Advances in gas sensors and electronic nose technologies for agricultural cycle applications
Graphical abstract
Introduction
Gas sensor technology has made great advances in the past few decades and is expected to achieve even more. Conceptual approach of gas sensor development from the past to the present focuses on creating and inventing new gas sensing instruments to overcome some of the most common life problems/pain points using odor detection such as food and beverage contamination (Bonah et al., 2020, Wongchoosuk et al., 2010, Timsorn and Wongchoosuk, 2019, Viejo et al., 2020, Traiwatcharanon et al., 2020), air pollution (Ahmad et al., 2020, Wongchoosuk et al., 2014, Chaloeipote et al., 2021a, Arunragsa et al., 2020), human health problems (Binson et al., 2021, Xu et al., 2018a) as well as safety and security (Bakar et al., 2018, Jha et al., 2019, Adib et al., 2018). These research output will help to increase convenience, safety and improve human life quality. Although, several spectrometry-based methods such as mass and ion mobility spectrometry (Zheng et al., 2021), gas chromatography (Zhenhe et al., 2020), and infrared spectrometry (Junaedi et al., 2021) have been successfully to identify and analyze odors/ volatile organic compounds (VOCs) molecules, these instruments are very expensive, time-consuming processes, complex, and bulky. An alternative method in arrays or as individual sensors based on metal oxide semiconductor (MOS), conductive polymer, electrochemical, quartz crystal microbalances (QCMs), or micro/nanocomposites gas sensors that offer easy operation, rapid, real-time detection, low operation cost, reliable, non-destructive measurement has become of great interest in recent years.
The evolution of gas sensor technology in terms of design and construction started with a single-gas detector and continued to develop until it was a gas-sensor array system known as electronic nose (E-nose) or also called as artificial olfactory system (AOS) or machine olfaction. In 1982, Krishna Persaud and George Dodd from University of Warwick published pioneering research on “Analysis of discrimination mechanisms in the mammalian olfactory system using a model nose” that provide researchers with valuable knowledge on array of heterogeneous chemical gas sensors for E-nose system (Persaud et al., 1982). Approximately a decade later, the first commercial E-nose has emerged (Gardner et al., 1994). The basic working principle of E-nose is based on the human olfactory system that consists of three main parts; (I) sample delivery part, (II) detection system and (III) computing system that can be learned, recognized and distinguished odors (Shurmer et al., 1990, Shurmer and Gardner, 1992, Wongchoosuk et al., 2009). For the sample delivery part, the sample is injected into a clean air carrier to the instrument. The direct diffusion of sample into sensor chamber is also usually found. After sensor signals reach to equilibrium stage or a fixed time, the clean air/inert gases are served as gas flushing to clean the sensor response into the baseline values. In the detection part, there are multiple gas sensors embedded in the sensor chamber to interact with various types of aroma molecules at room/high operating temperature. The computing system includes the pattern recognition algorithms to eliminate the background interferences, analyze the electrical signal data and identify the desired aroma (Zhang et al., 2013, Mirshahi et al., 2017). Various statistical techniques such as principal component analysis, (PCA) (Bedoui et al., 2018, Dittrich et al., 2021), artificial neural network (ANN) (Fu et al., 2007, Zou and Lv, 2020, Timsorn et al., 2016, Sun et al., 2021), support vector machine (SVM) (Timsorn et al., 2017, Kok et al., 2021) and cluster analysis (CA) (Falasconi et al., 2012, Xu et al., 2020) have been usually employed. Based on these three main parts of E-nose system, the gas sensors in detection system may be considered as the crucial component that contributes to the response of target odors in various E-nose applications (Zohora et al., 2013, Nazemi et al., 2019). For this reason, researchers worldwide have been trying to investigate a new gas sensor array leading to the enhanced performances and high accuracy of E-nose system that can be applied to several different sectors (Karakaya et al., 2020). The typical resistive-type gas sensor structure consists of substrate, electrodes, and sensing films. The heater may be integrated into sensor structure in case of MOS sensing materials due to their working principle on high operating temperature. In case of other gas sensors such as electrochemical sensors, they include membrane to specify gas/VOCs diffusion and electrolyte for the electrochemical reaction between the sensitive elements and the detected gas/VOCs molecules to generate electrical signals. The type of sensing material plays an important role for design circuits and data analysis for E-nose system. For practical application in agriculture, the gas sensors in an E-nose should be high sensitivity to various functional groups, high stability, less effect on temperature and humidity, and wide range of detection.
The discovery of graphene in 2004 and its exceptional ability to detect even a single gas molecules attracted worldwide efforts to explore sensing nanomaterials for gas sensing applications (Schedin et al., 2007). The bar diagram in Fig. 1, depicts the exponentially increasing number of publications over the years. In 2004, only 9 articles were published on nanomaterial-based gas sensors and the number of publications rises to 186 articles in 2020. To normalize the number of nanomaterial-based gas sensors publications against number of papers based on agriculture sensors (searching by using keyword “agriculture sensor”) in the same year, the ratio of papers contribution on nanomaterial-based gas sensors is currently in a range of 10–12%. It should be noted that the MOS gas sensors own micro/nano structured gas sensors. The E-nose based on MOS gas sensors could potentially be used agriculture robotics, pattern recognition, quality control, gas chromatography and air quality applications as depicted by the network in Fig. 2. Moreover, there have been several researches about the integration of gas sensors with other technologies, including wearable e-textiles technology (Lee et al., 2021, Li et al., 2019, Seesaard et al., 2015, Yun et al., 2015) and wireless communication technology (Park et al., 2016, Deng et al., 2016, Chiou and Wu, 2017). However, until now, a comprehensive review of the E-nose technologies based on gas sensors for applications of agricultural cycle is still limited.
This paper provides a review of the recent advances in the development of gas sensors including MOS, conducting polymer, nanomaterials in the E-nose technologies related to the agricultural cycle. The topics can be classified according to three main sections behind smart farm management solutions include: (I) cultivation preparation section, (II) crop production section and (III) harvesting and storage section. Firstly, gas sensors for the cultivation preparation section have been presented with soil quality assessment, adding organic fertilizers and water management. Secondary, gas sensors for the crop production section were used to anticipate and prevent damage from diseases and pests. Additionally, gas sensors were employed to elevate the quality of products to be safe from chemical contamination in the crop production process. Finally, gas sensors for the harvesting and storage section have been revealed in context of the development of real-time odor detection storage containers to reduce post-harvest losses and improved quality of products for maturation process monitoring such as fruit and vegetables stored in different conditions and also extended shelf life and transportability of food supplies. Most of this content will be placing more emphasis on depth of using gas sensing technologies to reduce production costs and increase crop yield and preventive maintenance and handling. In addition, a combination of gas sensors device and internet of things (IoT) can be improved farm management using digital technology. The schematic diagram as shown in Fig. 3 provides an overview of the entire literature review of this article.
Section snippets
Gas sensors for farm management of agricultural cycle
In the twenty-first century, world agriculture is entering to the era of technological paradigm shifting towards smart agriculture. Over the years in developed countries, there has been a transformation from the traditional agriculture to the modern agriculture that emphasizes the integration of technology and agricultural practices for creating efficiencies in the agricultural production process. Two major shifts in agricultural sector can be seen clearly into two dominant patterns: (I) The
Gas sensors for the cultivation preparation section
Land degradation and crop diseases are two major problems in agriculture sector from the past to the present (Thomas, 2008, Newbery et al., 2016, Fu et al., 2020). Soil quality is considered as the first important factor in the cultivation besides water supplies, weather, insect and disease problems (Maurya et al., 2020). Loamy soils having a mixture of organic matter are suitable to plant growth, but unfortunately, when soil resources are misused for long time resulting in minerals depletion
Gas sensors for the crop production section
During the process of plant growth, the necessary step is keeping plants healthy and protecting plants from an infestation of insects and most other pests. Today, most of the research has described the knowledge about insect management and many different approaches to diagnosing plant disease problems. In the modern agriculture, researchers are often focused on the problem-solving techniques based on being environmentally friendly concept. For examples, vegetable was grown in greenhouses to
Gas sensors for the harvesting and storage section
Harvesting can be considered as the final stage of basic agricultural practices which utilize many technologies to serve the specific needs based on the type of produce being harvested. E-nose will play an important role in determining fruit ripeness. According to research reports, it was found that E-nose technologies were used to classify the degree of ripeness of many fruits at harvest. For examples, the commercial MSGS-4000 microsensor array (Silsens, Newchatel, Switzerland) based on four
Bibliometric analysis
To further analysis of publication and the distribution of E-nose in agricultural applications, a bibliometric analysis (Silveira et al., 2021, Tao et al., 2021) was employed. Based on Scopus database, total publications from 1999 to 2021 are 106 papers searched by using keywords of “electronic nose” and “agriculture” on November 15, 2021. It includes 41 articles, 47 conference papers, 14 review articles, 3 book chapters and 1 conference review article. Top countries for the most contribution
Conclusion and future trend
Progress in gas sensors and statistical data analysis helps to open up the new opportunities towards the state-of-the-art applications of E-nose. In agricultural cycle, there have been efforts to apply the gas sensors and E-nose to monitor the soil quality for cultivation, the maintenance of cultivated plants and the harvesting process. The main benefits of these technologies are fast, non-destructive measurements, real time monitoring, and easy to integration into online platform. Combined
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by Office of the Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Higher Education, Science, Research and Innovation (Grant No. RGNS 63-197) and Kasetsart University Research and Development Institute (KURDI) under the grant number FF(KU) 25.64.
References (195)
- et al.
A review on polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: Source, environmental impact, effect on human health and remediation
Egypt. J. Pet.
(2016) - et al.
Upscaling of an electronic nose for completely stirred tank reactor stability monitoring from pilot-scale to real-scale agricultural co-digestion biogas plant
Bioresour. Technol.
(2015) - et al.
Mint treatment day prediction using a multi-sensors system and machine learning algorithms
Sens. Actuators, A
(2021) - et al.
Hydroxyl edge-functionalized graphene quantum dots for gas-sensing applications
Diam. Relat. Mater.
(2020) - et al.
Evaluation of a portable MOS electronic nose to detect root rots in shade tree species
Comput. Electron. Agric.
(2013) - et al.
Detection of potato brown rot and ring rot by electronic nose: from laboratory to real scale
Talanta
(2014) - et al.
Electronic nose as an innovative tool for the diagnosis of grapevine crown gall
Anal. Chim. Acta
(2010) - et al.
3D printed CuO semiconducting gas sensor for ammonia detection at room temperature
Mater. Sci. Semicond. Process.
(2021) - et al.
Fabrication of a sensitive gas sensor based on PPy/TiO2 nanocomposites films by layer-by-layer self-assembly and its application in food storage
Sens. Actuators, B
(2016) - et al.
Combining multivariate cumulative sum control charts with principal component analysis and partial least squares model to detect sickness behaviour in dairy cattle
Comput. Electron. Agric.
(2021)
An electronic nose for royal delicious apple quality assessment - A tri-layer approach
Food Res Int.
A review on analysis methods, source identification, and cancer risk evaluation of atmospheric polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons
Sci Total Environ.
A pattern recognition method for electronic noses based on an olfactory neural network
Sens. Actuators, B
Application of electronic nose with MOS sensors to prediction of rapeseed quality
Measurement
A brief history of electronic noses
Sens. Actuators, B
Detecting stink bugs/damage in cotton utilizing a portable electronic nose
Comput. Electron. Agric.
Recognition and sensing of organic compounds using analytical methods, chemical sensors, and pattern recognition approaches
Chemometr. Intell. Lab. Syst.
Support vector machine in precision agriculture: A review
Comput. Electron. Agric.
Nitrogen-doped carbon oxide quantum dots for flexible humidity sensor: Experimental and SCC-DFTB study
Vacuum
The effects of compost incorporation on soil physical properties in urban soils - A concise review
J. Environ Manage.
Development of a portable electronic nose for detection of pests and plant damage
Comput. Electron. Agric.
One-step and large-scale fabrication of flexible and wearable humidity sensor based on laser-induced graphene for real-time tracking of plant transpiration at bio-interface
Biosens Bioelectron.
Identification of stink bugs using an electronic nose
J. Bionic Eng. Suppl.
Gas sensor array for blueberry fruit disease detection and classification
Postharvest Biol. Technol.
Soil microalgae and cyanobacteria: the biotechnological potential in the maintenance of soil fertility and health
Crit. Rev. Biotechnol.
SnO2 nanowire-based aerosol jet printed electronic nose as fire detector
IEEE Sens. J.
Detection of ripeness grades of berries using an electronic nose
Food Science and Nutrition.
Electronic nose based on independent component analysis combined with partial least squares and artificial neural networks for wine prediction
Sensors (Basel).
A wireless and portable electronic nose to differentiate musts of different ripeness degree and grape varieties
Sensors (Basel).
Soil water availability for plants as quantified by conventional available water, least limiting water range and integral water capacity
Plant Soil
Soil organic matter characterization by Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass Spectrometry (FTICR MS): A critical review of sample preparation, analysis, and data Interpretation
Environ Sci Technol.
Electronic nose calibration process for monitoring atmospheric hazards in confined space applications
J. Telecommun. Electron. Comput. Eng.
Spoilage identification of beef using an electronic nose system
Trans. Am. Soc. Agric. Eng.
Electronic nose system and principal component analysis technique for gases identification
Sensors, Circuits Instrum. Syst.
Non-invasive method to detect infection with Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex in wild boar by measurement of volatile organic compounds obtained from feces with an electronic nose system
Sensors (Basel).
Evaluating soil moisture status using an e-nose
Sensors (Basel).
Evaluation of hydrocarbon soil pollution using e-nose
Sensors (Basel).
Sensor-based outdoor monitoring of insects in arable crops for their precise control
Pest Manag Sci.
Discrimination of COPD and lung cancer from controls through breath analysis using a self-developed e-nose
J. Breath Res.
Application of electronic nose as a non-invasive technique for odor fingerprinting and detection of bacterial foodborne pathogens: a review
J. Food Sci Technol.
Deliberate enhancement of rainfall using desert plantations
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
Early detection of bacterial diseases in apple plants by analysis of volatile organic compounds profiles and use of electronic nose
Ann. Appl. Biol.
Electronic nose and SPME techniques to monitor phenanthrene biodegradation in soil
Sens. Actuators, B
Use of electronic nose technology to measure soil microbial activity through biogenic volatile organic compounds and gases release
Soil Biol. Biochem.
High-performance resistive humidity sensor based on Ag nanoparticles decorated with graphene quantum dots
R. Soc. Open Sci.
Discrimination of different types damage of tomato seedling by electronic nose
ITM Web of Conferences.
Development of a dual MOS electronic nose/camera system for improving fruit ripeness classification
Sensors (Basel).
Development of neural network-based electronic nose for herbs recognition
Int. J. Smart Sens. Intell. Syst.
Cited by (59)
Electronic nose for detecting Colletotrichum coccodes causing anthracnose fruit rots in tomatoes
2024, Smart Agricultural TechnologyRecent methods in detection of olive oil adulteration: State-of- the-Art
2024, Journal of Agriculture and Food ResearchAdvanced evaluation techniques: Gas sensor networks, machine learning, and chemometrics for fraud detection in plant and animal products
2024, Sensors and Actuators A: PhysicalRapid identification of pesticides in soil by bionic sniffing sensing system with unknown category detection function
2024, Computers and Electronics in Agriculture