The influence of computer-assisted instruction on students’ conceptual understanding of chemical bonding and attitude toward chemistry: A case for Turkey
Introduction
Meaningful learning theory suggests that the learning process consists of an interaction between preexisting knowledge and new knowledge and as a consequence students’ own knowledge is central for further learning (Ausubel, 1968, Mintzes et al., 1998). The literature suggests that students often develop ideas that are different from those accepted by scientific community and intended by their teachers (BouJaoude, 1992, Ebenezer and Fraser, 2001, Peterson and Treagust, 1989, Treagust, 1988, Zoller, 1990). Students’ ideas that are different to scientific ideas are variously called misconceptions, alternative conceptions, and alternative frameworks (Özmen, 2004); the most being misconceptions and alternative conceptions. Students’ alternative conceptions is the term we use here, because it recognizes that to the students’ such ideas make sense and fit in with their everyday experiences. The conceptions are often highly resistant to change, and according to Niaz (2001a), such ideas should be considered as part of their ‘hard-core’ beliefs.
Many studies all levels of schooling to determine students’ ideas about basic chemistry concepts suggest that students who did not acquire a satisfactory understanding of scientific conceptions occurred as a result of traditional teaching methods such as simple lecturing. Such teaching requires students to sit passively and does not much engage students actively in learning (Morgil, Oskay, Yavuz, & Arda, 2003). In such a traditional teacher-centered classroom, the students thus become listeners, and the teacher gives out the facts and defines important ideas. Students’ participation is often limited to listening to the teacher and perhaps raising their hand to answer questions (Muir-Herzig, 2004). It is reported that traditional teaching methods when used in teaching science means students may understand the subject – but only at a ‘knowledge level’ that involves them memorizing concepts without achieving in-depth understanding. Similarly, highly teacher-centered teaching methods may negatively affect the learners’ beliefs about science, leading them to see science learning as a simple accumulation of facts, and science as uninteresting (Kiboss, 2002, Kiboss et al., 2004). These pedagogical approaches may then influence students’ attitudes, cognitive development and achievement in science education (Çepni, Taş, & Köse, 2006). Because of this, science and chemistry teachers may need to consider alternative teaching approaches – particularly for difficult and abstract science concepts. Some authors suggest this might be achieved by using more learner-centered approaches and particularly those that employ modern information and communication technologies. These technologies can help facilitate knowledge-construction in the classroom and guide student activities, leaving teachers the opportunity to interact with small groups and to diagnose difficulties (Williams, Linn, Ammon, & Gearhart, 2004). Whitworth and Berson (2003) claim that technology-based learning can help develop students’ decision-making and problem-solving skills, data processing skills and communication skills. In student-centered classrooms with the aid of computers, students are able to collaborate, to use critical thinking and to find alternatives solutions to problems (Jaber, 1997). Recently there has been interest expressed in science education reform which emphasizes the need for integrating computer technologies into learning and teaching (Herman, 1996).
The literature notes that computer-assisted instruction (CAI) is one such area recently lauded for its capacity to improve the teaching of difficult and abstract science concepts and to simulate dangerous experiments and to stimulate interest in science learning (Allessi & Trollip, 1991). Computer also may be effective in other areas as a general pedagogical aid that complements regular teaching methods (Kiboss et al., 2004). The term computer-assisted instruction (CAI) is used here to mean an approach where information is delivered by the computer in a manner similar to programmed learning, and that is aimed at student achievement of specific educational goals through step-by-step instruction (Simonson & Thompson, 1994). At this time computer-based technology is (and will likely become more) a component of school and university classrooms. Several capabilities of computers, such as providing individualized instruction, practice, revision, teaching and problem-solving, simulations during the applications and immediate feedback, make computers useful instructional devices for developing desired learning outcomes (Ertepınar, 1995). An additional advantage is that the teacher can use computers at different times and places according to the characteristics of the subject matter, the students, and available software and hardware (Morgil, Yavuz, Oskay, & Arda, 2005). In summary, although authors’ views about contribution of computer based learning environments can make to student achievement vary, the utilization of computers in learning points to positive contributions of computer based learning environments to student learning.
Section snippets
Technology and schooling: Turkish scene
Turkey is a candidate for membership of the European Union (EU), and is a developing country with a population of about 70 million. The Turkish Educational System comprises four components: (i) pre-school, which is optional; (ii) basic education, which is 8 years in duration, compulsory, and free in public schools; (iii) secondary education, which is 3 years in duration, is not compulsory and is free in public schools; (iv) higher education including universities, which is generally 4 years,
CAI and chemistry teaching
Chemistry is one of the most important subjects in science and contains a number of abstract concepts requiring complex concepts many of which are not obviously applicable outside the classroom (Stieff and Wilensky, 2003, Zoller, 1990). For this reason, students view chemistry as one of the most difficult subjects to study at all levels of schooling. Many researchers have reported on students’ conceptions of fundamental, underlying chemistry concepts saying that when fundamental concepts are
The study context
As mentioned above, science is a compulsory subject between the grade 4 and 8 in the Turkish Educational System. The elementary school teaching of chemical bonding begins with an introduction, as a part of science at the age of 13–14 (grade 8). At this level, basic concepts such as bonding, ionic and covalent bonds are briefly introduced to students. The formal chemistry lessons start with secondary education (lycee) at the age of 14–15 (grade 9). General chemistry is compulsory and in the
Results and discussion
The results are presented with regard to the effects of traditional and CAI lessons, and their effect on student attitude toward chemistry and understanding of chemical bonding concepts.
Conclusions and implications
In this study, the effect of a CAI intervention on student attitude toward chemistry, and their understanding of and remediation of alternative conceptions for chemical bonding were investigated. The CAS and CBAT instruments were administered to experimental and control groups before and after CAI. No statistically significant differences in means was found between the groups with respect to chemistry achievement (t = 0.48, p = 0.628) or attitude toward chemistry (t = 0.55, p = 0.585) pre-test, but
Acknowledgements
This study was supported by the Research Fund of Karadeniz Technical University, Project Number: 2004.116.004.04. And also, I am very grateful to Dr. Richard K. Coll from the University of Waikato, New Zealand for his proofreading and corrections.
References (90)
- et al.
The effects of computer-assisted material on students’ cognitive levels, misconceptions and attitudes towards science
Computers and Education
(2006) - et al.
Linking teacher and student learning to improve professional development in systemic reform
Teaching and Teacher Education
(2003) - et al.
Computer simulations in physics teaching and learning: A case study on students’ understanding of trajectory motion
Computers and Education
(2001) - et al.
Effectiveness of computer-based instruction: An updated analysis
Computers in Human Behavior
(1991) Technology and its impact in the classroom
Computers and Education
(2004)- et al.
Understandings and misunderstandings of eighth graders of five chemistry concepts found in textbooks
Journal of Research in Science Teaching
(1992) - et al.
Computer based instruction: Methods and development
(1991) Evaluating the use of computers in science assessment: Consideration and recommendations
Journal of Science Education and Technology
(1995)Information technology in developing nations: A study of lecturers’ attitudes and expertise with reference to Turkish education
Journal of Information Technology for Teacher Education
(1996)- et al.
Computer-based instruction and computer assisted language learning in schools in Bursa
Uludağ University Journal of Education Faculty
(2002)
Students’ alternative conceptions of the human circulatory system: A cross-age study
Science Education
Educational psychology: A cognitive viewpoint
Chemistry teaching in Turkey
Energy, Education, Science and Technology
Preparing student teachers to use computers in mathematics classrooms through a long-term pre-service course in Turkey
Journal of Information Technology for Teacher Education
High school chemistry students’ performance and gender differences in a computerized molecular modeling learning environment
Journal of Science Education and Technology
Effect of experience on retention and elimination of misconceptions about molecular structure and bonding
Journal of Chemical Education
Why changing the curriculum may not be enough
Journal of Chemical Education
Students’ understanding of chemical bonds and the energetic of chemical reactions
Journal of Research in Science Teaching
The relationship between students’ learning strategies and the change in their misunderstandings during a high school chemistry course
Journal of Research in Science Teaching
Developing and using conceptual computer animations for chemistry instruction
Journal of Chemical Education
Alternative conceptions of chemical bonding held by upper secondary and tertiary students
Research in Science and Technological Education
Mental models in chemistry: Senior chemistry students’ mental models of chemical bonding
Chemistry Education: Research and Practice in Europe
Learners’ mental models of chemical bonding
Research in Science Education
Exploring tertiary students’ understanding of covalent bonding
Research in Science and Technological Education
Investigation of secondary school, undergraduate, and graduate learners’ mental models of ionic bonding
Journal of Research in Science Teaching
Rethinking microcomputer instruction as a part of teacher education
Educational Technology
Conceptual change achieved through a new teaching program on acids and bases
Chemistry Education: Research and Practice
Comparison of computer assisted and traditional problem solving activities in science
Journal of Hacettepe University Faculty of Education
A hypermedia environment to explore and negotiate students’ conceptions: Animation of the solution process of table salt
Journal of Science Education and Technology
First year chemical engineering students’ conceptions of energy in solution process: Phenomenographic categories for common knowledge construction
Science Education
The relationship between formal reasoning ability, computer-assisted instruction, and chemistry achievement
Hacettepe Journal of Education
Computer simulations as tools for teaching and learning: Using a simulation environment in optics
Journal of Science Education and Technology
Teaching for understanding: Exemplary practice in high school chemistry
Journal of Research in Science Teaching
Effects of computer simulations and problem solving approaches on high school students
Journal of Educational Research
Using computer simulations to restructure students’ conception of force
Journal of Computers in Mathematics and Science Teaching
Use of the computer for research on instruction and student understanding in physics
American Journal of Physics
Learning about atoms, molecules, and chemical bonds: A case study of multiple-model use in grade 11 chemistry
Science Education
Effects of integrated video media on student achievement and attitudes in high school chemistry
Journal of Research in Science Teaching
Assessing the impact of computer based learning in science
Journal of Research on Computing in Education
Attitudes toward science of urban seventh grade life science students over time, and the relationship to future plans, family, teacher, curriculum, and school
Urban Education
The microcomputer and achievement and attitudes in high school biology
Journal of Research in Science Teaching
A comparison between computer-based and traditional assessment tests, and their effects on pupil learning and scoring
School Science Review
Cited by (72)
Effects of innovative science and mathematics teaching on student attitudes and achievement: A meta-analytic study
2016, Educational Research ReviewComputer Quiz Games in General Chemistry for Engineering Majors in an English as a Second Language Environment
2024, Journal of Chemical EducationEffects of technology-integrated chemistry instruction on students’ academic achievement and retention capacity
2023, Journal of Education and LearningThe Effect of Computer Simulation on Grade 11 Learners’ Conceptualisation of Stoichiometric Chemistry
2023, European Journal of STEM EducationChemistry lecturers’ attitudes toward educational technology: Afghanistan lecturer perspective
2022, International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education