Are Current Law Enforcement Strategies Associated with a Lower Risk of Repeat Speeding Citations and Crash Involvement? A Longitudinal Study of Speeding Maryland Drivers
Introduction
Speeding threatens public health worldwide 1, 2, 3 by increasing both motor vehicle crash risk and likelihood of crash mortality and morbidity 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19. In the United States, speeding contributes to one third of fatal crashes, an estimated 11,674 deaths in 2008 (20). A primary countermeasure for speeding is enforcing speed limits by punishing lawbreakers. License suspension/revocation significantly reduced subsequent traffic violations and crashes (21) and traffic convictions, especially speeding convictions that included points, reduced involvement in fatal crashes for several months after the conviction (22). Despite these measures, speeding remains widespread 23, 24, 25; active police enforcement reduces speeding around the targeted area for a limited period after it ends 26, 27. More severe penalties were not associated with fewer subsequent speeding citations (28).
It is unclear how to maximize the effectiveness of speeding enforcement. Law enforcement can be understood as a behavior modification system that includes negative feedback for undesirable behavior and attempts to modify individual attitudes. Individual perceptions, interpersonal influences, and community settings all affect behavior (29).
In Maryland, drivers who receive speeding tickets can elect to pay fines by mail or appear in traffic court, where cases can be upheld, dismissed, or changed to less severe charges and penalties. In traffic court, communications between judges and ticketed drivers are analogous to tailored individual health communication between physicians and patients (30). Traffic court proceedings, coupled with other negative consequences of speeding citations, may provide a stronger deterrent to speeding violations than paying fines by mail. Relatively little is known about the impact of traffic court appearance and its differing verdicts on road safety among speeding drivers. In this study, we investigated the associations of court appearance and the different verdicts rendered for a speeding ticket with both subsequent speeding citations and police-reported crashes by following a cohort of licensed Maryland drivers ticketed for speeding from 2003 to 2006.
Section snippets
Data Sources
We used Maryland driver licensure data from the Maryland Motor Vehicle Administration, traffic citation and court disposition data from Maryland District Court, and crash data from the Maryland Automated Accident Reporting System, and merged them using driver license numbers.
Study Sample and Design
We identified 30,603 individuals with a valid Maryland non-commercial driver license who settled a speeding citation in May/June 2003, and divided them into 2 groups: Those who chose court appearances (54%; n = 16,645) and
Driver Characteristics: Court Appearances and Verdicts
Among drivers who dealt with a speeding citation in May/June 2003, >54% went to court. Compared with drivers who paid fines by mail, they were more likely to be <25 years old, African American, and to have been cited for traveling >20 mph above the speed limit (Table 1). Fewer drivers who went to court lived in zip codes with household incomes >$70,000. In addition, a greater proportion of drivers who went to court had a history of speeding, alcohol-related violations, and crashes.
Once in
Discussion
Our study is among the first to address court verdicts and associated outcomes among speeding drivers. Traffic courts exist in many jurisdictions in the United States, but their impact on traffic safety is unclear. We found that, compared with those who paid fines by mail, drivers who went to court to settle a speeding citation had a significantly higher risk of subsequent crash involvement despite having a significantly lower risk for a repeat speeding citation after adjustment for other
References (50)
Velocity change and fatality risk in a crash—a rule of thumb
Accid Anal Prev
(1993)- et al.
The severity of pedestrian injuries in children: an analysis of the pedestrian injury causation study
Accid Anal Prev
(1990) - et al.
Motor vehicle crash fatalities in the second year of 65 mph speed limits
J Safety Res
(1990) - et al.
The effects of the new 65 mile-per-hour speed limit on rural highway fatalities: a state-by-state analysis
Accid Anal Prev
(1990) - et al.
Problem driver remediation: a meta-analysis of the driver improvement literature
J Saf Res
(2004) - et al.
Traffic-law enforcement and risk of death from motor-vehicle crashes: case-crossover study
Lancet
(2003) - et al.
Exceeding the speed limit: an evaluation of the effectiveness of a police intervention
Accid Anal Prev
(1996) Increased police enforcement: effects on speed
Accid Anal Prev
(1997)- et al.
Characteristics of speeders
J Saf Res
(2006) - et al.
Using traffic conviction correlates to identify high accident-risk drivers
Accid Anal Prev
(2003)
Estimating the accident potential of an Ontario driver
Accid Anal Prev
On preventing drunk driving recidivism: an examination of rehabilitation and punishment approaches
Journal of Criminal Justice
Intelligent speed adaptation: accident savings and cost-benefit analysis
Accid Anal Prev
Road speed: health impact and counteractive measures—scientific review
Speed, road injury, and public health
Annu Rev Public Health
Accidents on main rural highways related to speed, driver and vehicle
Traveling speed and the risk of crash involvement
Driving speeds and pedestrian safety in the city of Helsinki
Traffic Eng Contr
Driving speeds and pedestrian safety: a mathematical model
Speed management in Sweden
The effects of increased speed limits in the post-NMSL era
A review of risk factors for child pedestrian injuries: are they modifiable?
Inj Prev
Experiences with speed limits in the USA
Cited by (20)
Subsequent risky driving behaviors, recidivism and crashes among drivers with a traffic violation: A scoping review
2023, Accident Analysis and PreventionEffectiveness of a fixed speed camera traffic enforcement system in a developing country
2023, Ain Shams Engineering JournalAddressing endogeneity in modeling speed enforcement, crash risk and crash severity simultaneously
2022, Analytic Methods in Accident ResearchCitation Excerpt :For these regular commuters, the information set of a higher level of major speeding citations along these corridors may instigate higher levels of perceived apprehension resulting in more cautious driving behavior. For example, Li et al. (2011) reported that the drivers ticketed for speeding are likely to be associated with a lower level of subsequent speeding citations. Therefore, the result associated with speeding ticket propensity on crash risk is perhaps an indication that stringent enforcement of posted speed limit is highly likely to improve the overall safety in these locations.
Classifying and predicting risky driving among novice drivers: A group-based trajectory approach
2019, Journal of Safety ResearchCitation Excerpt :Despite the tremendous efforts made in recent years toward improving overall health status of adolescents, motor-vehicle crashes continue to be the most frequent cause of death for young individuals in the United States (Center for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC], 2017). Driving outcomes are not evenly distributed within the young driver population as some teenage drivers have no crashes and others have several (Simons-Morton, Hartos, Leaf, & Preusser, 2006; Simons-Morton et al., 2011a, Li et al., 2011; O'Malley & Johnston, 2003). Classifying adolescents according to their driving outcomes can increase the efficiency of targeted interventions to improve teen driving.