An intelligent supplier evaluation, selection and development system
Graphical abstract
Highlight
► The proposed method not only selects the best supplier(s), also clusters all of the vendors with respect to fuzzy similarity degrees. ► All evaluation criteria ratings are regarded separately for each supplier to group them in a high degree of accuracy. ► In this study we discover the most critical and important features of the suppliers, extract the decision rules which are used to characterize the supplier data. ► The proposed system is very flexible and can be easily applied to other multi-criteria decision making problems.
Introduction
A supply chain management (SCM) is a system consists of three key parts, which are: the supply focuses on obtaining raw materials to manufacturing, the manufacturing focuses on converting obtained raw materials into finished products and the distribution focuses on reaching these finished products to customers through distributors, warehouses and retailers. Supply chain activities begin with customer orders and end with customer satisfactions. Selection of suppliers plays a critical role in an organization because it heavily contributes to the overall performance of a supply chain system. Assessing suppliers and selecting suitable ones among them a complex and critical decision making problem due to considering several criteria such as quality, cost, service, production lead time and environmental impact [19]. Eventually firms should select the most appropriate suppliers, because significant supplier selection reduces the purchasing cost and improves corporate competitiveness however inaccurate selection of supplier may lead to problems of finance and operation.
In the literature, there are several approaches as linear weighting methods, total cost approaches, mathematical programming techniques, statistical methods and artificial intelligence approaches have been proposed for supplier selection and evaluation process, they mostly locks onto ranking the suppliers and selecting the most appropriate suppliers. However in this paper, all the vendors are clustered by similarity degrees among them so not only the most appropriate supplier is determined but also the supplier categories and the membership degrees to them are determined. With this aspect, the proposed approach makes the decision making process much more flexible. Furthermore, in the literature the majority of researches have focused on supplier selection or evaluation or development separately, but despite that, we focus on an integrated flexible and efficient decision making model for supplier selection, evaluation and development.
The proposed model can cope better with uncertainty than conventional methods because it is designed to be more like human decision making functioning by its clustering, rule induction and feature extraction modules. In the clustering module, suppliers are clustered with a fuzzy clustering algorithm – fuzzy c means (FCM) – to evaluate their performance and similarities degrees. For every vendor, the membership degrees to different clusters are calculated. Unlike traditional hard clustering schemes, such as k-means, that assign each data point to a specific cluster, the FCM algorithm employs fuzzy partitioning such that each data point belongs to a cluster to some degree specified by a membership grade [11]. If data groups are well-separated, the hard clustering approach can be a natural solution. However, if the clusters are overlapped and some of data belong partially to several clusters, then fuzzy clustering is a natural way to describe this situation. In this case, the membership degree of a data object to a cluster is a value from the interval [0, 1].
In terms of supplier selection, supplier can be described by large scaled attributes, which can be represented with features in the view of machine learning. Indeed the weights of these attributes considered differently while we are evaluating suppliers. So some intelligent methods should be used to determine the most critical and important supplier attributes. The feature extraction methods in machine learning are used to find which attributes are more efficient and important in a clustering or classification model. In the rule induction and feature extraction module of the proposed model, decision rules for these clusters are defined then the most efficient criteria in decision making process are discovered by a feature selection method based on RST and these criteria considered as the most important features for further supplier development process. This extraction would be also very valuable for the supplier firms. They can try to improve these attributes primarily to be preferred at the next time. A case study is conducted to illustrate the proposed system. The system can also be easily implemented with different real supplier selection problems.
Although all of these proposed supplier selection models have useful and interesting principles, none of them is an integrated long-term relationship system as our system which presents the supplier evaluation rules due to fuzzy clusters and the attributes of suppliers due to their importance degrees. Therefore, there is a space for the development of new intelligent approaches toward effective support in the evaluation of suppliers, mainly for long-term relationships, characterized by the important supplier attributes. Beyond these, the classification methods must use the previous experiences to evaluate the performance levels of the available suppliers. However, if the supplier evaluation is realized due to a hard or fuzzy clustering algorithm, the past experiences are not required any more. This point is the one of the important reasons of selecting the FCM algorithm as a machine learning technique for this study. After the clusters are formed the second important point is to represent these clusters accurately. The rough set technique is generally used as a classifier and rule extractor in the literature. But it cannot be very sufficient to extract confident rules when it is used as a classifier method. On the other hand, rough set is a very robust rule and core attribute extractor. Therefore the rough set is applied on the clusters formed by FCM which is the most efficient fuzzy clustering algorithm. Briefly, this paper contributes to the state-of-art of the supplier selection problem, presenting a new and novel approach that integrates FCM and RST to construct a long-term relationship with suppliers.
The rest of the paper is organized as follows: Section 2 surveys relevant literature. Section 3 provides brief background knowledge about FCM and RST. The proposed system and obtained results from a sample supplier selection problem are presented in Section 4. The final section discusses the findings and concludes with a summary of this study and future directions.
Section snippets
Literature review
Extensive multi-criteria decision making approaches have been proposed in the literature for supplier selection and evaluation, such as the analytic hierarchy process (AHP), analytic network process (ANP), case-based reasoning (CBR), data envelopment analysis (DEA), multi-objective programming (MOP), fuzzy set theory, genetic algorithms (GA), mathematical programming models, simple multi-attribute rating technique (SMART), artificial neural networks (ANN) and the hybrid approaches. There are
Background knowledge
In this section, the brief overviews of relevant concepts such as FCM and RST with the proposed system are provided.
Computational results
To test the contribution of the proposed system, a supplier dataset adopted from Talluri and Narasimhan [38] is used. Wu [43] tested their model with the same dataset as well. This dataset is referred as TN data and is derived from multinational telecommunications company which is a global design, production and marketing leader of communication systems. It operates production plants, research and development facilities, and distribution systems globally.
TN data contains capabilities and
Discussion and conclusions
Supplier evaluation and selection problems have been solved by several methods in literature such as linear weighting methods, total cost approaches, mathematical programming methods, statistical methods and AI methods. Through them, AI methods designed to be more like human judgment functioning and can cope better with the complexity.
This study presents an effective hybrid system by FCM and RST for solving supplier selection, evaluation and development problem. With the proposed system, the
References (45)
- et al.
Evaluating supplier development programs with a grey based rough set methodology
Expert Systems with Applications
(2011) - et al.
Integrating sustainability into supplier selection with grey system and rough set methodologies
International Journal of Production Economics
(2010) - et al.
Green supplier development: analytical evaluation using rough set theory
Journal of Cleaner Production
(2010) - et al.
A study of using RST to create the supplier selection model and decision-making rules
Expert Systems with Applications
(2010) - et al.
A hybrid approach for supplier cluster analysis
Computers and Mathematics with Applications
(2010) Clustering and selecting suppliers based on simulated annealing algorithms
Computers and Mathematics with Applications
(2012)- et al.
A fuzzy approach for supplier evaluation and selection in supply chain management
International Journal of Production Economics
(2006) - et al.
Developing an SVM based risk hedging prediction model for construction material suppliers
Automation in Construction
(2010) - et al.
A fuzzy c-means clustering-based fragile watermarking scheme for image authentication
Expert Systems with Applications
(2009) - et al.
A hybrid forecast marketing timing model based on probabilistic neural network, rough set and C4.5
Expert Systems with Applications
(2010)
A review of methods supporting supplier selection
European Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management
Combining Bayesian networks and total cost of ownership method for supplier selection analysis
Computers & Industrial Engineering
A fuzzy-Bayesian model for supplier selection
Expert Systems with Applications
Supplier selection based on hierarchical potential support vector machine
Expert Systems with Applications
Multi-criteria decision making approaches for supplier evaluation and selection: a literature review
European Journal of Operational Research
Supplier selection using a novel intuitionist fuzzy clustering approach
Applied Soft Computing
A review of soft computing applications in supply chain management
Applied Soft Computing
Integration of particle swarm optimization-based fuzzy neural network and artificial neural network for supplier selection
Applied Mathematical Modelling
A material supplier selection model for property developers using Fuzzy Principal Component Analysis
Automation in Construction
A neural networks approach for forecasting the supplier's bid prices in supplier selection negotiation process
Expert Systems with Applications
A confirmation technique for predictive maintenance using the Rough Set Theory
Computers & Industrial Engineering
Rough set based approaches to feature selection for case-based reasoning classifiers
Journal Pattern Recognition Letters
Cited by (83)
Decision-making models for formulating and evaluating supplier development programs: A state-of-the-art review and research paths
2023, Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation ReviewA comprehensive framework and literature review of supplier selection under different purchasing strategies
2022, Computers and Industrial EngineeringApplication of gray DEMATEL-ANP in green-strategic sourcing
2021, Technology in SocietySupply chain mapping for improving “visilience”: A hybrid multi-criteria decision making based methodology
2023, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis