Journal of Molecular Biology
Bridging the Gap between Structural Models of Nicotinic Receptor Superfamily Ion Channels and Their Corresponding Functional States
Introduction
Although the number of high-resolution structural models of membrane proteins continues to grow, our ability to associate structures with well-defined functional states lags far behind. Frequently, this is due to an incomplete understanding of the conformational dynamics of the protein in question (even in its native membrane microenvironment), a problem that is aggravated by the possibility that experimental artifacts (such as the effect of detergents1, 2 or the effect of forces developing within the crystal3) shift the equilibrium among conformations in hard-to-predict ways. In some other cases, structural data come from a given protein, whereas functional information is available for a distantly related ortholog, raising the inevitable question as to the extent to which the two sets of data can be compared.
The crystal structure of ELIC, a bacterial member of the nicotinic receptor superfamily4 whose conformational dynamics are still uncharacterized, was recently solved5 [3.3 Å resolution; Protein Data Bank (PDB) code 2VL0] and proposed as a model for the entire superfamily. Perhaps because the transmembrane portion of the ion permeation pathway is occluded near its extracellular end (minimum pore radius ≅ Na+ radius ≅ 1.0 Å; Fig. 1), this structural model was identified as the closed-channel conformation and was subsequently used to infer a mechanism for the closed ⇄ open gating conformational change.9, 10 But another structural model of the closed conformation of a nicotinic receptor, generated based on 4.0-Å-resolution cryo-electron microscopy data from the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) of Torpedo's electric organ (a muscle-type AChR) in the absence of activating ligands, features a much wider pore with a minimum radius of ∼ 2.5–3.0 Å at the center of the membrane7 (Fig. 1a). Thus, while the occluded pore of ELIC suggests that the closed ⇄ open gate poses a steric barrier to the permeation of ions, the model of Torpedo's AChR posits that this gate presents a desolvation penalty instead11, 12, 13 (radius of Na+ with the innermost hydration shell ≅ 3.0 Å14)—clearly two very different mechanisms for the same phenomenon.
Evidently, the resolution of the crystal structure (3.3 Å) is much better than that of the cryo-electron microscopy images (4.0 Å), but equally evident is the fact that the amino acid sequence of the AChR from Torpedo is much closer to the sequences of the functionally best-characterized members of the superfamily (such as the mouse muscle or human muscle AChR) than is any of the sequences from bacterial or archaeal origin described to date. So which model provides a more appropriate structural framework for interpreting the existing wealth of functional data?
The ion permeation pathway of ELIC is occluded because five pore-facing phenylalanines (phenylalanine 246), one per subunit, come together in a nearly T-shaped edge-to-face arrangement15 to form a structure akin to a narrow iris (Fig. 1c; Supplementary Fig. 1). Two other rings of pore-facing residues, the leucines at position 239 and the asparagines at position 250 (Supplementary Fig. 1), flank the phenylalanines at position 246 and contribute two additional constrictions (Fig. 1b), but the pore of ELIC is narrowest at the level of the central ring of phenylalanines (Fig. 1a; note that, throughout the article, we use the term “ring” to denote the arrangement of pore-facing atoms around the long axis of the channel rather than to refer to the benzene-ring-like properties of aromatic side chains). Owing to the low identity, there is some ambiguity in the alignment of primary sequences, but we favor the notion that positions 239, 246, and 250 of ELIC correspond to positions 9′, 16′, and 20′, respectively, of the second transmembrane (M2) segment of the better-understood metazoan members of the superfamily (Supplementary Fig. 1; others, however, have proposed that the ring of phenylalanines at position 246 aligns with position 20′; e.g., Hilf and Dutzler5).
Importantly, an inspection of sequenced genomes reveals that full rings of aromatic residues are not predicted to occur in vertebrate members of the superfamily at position 16′ or at any other pore-facing position, and that even the GLIC channel (a bacterial proton-gated homolog16 whose structure has also been determined by X-ray crystallography)9, 10 has an aliphatic residue at the aligned position4 (Supplementary Fig. 1). On the other hand, the amino acids forming the other two constrictions are not unique at all. Indeed, the leucine at position 239 of ELIC aligns with the very well-conserved leucine 9′ of the metazoan members of the superfamily, and the polar asparagine at position 250 aligns with the “extracellular ring of charge” (first identified in the AChR from Torpedo),17 which mainly contains asparagine, glutamine, and ionizable residues.
Admittedly, despite the very low sequence identity between ELIC and the AChR from Torpedo, many structural and functional features are remarkably well conserved; after all, ELIC is a bona fide member of the Cys-loop receptor superfamily even when lacking the signature cysteine loop. But it is conceivable that some sequence differences may have a more profound impact on structure and function than others. Therefore, we decided to focus on the central phenylalanines. Specifically, we asked how relevant the “aromatic plug” of ELIC and its mechanistic implications are to members of the superfamily that lack full rings of aromatic side chains at pore-facing positions.
Section snippets
Aromatic–aromatic interactions favor a nonconductive conformation
We engineered a full ring of phenylalanines at position 16′ of the well-characterized muscle (adult-type) AChR and assessed the functional consequences of such mutations using a variety of electrophysiological and toxin-binding assays. The most salient effect of the presence of this ring of pore-facing aromatic side chains was a marked decrease in the peak amplitude of the ensemble (“macroscopic”) currents elicited in response to step applications of nearly saturating concentrations of
Concluding Remarks
It is becoming increasingly clear that assigning a functional state (i.e., closed, open, desensitized, and inactivated) to the structural model of an ion channel solely based on how the transmembrane pore looks like (say, occluded or not occluded) may be misleading.
In the case of GLIC, we noticed that the channel desensitizes completely in a matter of seconds upon exposure of its extracellular side to pH 4.5. Of course, however, our results do not rule out the possibility that the X-ray crystal
DNA clones, mutagenesis, and heterologous expression
HEK293 cells were transiently transfected with wild-type or mutant complementary DNAs (cDNAs) encoding for the mouse muscle AChR (α1, β1, δ, and ɛ subunits) or the bacterial GLIC channel4, 16 using a calcium phosphate precipitation method. AChR cDNAs in the expression vector pRBG4 were provided by Dr. Steven Sine. GLIC cDNA was prepared by inserting a commercially synthesized stretch of DNA (Integrated DNA Technologies), consisting of the signal peptide of the chicken α7 AChR followed by the
Acknowledgements
We thank S. Sine for wild-type muscle AChR subunit cDNA; S. Elenes and D. Papke for critical advice on fast perfusion experiments; S. Rempe, S. Varma, and E. Tajkhorshid for discussions; and G. Papke, M. Maybaum, and J. Pizarek for technical assistance. This work was supported by a grant from the US National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (R01–NS042169 and corresponding American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 supplement to C.G.).
References (32)
Comparison of three structures of the multidrug transporter EmrE
Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol.
(2006)- et al.
Revival of electron crystallography
Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol.
(2007) - et al.
Design and characterization of a constitutively open KcsA
FEBS Lett.
(2010) - et al.
HOLE: a program for the analysis of the pore dimensions of ion channel structural models
J. Mol. Graphics
(1996) Refined structure of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor at 4 Å resolution
J. Mol. Biol.
(2005)- et al.
VMD: Visual Molecular Dynamics
J. Mol. Graphics
(1996) - et al.
Ion transport through membrane-spanning nanopores studied by molecular dynamics simulations and continuum electrostatics calculations
Biophys. J.
(2005) - et al.
The hydration number of Na+ in liquid water
Fluid Phase Equilib.
(2001) - et al.
π–π interactions: the geometry and energetics of phenylalanine–phenylalanine interactions in proteins
J. Mol. Biol.
(1991) - et al.
Aromatic–aromatic interactions and protein stability. Investigation by double-mutant cycles
J. Mol. Biol.
(1991)