First assessment of triclosan, triclocarban and paraben mass loads at a very large regional scale: Case of Paris conurbation (France)
Graphical abstract
Introduction
As a result of human activities and consumption of a large array of chemicals, numerous contaminants including pharmaceuticals and personnel care products (PPCPs), flame retardants, endocrine disruptors and priority pollutants as defined by the European water framework Directive are present in wastewater (Berge et al., 2013, Gasperi et al., 2008a, Kolpin et al., 2002, Lee et al., 2005, Paxeus, 1996). Among them, PPCPs are of increasing concerns owing to their ubiquities in environmental compartments, their persistent inputs, and their potential threat to environment and human health (Halling-Sorensen et al., 1998, Lee et al., 2005, Liu and Wong, 2013, Onesios et al., 2009). Among the most concerned PPCPs, preservative agents such as parabens (esters of p-hydroxybenzoic acid), triclosan (TCS, 5-chloro-2-2,4-dichlorophenoxy) and triclocarban (TCC, 3,4,4′-trichlorocarbanilide) are commonly employed in food, cosmetic (soaps, shampoos, detergents, toothpastes, etc.) and pharmaceutical products. These compounds are antiseptic, bactericidal and fungicidal agents. The esters of p-hydroxybenzoic acids with alkyl and aryl subsistent including methyl- (MeP), ethyl- (EtP), propyl- (PrP), isobutyl- (IsoBuP), butyl- (BuP) and benzyl-paraben (BzP) are mostly used in personal care products. Short chain parabens (methyl-, ethyl- and propyl-) are mainly used in liquid personal care products (liquid soap, etc.), while long chain congeners (butyl- and isobutyl-) are mostly employed in creams (Eriksson et al., 2009). According to an enquiry led by Tavares et al. (2009) in Spain on 215 personal care products, 99% of creams and 77% of cleansing lotions and make-up removers contained parabens. In France in 2009, about 7000 personal care products or formulations containing MeP were marketed against 3000–5000 products containing the remaining paraben esters (Mintel database, Global Market Research and Market Insight (Mintel, 2013)). Similarly, 860 products containing TCS were listed against only 4 containing TCC. Data on their mass loads are nevertheless not available.
For parabens, the maximum allowable concentration is 1% (w/w) (Tavares et al., 2009). According to EC Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) updated opinion in 2013 (SCCS, 2013), ethyl- and methyl-parabens are considered safe at a maximum concentration of 0.4% w/w for single and 0.8% w/w for mixtures of esters. Following the recent debate on the safety of the use of parabens as preservatives in cosmetics in 2013, and based on the last SCCS opinion, the European Commission (EC) decided to ban benzyl-, pentyl-, isopropyl-, isobutyl- and phenyl-parabens. The combined use of butyl- and propyl-parabens is to be limited to 0.19% w/w (as esters).
Similar to parabens, TCS is used in a large array of products including soaps, deodorants, toothpastes and can be also used as additives for plastics or food packaging and textiles whereas TCC has a more restricted use (soaps or body washes). The main application of TCS is in PPCPs (85% of total production) against 10% for textile or food packaging (Bedoux et al., 2012). Recently in 2010, the use of TCS as additive in food plastic packaging was banned by the EC 2010/169/EU. For TCS and TCC, up to 0.3% (w/w) and 5% (w/w) are respectively added to a variety of consumer products in the US (Halden and Paull, 2005).
For these compounds, a particular attention has been paid to their fate within wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) in different areas (Gracia-Lor et al., 2012, Kasprzyk-Hordern et al., 2009, Miege et al., 2009, Sim et al., 2010). However, today, data on their production and consumption are confidential and thus rather difficult to obtain. As an alternative way, some experimental studies estimated the mass loads of triclosan and parabens in wastewater at different scales (houses, neighborhood or catchments) (Eriksson et al., 2009, Lindstrom et al., 2002, Palmquist and Hanæus, 2005, Wind et al., 2004). For parabens, only Eriksson et al. (2009) in Denmark evaluated individual paraben mass loads in graywater between 30 and 275 μg inhab− 1 d− 1 at the scale of 120 resident buildings. In Sweden, Palmquist and Hanaeus (2005) evaluated the load of triclosan at 200 μg per population equivalent and per day (μg PE− 1 d− 1) in graywater and 100 μg PE− 1 d− 1 in blackwater for a block of 47 small one-family houses consisting of 169 persons. At a larger scale, Lindstrom et al. (2002) reported in Switzerland triclosan mass loads at 412 μg inhab− 1 d− 1 (190–750 μg inhab− 1 d− 1) in influents from WWTPs serving populations between 4500 and 19 000 persons. In spite of these significant experimental inputs, knowledge on the occurrence and mass loads of these chemicals are deeply needed since data are rather limited for both compound families and concerned quite small areas. Due to high short-term variation in flow and pollutant concentrations, working at a too small scale can lead to potential bias to get a representative mass load evaluation. In addition, and due to the emerging concerns and the media coverage of parabens and triclosan as potential endocrine disruptors, a consumption decrease of personal care products containing parabens, TCS and TCC is expected. To date, no data show this trend and no study fixed an initial state.
In this context, this study was therefore launched as part of the OPUR (Observatory of Urban Pollutants in Paris) research program, with the objective of examining the occurrence of parabens, TCS and TCC at the scale of the Parisian sewer network and to provide representative data on these compounds in France at the scale of the Parisian conurbation. For this purpose and in collaboration with the Parisian public sanitation service (SIAAP) in charge of the collect and treatment of the Parisian wastewater, this study focused on the main seven sewer trunks of the Paris conurbation (Fig. 1). The total flow was estimated at 1 900 000 m3 d− 1, corresponding to about 8 million inhabitants, i.e., 13% of the national population. At this scale, the objectives of the present study are i) to assess the occurrence and the concentration ranges of parabens, TCS and TCC in the Parisian wastewater, ii) to examine their partitioning between the dissolved and particulate phases, iii) to evaluate pollutant mass loads per population equivalent (PE) at a large scale area and finally iv) to extrapolate mass loads at a national scale.
By investigating the occurrence and mass loads of these chemicals at the Parisian and then at the national scales, this study delivers new and original data on the actual consumption of these chemicals in developed countries such as France. This study also provides a reference status which could be used as a basis for future monitoring and for setting sustainable policies.
Section snippets
Site description and sampling strategy
The main seven Parisian sewer trunks were considered; the 5 deserving the Seine Aval wastewater treatment plant (WWTP): Saint-Denis Achères (SDA), Clichy Achères Argenteuil (CAA), Clichy Achères Bezons (CAB), Sèvres Achères Nanterre (SN), Sèvres Achères Rueil (SR), and those deserving the Seine Amont (SAM) and Marne Aval (MAV) WWTPs. The Parisian sewer network is combined and all campaigns were performed during dry weather periods. The main characteristics of these sewer trunks are given in
Concentrations of parabens, triclosan and triclocarban in wastewater
The total concentrations of parabens, TCS and TCC in wastewater are illustrated in Fig. 2. Mean concentrations ± standards deviations (SD) on the basis of the four campaigns performed are shown for each sewer trunk. Numeric results are available in Supporting Table 4. Out of the height compounds monitored, benzyl-paraben was never detected in both dissolved and particulate phases (< 52 ng l− 1 for dissolved and < 0.02 mg kg− 1 for particulate phases) whereas the remaining compounds were systematically
Conclusions
This study was launched with the objectives of examining the occurrence and concentration ranges of parabens, TCS and TCC in wastewater at the scale of the Parisian sewer network and for providing representative knowledge on these compounds in developed countries such as France and for a large area. In this context, this innovative approach delivers some interesting findings.
For the first time, this study evaluated the pollutant mass loads per population equivalent of parabens, TCS and TCC at
Acknowledgments
This study was carried out within the framework of the OPUR research program. The authors gratefully acknowledge the Paris public sanitation service (SIAAP) for their technical support during this study.
References (44)
- et al.
Greywater pollution variability and loadings
Ecol Eng
(2009) - et al.
Priority pollutants in wastewater and combined sewer overflow
Sci Total Environ
(2008) - et al.
Simultaneous determination of the endocrine disrupting compounds nonylphenol, nonylphenol ethoxylates, triclosan and bisphenol A in wastewater and sewage sludge by gas chromatography–mass spectrometry
J Chromatogr A
(2007) - et al.
Occurrence and removal of pharmaceuticals in wastewater treatment plants at the Spanish Mediterranean area of Valencia
Chemosphere
(2012) - et al.
Mass flows of endocrine disruptors in the Glatt River during varying weather conditions
Environ Pollut
(2009) - et al.
The removal of pharmaceuticals, personal care products, endocrine disruptors and illicit drugs during wastewater treatment and its impact on the quality of receiving waters
Water Res
(2009) - et al.
Determination of endocrine-disrupting phenols, acidic pharmaceuticals, and personal-care products in sewage by solid-phase extraction and gas chromatography–mass spectrometry
J Chromatogr A
(2005) - et al.
Pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs): a review on environmental contamination in China
Environ Int
(2013) - et al.
Fate of triclocarban, triclosan and methyltriclosan during wastewater and biosolids treatment processes
Water Res
(2013) - et al.
Fate of pharmaceuticals and personal care products in wastewater treatment plants — conception of a database and first results
Environ Pollut
(2009)
Hazardous substances in separately collected grey- and blackwater from ordinary Swedish households
Sci Total Environ
Organic pollutants in the effluents of large wastewater treatment plants in Sweden
Water Res
Occurrence and fate of pharmaceuticals in wastewater treatment plants and rivers in Korea
Environ Pollut
Occurrence and fate of endocrine disrupters in Greek sewage treatment plants
Water Res
Contribution of primary and secondary treatment on the removal of benzothiazoles, benzotriazoles, endocrine disruptors, pharmaceuticals and perfluorinated compounds in a sewage treatment plant
Sci Total Environ
Parabens in male infertility—is there a mitochondrial connection?
Reprod Toxicol
Occurrence of pharmaceutical compounds in urban wastewater: removal, mass load and environmental risk after a secondary treatment—a review
Sci Total Environ
Triclosan determination in water related to wastewater treatment
Talanta
Estrogenic personal care products in greywater reuse system
Water Sci Technol
Occurrence and toxicity of antimicrobial triclosan and by-products in the environment
Environ Sci Pollut Res
Meta-analysis of environmental contamination by phthalates
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int
Determination of biocides in different environmental matrices by use of ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry
Anal Bioanal Chem
Cited by (58)
Superior methylparaben removal by anaerobic fluidized bed ceramic membrane bioreactor with PVDF tubular fluidized biocarrier: Reactor performance and microbial community
2023, Journal of Environmental Chemical EngineeringEnvironmental occurrence of endocrine disrupting chemicals in personal care products
2023, Endocrine-Disrupting Chemicals: Environmental Occurrence, Risk, and RemediationParabens as emerging contaminants: Environmental persistence, current practices and treatment processes
2022, Journal of Cleaner ProductionOccurrence and human exposure assessment of parabens in water sources in Osun State, Nigeria
2022, Science of the Total Environment