS) (i.e., snoring without medical co-morbidity).
Recently, the 2014 revision of the International Classification of Sleep Disorders (ICSD), ICSD-3, was published by the American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) [2]. The ICSD-3 moved the classification of snoring to the category of ‘sleep-related breathing disorders’, as a separate entity, namely the first of the subdivision of ‘isolated symptoms and normal variants’. The ICSD-3 describes PS as ‘audible vibrations of the upper airway during respiration in sleep’. In the same paragraph, the ICSD-3 does not repeat the adjective ‘primary’, and shifts first towards the aspect of possible malignancy. It mentions dry mouth and irritated tissues, and continues towards the presence of apnoeas, influencing factors, and treatments. This definition remains relatively vague. The approach of the ICSD-3 suggests that the absolute absence of apnoea is not maintained, indicating that to translate the concept of PS/SS into practice, a certain degree of apnoea during sleep must be allowed for.
Because of the diverse acoustical, individual, and physical aspects of snoring, several authors [2], [3], [4], ∗[5], ∗[6] have agreed only on the following points in their definitions of snoring:
- -
Location in the body: the upper airway or aero-digestive tract.
- -
Moment of respiration: mainly during inspiration, but eventually occurring during expiration or during the complete respiration cycle.
- -
Mental condition of the snorer during sleep.
- -
Causative factor: vibrations of the pharyngeal tissues during breathing causing a fluttering sound.
These aspects do not specify diagnostic criteria such as acoustical metrics and non-acoustical and social aspects. Consequently, the diagnosis of isolated snoring or PS/simple snoring (SS) is indistinct and the boundaries are open to interpretation. Therefore, investigation of the operational definitions used in research practice is essential. To our knowledge, no study has been conducted on this topic.
In 2005, Hoffstein et al. attempted to categorise the different clinical conditions that are accompanied by a specific snore signal [6]. The key criterion was the Apnoea/Hypopnoea Index (AHI), namely the number of apnoeic/hypopnoeic events per hour measured during polysomnography (PSG).
- -
Asymptomatic non-apnoeic snoring with an AHI ≤5/h and no daytime sleepiness
- -
Non-apnoeic snoring concomitant with upper airway resistance syndrome (UARS) with respiratory-effort-related arousals (RERAs) between > 5 and ≤10 and AHI ≤ 5/h and daytime sleepiness and oxygen desaturation > 90% [7], [8].
- -
Apnoeic snoring concomitant with obstructive sleep apnoea syndrome (OSAS) characterised by oxygen desaturation (SaO2), AHI > 5/h, and a deviating electroencephalogram pattern.
In 2008, Stoohs classified obstructive sleep-disordered breathing (SDB) as four entities, taking into account the respiratory disturbance index (RDI) and daytime sleepiness. Patients were classified as having either PS (no sleepiness) or UARS (sleepiness) if the RDI was <5 events/hour of sleep, and if the RDI was ≥5, patients were classified as having obstructive sleep apnoea-hypopnoea (no sleepiness) and obstructive sleep apnoea-hypopnoea syndrome (sleepiness) [9]. The RDI is based on respiratory events during sleep, but unlike the AHI, it also includes RERAs [10].
Deary et al. also referred to a continuum or evolution of snoring within the spectrum of SDB from PS to UARS to OSAS [5]. Although a patient with PS is assumed to move gradually towards OSAS based on a continuum of factors (e.g., weight gain or alcohol abuse), no convincing evidence has shown this to be the case; more than 40% of habitual snorers reported resolution rather than worsening of their snoring when asked about it in a 10-year follow-up study by Lindberg et al. [11]. An early diagnosis of PS can possibly prevent progression to a more severe medical condition such as UARS or OSAS [12].
This review paper includes a draft inventory of definitions for PS/SS. The focus lies on current practice regarding the different aspects used in the operationalisation (the translation into practice) of the concept of PS/SS. The encountered definitions will be discussed in terms of the function of their conceptual angles and possible applications.
Section snippets
Materials and methods
The focus of this concise review was on snoring without immediate medical effects on the patient. The aim was to investigate current definitions operationalising PS in research practice. An overview of the literature on snoring was not the aim. Therefore, based on the literature presented in the introduction, we used the following search terms:
(‘primary snoring’ OR ‘simple snoring’ OR ‘non-apnoeic snoring’ OR ‘isolated snoring’ OR ‘occasional snoring’ OR ‘socially disruptive snoring’ OR
Results
In 29 of the 39 selected papers, a definition or reference to a definition was included in the manuscript. Nineteen publications contain a formal definition of PS, all of which included an AHI threshold. The threshold values range from 0 to 15 (exclusive). Two sources combined AHI with body mass index (BMI) to define PS: Baish et al. [13] used AHI < 15/h in combination with BMI < 32 kg/m2, and Welt et al. used AHI <10/h and BMI <32 kg/m2 [14]. Herzog et al. introduced peak intensity, a sound
Discussion
No universal definition of PS/SS exists in the literature. Little research supports the current criteria and the nearly omnipresent apnoea/hypopnea criterion (i.e., AHI < 5). When considering PS/SS, the sole cut-off criterion for all but three studies was the breathing-related parameter AHI, which is measured during PSG. A useful classification cannot be found in the literature to differentiate snoring using generally accepted quantitative and qualitative determinants (acoustical and
Conclusions
A tendency exists to use the physical parameter AHI-based cut-off of <5 events per hour of sleep (69% of the selected publications). Nevertheless, the AHI cut-offs ranged from 0 to <15/h. Occasionally, additional requirements were imposed. Unfortunately, the cut-offs and requirements did not match the conceptual definition of the predominant reference by the AASM. This requires a rethinking of the operationalisation of PS/SS and additional research.
The level of the physical measurements of
Financial support
None.
Off-label or investigational use
Not applicable
Conflict of interest
The authors do not have any conflicts of interest to disclose.
References∗ (69)
- et al.
Simple snoring: not quite so simple after all?
Sleep Med Rev
(2014) Snoring and upper airway resistance
- et al.
The symptoms and signs of upper airway resistance syndrome: a link to the functional somatic syndromes
Chest
(2003) - et al.
Differences in clinical features of upper airway resistance syndrome, primary snoring, and obstructive sleep apnea/hypopnea syndrome
Sleep Med
(2008) - et al.
A 10-year follow-up of snoring in men
Chest
(1998) - et al.
Effects of oropharyngeal exercises on snoring: a randomized trial
Chest
(2015) - et al.
Modified cautery-assisted palatal stiffening operation: new method for treating snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
(2007) - et al.
Daytime sleepiness relates to snoring independent of the apnea-hypopnea index in women from the general population
Chest
(2008) - et al.
Quantitative sensory testing in the oropharynx: a means of showing nervous lesions in patients with obstructive sleep apnea and snoring
Chest
(2009) - et al.
Is the Berlin questionnaire a useful tool to diagnose obstructive sleep apnea in the elderly?
Sleep Med
(2011)