Supply chain simulator: A scenario-based educational tool to enhance student learning
Introduction
Simulation-based educational products are excellent “illustrative tools”, used exceedingly in student centered learning methodologies. It is an active learning technique, which stimulates a player’s diverse cognitive skills and insight into a system by instantly staging the consequences of their actions and strategies. Such actions and strategies can be tested without the apprehension of failures or reprisal. Such products allow a player to increase his understanding of a system in a short span of time. As compared to real world experience, this accelerated learning is one of the unequaled advantages of such products.
These simulation-based educational products provide a unique way to reinforce the theory discussed in the classrooms. As a player/student becomes deeply involved in the scenario, simulation or gamming situation, a sense of competition and a desire to perform well is most likely to develop. Consequently, the teaching effectiveness of these products is exceptionally high. These products render a great opportunity for the students to visualize and experience a practical scenario of what they learn in their coursework.
An elating facet of these products is the inherent concentration of a player on decision-making. It is this intensity that gives these simulation-based educational products its richness and effectiveness. Even though these interactive approaches are not considered to be a substitute of more formal approaches in teaching, it effectively complements these methods. Using Bloom’s taxonomy, the first three levels of knowledge, comprehension, and application, in most cases, are fully served. The fourth level of analysis could be present fully or partially depending upon the type of the tool or product and the use of it by the instructor.
The tool or product presented in this paper is developed in an academic project at King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals (KFUPM). The motivation behind this project came from a workshop on increasing teaching effectiveness (Ellington, 2002) and an undergraduate course that the authors are teaching. The course is an introductory technology course namely ‘introduction to technology’ which is a compulsory course taken by the undergraduate students in the College of Industrial Management at KFUPM. The objective of the course is to improve the understanding of the undergraduate management students in various areas of technology such as manufacturing, construction, communication, etc. To increase the effectiveness of the course, three simulation-based products were developed in this project. According to taxonomy presented in Randall (2002) these products can be categorized as a scenario-based e-learning products referred to as SBELP in this paper. One of these SBELP ‘supply chain simulator’ is presented in this paper. As the course is compulsory, average enrollment per semester is essentially high.
In Section 2, literature review is presented. Section 3 elaborates on the features of the SBELP. Feedbacks from the instructors, who have taught this course, are presented in Section 4. Section 5 shows the outcomes when the SBELP was tested with the students. Finally, conclusions are presented in Section 6.
Section snippets
Literature review
Simulation-based educational products in academics are becoming wide spread and ample literature is available on this area. These products are categorized as scenario-, simulation-, and game-based e-learning (Randall, 2002). The realization of the efficacy of these products is growing (Albrecht, 1995, Carlson, 2003, Curland and Fawcett, 2001, Gilad and Sheizaf, 2000, Holweg and Bicheno, 2002, Shifrony and Ginat, 1997, Sparling, 2002, Walter et al., 1997). Literature on specific studies is
The SBELP: ‘supply chain simulator’
The SBELP is named as ‘supply chain simulator’ as it tries to emulate an international supply chain network. This supply chain is used to deliver goods such as electronic equipments or a machine. The performance of these supply chains is judged by parameters such as inventory holding cost, backorder cost, and transportation cost, etc. Some other important terminologies and parameters are expressed below for understanding:
- 1.
Supply chain: a supply chain is a network of facilities and distribution
Feedback from the instructors
As mentioned earlier, the course is compulsory. Accordingly, it is one of the highly populated courses. As a result, the number of instructors who have taught this course is sizeable. These instructors were asked by the authors to evaluate this game. A questionnaire is given to these instructors to give their feedback. The results of each question, in terms of percentage response, are shown in Table 1. The prime objective of this survey was to evaluate, in their opinion, the effectiveness of
Feedback from the students
The SBELP was put to test for about four semesters. The students’ response was judged based on change in motivation and overall learning on the topic. This response is evaluated mainly by student interviews and scores obtained during the tasks. During submissions of the results/scores obtained the students were cross-questioned about the core concepts and there was a clear correlation between the number of times a student has played and the learning and scoring. The students were informally
Conclusion
Simulation-based educational products have enormous potential as an active learning tool. Its use in management, engineering and sciences education is common. However, the realization of its potential is on the rise. As discussed earlier in Section 2, the literature on the use of such games suggests this trend. The authors still believe that the real momentum and focus to reap the benefits of this tool is yet to come, especially in engineering and sciences education.
A very distinctive and
Acknowledgement
The authors would like to acknowledge King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals for its support and funding in conducting this research.
References (24)
- et al.
Supply chain simulation – a tool for education, enhancement and endeavor
International Journal of Production Economics
(2002) - Advanced Distributed Learning (ADL). (2007). SCORM....
- Advanced Distributed Learning (ADL2). (2007). CORDRA....
- Alarcon, L. F., & Ashely, D. B. (1999). Playing games: Evaluating the impact of lean production strategies on project...
A financial accounting and investment simulation game
Issues in Accounting Education
(1995)- et al.
A simulation game for teaching service-oriented supply chain management: Does information sharing help managers with service capacity decisions?
Production and Operations Management
(2000) Transformational leadership in a management game simulation
Group & Organization Studies
(1988)- Carlson, S. (2003). Can grand theft auto inspire professors? The Chronicles of Education: Information...
The design and implementation of a simulation game for teaching knowledge management
Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology
(2005)- Cordra.net, (2007). CORDRA....
Using simulation and gaming to develop financial skills in undergraduates
International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management
Cited by (104)
Review on intelligent pipeline technologies: A life cycle perspective
2023, Computers and Chemical EngineeringDeveloping and validating a business simulation systems success model in the context of management education
2022, International Journal of Management EducationCitation Excerpt :Due to increases in computing power, a relatively recent phenomenon has seen a broader use of diverse simulations with information technologies within learning alternatives (Lamb et al., 2018). In business and management fields, business simulation games (BSGs) are a critical tool widely used in management training (Siddiqui et al., 2008). Simulations of on-the-job scenarios within business simulation gaming environments stimulate student interactivity and improve classroom communications (Kent et al., 2016), give students an active role in developing their learning process (Romero-Martín et al., 2017), and improve student learning outcomes (Pando-Garcia et al., 2016; Lonn et al., 2011).
Education and training of manufacturing and supply chain processes using business simulation games
2021, Procedia ManufacturingStudents’ perception of the impact of competences on learning: An analysis with business simulations
2019, Computers in Human BehaviorA study on the relation between industry 4.0 technologies and gamification in e-learning
2023, Interactive Technology and Smart Education