Reading EAP: Investigating high proficiency L2 university students' strategy use through reading blogs
Introduction
Reading is a central, high-stakes activity in any tertiary-level academic course; course literature often provides the basis for the content knowledge students require in order to complete written assignments, which are in turn used as the basis for assessment. The interdependent relationship between the development of reading and writing skills has now been established. Indeed, it is widely acknowledged that good readers make good writers (e.g. Hirvela, 2004), and that students' writing problems are often rooted in the difficulties they experience when reading (Hirvela, 2004). Nonetheless, a scan of JEAP, for example, reveals that recent scholarship within EAP has tended to focus more on the productive rather than receptive skills.
From a course-design perspective, identifying the “target situation” (Hutchinson & Waters, 1987) and supporting students' development of academic reading skills entails an understanding of how successful readers read (e.g. Ashby & Rayner, 2006). To this end, research has provided an account of how texts are tackled by experienced academic readers, such as professional scholars who are acculturated into their disciplinary context (e.g. Bazerman, 1985). Grabe (2008, p. 220) describes such readers as “strategic” as they “automatically and routinely apply combinations of effective and appropriate strategies depending on reader goals, reading tasks, and strategic processing abilities”. Furthermore, the strategic reader is “aware of his or her comprehension effectiveness in relation to reading goals and applies sets of strategies appropriately to enhance comprehension of difficult texts”.
In terms of methodological approaches to uncovering students' reading strategies, studies tend to fall into the following categories: large-scale quantitative surveys investigating trends in reading habits (e.g. Malcolm, 2009, Matsumoto et al., 2013, Pecorari et al., 2012), experimental studies (e.g. Martínez, 2002), questionnaire studies investigating reading strategies (e.g. Malcolm, 2009, Mokhtari and Reichard, 2004, Sheorey and Mokhtari, 2001) and qualitative studies using interviews and think-aloud protocols with small groups (e.g. Hirano, 2015, McCulloch, 2013). In accordance with Grabe (2008), results derived from these methods show that effective readers have a portfolio of strategies, categorized as top-down and bottom-up (e.g. Abbott, 2006), mining and writerly (Hirvela, 2004) and metacognitive and cognitive (e.g. Dhieb-Henia, 2003). These studies have greatly increased our knowledge of reading strategies in a variety of contexts. Nonetheless, in order to develop students' reading skills at the start of their university careers, more insight is needed into students' skill sets when they arrive at university (“the current situation” (Hutchinson & Waters, 1987)), and how they engage with academic texts within their own study contexts (McCulloch, 2013). Indeed, what happens outside the classroom, and in a “real life setting” has received considerably less attention (Malcolm, 2009, p. 640) in the EAP literature.
Thus, the focus of the present study is how inexperienced academic readers read when they begin their studies in tertiary education, at the start of socialization into their disciplines. Students' prior general and educational experience is a pertinent factor here (Bernhardt, 1991, Bernhardt, 2005), and therefore investigations of readers from different linguistic, sociocultural (e.g. Parry, 1996) and educational backgrounds (e.g. Hirano, 2015) are needed. Recent studies into academic reading include investigations situated in, for example, Asia (Ohata & Fukao, 2014), Turkey (Nergis, 2013), North Africa (Dhieb-Henia, 2003, Mokhtari and Reichard, 2004), and the Middle East (Malcolm, 2009) as well as in the US (e.g. Plakans, 2009). Students in Scandinavia have received less attention, as the reading research focus in this sociolinguistic context has been predominantly parallel language use (i.e. lectures in L1 accompanied by course literature in English) (e.g. Mežek, 2013a, Mežek, 2013b), rather than strategies students of English use to complete reading assignments per se. Nonetheless, these students present a particularly interesting case for EAP reading research, as their general English proficiency is comparatively high. Thus reading difficulties may stem from unfamiliarity with the discursive conventions of academic writing and domain-specific vocabulary, and a lack of prior content knowledge, rather than L2 deficits (Bernhardt, 2011).
We therefore investigate 26 first-semester students training to be English teachers at a Swedish university. Academic Reading and Writing 1 is the first course taken by these students, and is delivered via five two-hour seminars over a five-week period. While dealing with EAP material and skills, the course is a compulsory component in the teacher-education programme, and should not be understood as a preparatory language class. The overarching aim is to develop academic reading and writing skills, as well as content knowledge, which students will draw on in subsequent courses in the English department. The final assignment is a short argumentative essay on the topic of implicit and explicit vocabulary learning.
In order to support students in their construction of an academic argument, a need to ensure that students were reading the set literature more effectively was identified, and was the motivation behind our study. Through an analysis of student reading blogs, we investigate the strategies students report and the relationship between the strategy selected and text (see research questions 1 and 2 below). Our third research question asks what reading blogs can reveal in terms of students' reading practices:
RQ1. What reading-related strategies do novice, high proficiency academic readers report in their reading blogs?
RQ2. Do students adjust their reading according to text and task?
RQ3. What can reading blogs tell us about how students tackle academic reading?
The article is organised as follows. First, a brief overview of the educational background of the students is provided, followed by the theoretical framework and methodological approach adopted in the study. The results are then presented and discussed, supported by illustrative examples from the students' reading blogs. Last, pedagogical implications arising from the findings and future research directions are discussed.
Section snippets
Learning English in Swedish schools
Pupils in Sweden have extensive exposure to English and generally achieve a high proficiency in the language. As an illustration, two thirds of Swedish pupils in Year 9 achieved B2 (CEFR) (Council of Europe, 2001) in reading comprehension in the ESLC 2011 survey (Skolverket, 2012). To qualify for tertiary-level education, pupils take two further obligatory English courses at upper-secondary level (English A and B1
Theoretical framework
We view academic reading as a practice undertaken within a specific social context (e.g. Hirano, 2015). In other words, while the ability to engage with academic texts (reading them as well as writing them) is contingent on linguistic knowledge, an understanding of how disciplinary specific knowledge is constructed, validated and presented (e.g. Wingate & Tribble, 2012) is also beneficial. Therefore, the ‘problem’ of academic reading is not understood here primarily in terms of an L2 deficit,
The students
In total, 29 students were recruited from two groups taught by the second author in the study. All the students have at least completed English B and many of them also reported taking English C (see Section 2). All are training to be English teachers. The students were self-selecting and recruited by one of the authors of the study who was not involved in delivering the course. Participants were recruited after course completion. Informed consent was obtained, and students were told that they
Results
In this section, the results of the analysis are presented. Section 5.1 corresponds to the first research question, which probes the reading-related strategies students employed. Section 5.2 reports the results corresponding to the second research question, namely which strategies students used repeatedly and in relation to which text. Section 5.3 draws out significant themes from the data, and reveals what can be learnt about students' reading behaviours from the analysis of reading blogs.
Discussion, conclusion and pedagogical implications
The aim of this study was to gain insight into how high proficiency novice readers tackle academic reading in English in their own study contexts. The main contribution therefore is the insight gained into how students tackle academic reading in their own settings, as reported in the reading blogs, and the examination of the potential of reading blogs as both a pedagogical and methodological tool. Given the increasingly global nature of higher education, the results are of interest to not only
Lisa McGrath is a lecturer at the TESOL Centre at Sheffield Hallam University. Her research interests include advanced EAP, disciplinary discourse, and issues surrounding English for research and publication purposes.
References (53)
Evaluating the effectiveness of metacognitive strategy training for reading research articles in an ESP context
English for Specific Purposes
(2003)Genre-based pedagogies: a social response to process
Journal of Second Language Writing
(2003)- et al.
Metacognitive strategies in second language academic reading: a qualitative investigation
English for Specific Purposes
(1996) Reading strategy awareness of Arabic-speaking medical students studying in English
System
(2009)Empirical examination of EFL readers' use of rhetorical information
English for Specific Purposes
(2002)- et al.
Exploring the development of individual difference profiles in L2 reading
System
(2013) Investigating the reading-to-write processes and source use of L2 postgraduate students in real-life academic tasks: an exploratory study
Journal of English for Academic Purposes
(2013)Multilingual reading proficiency in an emerging parallel-language environment
Journal of English for Academic Purposes
(2013)- et al.
Investigating the strategic reading processes of first and second language readers in two different cultural contexts
System
(2004) Exploring the factors that affect reading comprehension of EAP learners
Journal of English for Academic Purposes
(2013)
L2 learners' conceptions of academic reading and themselves as academic readers
System
Differences in the metacognitive awareness of reading strategies among native and non-native readers
System
ESL reading strategies: differences in Arabic and Mandarin speaker test performance
Language Learning
Individual differences in strategy use in second language reading and testing
The Modern Language Journal
Literacy development: insights from research on skilled reading
Physicist reading physics: schema-laden purposes and purpose-laden schema
Written Communication
Learning from giving feedback: a study of secondary school students
ELT Journal
Reading development in a second language: Theoretical, empirical and classroom perspectives
Progress and procrastination in second language reading
Annual Review of Applied Linguistics
Understanding advanced second-language reading
The comprehension strategies of second language readers
TESOL Quarterly
Technical vocabulary in specialist texts
Reading in a Foreign Language
‘I want to go back to the text’: response strategies on the reading subtest of the new TOEFL®
Language Testing
Common European framework of reference for languages: Learning, teaching, assessment
An academic word list
Cited by (18)
“Their encouragement makes me feel more confident”: Exploring peer effects on learner engagement in collaborative reading of academic texts
2022, Journal of English for Academic PurposesReading habits of Vietnamese University English majors
2020, Journal of English for Academic PurposesDeveloping an effective three-stage teaching method for collaborative academic reading: Evidence from Chinese first-year college students
2020, Journal of English for Academic PurposesCitation Excerpt :To address research question two, we conducted interviews with the students to investigate the limitations of the teaching method perceived by them and elicit their suggestions for improvement. The discussion recordings, each lasting 10–15 min, were transcribed and coded using the coding scheme developed by two researchers through adapting the taxonomies of strategies found in the literature (e.g. McGrath et al., 2016; Oxford, 2017), and adding emergent categories found in the data. The coded transcripts were examined by a third researcher to ensure accuracy.
A comprehensive review of research on reading comprehension strategies of learners reading in English-as-an-additional language
2020, Educational Research ReviewCitation Excerpt :Reading multiple texts for information integration elicited a more exhaustive range of strategies than reading a single text (Karimi & Alibakhshi, 2014). During writing-integrated reading tasks, not only did EAL readers pay attention to text features and structures of texts, but they also analyzed and evaluated ideas in texts intending to use these text features and ideas in their writing (McCulloch, 2013; McGrath et al., 2016; Plakans, 2009; Zhao & Hirvela, 2015). Furthermore, EAL readers coordinated different comprehension strategies across different reading and writing stages by selecting appropriate strategies to support specific tasks in each stage (Trenchs Parera, 2006).
Students’ intrinsic perspectives on the diverse functions of short stories beyond language learning
2018, SystemCitation Excerpt :Macalister (2008) reports that extensive reading is also beneficial in the EAP context because of the reduction of teacher-centered class management and the appearance of a non-EAP focus through literary texts (see Carrell & Carson, 1997). Since EAP emphasizes both, language and subject content mastery, the reading strategies imparted through intensive reading (e.g., stylistics, text analysis, and reader awareness of metacognition) yield positive effects even in language-learning EFL settings (Macalister, 2008; McGrath, Berggren, & Mežek, 2016; Spector-Cohen, Kirschner, & Wexler, 2001). Therefore, the prominence of extensive reading in scholarship should not be seen as an indictment of intensive reading.
Development and validation of an academic reading instrument for graduate students of applied linguistics
2024, Australian Journal of Language and Literacy
Lisa McGrath is a lecturer at the TESOL Centre at Sheffield Hallam University. Her research interests include advanced EAP, disciplinary discourse, and issues surrounding English for research and publication purposes.
Jessica Berggren is a doctoral student at the Department of English at Stockholm University. Her research interests are EAP, second language instruction, and the use of assessment as a learning activity.
Špela Mežek is a teacher and researcher in English linguistics at the Department of English at Stockholm University. Her research interests are EAP, advanced second-language reading and writing, second language acquisition, and vocabulary learning.