Elsevier

Aquaculture

Volume 317, Issues 1–4, 4 July 2011, Pages 214-222
Aquaculture

Use of hapas to produce Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus L.) seed in household foodfish ponds: A participatory trial with small-scale farming households in Northwest Bangladesh

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2011.04.005Get rights and content

Abstract

Seed production of Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus L.) in nylon mesh net cages (hapas) was tested through a participatory on-farm trial with households in NW Bangladesh. A total of 43 households with small ponds (0.04–0.08 ha) located close to the homesteads were sampled from poor to medium social groups in three communities: Tarala Banara (TB), Dewnaghata (DW) and Dola Para (DP). Broodfish of GIFT strain Nile tilapia (12 female and 6 male; 60 g size) were stocked in a single spawning hapa (3 × 2 × 1 m). Swim-up fry were collected from breeding hapas at 15 day intervals and stocked alternately in two nursing hapas (1.5 × 1 × 1 m). With the exception of 15 households at DP in which flooding caused loss of fish, most of the households in TB and DW produced tilapia fry from hapas for 4–5 months in addition to the usual production of foodfish/fingerlings in their ponds. Mean swim-up fry production in TB and DW was 5185 ± 3764 and 3415 ± 1536 fry household 1, leading to nursed fry production of 2708 ± 1967 and 1380 ± 734 fry household 1 respectively. Nursed fry were sold (70%) or re-stocked (30%) for foodfish production in the participants' own ponds. Only households with perennial ponds that were able to hold and rear tilapia broodfish (25% of total households at TB and DW) successfully produced seed in Year 2, but such households started earlier in the season (March) and achieved significantly higher productivity than the previous year. Hapa productivity was impacted by local soil type, presence of shade, depth of mud and level of drainage inputs; more fry were produced in ponds based on sandy and sandy-loam soils with less overhanging vegetation and shade, lower levels of turbidity and benthic mud, and no drainage connections with tube wells or surface run-off. Poorer households were more successful overall and tended to prioritise sale of fry over retention for foodfish culture Households engaged in ancillary fry trading and/or nursery businesses also tended to be relatively successful.

Between 8 and 20 customers were supplied by each hapa operator, indicating the broader impacts of local seed production on grow-out for foodfish production.

Introduction

Production and supply of fish seed-stock are essential for the promotion of aquaculture. Traditional inland aquaculture was based on the collection of seed-stock from rivers and required the sorting and acclimatising of mixed species. Fine meshed nylon net cages ‘hapas’ have been used for this purpose for Chinese carps in China (FAO, 1962, Lin, 1949) and in Bangladesh and India for Indian major carp for a long time (Bardach et al., 1972, FAO, 1962). Hapa nursing of small fry to larger, more predator-resistant fingerlings has been the focus for intensification of aquaculture in North East Thailand and Lao PDR (Edwards et al., 1990, Haitook et al., 1999, Little et al., 1991).

Several studies have indicated that tilapia contribute more than other cultured species to meeting the food security needs of resource-poor people in parts of rural Bangladesh; women and children catch small tilapia themselves in homestead water bodies using hook and line (Ahmed et al., 1997, Barman et al., 2002, Barman and Little, 2006, Haque, 2007, Haque et al., 2006) . Performance trials of the GIFT strain Nile tilapia showed significant improvements over the local strains in Bangladesh (Dey, 2000) but more widespread benefits require timely and consistent supply of seed to rural fish producers. A lack of hatchery technologies that allow a predictable output of quality fingerlings have constrained tilapia culture in several contexts (Little and Hulata, 2000). The high degree of control of broodfish that is possible using fine meshed nylon net cages or ‘hapas’ has made them popular for both breeding and nursing tilapia seed-stock at several levels of intensity (Beveridge, 2004, Guerrero and Garcia, 1983; Hughes and Behrends, 1983, Little et al., 1993, Mair and Little, 1991) and can result in high quality mixed-sex fish (Little, 2004) of the same age and size (Dan and Little, 2000, Little et al., 2003). Hapa production may be particularly appropriate in marginal rain-fed areas with prolonged dry seasons and shortages of surface water. In such areas, demand for fish seed peaks early in the wet season in synchrony with seed production from hapas suspended in perennial water ponds.

Lack of access to land and water typically constrains the resource-poor from benefiting directly from aquaculture (Lewis, 1997) and the hatchery sector tends to be dominated by entrepreneurs and wealthier farmers (Barman and Little, 2006). Recent studies suggest that fish culture is increasingly widespread in small ponds and ditches, typically those located close to the homesteads of households with limited agricultural land (Karim, 2006). Location of ponds has been identified as a critical factor in the level of sustained management of such small water bodies (Arjinkit et al., 2006) and participation in their management by women (Barman, 2001). The development of appropriate technologies and management approaches for resource-poor households requires their participation, which can in turn improve their capacity for self-experimentation (Cramb et al., 2004, Fleisher et al., 2002). This paper presents the results of an on-farm trial with farming households in NW Bangladesh over two years to assess the adoptability and performance of. hapa-based seed production.

Section snippets

Community and household selection

The study was conducted in three communities, Tarala Banara (TB), Dewnaghata (DW) in Kaharole and Dola Para (DP) in the Parbatipur Sub-district (Upazila) of Dinajpur District in NW Bangladesh. A Government centralised seed production facility for carps and a fish seed market was located in Parbatipur close to DP. The communities of TB and DW are located 50–60 km away from Parbatipur and have comparatively fewer facilities. Key informants identified every household in the three communities as

Fry production

Tilapia seed production in hapas in ponds was technically most successful at TB, intermediate at DW and largely unsuccessful at DP where flash flooding of hapas by rains caused loss of stock from hapas and led to the activity being completely discontinued after two months (Fig. 1). Most households continued production at TB and all households completed a total of nine seed harvests during the season at DW. Three households at TB discontinued their production because of flash flooding resulting

Discussion

The appropriateness of hapa-based tilapia seed production for poor rural people in NW Bangladesh was demonstrated in this study. The key technical and socio-economic factors that affected the success of hapa spawning and nursing were also identified as were broader benefits of such a decentralised seed strategy in the promotion of rural aquaculture.

Hapa-based production was a simple and adoptable method that could be integrated in ponds producing foodfish and for a range of specific farming

Acknowledgements

The study was part of Benoy Kumar Barman's dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Technical Science supported by the Department of International Development (DFID) and assisted by the Northwest Fisheries Extension Project (NFEP-2), Bangladesh and the WorldFish Center SA Office. Prof. Peter Edwards, Dr. Harvey Demaine and Dr. Govind Kelkar are acknowledged as committee members. The authors wish to thanks DFID, NFEP, CARITAS and others who directly or indirectly helped for the study. The study

References (39)

  • B.K. Barman et al.

    Small-scale fish culture in northwest Bangladesh — a participatory appraisal focusing on the role of tilapias

  • B.K. Barman et al.

    Tilapia and common carp fingerling production in rice fields of farmers in northwest Bangladesh: adoption and dissemination strategies

  • M.C.M. Beveridge

    Cage aquaculture

    (2004)
  • C.E. Boyd et al.

    Pond bottom soils

  • M.C.J. Broussard et al.

    Evaluation of hatchery management schemes for large scale production of Oreochromis niloticus fingerlings in Central Luzon, Philippines: 414–424

  • M. Dey

    The impact of genetically improved farmed Nile tilapia in Asia

    Aquaculture Economics and Management

    (2000)
  • P. Edwards et al.

    Towards the improvement of fish culture by small-scale fish farmers in northeast Thailand

  • S.C. Ellis et al.

    Effect of initial age variation on production of Florida red tilapia fry under intensive, brackishwater tank culture

    Aquaculture Research

    (1993)
  • FAO

    Handbook on fish culture in the Indo-Pacific Region

  • Cited by (25)

    • Problems and prospects of fish farming in the Chattogram Hill Tracts of Bangladesh: Community-based aquaculture might be a right choice

      2024, Aquaculture and Fisheries
      Citation Excerpt :

      Small-scale aquaculture can significantly improve the livelihoods of marginalized peoples, including ethnic minorities. For this, expansion of aquaculture is necessary with due consideration for social, economic, and environmental aspects (Barman & Little, 2011). Fish serves as one of the cheapest and most digestible proteins and meet nutritional needs, particularly in the hilly regions of northeast India.

    • Optimization of 17α-methyltestosterone dose to produce quality mono-sex Nile tilapia Oreochromis niloticus

      2022, Heliyon
      Citation Excerpt :

      The rearing pond was 4050 m2 in size with 1.53 m average depth. A total of fifteen synthetic nylon hapas, covering 5 m3 size each, have been employed in 5 columns and 3 rows, and fixed tightly using bamboo poles followed by the previous description (Argue, 1995; Barman and Little, 2011). Four treatments and one control each with 3 replications were used for this experiment.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text