Articles
Associations between early-life screen viewing and 24 hour movement behaviours: findings from a longitudinal birth cohort study

https://doi.org/10.1016/S2352-4642(19)30424-9Get rights and content

Summary

Background

Screen viewing is a sedentary behaviour reported to interfere with sleep and physical activity. However, few longitudinal studies have assessed such associations in children of preschool age (0–6 years) and none have accounted for the compositional nature of these behaviours. We aimed to investigate the associations between total and device-specific screen viewing time at age 2–3 years and accelerometer-measured 24 h movement behaviours, including sleep, sedentary behaviour, light physical activity, and moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) at age 5·5 years.

Methods

The Growing Up in Singapore Towards healthy Outcomes (GUSTO) study is an ongoing longitudinal birth cohort study in Singapore, which began in June 2009. We recruited pregnant women during their first ultrasound scan visit at two major public maternity units in Singapore. At clinic visits done at age 2–3 years, we collected parent-reported information about children's daily total and device-specific screen viewing time (television, handheld devices, and computers). At 5·5 years, children's movement behaviours for 7 consecutive days were measured using wrist-worn accelerometers. We assessed the associations between screen viewing time and movement behaviours (sedentary behaviour, light physical activity, MVPA, and sleep) using Dirichlet regression, which accounts for the compositional nature of such behaviours. This study is active but not recruiting and is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT01174875.

Findings

Between June 1, 2009, and Oct 12, 2010, 1247 pregnant women enrolled and 1171 singleton births were enrolled. 987 children had parent-reported screen data at either 2 or 3 years, of whom 840 attended the clinic visit at age 5·5 years, and 577 wore an accelerometer. 552 children had at least 3 days of accelerometer data and were included in the analysis. Total screen viewing time at age 2–3 years had a significant negative association with sleep (p=0·008), light physical activity (p<0·0001), and MVPA (p<0·0001) in relation to sedentary behaviour at age 5·5 years. Compared with children who spent 1 h or less per day screen viewing at age 2–3 years, children who screen viewed for 3 h or more per day at 2–3 years engaged in more sedentary behaviour (439·8 mins per day [≤1 h screen viewing time] vs 480·0 mins per day [≥3 h screen viewing time]), and less light physical activity (384·6 vs 356·2 mins per day), and MVPA (76·2 vs 63·4 mins per day) at age 5·5 years. No significant differences in time spent sleeping were observed between the groups (539·5 vs 540·4 mins per day). Similar trends were observed for television viewing and handheld device viewing.

Interpretation

Longer screen viewing time in children aged 2–3 years was associated with more time spent engaged in sedentary behaviour and shorter time engaged in light physical activity and MVPA in later childhood. Our findings indicate that screen viewing might displace physical activity during early childhood, and suggest that reducing screen viewing time in early childhood might promote healthier behaviours and associated outcomes later in life.

Funding

Singapore National Research Foundation, and Singapore Institute for Clinical Sciences, Agency for Science Technology and Research (A*STAR).

Introduction

Screen viewing is increasingly prevalent and has become a part of common sedentary behaviour globally. Excessive screen viewing time has been reported to be associated with poorer health outcomes in children, including increased obesity risk, reduced motor and cognitive development, and worse psychosocial health.1 Considering the detrimental effects of excessive sedentary behaviour on health, WHO2 and several countries have developed and issued recommendations to limit screen time to 1 h per day or less among children aged 2–5 years. However, concerns about the recommendation for a universal cutoff for children's overall screen time have been raised,3, 4 considering the relatively weak evidence and the differential effects of different types of screen time.

Research in context

Evidence before this study

Early childhood is a crucial period for developing behavioural habits that persist into adolescence and adulthood. Screen viewing has been suggested to have detrimental effects on child health, including an increased risk for obesity, reduced motor and cognitive development, and poorer psychosocial health. According to an estimation from UNICEF, WHO, and the World Bank, in 2016, more than 41 million children aged younger than 5 years were overweight and obese; the number has continued to increase during the past few years and is estimated to reach more than 50 million by 2030. Possible mechanisms linking screen viewing time with obesity include the inverse associations between screen viewing time and physical activity and sleep. However, the longitudinal effects of screen viewing on movement behaviours within a finite 24 h period are unknown. To identify studies that have assessed the associations between screen viewing time and physical activity, sedentary behaviour, and sleep in children, we searched PubMed from database inception to Sept 17, 2019, for studies published in English using the primary search terms “children”, “screen viewing”, “media use”, “television viewing”, “physical activity”, “exercise”, “fitness”, “sleep” and “movement behaviour”. Most studies assessing associations between screen viewing time and physical activity and sleep included school-aged children (age 6–12 years) and adolescents (age 12–19 years). A systematic review concluded that associations between screen time and physical activity were weak and inconsistent in school-aged children and adolescents. The literature consistently supports the importance of reducing screen viewing time for adequate sleep duration among children and adolescents. We further observed that most of the existing studies reporting on the association between screen viewing time and movement behaviours used a cross-sectional design. No previous study has assessed the associations between screen viewing time and movement behaviours using composition techniques, which take into account the compositional nature of movement behaviours within a defined 24 h period.

Added value of this study

By using analyses that account for compositional time use, we found that longer total and device-specific screen viewing time at age 2–3 years was associated with a higher proportion of time spent on sedentary behaviours and a lower level of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity and light physical activity at age 5·5 years. These findings extend existing research in children of preschool and school age (age 0–12 years) through the use of a longitudinal study design and the objective assessments of all movement behaviours, thereby strengthening the existing evidence linking screen viewing time with later child health.

Implications of all the available evidence

Our analysis addresses an important research gap and establishes a platform for research to further assess the effect of content type, timing, and parental co-use of media with their children on unfavourable movement behaviours. The findings suggest that further research on the longitudinal effects of screen viewing on other movement behaviours is warranted, and support public health efforts to reduce screen viewing time in young children to minimise the possible negative impact on children's health behaviours and general health.

One of the suggested mechanisms through which screen viewing might influence health is by displacing time that would otherwise be spent engaged in physical activity. This proposed hypothesis has, to our knowledge, rarely been investigated in children of preschool age (age 0–6 years), but has been supported by evidence from studies in adolescents. On one hand, some studies have suggested that long periods of screen viewing are strongly associated with decreases in physical activity.5, 6 On the other hand, a previous meta-analysis and a 2013 study reported that such associations are either weak or non-existent.7, 8 As such, evidence on the association between screen viewing time and physical activity is mixed and inconclusive. Inadequate sleep is another possible mechanism linking screen viewing time and poor health. School-aged children (age 6–12 years) and adolescents who spend excessive time watching screens might be more likely to have inadequate sleep, which is usually measured by a lower total sleep time and later bedtimes.9 Such associations are concerning since they develop during infancy and can persist in mid-childhood.10

However, studies investigating the associations between screen viewing time and other behaviours, such as physical activity and sleep, have mainly been done in school-aged children and adolescents (age 12–19 years), and adequate empirical evidence is scarce in young children. Moreover, most previous studies have been largely cross-sectional and thus findings could be affected by reverse causation. Previous studies have focused on conventional electronic devices such as televisions and computers, and little evidence is available regarding newer portable devices such as smartphones and tablets that have broad capabilities (eg, internet). Newer types of screen devices, which allow real-time interaction and potentially continuous stimulation for children, provide a different type of exposure and have become increasingly common in young children.11 Studies have also been criticised for investigating physical activity, sedentary behaviour, and sleep in isolation, or with only partial adjustment for time spent on other behaviours.12, 13 This approach does not account for the fact that an increase in one behaviour might lead to a decrease in at least one of the remaining behaviours.

Physical activity, sedentary behaviour, and sleep represent the movement spectrum across 24 h and are referred to as movement behaviours.13 Since 2016, several individual countries and WHO2 have developed integrated movement guidelines for children, which highlight the importance of targeting all movement behaviours to maximize health benefits. Previous evidence from our GUSTO mother-offspring cohort in Singapore showed that the majority of children aged 5·5 years engaged in excessive screen viewing time, had inadequate sleep, and low levels of physical activity; only one in 20 children met all the integrated guideline targets.14 Such a high prevalence of unfavourable behaviours highlights the necessity of identifying opportunities to improve all these behaviours in young children. Previous studies have repeatedly suggested the conceptualisation of individuals' daily activity data as compositions, consisting of time spent asleep, sedentary behaviour, and different intensities of physical activity (ie, light physical activity and moderate-to-vigorous physical activity [MVPA]), which sum to 24 h.13, 15 24 h movement data require different analytical methods than traditional regressions, to account for their compositional nature. Although composition techniques have been proposed to be valid approaches for analysing a set of variables that sum to a constant16 and implemented in a number of research areas,17, 18 few studies have implemented these techniques in movement behaviour research,15, 19 and no studies have explored how screen viewing behaviour affects these activity components.

To address existing research gaps, we aimed to investigate the associations of total and device-specific screen viewing time at ages 2–3 years with accelerometer-measured movement components, including sleep, sedentary behaviour, light physical activity, and MVPA at age 5·5 years.

Section snippets

Study design

Growing Up in Singapore Towards healthy Outcomes (GUSTO) is an ongoing longitudinal birth cohort study in Singapore, which began in June 2009. The study design and protocols have been reported elsewhere.20 Briefly, pregnant women were recruited during their first ultrasound scan visit at two major public maternity units in Singapore (KK Women's and Children's Hospital and National University Hospital). Pregnant women who were Singaporean citizens or permanent residents of Chinese, Malay, or

Results

Between June 1, 2009, and Oct 12, 2010, 1247 pregnant women enrolled and 1171 singleton births were enrolled. Of the 987 children who had parent-reported screen data at either 2 or 3 years, 840 attended the clinic visit at age 5·5 years, and 577 wore an accelerometer. Of the 577 children who wore an accelerometer, 552 had at least 3 days of accelerometer data and thus were included in the analysis (figure). Children included in the present analysis (552 of 1171 singleton births) were similar to

Discussion

We found that children who spent a longer time viewing screens at age 2–3 years were less likely to spend time sleeping and to engage in light physical activity and MVPA in relation to sedentary behaviour at age 5·5 years compared with children who spent less time viewing screens as toddlers. In absolute terms, children with more screen viewing time in toddlerhood spent more time engaged in sedentary behaviour and less time doing light physical activity and MVPA at older ages. Time spent

Data sharing

The dataset supporting the conclusions of this article can be made available upon request from the corresponding author after approval is obtained from the GUSTO Executive Committee.

References (37)

  • C Forde et al.

    How Children Use Active Videogames and the Association Between Screen Time and Physical Activity

    Games Health J

    (2015)
  • SJ Marshall et al.

    Relationships between media use, body fatness and physical activity in children and youth: a meta-analysis

    Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord

    (2004)
  • TH Fakhouri et al.

    Physical activity and screen-time viewing among elementary school-aged children in the United States from 2009 to 2010

    JAMA Pediatr

    (2013)
  • EM Cespedes et al.

    Television viewing, bedroom television, and sleep duration from infancy to mid-childhood

    Pediatrics

    (2014)
  • JS Radesky et al.

    Mobile and interactive media use by young children: the good, the bad, and the unknown

    Pediatrics

    (2015)
  • Ž Pedišić

    Measurement issues and poor adjustments for physical activity and sleep undermine sedentary behaviour research—the focus should shift to the balance between sleep, sedentary behaviour, standing and activity

    Kinesiology

    (2014)
  • MS Tremblay et al.

    Canadian our Movement Guidelines for Children and Youth: an integration of physical activity, sedentary behaviour, and sleep

    Appl Physiol Nutr Metab

    (2016)
  • B Chen et al.

    Socio-demographic and maternal predictors of adherence to 24-hour movement guidelines in Singaporean children

    Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act

    (2019)
  • Cited by (33)

    • Asia–Pacific consensus statement on integrated 24-hour activity guidelines for the early years

      2023, The Lancet Regional Health - Western Pacific
      Citation Excerpt :

      While some forms of screen viewing can be educational in nature, recreational screen time should not exceed 1 h per day; less is better.43 Recreational screen-based sedentary behaviour displaces physical activity and has detrimental effects on fitness, adiposity, movement behaviours and sleep in early childhood.141,142 Instead of using screen devices for recreational activities, caregivers are encouraged to engage them in reading, drawing or imaginative play where feasible.48,111

    • Screen use and early child development: Risks and benefits

      2023, Encyclopedia of Child and Adolescent Health, First Edition
    • Results from the Singapore 2022 report card on physical activity for children and adolescents

      2023, Journal of Exercise Science and Fitness
      Citation Excerpt :

      When considering 24-h movement behaviour profiles of children from the same study, it was found that behaviours of Singaporean children track with age, and that children shift towards less active and more sedentary lifestyles with increasing age.3 Aside, research in Singapore has also demonstrated that longer screen viewing time in younger children is associated with longer sedentary time and shorter time engaged in physical activity in later childhood.4 This highlights the importance of improving methods of PA promotion in children and adolescents in Singapore.

    • The Development of a Parental Questionnaire (QQ-MediaSEED) on Bilingual Children's Quantity and Quality of Digital Media Use at Home

      2022, Acta Psychologica
      Citation Excerpt :

      For instance, increased screen time in this age group – measured as a combination of time spent on both television and interactive screen devices – is linked to cardiovascular disease and obesity (Poitras et al., 2017) and behavioural problems (Tamana et al., 2019). Two- to three-year-olds in Singapore who spent more than three hours each day viewing screens, using a mix of passive and interactive devices, were also shown to engage in more sedentary behaviour and less exercise, at the age of five and a half, than their peers who had spent less than an hour (Chen et al., 2020). Greater tablet and smartphone use in particular was also associated with longer sleep onset latency and the likelihood of insufficient sleep in preschoolers (Chindamo et al., 2019; Lan et al., 2020; Twenge & Campbell, 2018), while daily smartphone use >15 min was linked to both later sleep and later wake time, as well as poorer sleep consistency (Hiltunen et al., 2021).

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text