Preliminary CommunicationPersonality and object relations in patients with affective disorders: idiographic research by means of the repertory grid technique
Introduction
Studies of personality related dispositions in patients with affective disorders have a long clinical tradition (Kraepelin, 1913, Bleuler, 1922, Sjöbring, 1923, Tellenbach, 1961, Leonhard, 1963, Lauter, 1969, Zerssen, 1977, Hirschfeld and Cross, 1982, Akiskal, 1983, Akiskal et al., 1983, Blankenburg, 1986, Kisker et al., 1987, Möller and Zerssen, 1987, Peters, 1988, Möller, 1992). More recent studies underline the moderating function of the personality in the free interval (Kröber, 1988, Kröber, 1992, Kröber et al., 1998). Various research strategies were developed to answer the question which role interpersonal factors play in relation to etiology, prognosis, therapy and coping with depressive disorders (Halweg, 1991, Mundt, 1991, Corryell et al., 1993).
Some of the personality dimensions investigated by means of standardized personality inventories were only weakly related to the clinically relevant personality constructs (Möller and Zerssen, 1987) The results of factor analyses, cluster analyses and discriminant analyses showed multipolar group structures with permeable boundaries (Steck, 1988). Further relevant dimensions which were neglected until now, can be presumed. Therefore an idiographic approach was chosen (Repertory Grid-Technique) that attempted to develop quantitative measures of subjective data. Thus trait markers of the personality and typical features of the relationships of the different groups of depressive patients were investigated in the so called symptomless interval.
Section snippets
Methods
The study focuses on the subjective appraisal of the self concept and of the self object relations of patients suffering from affective disorders. Dimensions which are significant for the self-esteem regulation and interaction dynamics of depressive patients were empirically explored in the so-called free interval. The one point measurement of individually centred data can be regarded as an initial rapprochement to complex intrapsychic and interactional processes. The aim was to investigate
Sample
One hundred and twenty-seven inpatients affected by an affective and schizoaffective disorder admitted to the psychiatric university hospital of Frankfurt/Main were included into this study. Diagnoses were assigned by two independent psychiatrists on the basis of interviews and medical records, according to ICD10-criteria (Table 1). The final study sample consisted of those patients whose HAMD-score was below 10 prior to dismission. All patients were receiving psychopharmalogical treatment.
Results
The HAMD total score of the depressive sample was 5.66 (S.D. 4.94). It was significantly higher than that of the orthopaedic sample 3.50; (S.D. 2.13, Mann–Whitney U-test: P<0.05).
The self esteem of the depressive sample operationalized on the basis of self-idealself-, self-normative-self-, and idealself-normative self-distances did not differ significantly from that of the controls (Fig. 2). The level of the self esteem did not correlate with sociodemographic characteristics.
Comparing the three
Discussion
This study is the first to use the Repertory Grid Technique in order to assess personality traits and object relations of patients suffering from affective disorders. In contrast to former studies that used standardised personality inventories only the methodological approach of this study permits to record quantitative measurements of subjective phenomena. The evaluation of distribution patterns of the self-idealself–partner relations in the self-ideal–object system revealed that the partners
References (43)
Subaffective disorders: dysthymic, cyclothymic, and bipolar II disorders in the ‘borderline’ realm
Psychiatr. Clin. North Am.
(1983)- et al.
The relationship of personality to affective disorders
Arch. Gen. Psychiatry
(1983) Die Selbst-Identitäts-Grafik (SIG)
Persönlichkeit, prämorbide
Die Probleme der Schizoidie und Syntonie
Z. ges. Neurol. Psychiatr.
(1922)Selbstbild und Objektbeziehungen bei Depressionen. Untersuchungen mit der Repertory Grid Technik und dem Gießen-Test an 139 PatientInnen mit depressiven Erkrankungen
(1999)- et al.
Macht, Status und Valenz in den Partnerschaften affektpsychotischer, schizoaffektiver und depressiv neurotischer Patienten
Psychother. Psychosom. Med. Psychol.
(1997) - et al.
The enduring psychosocial consequences of mania and depression
Am. J. Psychiatry
(1993) Interpersonelle Faktoren bei depressiven Erkrankungen
Ehen depressiver und schizophrener Menschen. Eine vergleichende Studie an 103 Kranken und ihren Ehepartnern
Praxisorientierte Depressionsbehandlung heute
Schweizerische Rundschau für Medizin (Praxis)
Epidemiology of affective disorders
Arch. Gen. Psychiatry
Die Persönlichkeit bipolar manisch-depressiv Erkrankter
Nervenarzt
Akute Krisen bei Manien
Nervenheilkunde
Bipolare Patienten im Intervall: Persönlichkeitsstörungen und Persönlichkeitswandel
Nervenarzt
Einflüsse auf die Rückfälligkeit bipolar Manisch-Depressiver
Nervenarzt
Cited by (21)
Using the repertory grid technique to explore the experience of compassion by mothers in a mother and baby unit
2019, MidwiferyCitation Excerpt :Repertory Grid technique has previously been used in research examining staff perspectives of mothers (Blundell et al., 2012) and this method enables the construct of compassion to be explored widely, without making assumptions about its nature or relative importance in comparison to other aspects of care. Moreover, the same techniques have been employed with service users with a range of presentations including depression (e.g. Feixas et al., 2008), personality disorders (e.g. Golynkina and Ryle, 1999), affective disorders (e.g. Böker et al., 2000) and treatment preferences in physical health care (e.g. Rowe et al., 2005; Schaffalitzky et al., 2009). A further reason for the use of the repertory grid technique to examine this topic instead of a more conventional form of qualitative methodology, such as thematic analysis, was the ability to go beyond describing the service users’ experiences and views and to subject these to a systematic analysis without introducing researcher bias.
Psychopathology and pathophysiology of the self in depression - Neuropsychiatric hypothesis
2007, Journal of Affective DisordersPsychodynamic psychiatry and neurobiology
2020, Swiss Archives of Neurology, Psychiatry and PsychotherapyWhat psychopathology can learn from neuropsychodynamic psychiatry? A spatiotemporal approach
2018, Psychoanalysis and Psychiatry: Partners and Competitors in the Mental Health FieldNeuropsychodynamic Approach to Depression: Integrating Resting State Dysfunctions of the Brain and Disturbed Self-Related Processes
2018, Frontiers in Human NeurosciencePsychosocial problems of patients with difficult to treat depression
2018, Crossing Bordersintegrating Differences: Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy in Transition